The Silent Crisis: Wage Theft, Underpayment and Modern Slavery in Australia’s Agricultural Sector

CNN | AU

A crisis festers in the fields of Australia—a crisis that threatens to undermine the moral fabric of one of the world’s most developed nations. Beneath the sprawling landscapes of South Australia’s Riverland, the lush orchards of Victoria, the rolling vineyards of New South Wales, and the vast farming plains of Queensland, a silent epidemic unfolds—an epidemic of wage theft, exploitation, and suffering. This is not a mere administrative issue; it is a catastrophe, rooted in systemic injustice, where the labor of thousands is withheld, their pay stolen, and their human dignity trampled under the weight of corporate greed. Here, workers are promised fair compensation, but instead find themselves enslaved by broken promises, their wages withheld for months—sometimes up to a year and beyond.

“Are you paying employees correctly?” The Fair Work Ombudsman poses this question with an urgency that resonates far beyond the corridors of government institutions. The new Commonwealth criminal underpayment laws are a step toward accountability, transforming intentional wage underpayment into a criminal offence—a move that signals Australia’s commitment to combating exploitation. However, as workers toil under unbearable conditions in the agricultural and horticultural sectors, the question remains: how deep does this exploitation run, and how many lives will continue to be destroyed before real justice is served?

In interviews with victims spanning South Australia, Victoria, New South Wales, and Queensland—regions where agriculture drives the economy—a disturbing truth emerges. Contractors and subcontractors have callously withheld wages from vulnerable workers for months on end. Promises of payment are nothing more than hollow words, cruelly repeated week after week, month after month. Yet the money never comes. Workers, many of whom hold horticultural awards, are left in a state of perpetual uncertainty, their hopes dashed and their futures uncertain.

In South Australia, where the sun beats relentlessly on the backs of the workers in vineyards, rose farms, orchards, the hidden story | facts is the same. Promises of fair pay turn to dust as subcontractors withhold wages for up to a year, offering nothing but empty assurances. Workers, often migrant laborers, are left stranded, unable to pay for basic necessities—food, petrol, rent. The cost of living continues to rise with inflation, further eroding the ability of these workers to survive. Employment is secured, but the wages that should support them are withheld.

“The work was hard, yes. But we were told we would be paid,” recalls one worker, his voice heavy with the burden of despair. “Every week, they said, ‘next week, next week.’ But next week never came. After a while, you stop asking, because you realize nothing will change.”

This scenario is not isolated—it is a pattern. In Victoria’s Dandenong Ranges and Gippsland, South Australia workers employed in fruit picking and vineyard labor faced similar hardships. Wages were promised, but rarely, if ever, delivered. In New South Wales, vineyards in the Hunter Valley and the Mudgee region became the sites of widespread underpayment, where workers toiled under extreme conditions only to be told that “the money will come tomorrow.” Tomorrow never arrives.

In Queensland, where the sugarcane and tropical fruit industries dominate, the situation is no different. Workers, already burdened by physical strain and exposure to the elements, find themselves in an economic straitjacket, unable to leave their jobs because they need the work to survive, yet unable to meet their basic needs because their pay is perpetually delayed. Their debts mount, and their despair deepens.

Australia is often regarded as a beacon of prosperity, a land of opportunity. Yet, within the vast agricultural industries that sustain the nation, there exists a brutal form of modern slavery. Workers are forced to toil in unsafe conditions, their labor extracted with the promise of pay that never materializes. The harshest irony is that the agriculture sector, responsible for feeding a nation and exporting billions of dollars worth of goods to the world, has become a breeding ground for exploitation.

In this so-called “secure employment,” workers find themselves trapped. Despite the illusion of job security, their work goes uncompensated, leaving them vulnerable to exploitation. There is no safety net, no means of escape. They are often isolated in remote areas, far from urban centers where they might seek assistance. The tragic result is a system of labor that resembles modern-day slavery: workers are bound by the chains of broken promises and unpaid wages, struggling to survive, yet unable to free themselves.

It is not just the unpaid wages that exact a toll on these workers—it is the physical and emotional strain of their labor. Working under the scorching heat of summer and the numbing cold of winter, workers face illness, exhaustion and injury. In many cases, they have no access to healthcare, as their wages are withheld. One worker, employed in South Australia, collapsed from heatstroke during a particularly grueling day in the rose farm. He was left to die in the fields, his cries unheard as the temperatures reached dangerous levels. Another worker, suffering from a chronic illness exacerbated by overwork, was unable to afford treatment and perished without ever seeing a doctor.

