WILL A SOLUTION BE ARRIVED AT WITH INCREASING MISCONCEPTIONS ON FARMER GRAZER CONFLICT IN MENCHUM AND NWR-CAMEROON IN GENERAL?

Farmer-Grazer Conflicts in Northwest, Cameroon: A Multidimensional Analysis of Land Governance, Climate Change, and Social Inclusion

This write-up examines the persistent farmer-grazer conflicts in the North West Cameroon, focusing on the complex interplay of historical, socio-economic, and environmental factors. Exploring via perspectives the impacts of religious mentalities, extremist ideologies, land governance gaps, demographic pressures, and climate change on these conflicts, analyzing the effectiveness of proposed solutions, this contributes to the ongoing discourse on sustainable conflict resolution and social inclusion in the region.

1. Introduction

The NW region of Cameroon have long been plagued by conflicts between farmers and grazers, primarily involving ethnic Mbororo cattle herders and non-Mbororo subsistence farmers. These conflicts, rooted in competition over land resources, have persisted for decades, significantly impacting local communities and posing challenges to social cohesion and sustainable development. This edition of our article aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of the multifaceted nature of these conflicts, examining their historical context, religious and ethnic dimensions, land governance issues, demographic pressures, and the growing impact of climate change.

The complex interplay of identities, citizenship, and land rights in Cameroon's Northwest and Southwest (NWSW) regions has led to persistent conflicts and misunderstandings. To address these issues, it is crucial to critically examine the distinctions between various groups and the misconceptions that often blur these categories.

"On March 19, 2025, at 9:38 AM, I engaged in a discussion regarding recent reports circulating in online forums related to the situation in Menchum. These reports indicated that a group identified as a Muslim armed faction from Nigeria has been involved in violent incidents in the area. Initial reports suggest that the group began its activities in Akwaya, resulting in the deaths of seven members of the state armed forces. Subsequently, two weeks later, five members of the BIR (Rapid Intervention Battalion) were also reported killed. Currently, the group is said to have moved to Baworro, where numerous individuals have sustained injuries, but the total number of casualties remains unclear. Access to Baworro has been restricted due to blocked roads, contributing to escalating tensions in Esimbi Land. The community most severely impacted appears to be Benabeke, where significant destruction has occurred, including the burning of houses and the displacement of villagers. According to unconfirmed reports, approximately 500 individuals have been displaced, and up to 30 homes have been destroyed."

"This incident highlights the urgent need to address the root causes of these conflicts rather than focusing solely on their consequences.

In our argument a deeper auto-critique of the situation reveals several key points:

1. Muslims vs. Mbororo: While the Mbororo are predominantly Muslim, not all Muslims in the region are Mbororo. The Mbororo are a distinct ethnic subgroup of the Fulani, known for their nomadic pastoralist lifestyle
2. Herders vs. Farmers: The distinction between herders and farmers is not always clear-cut. While the Mbororo are traditionally associated with cattle herding, many have adopted sedentary or semi-sedentary lifestyles, engaging in both herding and farming activities
3. Citizens vs. Strangers: The concept of citizenship in Cameroon is deeply intertwined with notions of autochthony or "son of the soil"
4. Indigenous People: The term "indigenous" is particularly contentious in the Cameroonian context, as the legal framework does not formally recognize any community as indigenous

The incident reported in Menchum demonstrates how these misconceptions can lead to violence and displacement. By attributing the attacks to a "Muslim armed group from Nigeria," the report risks stigmatizing all Muslims in the region, including the Mbororo, who may have no connection to the violence. This type of misreporting can fuel further tensions and lead to retaliatory actions against innocent communities. Furthermore, the focus on religious identity (Muslim) and national origin (Nigeria) in the report obscures the underlying issues that may be driving the conflict, such as competition over land and resources, political marginalization, or cross-border security challenges. This simplistic framing fails to address the complex historical, social, and economic factors that contribute to violence in the region.To address these issues effectively, it is crucial to:

1. Promote a more nuanced understanding of identity categories, recognizing that individuals may hold multiple, overlapping identities (e.g., a Mbororo person who is both a herder and a farmer).
2. Challenge the binary distinction between "citizens" and "strangers" by advocating for a more inclusive concept of citizenship that is not tied to autochthony.
3. Address the root causes of conflicts, including land governance issues, economic disparities, and political marginalization, rather than focusing solely on ethnic or religious identities.
4. Improve media literacy and responsible reporting to avoid the spread of misinformation that can exacerbate tensions between communities.
5. Develop conflict resolution mechanisms that take into account the complex identities and historical grievances of all parties involved.

In conclusion, the situation in Menchum and the broader NWSW regions of Cameroon requires a comprehensive approach that goes beyond simplistic categorizations of identity. By addressing the root causes of conflicts and promoting a more nuanced understanding of citizenship and belonging, it may be possible to reduce tensions and build a more inclusive society for all residents of the region, regardless of their ethnic, religious, or occupational background.

