Software Licensing Pitfalls to Avoid: A Practical Guide for Business Owners

Welcome to the second issue of "Insights by P. Ioannou"—a newsletter designed to empower business owners, entrepreneurs, and professionals with practical legal advice. Each month, I share insights to help you tackle legal complexities with clarity and confidence, ensuring your business thrives in today’s competitive landscape.

In this issue, we focus on software licensing agreements, a cornerstone of many tech-driven businesses. Whether you are developing software, licensing it to others, or integrating third-party software into your operations, a well-drafted software license agreement is vital for protecting your intellectual property and ensuring smooth business relationships.

Here’s a closer look at the common pitfalls, risks, and strategies for creating strong software license agreements.

Vague Licensing Scope

When it comes to software licenses, defining the scope of the license is critical.

The Mistake: Failing to specify how the software can be used, who can use it, and under what conditions.

The Impact: Misuse of your software, unauthorised sub-licensing, or disputes over whether certain uses are permitted.

The Solution: Clearly define the scope of the license. Specify authorised users (single user, a company, or unlimited users), the purpose (e.g. commercial or internal use), the territory (e.g. global or restricted to certain regions), and the duration ( e.g. perpetual or fixed-term).

Overlooking License Fees and Payment Terms

Software licensing is often a key revenue stream, but unclear payment terms can create financial and legal headaches.

The Mistake: Failing to outline payment structures, such as whether fees are subscription-based, one-time, or tied to specific milestones.

The Impact: Disputes over unpaid fees, delayed payments, or confusion about royalty calculations.

The Solution: Clearly outline the fee structure (e.g. fixed, subscription, or usage-based), payment schedules (monthly, quarterly, or annually), compensation for late payments, and rights to audit the licensee’s records to verify usage and compliance.

Neglecting Intellectual Property Ownership

Software often evolves, and your license agreement must address ownership of modifications and derivative works.

The Mistake: Failing to address who owns enhancements or customisations made by the licensee.

The Impact: You risk losing control over valuable improvements or facing disputes about ownership.

The Solution: Specify ownership clearly. Does the licensor retain ownership of all derivative works? Are modifications allowed, and if so, who owns them? Should the licensee assign any improvements back to the licensor?

For example, in many agreements, the licensor retains ownership of the core software and any customisations made by the licensee but may grant the licensee a non-exclusive right to use those customisations.

Failing to Include Usage Restrictions

Without clear restrictions, your software could be used in ways you never intended.

The Mistake: Overlooking clauses that limit reverse engineering, decompiling, or unauthorised distribution.

The Impact: Your software’s value could be diminished if it’s reverse-engineered or redistributed without your consent.

The Solution: Include explicit prohibitions against reverse engineering, decompiling, disassembling the software, using the software beyond the agreed scope (e.g., for unauthorised commercial purposes), and sharing or sub-licensing the software to third parties without prior approval.

The Licensor’s Failure to Secure Auditing Rights

One critical yet often overlooked clause is the licensor's right to audit the licensee's records to ensure compliance.

The Mistake: Some licensors avoid asking for this right, fearing it may insult or strain their relationship with the licensee.

The Impact: Without an audit clause, the licensor may have no way to verify proper usage or royalty payments without resorting to litigation—an expensive, time-consuming process.

The Solution: Include a clause granting the right to audit the licensee’s books and records periodically. This provision ensures transparency and provides a way to resolve disputes without litigation. Simply having this right in the agreement often prevents the need to exercise it.

Your Agreement Does Not Limit Your Liability

A limitation of liability clause is essential in any software license agreement, particularly because software is often business-critical.

The Mistake: Failing to include a well-drafted clause that limits the licensor’s liability for certain types of damages.

The Impact: If the software experiences downtime or malfunctions, the customer could claim significant damages, such as loss of profits or missed business opportunities, far exceeding the license fees paid. This could expose your business to substantial financial risks.

The Solution: Include a clear limitation of liability clause that caps the licensor’s liability to a specific amount (e.g., the total license fees paid) and excludes liability for consequential damages, such as lost profits. This protects your business from claims that could otherwise jeopardise its financial stability.

Ignoring Data Protection and GDPR Compliance

In today’s regulatory environment, compliance with data protection laws like GDPR is non-negotiable.

The Mistake: Overlooking data privacy requirements in agreements that involve the processing or handling of personal data.

The Impact: Non-compliance with GDPR or similar laws could result in fines, reputational damage, and legal liability, especially if the software processes customer or user data.

The Solution: Address data protection obligations in your license agreement. Ensure the agreement includes a clear description of the roles and responsibilities (e.g., who is the data controller and processor), provisions requiring GDPR-compliant practices, such as data security and breach notifications, and a data processing agreement (DPA), if applicable.

Regularly review your software and agreements to ensure compliance with evolving data privacy laws in different jurisdictions.

?Conclusion

Software licensing agreements are not just contracts—they are strategic tools for monetising your intellectual property while protecting your business interests. Whether you are a licensor or licensee, investing in a well-drafted agreement can save you from costly disputes and safeguard your software’s value.

If you are navigating software licensing agreements and need tailored advice, feel free to reach out. Together, we can craft agreements that align with your goals and protect your business.

Have you faced challenges with software licensing agreements? We would love to hear your experiences or questions—drop a comment or message me directly.

Thank you for reading "Insights by P. Ioannou." Let’s continue making the law work for your business success!

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice.

?