Shaping the Future of Money: Navigating the Complexities of CBDC Implementations

Authored by Mustafa Syed

Introduction

In the rapidly evolving landscape of digital finance, Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) have emerged as a groundbreaking innovation, poised to redefine the very fabric of monetary transactions and financial systems globally. As nations and financial institutions grapple with the intricacies of implementing CBDCs, it becomes imperative to delve deep into the multifaceted challenges and opportunities that these digital currencies present. This article aims to shed light on the critical considerations surrounding the implementation of CBDCs, focusing on the pivotal aspects of security, data privacy, and the underlying technological framework [1].

The advent of CBDCs marks a significant departure from traditional financial models, introducing a digital form of central bank money that promises enhanced efficiency, inclusivity, and innovation in payments and settlements [1]. However, the journey towards a fully-realized CBDC ecosystem is laden with complex questions and challenges. How can central banks ensure robust security measures to safeguard against cyber threats and fraud? What strategies can be employed to uphold stringent data privacy standards, ensuring user trust and regulatory compliance? And importantly, what technological choices must be made to build a resilient, scalable, and interoperable CBDC infrastructure?

As we navigate these questions, it becomes clear that the successful implementation of CBDCs requires a nuanced understanding of various interrelated domains. From cybersecurity, transaction security, and network resilience to data management, analytics, and regulatory compliance, each aspect plays a crucial role in shaping the CBDC landscape. Moreover, the choice of core ledger technology – whether blockchain-based, centralized, or a hybrid approach – has far-reaching implications for the performance, security, and acceptance of CBDCs [2].

This latest article delves into these critical areas, offering insights and analyses that are essential for policymakers, financial experts, and technology enthusiasts alike. As we stand at the cusp of a digital currency revolution, it is essential to foster an informed dialogue on the path forward for CBDCs – a path that balances innovation with stability, efficiency with privacy, and progress with security.

The Emergence of CBDCs: A Global Overview

In recent years, the financial world has witnessed a paradigm shift with the emergence of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs), a digital form of central bank money. This transformation is not just a fleeting trend but a global movement, reshaping how we think about money and transactions in an increasingly digital economy.

The level of global interest in central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) is unprecedented. According to the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) survey in 2022, 93 percent of central banks are exploring CBDCs, and 58 percent consider that they are likely to or might possibly issue a retail CBDC in either the short or medium term (Kosse and Mattei 2023). Indeed, retail CBDC issuance is being explored in more than 100 countries. Several central banks have already launched pilots or even issued a CBDC [10].

As recently highlighted by Kraft and Gross (CoinDesk, 2023), CBDCs are navigating a path characterized by deliberation and measured, but consistent, growth. The philosophy of "slow and steady" isn't simply a lack of urgency by citizens to use CBDCs or a failure to kickstart into a sprint. Instead, it's also a thoughtful, measured approach that, albeit seemingly slower, is endorsed by its benefits. CBDCs aren't stepping into a void, but rather into a bustling, ever-crowded digital money landscape, making it all the more crucial to build a stable foundation amidst this clamor [13].

Adopting CBDCs gradually promotes sustainability, permits thorough testing and improvements to technology, encourages a thorough process for creating policies, and raises public knowledge gradually. Central banks make sure they discover their "sweet spot" in the fiercely competitive world of digital currency by implementing CBDCs gradually [13].

The Global Landscape of CBDC Adoption

As of the latest update (November 2023), over 90% of the world's central banks were actively exploring or developing CBDCs. This widespread interest stems from a variety of factors, including the desire to improve financial inclusion, enhance the efficiency of payment systems, and respond to the declining use of cash. Notably, the COVID-19 pandemic accelerated this interest, as digital payments became more prominent.

Leading Examples

• The Bahamas' Sand Dollar: As one of the first fully-functional CBDCs, the Sand Dollar aims to enhance financial inclusion across the Bahamas' many islands, addressing challenges related to banking access.
• Nigeria's eNaira: Launched in October 2021, the eNaira is a bold step by the Central Bank of Nigeria to foster financial inclusion, improve payment efficiency, and facilitate remittances. It represents a significant move in a large African economy towards embracing digital currency.
• Jamaica's Jam-DEX: The Bank of Jamaica is pioneering its digital currency, Jam-DEX, aimed at improving transaction efficiency and financial inclusion. This initiative is particularly noteworthy as it represents a significant step in the Caribbean region towards digital currency adoption.