2. Historical Context and Persistence of Farmer-Grazer Conflicts

The farmer-grazer conflicts in the NWSW regions have a complex historical background, characterized by the traditional transhumance practices of Mbororo herders and the sedentary farming of non-Mbororo communities. Over time, several factors have contributed to the evolution and intensification of these conflicts:

1. Land Use Changes: The conversion of traditional grazing lands into agricultural fields has increased competition for land
2. Population Pressure: Significant population growth has intensified the demand for land, leading to more frequent conflicts
3. Weak Land Governance: The absence of effective land governance and lack of formal land titles have made it difficult to resolve disputes amicably
4. Cultural and Ethnic Tensions: The conflicts involve cultural and ethnic dimensions, with Mbororo herders often viewed as outsiders by indigenous farming communities
5. Environmental Factors: Climate change has further strained available resources, affecting both agricultural and pastoral productivity

3. Religious Mentalities and Extremist Ideologies

The religious dimension of these conflicts adds another layer of complexity to the situation. The NWSW regions have a significant presence of both Christian and Muslim populations, and religious affiliations often exacerbate existing tensions. The perception of minority groups as "strangers" or outsiders can lead to discrimination and marginalization, contributing to societal tensions and potentially fueling extremist ideologies.

4. Gaps in Land Governance Laws

The land governance framework in Cameroon is characterized by a complex interplay of customary and statutory systems. While the legal framework for land acquisition is comprehensive, its implementation is fraught with challenges that lead to conflicts and uncertainties in land ownership.

Key gaps in land governance include:

1. Misalignment of Customary and Statutory Systems
2. Lack of Formalization
3. Implementation Discrepancies
4. Influence of Private Corporations
5. Large-Scale Land Acquisitions

5. Demographic Pressures and Limited Land Resources

The NWSW regions are experiencing rapid population growth, exerting significant pressure on limited land resources. This demographic shift is driving changes in land use, with more land being converted for agricultural purposes to meet the food demands of the growing population.The increased demand for land is not only for agriculture but also for housing and infrastructure development, exacerbating the strain on already limited land resources and leading to conflicts over land use and ownership.

6. Climate Change Impacts and Future Risks

Climate change is significantly affecting agricultural activities in the NWSW regions of Cameroon, impacting both farming and grazing practices. The effects of climate change in these areas are multifaceted, involving changes in temperature, precipitation, and the frequency of extreme weather events.

Key impacts include:

1. Temperature and Precipitation Changes
2. Extreme Weather Events
3. Pest and Disease Pressure
4. Water and Feed Availability

These climate change impacts are likely to exacerbate existing tensions between farmers and grazers, as resources become scarcer and competition intensifies.

7. Community Impacts and Proposed Solutions

The persistent farmer-grazer conflicts have had devastating effects on local communities, leading to loss of lives, displacement of people, destruction of property, and a general decline in socio-economic development.

Several solutions have been proposed and implemented to address these conflicts:

1. Community-Based Dispute Resolution (CBDR)
2. Indigenous Conflict Resolution Mechanisms (ICRMs)
3. Integration of Traditional and Formal Systems
4. Land Governance Reforms
5. Climate Change Adaptation Strategies

The farmer-grazer conflicts in the NWSW regions of Cameroon are complex and multifaceted, involving religious, ethnic, demographic, and environmental dimensions. Addressing these conflicts requires a comprehensive approach that considers all these factors. While some solutions have been proposed and implemented, they often face challenges in addressing the root causes of the conflicts. Moving forward, it is crucial to develop tailored approaches that consider the unique local dynamics, involve community participation, and address the underlying issues of land governance, religious and ethnic tensions, and environmental challenges. Only through such comprehensive and inclusive approaches can the NWSW regions of Cameroon hope to overcome the persistent farmer-grazer conflicts and build a more harmonious and sustainable future for all its inhabitants.

References

Journal of African Conflicts and Peace Studies (JACAPS).https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/jacaps/

World Bank. "Climate Risk Country Profile: Cameroon."https://climateknowledgeportal.worldbank.org/country/cameroon/climate-sector-agriculture

Global Environment Facility. "Cameroon."https://www.thegef.org/projects-operations/country-profiles/cameroon

Nkwemoh, C. A., et al. "Land Use and Land Cover changes in the Centre Region of Cameroon."https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10106049.2017.1307969

Land Portal. "Cameroon - Context and Land Governance."https://landportal.org/book/narratives/2022/cameroon

Mbih, R. A., et al. "Farmer-Grazer Conflicts in the North West Region of Cameroon: Causes, Consequences and Management Mechanisms."https://www.researchgate.net/publication/340460526_Farmer-Grazer_Conflicts_in_the_North_West_Region_of_Cameroon_Causes_Consequences_and_Management_Mechanisms.

Pelican, M. "Mbororo Claims to Regional Citizenship and Minority Status in North-West Cameroon."https://www.jstor.org/stable/40389225

Manu, I. N., et al. "Farmer-Grazer Conflict in Cameroon: Implications for Sustainable Development."https://www.researchgate.net/publication/340460526_Farmer-Grazer_Conflicts_in_the_North_West_Region_of_Cameroon_Causes_Consequences_and_Management_Mechanisms

Moritz, M. "Understanding Herder-Farmer Conflicts in West Africa: Outline of a Processual Approach."https://www.jstor.org/stable/40389225

Sone, P. M. "Conflict over landownership: The case of farmers and cattle grazers in the northwest region of Cameroon."https://www.researchgate.net/publication/340460526_Farmer-Grazer_Conflicts_in_the_North_West_Region_of_Cameroon_Causes_Consequences_and_Management_Mechanisms