In fact, perhaps the most haunting cost is the mental anguish that these workers endure. Stripped of their dignity and hope, some face despair so deep that they contemplate and in some cases, follow through with suicide. “I was told every week that my wages would come, but they never did. It felt like I was drowning. I didn’t know how much longer I could survive like this,” said one worker, his words laced with the bitter sting of defeat. The mental health crisis among these workers is not an anomaly—it is the direct result of a system designed to extract labor without giving anything back.

The Australian government’s decision to criminalize wage theft is a significant step forward, but it is not enough. The fact-finding investigations conducted by the Fair Work Commission and the Fair Work Ombudsman have revealed that the scale of wage theft in the agricultural sector is staggering. Yet the enforcement of existing laws has been inconsistent and many workers continue to suffer in silence.

The new Commonwealth criminal underpayment laws offer hope, but they must be accompanied by a robust system of enforcement and protection for workers. Investigations must lead to swift and meaningful action. Employers who continue to exploit their workers must be held accountable and the lives of these workers—often so far removed from public view—must be valued.

The scale of exploitation unfolding within Australia’s agricultural sector calls for intervention on a global scale. As a signatory to numerous international labor conventions, Australia is bound by its commitments to uphold the rights and dignity of workers. The International Labour Organization (ILO), which has long championed the rights of workers worldwide, must turn its gaze toward this tragedy and demand immediate action. Australia’s failure to prevent widespread wage theft is a direct violation of several ILO conventions, particularly Convention 87 (on Freedom of Association), Convention 98 (on the Right to Organize and Bargain Collectively), and Convention 111 (on Discrimination in Employment and Occupation). These conventions enshrine the right to fair wages, safe working conditions, and the freedom to seek redress against employers who violate workers’ rights. The international community must hold Australia accountable for its failure to protect the very workers upon whom its agricultural economy relies.

Furthermore, global human rights organizations, such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, must step forward to amplify these voices, which are all too often silenced by the weight of exploitation and fear. These bodies possess the influence necessary to bring international attention to the systemic abuse taking place, and through their advocacy, pressure can be applied to the Australian government to enact meaningful reform. The United Nations—in its capacity to enforce universal human rights standards—must also play a pivotal role, demanding that Australia cease its violation of the fundamental rights of these workers and uphold its obligations under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

The question posed by the Fair Work Ombudsman, “Are you paying employees correctly?”, must be addressed not just by individual employers but by an entire nation. Australia’s agricultural sector cannot be allowed to continue to profit from the exploitation of its workers. The new Commonwealth Criminal Underpayment Laws, while a positive step forward, must be enforced rigorously, with employers who flout these laws held accountable for their actions. It is not enough for laws to exist on paper; they must be upheld in practice. The failure to hold employers to account is not just an oversight—it is a compounding injustice that devastates lives. It is the duty of the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Fair Work Commission, and the Australian government to ensure that workers receive the wages they have earned and that justice is not delayed or denied.

For this to happen, however, there must be a systemic overhaul of the regulatory framework governing the agricultural sector. Subcontractors must be held to the same standards of accountability as primary employers, and stronger labor protections must be put in place to ensure that workers are not left vulnerable to exploitation. Furthermore, there must be greater transparency in the way wages are paid, and mechanisms must be established to allow workers to report abuses without fear of retribution. This is not simply a matter of economic fairness; it is a matter of human dignity.

It is time for Australia to confront the reality of its agricultural sector: that beneath the glossy veneer of prosperity lies a dark undercurrent of exploitation, where the people who feed the nation are denied the very wages they have earned. This is a systemic issue that cannot be solved by mere policy changes alone. It requires a shift in the values that drive the industry—a fundamental recognition that workers are not mere commodities, but human beings deserving of respect, fairness and dignity.

The world must take note. The plight of these workers is not just an Australian issue—it is a global one. As agricultural industries around the world continue to rely on cheap, exploited labor, Australia’s experience serves as a harrowing warning. Global supply chains that profit from the labor of the vulnerable must be reexamined, for the exploitation of one group of people reverberates through economies, societies and lives far beyond the fields.

The time for action is now. The Fair Work Ombudsman has posed the question: “Are you paying employees correctly?” But the real question is: Will Australia—and the world—respond with the urgency, accountability and compassion needed to end this cycle of exploitation and suffering once and for all? The lives of these workers are not just statistics—they are real people, real lives and their stories demand to be heard.

CNN ? CNN Indonesia ? CNN Brasil ? United Nations ? UNESCO ? International Labour Organization ? Fair Work Commission ? The Fair Work Ombudsman ? Parliament of Australia ? Australian Government ? United Nations Human Rights ? 联合国粮农组织 ? 联合国开发计划署