Six Nations offers up some Lion-hearted 10's

Six Nations offers up some Lion-hearted 10's

For the tournament, England's dramatic last minute Houdini act is a blessing. It means that Ireland v France is not a winner takes all match and introduces England as potential winners too especially given their remaining matches. Scotland and France away are always trickier years. Sadly, the double collision in Murrayfield now means Scotland is without three matchwinners in the back line and with a player base at 10% of England's, their replacements will be nowhere near good enough at Twickenham. A resurgent England will isolate Finn Russell and that will be it. I sense that Finn may secretly see domestic success with Bath as more of an objective right now.

The other Fin(n) needs no more plaudits than he has already received, but together with Prendergast has created an intriguing Lions narrative for themselves all of a sudden. Their passing intuition and ability to make others look better follow a path which Russell has already trodden.

Trial by video started back in my day, as freeze frames led to uncomfortable questions on overlaps missed and other opportunities spurned. First half England v France 2025 will be a horror show for both but with a different lense. The profligacy shown by a clearly superior French team will haunt them for years. The subconscious of the Twickenham hammering two years before and European club supremacy via Toulouse and Bordeaux was clearly in dominant mood. As England knows too well, no one wins a match in the opening 40 but to be 20 points down would have been a mountain to climb. Their defence on a wet day was picked apart with ease but then they won't face a team with the multiple skills of the French for a while so they have time to sharpen that up.

England will drink deep of the new level of confidence and belief - replacements can make a difference, discipline when fatigued can be maintained and great decision making and performance under pressure (FIn Smith and Tommy Freeman take a bow) wins you matches even if they so nearly fell short again. The last French try which should have won the match was sublime and reinforced the frustration Galthié will feel. Does he lack that crucial ingredient to combine the talents of two club teams and turn them into something world beating? Dublin will tell more.

The one point margin was wafer thin, but it is always enough. 'Never in doubt' I hear Gareth Chilcott growling repeatedly in a triumphant Bath changing room, over a long period of years. Ask the World Champions. Ask the All Blacks who denied this Irish team a semifinal in the World Cup by a single point and a ball held up over the line or who denied France a World Cup in 2011.

As for Borthwick, he will be scouring the data for more insight but lets give him credit for some good selections. We can and should reach 4 wins out of 5 when one of the big three is beaten. How is that then assessed and valued with a view to improvement? Off field, as in Wales, the structure leaves far too much to the efforts of the players and when the system is broken it is hard to see a way back or to take the next step upwards depending on whether you are Wales or England. More significant rugby knowledge must be introduced and the teams are then set up to succeed and not just win famous one offs which gives the impression that all is well. Go back to the last Welsh Grand Slam for example which was a cliff off which the National game then fell very hard.

Lastly, the Twickenham crowd is now baying for more, and a damaged Scotland is in no state to resist the 24th man. Remember who has won the last half dozen Calcutta Cups - time for change if not revenge but before that a week off to gather breath and celebrate another great week of Six Nations rugby.

And, importantly, for the rugby widows amongst us, it means we survive for another week! ??????????

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Simon Halliday的更多文章

  • View from the Cape - On a Wing and a Six Nations Prayer

    View from the Cape - On a Wing and a Six Nations Prayer

    There has been a company formed in South Africa called 'Win By One' and the Springboks have turned this margin of…

    1 条评论
  • Six Nations - the pressure builds.

    Six Nations - the pressure builds.

    I counted 25 plus articles that I read myself on the opening weekend and it shows there is a voracious appetite which…

  • View from the Cape -Six Nations is here

    View from the Cape -Six Nations is here

    I am sorely tempted to join the crowd and make some Six Nations predictions, but as a Francophile who was born in…

    4 条评论
  • View from the Cape - French lessons become compulsory

    View from the Cape - French lessons become compulsory

    I heard Dom McKay, Chairman of EPCR, repeat a statement on TV which has often epitomised this great competition that is…

    1 条评论
  • View from the Cape - Europe, England, Defence,Centres

    View from the Cape - Europe, England, Defence,Centres

    When I first became Chairman of EPCR in 2014, the Pool draw was a big moment due to the competition structure and the…

    2 条评论
  • View from the Cape

    View from the Cape

    The weather having gone very seasonal all of a sudden in the UK, last weekend I watched the Stormers take on The Sharks…

    1 条评论
  • Rugby 2025 - Let me Entertain you- but first.....

    Rugby 2025 - Let me Entertain you- but first.....

    Whatever happened in 2024, the quality and entertainment factors were high on the to do list and by and large various…

    16 条评论
  • French lessons handed out on the second Champions Cup weekend

    French lessons handed out on the second Champions Cup weekend

    It is Reconciliation Day here in South Africa, and I for one consistently think of the most transformational event that…

  • Champions Cup- a big tournament with small moments

    Champions Cup- a big tournament with small moments

    It is tempting to raise the imponderable issue of differing salary caps in Europe being the deciding factor in key…

  • Rugby - A viable Currency or Junk Bond?

    Rugby - A viable Currency or Junk Bond?

    Having experienced such a thrilling Autumn Series, the dénouement was inevitably a little underwhelming, with the…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了