Whilst this is not fully live, China's Digital Yuan (e-CNY) has been a frontrunner in CBDC development, conducting extensive trials and aiming to increase the international reach of its currency. An overview of the latest CBDC statuses is illustrated below based on the CBDC Tracker (November, 2023) [3].

While banks and financial institutions worldwide experiment with CBDCs and launch pilot programs, it is clear that adoption remains steady, albeit slow. A key takeaway, however, is that there is a consistent and growing interest in CBDC globally, even as authorities proceed with caution (Kraft & Gross, 2023).

Trends and Patterns in CBDC Development

1. Diverse Motivations: Different countries pursue CBDCs for varied reasons, from bolstering financial inclusion in underbanked regions to maintaining control over monetary policy in the face of rising private digital currencies. For example, Financial Inclusion: Countries like Nigeria (with its eNaira) and The Bahamas (Sand Dollar) are focusing on CBDCs to enhance financial inclusion, especially in remote or underserved areas. Whereas others have focused on Digital Economy Transition: Sweden's e-Krona reflects a response to the country's rapid move towards a cashless society.
2. Technological Experimentation: There's a significant variation in the technological approaches to CBDCs. While some countries are leaning towards blockchain or distributed ledger technology (DLT), others are considering more traditional digital currency systems.
3. Focus on Cross-Border Payments: Many central banks are collaborating to explore how CBDCs can facilitate faster and cheaper cross-border payments, a traditionally complex and costly process. The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) is facilitating multiple projects, like 'Project Dunbar', which involves central banks from Australia, Malaysia, Singapore, and South Africa, exploring cross-border payments using CBDCs. Project M-Bridge: A collaboration between the Hong Kong Monetary Authority, the Bank of Thailand, the Central Bank of the United Arab Emirates, and the Digital Currency Institute of the People's Bank of China. This project aims to create a cross-border corridor network for CBDCs to facilitate more efficient and secure international transactions.
4. Privacy Concerns: Balancing privacy with regulatory compliance, particularly in AML and CTF, is a key challenge. Different jurisdictions are taking varied approaches to this issue. The European Central Bank (ECB) in its exploration of a digital euro is placing a strong emphasis on privacy, balancing it with regulatory requirements whereas China’s Digital Yuan has sparked discussions about user privacy in the context of a state-issued digital currency. The Bank of Canada has also been vocal about prioritizing privacy in its exploration of a potential CBDC. Recognizing the delicate balance between privacy and the need for regulatory compliance, the Canadian approach reflects a commitment to uphold individual privacy rights while ensuring the effectiveness of AML and CTF measures.
5. Pilot Programs and Research: Numerous countries are in different stages of CBDC exploration, from theoretical research to pilot programs. These pilots are crucial for understanding the practical challenges and impacts of CBDCs. Advanced Pilots: China is in advanced stages of piloting the Digital Yuan in various cities. Research Phase: The U.S. The Federal Reserve is still in the research phase, evaluating the potential benefits and risks of a digital dollar.
6. Public and Private Sector Collaboration: There's an increasing trend of collaboration between central banks and private sector entities, leveraging the latter's innovation and technology expertise. The collaboration between the private sector and central banks is evident in the development of the eNaira in Nigeria, where fintech companies played a significant role.

Core Ledger Technologies: The Foundation of CBDC

The backbone of any Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) is its underlying ledger technology. This foundational layer not only dictates the operational efficiency and scalability of the CBDC but also influences its security, privacy, and overall architectural design. As central banks around the world explore CBDCs, a diverse array of core ledger technologies has come to the forefront, each offering unique advantages and posing distinct challenges.

