Should environmental impact be an integral part of startup pitches and plans?
Davender Gupta
Guiding visionary innovators to prosper in unpredictable times #momentumscaling
Traditionally, startup pitches start with a problem or opportunity, propose a solution, then go straight into the market, growth potential, financials and investment opportunity. Nowhere is there a discussion of climate or environmental impact. Should there be?
The United Nations IPCC report released in October 2018 announced that "we have 12 years to limit climate change catastrophe". This dire prediction is backed by credible studies in the US and Canada, as well as elsewhere. We can no longer do things the old way.
Startups start with a clean sheet, building a new offer, a new team and a new infrastructure to match an unmet need. However when we coach new businesses, we urge them to focus their message on raising money, as if we were stuck in the mid-2000s before Al Gore’s “An Inconvenient Truth”. Nowhere in pitch deck models do we mention environmental impact. What should be the responsibility of Founders on this very important topic? What should Funders do to encourage business models which acknowledge this inescapable predicament? Or is it something that we’ll deal with later if the business lasts beyond seed stage? The problem is that if environmental impact is not addressed from the start, like a path to profitability, we risk never getting around to dealing with it. And by then, it’s too late.
Startups launching today (2019-2020) will quickly face volatile economic, political and climatic changes - all caused by the environmental challenge. This uncertainty is probably the biggest risk for any Founder or Funder.
The flip side is that with uncertainty comes opportunity. Value innovation focusing on increasing utility while reducing all costs, and not just externalizing them to other stakeholders or to the commons (a la Uber), will be the key to long-term business success.
Environmental impact needs to be a foundational part of the startup business model starting now. All this entrepreneurial energy should not be limited to just creating value for customers and valuation for investors. If we're going to make capitalism better, our activities must also price the impact on our valuable and life-sustaining commons.
So when are we going to see Demo Days scored not just on growth potential but also on how they address environmental impact?
Davender empowers growth-focused entrepreneurs to thrive in an unpredictable world. Is is the founder of The Scaleup Project, a consultancy helping startups to mature into sustainable and profitable businesses. He is also a co-founder of the Defi Croissance Montreal Growth Challenge and a TEC Canada Chair for emerging businesses. https://TheScaleupProject.com
Directeur service à la clientèle chez Ninja Bleu
5 年Great article that brings a interesting point of view. If we can no longer live on our own (an only planet) what's the purpose of making money in the firts place.
Citizen Service Officer at Service Canada
5 年Doing both is indeed a challenge, specially if it was not integrated from the beginning. However more and more consumers are demanding it Davender Gupta, MS, MBA
Portfolio, Programs and Project Management
5 年Oh yes!
A few more thoughts. Startups have to operate inside existing financial systems. VCs have to operate inside existing financial systems. LP's at VC's have to operate inside existing financial systems. All of this is framed inside public equity markets on stock exchanges. No earnings are reported in GhG impact. So what you are really asking is can the overall economic rewards system into which Startups pitch be modified. That's not happening before most of us get to cash flow positive. So what goes into our pitches has to work inside the economic system in which we exist.
Guiding visionary innovators to prosper in unpredictable times #momentumscaling
5 年The way things are doesn't have to be the way things are. "Systems look immutable until they suddenly disintegrate. As soon as they do, the disintegration retrospectively looks inevitable. Our system – characterised by perpetual economic growth on a planet that is not growing – will inevitably implode. The only question is whether the transformation is planned or unplanned. Our task is to ensure it is planned, and fast. We need to conceive and build a new system based on the principle that every generation, everywhere has an equal right to enjoy natural wealth."? -- George Monbiot https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/apr/15/rebellion-prevent-ecological-apocalypse-civil-disobedience