The Stakeholder-Bystander Effect: Why Engaging Stakeholders Is Critical for Project Success

In the world of big projects and strategic initiatives, stakeholder engagement is often hailed as a cornerstone of success. Yet, stakeholders are sometimes relegated to the sidelines. While this may simplify the project in the short term, it comes at a high cost. Keeping stakeholders as bystanders can significantly complicate the journey to the finish line. Effective leaders know that turning stakeholders into meaningful collaborators is not just important—it’s essential.

The Risk of a Moving Finish Line

The ultimate danger for any project isn’t just failing to reach the finish line. It’s reaching it, only to find that the finish line has moved. Imagine delivering a project only to discover that stakeholders’ priorities have shifted, their expectations have evolved, and their needs are unmet. Disappointment looms, and progress unravels.

This “moving finish line” is a particular challenge for large initiatives. As business and stakeholder needs evolve over the project’s lifespan, misalignment becomes a real risk. Why does this happen? Sometimes stakeholders don’t voice their concerns, or the project team fails to listen. Either way, the result is the same: stakeholders left on the sidelines, disconnected from the project’s direction.

When Stakeholders Become Bystanders

We call this the stakeholder-bystander effect. It occurs when stakeholders are either kept at arm’s length by project leaders or choose to stay uninvolved.

For leaders, involving stakeholders can feel like a double-edged sword. Engagement brings complexity—it can raise questions, uncover hidden issues, and even challenge what’s already been agreed upon. In some cases, leaders worry that involving stakeholders might slow down progress or introduce uncertainty.

But ignoring stakeholders has risks too. Their input, perspective, and authority are crucial for navigating challenges, aligning priorities, and ensuring the project delivers value. When stakeholders remain disengaged, their absence can hinder decision-making, morale, and ultimately, project success.

The Challenges of Stakeholder Engagement

Stakeholders themselves may contribute to the bystander effect by staying on the sidelines. This can happen for several reasons:

• Busyness: Stakeholders are busy and may feel their involvement is unnecessary or unwelcome.
• Lack of Invitation: Sometimes they aren’t asked to participate in meaningful ways.
• Functional Silos and Hierarchies: Reaching across silos or up the chain of command can be cumbersome and intimidating.
• Cumbersome Engagement Processes: Formal presentations and committee meetings may slow down the pace of interaction, reducing agility.

Additionally, some organizations struggle to foster open, honest conversations about strategy and success. In environments where only good news is acceptable, critical feedback and constructive dialogue are stifled.

Transforming Stakeholders from Bystanders to Collaborators

To overcome the stakeholder-bystander effect, project leaders must embrace proactive, strategic engagement. This means:

1. Involving Stakeholders Early: The foundational first mile of a project is critical. Skipping consultation and co-creation at the outset can set the stage for misalignment down the road.
2. Facilitating Effective Communication: Create spaces where stakeholders feel safe to share their honest perspectives.
3. Assuming Positive Intent: Trust that stakeholders want the best for the organization and aim to understand their perspectives and pressures.
4. Breaking Down Silos: Make it easier for stakeholders to engage across functional and hierarchical boundaries.
5. Sharing Responsibility: Stakeholders must have a stake in the project’s success—and share responsibility for delivering outcomes.

A Shared Path to Success

As one coaching partner put it: “Stakeholders have a ‘stake’ in the game. But it’s essential that they share in the responsibility too.” This means stakeholders need to do more than watch from the sidelines. They must roll up their sleeves and actively contribute to solutions, trade-offs, and decision-making.

When stakeholders become collaborators, projects benefit from their expertise, foresight, and strategic insight. The path to the finish line becomes clearer—and success is shared by all.

In your next big initiative, ask yourself: Are your stakeholders bystanders, or are they partners? The difference could determine whether your project reaches the finish line—or whether it finds the line has moved.

Want to read more on this article? Click here: https://growthpitstop.com/2024/04/22/is-your-big-project-suffering-from-stakeholder-aversion/