1. Blockchain and Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT)

• Public Blockchain: Some CBDC projects consider public blockchains, which are decentralized and transparent. However, they often face challenges in scalability and privacy, which are crucial for a national currency.
• Private/Permissioned Blockchain: More commonly favored for CBDCs, these blockchains offer greater control and privacy. They allow only authorized nodes to participate, which can help in adhering to regulatory standards and ensuring system integrity. For instance, China's Digital Yuan utilizes a permissioned blockchain structure.
• Consortium Blockchain: This is a middle ground, managed by a group of organizations rather than a single entity. It offers a balance of decentralization and control, potentially suitable for CBDCs that seek collaborative governance, as seen in some cross-border payment projects.

2. Centralized Ledger Systems

• Traditional Database Systems: These systems, managed centrally by the issuing authority (like a central bank), offer high throughput and easier control over monetary policy and regulatory compliance. However, they lack the decentralization aspect, which can be a critical factor for trust and security in the digital currency space.
• Distributed Database Systems: While still under central control, these systems distribute data across multiple locations for redundancy and potentially faster access. They offer a compromise between traditional centralized systems and fully decentralized models.

3. Hybrid Systems

• Combining DLT with Centralized Systems: Some CBDC initiatives are exploring hybrid models that integrate elements of both DLT and centralized systems. This approach aims to leverage the benefits of blockchain technology, like enhanced security and transparency, while retaining the control and efficiency of centralized systems.

4. Emerging Technologies

• Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG): Unlike traditional blockchains, DAGs allow for faster transaction processing times and scalability, which can be crucial for a national digital currency dealing with high transaction volumes.
• Quantum-Resistant Ledgers: With the advent of quantum computing, some CBDC projects are considering the long-term implications on security. Quantum-resistant ledgers are being explored to ensure that the CBDC remains secure against future technological advancements.

Security: Fortifying the Digital Currency

In the realm of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs), security is not just a feature but a cornerstone. As digital representations of a nation's currency, CBDCs demand an unparalleled level of security to maintain trust, integrity, and stability in the financial system. This imperative for robust security spans several dimensions, each critical to the successful operation and acceptance of a CBDC [4].

At the forefront is cybersecurity. CBDCs, like any digital system, are susceptible to cyber threats, including hacking and digital fraud. Ensuring the security of a CBDC involves implementing state-of-the-art cybersecurity measures, such as advanced encryption, secure coding practices, and continuous monitoring for vulnerabilities. For instance, the use of blockchain or DLT in some CBDCs inherently includes cryptographic security measures, but these must be complemented with additional layers of defense to protect against evolving cyber threats.

Transaction security is another vital aspect. Every transaction in a CBDC network must be secure and tamper-proof. Techniques like digital signatures and cryptographic hashing are employed to ensure the authenticity and integrity of transactions. Moreover, the ledger technology chosen (be it blockchain, a centralized database, or a hybrid) plays a significant role in how transactions are verified and recorded, impacting the overall security of the system.

Network security is equally crucial. Protecting the infrastructure that supports the CBDC — from servers to communication networks — is essential to prevent attacks such as Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS). This involves not only technical solutions like firewalls and intrusion detection systems but also operational practices like regular security audits and response protocols for potential breaches.

The security of a CBDC also extends to data privacy and protection. Ensuring the confidentiality of user data and transaction details is paramount, especially in an era where data privacy concerns are at an all-time high. This involves compliance with data protection laws, implementation of privacy-enhancing technologies, and careful design to balance transparency with privacy.

Furthermore, the resilience of the CBDC system against various risks — including technical failures, natural disasters, and other operational disruptions — is critical. This requires robust disaster recovery and business continuity plans to ensure that the CBDC remains operational under all circumstances.

Encryption is another key dimension when it comes to security. In CBDCs, encryption is the process of encoding data so that only authorized parties may access or decrypt it. Sensitive data, including transactional data, user identities, and balances, are protected from unwanted access and potential cyberattacks thanks to this encryption. Encryption contributes to the privacy protection of CBDC consumers. Data encryption makes it more difficult for unauthorized parties to access sensitive data, including account balances, transaction histories, and other personal information. In order to guarantee that consumers have control over their financial data and that it is not disclosed without authorization, privacy is crucial [5].

