Should An Executive Be Hopeful or Optimistic?

?? When evaluating whether it is better for an executive to be hopeful or optimistic, it's essential to understand the nuances of these two mindsets.

Hope is rooted in the belief that desired outcomes are possible and can be achieved through effort and planning.

Optimism, on the other hand, is a general expectation that good things will happen, often irrespective of the specifics of a situation.

While these qualities are interrelated, they play different roles in leadership and decision-making.

Hopefulness often drives strategic action and resilience. An executive who is hopeful doesn’t merely expect positive outcomes, they actively seek to create them. Hope fosters a problem-solving mindset, encouraging leaders to identify pathways toward their goals and adapt to challenges as they arise. This trait can be particularly valuable in times of uncertainty, as hope empowers leaders to inspire their teams, focus on long-term objectives, and maintain momentum even when obstacles seem daunting.

Optimism, by contrast, can instill confidence and morale, especially in high-stakes or pressure-filled environments. An optimistic leader exudes assurance and positivity, which can motivate teams and build trust. However, unchecked optimism can sometimes lead to blind spots. Overly optimistic executives may underestimate risks or overlook warning signs, potentially compromising strategic decision-making. Therefore, optimism is most effective when tempered by realism and paired with critical thinking.

In practice, the most effective executives strike a balance between hope and optimism.

They embrace hope to maintain determination and chart pathways to success while leveraging optimism to inspire confidence and foster a positive workplace culture. This combination enables them to pursue ambitious goals with clarity and foresight, leading their organisations with both vision and pragmatism.

Locus of control is significant in achievement motivation. People attribute their performance and destiny to internal or external reinforcers. An internal locus attributes success or failure to personal ability or effort, assuming responsibility. An external locus attributes performance to factors over which there is no responsibility, citing the ease of the task or luck. Executives with high self-efficacy, sense of self and internal locus of control hope they can succeed, perform well in future tasks and make things happen.

Clearly executives and board directors always need to consider growth and risk – and they need to be right a lot more than they are wrong. Ultimately, the interplay between hope and optimism allows them to navigate strategic agendas with resilience and purpose.

Further reading: Opportunity from AI Tools to Human Teams

Further reading: Executive Resilience

Further reading: Fail Forward

Further reading: Savvy Achievers

Further reading: Tensions, Dilemmas, Paradoxes

Further reading: Love The Problem

EVERY EXECUTIVE NEEDS A TRUSTED SOUNDING BOARD

“How do I choose a mentor-coach and what should I look for?" is a natural question. Look for someone who is compatible, but has enough of a contrast to bring new perspectives. Someone who has the expertise you would need to work through the 'how' and the 'why'; that you could trust and respect. You would want a good listener and someone who has your interests at heart to the extent that they will encourage a frank dialogue on both sides and support you through the changes that will need to be made.”- Dianne Jacobs

This article is part of our Insights for Action series and forms part of our mentoring and coaching work. Explore our Executive Reading List for new perspectives on leadership and governance. Join the mailing list to receive this and more.

?? Discover what mentoring or coaching support we offer executives aiming for the next level or the boardroom or enquire about a session

With a range of clients nationally and internationally, we work 1:1 or together; in person or virtually. We are based in Melbourne, Australia. Some time zones are friendlier than others, but that’s ok as we can always find a time that is mutually convenient.