Social Security COLA ‘Click Bait’

Social Security COLA ‘Click Bait’

Over the past couple of years, one of the most-clicked posts on NAPA-Net has been on a topic that is a bit of a head-scratcher.

I’m speaking, of course, of the (now-incessantly tracked), monthly projections of the (potential) cost of living adjustment (COLA) for Social Security. It started back when inflation emerged as a real consumer concern—and it was spurred by the efforts of a group called the Senior Citizens League in publishing—EVERY MONTH—a projected cost of living adjustment (COLA) for Social Security.[i] And our coverage of those projections has been, and continues to be, one of the most clicked-on stories[ii] (ditto other publications, apparently).??

Like many, perhaps most, of you, I was initially intrigued by the reporting. Let’s face it, after a couple of decades of relative economic slumber, inflation has reared its ugly head in a way that reminds some of us of the days of our youth when inflation was an actual scary economic reality, rather than an obscure concept. And, at a time when the soaring cost of—well, everything—has (re)garnered our attentions, the notion that those impacts for older workers might be muted by a positive adjustment in their monthly benefit (not to mention those prospective increases in contribution and benefit limits of qualified plans) was encouraging.

But every single month????????

Not that Social Security has always had a COLA. In fact, Congress enacted the COLA provision as part of the 1972 Social Security Amendments, and automatic annual COLAs didn’t begin until 1975. Prior to that, benefits were increased only when Congress enacted special legislation. As for its calculation, Social Security’s COLA is based on the percentage increase in the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W) from the third quarter of the last year a COLA was determined to the third quarter of the current year. If there is no increase—and, believe it or not, that’s been the case in recent memory—there can be no COLA. That said, you can imagine that there tends to be something of a hue-and-cry from Social Security beneficiaries in those rare situations (most recently in 2016,[iii] though the increase in 2017 was just 0.3%).?

Of course, inflation measures often seem to be as much art as science—varying largely on what you spend your money on—and seniors do tend to spend money differently. In fact, one of the criticisms of the current formula is that it considers the purchases that current workers make, rather than retirees.[iv]?Another factor is the timing of the formula, which considers the period from September of one year to the next—while the government reports tend to reference the change from the PRIOR month, or in some cases from the same month a year earlier.?

That said, those on what are commonly referred to as “fixed incomes”[v] are understandably interested (and anxious) about potential increases (or lack thereof) in those finances. Let’s face it—retirement is not a profession that warrants merit increases, after all, nor are there typically opportunities for “promotion.” Purely from an SEO perspective, one can understand and appreciate the internet search engines cranking up to try and get a peek at what’s coming up in terms of potential benefit increases (and, to be sure, we do get significant traffic for those posts outside of our newsletter distribution). Still, and while those projections are based on the realities of the official inflation numbers reported by the federal government, they are merely point-in-time guestimates when it comes to knowing what the actual COLA number will be.

Not that I don’t “get” and appreciate the significance of the ACTUAL Social Security COLA—its impact on retirement projections, not to mention realities, is significant. That said, relentlessly tracking the POTENTIAL COLA based on interim monthly readings of inflation a year out from the actual establishment of the COLA have always struck me as a bit… obsessive. But clicks drive coverage these days and for the foreseeable future, and therefore, as long as you (all) keep clicking, we’ll keep covering…

Still, it should serve as a reminder to us all that planning for retirement should look beyond the income we happen to be drawing when we leave the workforce. After all, if the income we have at retirement isn’t enough to adjust to the costs of living in retirement—it might well cost us an “adjustment” in how, or how well, we live through retirement.



[i] According to their website, they are a nonpartisan seniors group, and have been since 1992, though it wasn’t until the COLA adjustment reports that they crept onto my radar. And perhaps that, as much as anything else, explains the monthly COLA reports.

[ii] And by including “Social Security” in the title of this post, I’m shamelessly trolling for some additional SEO visibility, of course.

[iii] You can find a table of the COLA at https://www.ssa.gov/cola/

[iv] For more details, check out https://assets.aarp.org/rgcenter/ppi/econ-sec/fs160.pdf or https://www.aarp.org/retirement/social-security/info-2020/colas-history.html.

[v] And it’s not just retirees. Disabled workers and their dependents account for 19% of total benefits paid, according to the Social Security Administration (see https://www.socialsecurity.gov/pressoffice/basicfact.htm).

this post originally appeared here.

Mike Dullaghan, AIF?

Director of Retirement Sales Execution

1 年

Interesting article Nevin. As a guy who is in the retirement industry “click bait” business, your stats remind me how important SS, SS claiming strategies, and, as you have explained to me, Medicare filing decisions are. That may be the reason their are so many clicks on this topic. It also reminds me #AdviceisaGrowthBusiness. Your article demonstrates why advice and guidance is crucial for retirees. Thanks for your post.

回复
Matthew Wolniewicz, AIFA

President, Income America | Champion for Guaranteed Income & Retirement Planning | 401(k)

1 年

Nevin Adams luv your perspective on #socialsecurity now that you are (kind of) in #retirement

Faith Teope

The 401k & ESOP Provider Inspired By People | Forbes Finance Council | Human advocate

1 年

With so many unknowns (predictions or even how-tos regarding personal finance) it seems like people are grasping at the magic ball hoping it will give them the answer that will set them at ease

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Nevin Adams的更多文章

  • (Back to) The Way We Were?

    (Back to) The Way We Were?

    It’s hard to believe that it’s now been five years ago that many of us went into our places of work, packed up, and…

    8 条评论
  • "Springing" Forward?

    "Springing" Forward?

    This past weekend most of America underwent a rather painful change — though it’s probably only just setting in. I’m…

    5 条评论
  • Less Than You’d Think

    Less Than You’d Think

    “Larry Fink Knows Less About Retirement Than You’d Think an Investment Billionaire Would.” That’s the provocative title…

    1 条评论
  • ‘Mad Money’s’ Mixed Bag

    ‘Mad Money’s’ Mixed Bag

    Last week a reader brought to my attention an episode of Jim Cramer’s “Mad Money” — an episode wherein he referred to…

    6 条评论
  • The "Find" Print

    The "Find" Print

    In case you hadn’t noticed, today (February 14) is Valentine's Day — and, as usual, there’s been the typical seasonal…

    16 条评论
  • Could Super Bowl 59 Influence Your 401(k)’s Future?

    Could Super Bowl 59 Influence Your 401(k)’s Future?

    Will your 401(k) be chopped by the Chiefs — or soar with the Eagles? That’s what adherents of the so-called Super Bowl…

    3 条评论
  • A Red Flag for a ‘Red Flag’ Report

    A Red Flag for a ‘Red Flag’ Report

    Did you hear the one about how nearly all U.S.

    21 条评论
  • Missing the Mark

    Missing the Mark

    A recent survey posed an intriguing question: Why are employees not participating in their 401(k)s? The answer(s) were…

    28 条评论
  • The Limits of Behavioral Finance?

    The Limits of Behavioral Finance?

    It’s long been noted that inertia is a powerful force regarding behavioral finance and automatic enrollment — but it…

    25 条评论
  • Encouraging Words

    Encouraging Words

    On what turned out to be the longest day of 2024, I said good-bye to my dear 94-year-old mother. It wasn’t how any of…

    42 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了