One should also note that when it comes to security, privacy needs to be balanced alongside it. While CBDCs offer numerous benefits such as increased efficiency and financial inclusion, they also raise concerns regarding privacy and security. In this regard, encryption plays a crucial role in ensuring that CBDCs are both secure and private for users [5]. Although encryption protects data, it may also make it more difficult for authorities to keep an eye on illicit activities like financing of terrorism and money laundering. As a result, finding a balance between privacy and security issues is essential.

Establishing a transparent encryption system that permits authorized parties, including regulators, to access encrypted data when needed is one method to strike this balance. For example, the Monetary Authority of Singapore has put in place an encryption system that guarantees user privacy protection while permitting regulators to access encrypted data [6].

Utilizing a multi-layered encryption scheme is an additional means of guaranteeing the confidentiality and integrity of CBDCs. This technology encrypts data on several layers, increasing the difficulty for cybercriminals to compromise the system. To protect the security of its digital euro, for instance, the European Central Bank is investigating the use of multi-layered encryption [7].

Interoperability: Integrating with Existing Financial Systems

Interoperability stands as a critical pillar in the successful implementation of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs). It involves the seamless integration of CBDCs with existing financial systems, both domestically and internationally. This integration is essential for ensuring that CBDCs can function alongside traditional currencies and financial infrastructures, facilitating a smooth transition and widespread adoption.

At the domestic level, interoperability means that CBDCs must effectively work within the existing financial ecosystem, including commercial banks, payment networks, and other financial services. This integration is crucial for maintaining the efficiency of financial transactions and ensuring that CBDCs are accessible and convenient for all users. For instance, users should be able to easily convert between digital and traditional forms of currency and use CBDCs for a wide range of transactions, from retail purchases to large-scale financial transfers. Achieving this requires robust technical solutions, such as compatible software interfaces and standardized protocols, which allow different systems to communicate and exchange data seamlessly.

Internationally, interoperability takes on an additional layer of complexity. CBDCs must be able to interact with different currencies and regulatory environments. This is particularly important for cross-border transactions, where CBDCs have the potential to significantly reduce costs and increase speed. Projects like 'Project Dunbar' and 'Project M-Bridge' are exploring this aspect, aiming to create a cross-border payment network using CBDCs. Such initiatives require collaboration among central banks, international regulatory alignment, and the development of common standards to ensure smooth and secure transactions across borders [8].

In October 2023, the BIS Innovation Hub published an update on Project mBridge, a collaborative effort to experiment with a multi-CBDC platform for cross-border payments. The update highlights the following key findings:

• Project mBridge has successfully demonstrated the feasibility of using CBDCs for cross-border payments. The project team has been able to conduct real-time, peer-to-peer cross-border payments and foreign exchange transactions using CBDCs.

• The mBridge platform has the potential to significantly reduce the cost, speed, and complexity of cross-border payments. The platform can eliminate the need for intermediaries, such as correspondent banks, which can significantly reduce costs. Additionally, the platform can automate many of the manual processes involved in cross-border payments, which can reduce errors and improve efficiency.
• The mBridge platform is designed to be interoperable with other CBDC platforms. This means that central banks can use the platform to connect with other central banks that have issued CBDCs, even if those CBDCs are based on different technologies.

The basic takeaway from the latest findings on Project mBridge is that CBDCs have the potential to revolutionize cross-border payments. The mBridge platform has demonstrated that CBDCs can be used to make cross-border payments faster, cheaper, and more efficiently. Additionally, the platform's interoperability design means that it can be used to connect a wide range of CBDCs, which could foster greater financial inclusion and economic growth [8].

However, achieving interoperability is not without challenges. It involves navigating a landscape of diverse regulatory standards, ensuring compliance with international anti-money laundering (AML) and counter-terrorism financing (CTF) regulations, and addressing technical hurdles related to system compatibility. Moreover, there is the challenge of ensuring that the privacy and security of transactions are maintained across different jurisdictions and systems [9].

