Stages of Financial Distress

*****

This is the first of five articles in the Financial Distress series:

1. Stages of Financial Distress?
2. Sources of Liability in Financial Distress
3. Out-of-Court Restructuring Strategies
4. Voluntary Insolvency Proceedings
5. Do’s and Don'ts - Action Plan for Debtors in Financial Distress

*****

Financial distress in corporations is a complex process that evolves through various stages, each requiring different strategies and interventions. In the Mexican context, this progression typically follows a pattern from emerging problems to acute issues, potentially culminating in formal insolvency proceedings.

Early Stages: Management-Led Corrective Actions

The initial phase of financial distress often manifests as emerging problems within the organization. At this stage, the primary responsibility for addressing these issues lies with the company's management. The paper emphasizes the crucial role of management-led corrective actions during this period. These actions may include cost-cutting measures, restructuring of operations, or seeking additional financing. The effectiveness of these early interventions can significantly impact the company's ability to avoid more severe financial difficulties.

Escalation to Acute Problems

If management is unable to resolve the emerging problems effectively, the situation can escalate to more acute and worsening issues. This stage is characterized by increasing financial pressure, potential defaults on obligations, and growing concern among creditors and stakeholders. At this point, the company may need to consider more drastic measures to address its financial challenges.

Out-of-Court Workouts

As financial distress becomes more severe, the company may attempt to reach an out-of-court workout plan with its creditors. This process involves negotiating with creditors to restructure debts, extend payment terms, or obtain other concessions that can help the company regain financial stability. The success of these workouts depends largely on the willingness of creditors to cooperate and the viability of the proposed restructuring plan.

Formal Insolvency Proceedings

If out-of-court negotiations fail to produce a satisfactory resolution, or if the agreement reached is not supported by a sufficient number of creditors, the company may need to resort to formal insolvency proceedings. In Mexico, this process is governed by the Mexican Insolvency Law, which provides for a single insolvency proceeding with two successive stages.

Reorganization Stage

The first stage of the formal insolvency process is the reorganization stage. The primary goal of this stage is to preserve the business enterprise through a restructuring agreement. This stage is designed to be completed within 185 calendar days, with potential extensions up to a maximum of 365 days. During this period, the company works with a court-appointed conciliator to develop and implement a restructuring plan that can satisfy creditors while allowing the business to continue operations.

Liquidation Stage

If the reorganization stage does not result in a successful restructuring agreement, or if the debtor requests it, the process moves to the liquidation stage. The purpose of this stage is to liquidate the business, either as a whole, by sale of productive units, or by selling individual assets. The proceeds from this liquidation are then used to repay recognized claims according to the statutory priority of payments.

The progression through these stages illustrates the increasing severity of financial distress and the corresponding escalation in the formality and legal involvement of the resolution process. It underscores the importance of early recognition and management of financial problems, as well as the need for proactive engagement with creditors. Understanding this progression can help companies in Mexico better navigate financial difficulties, potentially avoiding the more drastic measures of formal insolvency proceedings through timely and effective interventions at earlier stages.