Should You Accept a Counteroffer?

You apply for a new job, attend an interview, and receive a decent salary offer. You inform your boss and formally resign from your current job. Suddenly, your employer presents a counteroffer while you're still in your notice period. Should you accept it?

The answer isn't straightforward. A Harvard Business Review survey revealed that nearly 40% of senior executives and HR leaders believe accepting a counteroffer from a current employer can negatively impact your career. Your decision should hinge on the reasons for your resignation, your overall satisfaction with the company, and the specifics of the counteroffer.

Risks in Taking a Counteroffer

When you decide to accept a counteroffer, there are several factors to consider, particularly regarding your reputation both within the company and in the job market. One of the main risks is the potential reputational damage that comes with accepting an offer and then backing out of it. This action can lead to perceptions of unreliability and indecisiveness.

Additionally, employees who accept counteroffers often feel stigmatized. Even though they remain with their current company, they may be labeled as "a renegade." This is because, for weeks or months, they were engaged in discussions with another company while maintaining a fa?ade of normalcy with their colleagues and bosses. This can lead to a perception of decreased loyalty, as colleagues may feel betrayed by the secrecy and the actions of the employee.

The jealousy factor also comes into play. Colleagues might feel envious of the salary increase that often accompanies a counteroffer, leading to tension and potentially damaging workplace relationships. The overall result is a loss of trust and a tarnished reputation within the team and the company.

Furthermore, it’s essential to assess the company's motivations behind the counteroffer. Are they offering you a better deal because they truly value your contributions, or are they simply trying to buy time while they look for a replacement? Understanding the true intentions behind the counteroffer can help you make a more informed decision about your career path.

Why You Might Consider Taking a Counteroffer After All

Accepting a counteroffer can be a strategic decision in certain situations. Here are the instances where it might make sense to stay with your current company:

• If your resignation was solely due to salary concerns and your employer is prepared to match or even exceed the compensation offered by the new company, it could be a compelling reason to stay. This way, you can enjoy the benefits of increased pay without the disruption of changing jobs.
• Additionally, if your departure was motivated by a lack of new challenges, and the counteroffer includes significant new responsibilities or projects that align with your career goals, it might be worth reconsidering your decision to leave. This opportunity can provide the growth and advancement you seek within a familiar environment.

Remember, joining a new company means starting from scratch. You will have to navigate a new workplace culture, build relationships with colleagues, and adapt to new processes. You will also likely be subject to a probationary period, during which you'll need to prove your capabilities all over again. Often, the reality of a new job may not live up to the idealistic picture presented during the hiring process. Therefore, staying in a familiar environment, where you understand the dynamics and expectations, might offer more stability and predictability. As the saying goes, sometimes the devil you know is better than the devil you don’t know.

Conclusion

When considering a counteroffer, it is crucial to evaluate all aspects carefully to ensure that accepting it does not lead you into a dead-end position. Consider whether this acceptance might be your final opportunity within your current company, leaving you with no room for further growth or advancement. If you find the decision-making process challenging, using a weighted scoring sheet can be beneficial. This tool can provide structure to your evaluation, allowing you to weigh different factors and their importance to your career goals.

From a psychological standpoint, it’s important to acknowledge the emotional journey of resignation. Once an employee decides to leave a company, they often begin to emotionally detach from their role and workplace. This detachment can be difficult to reverse, even if they decide to stay. Statistically, about 90% of employees who accept a counteroffer end up leaving the company within a year anyway, as the underlying reasons for their initial decision to resign often remain unresolved. Therefore, it’s essential to consider not just the immediate benefits of a counteroffer but also the long-term implications for your career and personal growth.

Good luck!

P.S.: If you don’t want to leave but only want to leverage your resignation to gain a higher salary, better benefits, or perhaps even a promotion, that can be a bit tricky. Check how to play this properly in my earlier article here: https://getyourdreamjob.co/2024/02/13/how-to-leverage-resignation-to-gain-salary-increase/

Click here to subscribe and receive this newsletter directly to your mailbox.

P.S.: There are three ways how I can help you further:

1. Get my books - Learn all the job search and career management insider tips and tricks and use them to your advantage.
2. Get my online course - Get access to aids, guides, workbooks, checklists, cheat sheets, and other exclusive content to speed up your job search.
3. Work with me 1:1 - Book one of my coaching packages and get my personal support.