Specificity versus Functional Training – is there a difference?

A discussion with a fellow coach threw up this question, is there a difference between specificity and functional training? As a personal trainer I love functional training for my clients as it helps them become strong and flexible for the demands of everyday life. I use equipment such a ViPRs to mimic three dimensional and loaded movements such as digging, lifting, carrying, chopping etc. I also use kettlebells, Metafit HIIT and suspension trainers for functional fitness but more about that later.

Specificity, as a triathlon coach for me this means swimming, cycling and running and performing these activities at different intensities and durations to improve performance in these areas. The training plan must be relevant to the individual aims, for example training for a Sprint triathlon will be different to training for an IRONMAN.

For a formal definition; Specificity - training must be relevant to the individual and their sport. This can be achieved by tailoring training specifically for the sport or even the position that the individual plays, the muscle groups that they use the most or the dominant energy system of the athlete. For example, a 100 m sprinter is likely to train very differently to a 10 km racer despite them both being track athletes. The sprinter will focus on speed and power while the distance runner will train for cardiovascular fitness and the ability to work at high intensity aerobically.

So, is there much difference between Specificity and Functional training? The training regime chosen by the fitness professional or coach depends on the aims of the client or athlete. For some clients it important to be strong enough to walk their dog in the mountains or muck out their horses for example. A training session focusing on glutes, quads, calfs, core and hamstrings using a suspension trainer and kettlebells for walking the dog may be a good idea. For mucking out the horses then mimicking the movement patterns of digging using a ViPR may be appropriate to make appropriate adaptations in the deltoids, biceps/triceps, lats, traps and core muscles may be a way forward.

For a triathlete, apart from cross training and strength & conditioning then an appropriate session could be a swim, bike or run session focussing on Progressive overload - training frequency, intensity, time or type (FITT) must be increased over the training period to ensure that the body is pushed beyond its normal rhythm. Increases must be gradual so that the athlete avoids a plateau in performance or, worse, injury.

FITT - (Frequency, Intensity, Time, Type) - Frequency is increased by training a greater number of times each week. Intensity is increased by lifting a greater resistance, such as with weight training, or by training at a higher percentage of maximum heart rate (HR Max). This can be done either as continuous or interval training. Time can be manipulated by training for longer, reducing recovery times or by completing a greater number of sets or repetitions (also known as reps). Type of training is manipulated by offering a variety of training types and experiences to the athlete by combining training methods. Progressive overload is relevant to both Specificity and Functional training.

Functional Training Equipment

ViPR

ViPR is a rubber, hollow, weighted tube with handles, and it is used for total body training under the concept of “Loaded Movement Training.” ViPR stands for Vitality, Performance and Reconditioning. This tool can be used in any portion of a workout or as entire workouts. It can be used for mobility, strength and conditioning. ViPR can be used for movements that include both the upper and lower body and that simulate a specific task, such as lifting, shifting, dragging and tilting.

Using the ViPR can train your body to perform everyday movements that should be basic and functional in nature. Training with the ViPR can help your body stay in proper form when you’re at home lifting a large basket of laundry, or if you are constantly hoisting large items over your shoulder at a farm.

ViPR differs from other tools such as kettlebells and medicine balls because of the length of the rubber tube. It increases the lever arm of load, which makes the entire body stabilize against the load of the tube. Its shape, material, handles and length also make it easy for users to perform a variety of movements that may not be feasible with kettlebells or medicine balls.

Cycling requires a great deal of power from the legs and glutes. Mixing traditional squat routines with some progressive ViPR lateral shift motions will help cyclists improve muscle activation from the sagittal plane to the frontal plane. This will be useful for cyclists when they are performing climbs and sprints. A great exercise would be the ViPR lateral step with shift.

Suspension Trainer

The term suspension training refers to an approach to strength training that uses a system of ropes and webbing called a "suspension trainer" to allow users to work against their own body weight.

The field of suspension training is a form of resistance training that includes bodyweight exercises in which a variety of multi-planar, compound exercise movements can be performed. These are done with the aim of developing strength, balance, flexibility, and joint stability simultaneously. Suspension training develops physical strength while using functional movements and dynamic positions.

The versatile piece of kit can be taken on holiday, away on business and when packed in to its bag take up very little room. I love using it for both clients and athletes alike as it can mimic movements such as the pull and push phases of the freestyle stroke using a move called the swimmers pull. This movement strengthens the muscles used in the freestyle stroke.

Kettlebells

The kettlebell is a cast-iron or cast steel ball with a handle attached to the top (resembling a cannonball with a handle). It is used to perform many types of exercises, including but not limited to ballistic exercises that combine cardiovascular, strength and flexibility training. They are also the primary equipment used in the weight lifting sport of kettlebell lifting.

In his book Kettle Bell Training, world renowned Kettle Bell expert Steven Cotter describes ‘functional training’ as: “Exercise that addresses the body as a whole system in order to train movements and motor patterns that result in effective movement. Functional fitness programs focus on performance rather than aesthetics”. This requirement for performance or movement not aesthetics is also gaining traction in other publications on human motion and how we evolved as a species of hominid (Forencich, Frank. Play as if your life depends on it: Functional exercise and living for Homo Sapiens. GoAnimal, 2003.).

My favourite exercise is the swing. The swing works your rear chain muscles, core and glutes. Both exercises are equally effective in building power. It great at upper back development, posterior chain and midsection development and strength.

For beginners, it is probably best to focus on building a powerful hip hinge movement before moving on to more advanced moves like the kettlebell snatch. Otherwise, those new to KBs might be more tempted to use the upper body to complete the movement. 

Swings are great for waking the glutes up. When done correctly, almost all of the “pop” of a swing comes from a powerful contraction of the glutes. This is important for both runners and cyclists. What’s more, that contraction is initiated from a closed hip angle. A factor that is very relevant for anyone riding in the steep aero position mentioned above.

Metafit HIIT

Metafit is a form of High Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) and has many benefits for clients and athletes alike. It combines strength, functional movements and cardiovascular elements. Activities are performed with full range of movement and/or flat out to enable the EPOC effect. Excess Post exercise Oxygen Consumption (EPOC) is also known as oxygen debt, EPOC is the amount of oxygen required to restore your body to its normal, resting level of metabolic function (called homeostasis). It also explains how your body can continue to burn calories long after you’ve finished your workout.

Metafit is an all over body workout in an interval training format, intense exercise followed by short rest periods. It combines core exercises such as planks with functional moves like get ups and cardio in the form of exercises like sprints and 2 step dash. I particularly like the get up as is starts with you lying on the floor and you need to get up with minimal or hand to ground touches and ends standing up with a powerful jump. It uses most of your bodies muscle groups and ends with a plyometric jump. Do these a few times and your will be out of breath! Everybody should be able to get up from the ground.

A Metafit main set (i.e. without including warm up, warm down and stretches) is about 20 minutes long. Any longer than 30 minutes and its not a HIIT workout as you do need to be working flat out. Working at this intensity level for longer than 30 minutes can lead to injury or simply not working at the level needed to get the benefits of a HIIT workout.

Conclusion

For clients and athletes, the use of ViPRs, Kettlebells, Suspension Trainers and Metafit HIIT are all relevant and effective. As long as the movement patterns, intensity level, frequency/repetitions and duration prescribed by the coach or personal trainer is relevant to your specific goals then this will be effective.

For the athlete then specificity training relevant to the sport you are competing in is also highly effective and proven. For me a blend of functional and specificity is the best as it can also help to avoid injuries by strengthening specific areas of the body that may be susceptible to over training such as the knees and back.

 Metafit Espana