Some of the key challenges include:

• Technical heterogeneity: CBDCs may be based on different technologies, such as distributed ledger technology (DLT) or centralized systems. This heterogeneity can make it difficult for different CBDC platforms to communicate with each other.
• Regulatory fragmentation: CBDCs are subject to different regulatory frameworks in different jurisdictions. This fragmentation can create legal and compliance hurdles for cross-border CBDC payments.
• Governance: Central banks will need to agree on common standards and governance arrangements for CBDC interoperability. This will require international cooperation and coordination.
• Data privacy and security: Cross-border CBDC payments will involve the sharing of sensitive data, such as customer identities and transaction details. Central banks will need to ensure that this data is protected from unauthorized access and use.

The success of a CBDC hinges not just on its technological robustness or economic design but also on its accessibility and inclusivity. A CBDC must cater to a wide range of users, from tech-savvy individuals to those with limited digital literacy, ensuring that everyone can benefit from this digital financial evolution.

Prioritising Ease of Use

The interface and interaction design of CBDC platforms should be intuitive and user-friendly. This involves creating simple, clear, and navigable interfaces that can be easily understood, regardless of a user's technical background. For instance, the digital wallet or application used for transacting with the CBDC should be straightforward, with clear instructions and support features. This simplicity is crucial in encouraging adoption among those who might be hesitant to transition from traditional cash to digital currencies.

1. Financial Inclusion

A significant advantage of CBDCs is their potential to enhance financial inclusion, especially in regions with limited access to traditional banking services. To realize this potential, CBDCs must be designed to be accessible to people without advanced technology or high-speed internet. This might involve offline transaction capabilities or the integration of CBDCs with simple mobile technology, rather than relying solely on smartphones or high-end devices [10].

Financial inclusion is a key policy objective that central banks, especially those in emerging and low-income countries, are considering for retail CBDC. About 60 percent of emerging and low-income countries see financial inclusion as one of the top three motivations for issuing CBDC (Kosse and Mattei 2023). Globally, 1.4 billion people remain outside of the formal financial system, and tackling this challenge is a top priority in many regions.

Because households globally are still mostly cash-based households, those who are financially excluded are ostracized from the official sector [9]. Financial services are not possible without payments; these include overdraft credit lines, deposits, withdrawals, and increasingly digitalized repayments. Because dealing with low-income families is expensive for banks, insurance firms, and other organizations, the "cash-digital divide" creates a barrier between them and the formal economy.

CBDCs have the potential to become accepted as a digital payment method by those who are financially excluded if they are appropriately crafted to overcome the obstacles to financial inclusion. As "digital cash," CBDC may be made to mimic some of the advantageous characteristics of cash. For example, CBDC makes financial inclusion more accessible by enabling usage without the need for a bank account. For modest transactions, CBDC might be utilized similarly to cash, with minimal or no fees and less strict identity criteria for low-risk groups that have trouble getting official identity documents. It is also possible to create 3 CBDCs that function in offline settings. From the standpoint of credit risk, a CBDC may be just as reliable and risk-free as actual currency as it is a direct responsibility of the central bank.

2. Catering to Diverse Needs

CBDCs can help to promote financial inclusion by providing access to financial services to people who are currently unbanked or underbanked. This could include people in remote areas, people with disabilities, and people who are unbanked due to lack of documentation. CBDCs could also be used to make financial services more affordable, as they would eliminate the need for intermediaries such as banks.

Different user groups have varying needs and preferences. For example, the elderly or people with disabilities may require additional accessibility features. Similarly, businesses and individuals will have different use cases for a CBDC. Tailoring the UX to accommodate these diverse requirements is essential. This could involve customizable interfaces, multilingual support, and features that address specific needs, such as large text options or voice commands for users with visual impairments.

CBDCs can also help to protect consumer privacy by providing a more secure and transparent way to make payments. CBDC transactions are recorded on a distributed ledger, which is a tamper-proof record of all transactions. This means that CBDC transactions are more difficult to counterfeit and fraud than traditional electronic payments [12].

3. Education and Awareness

One of the key challenges to CBDC adoption is ensuring that consumers are aware of and understand how to use these new digital currencies. Central banks can play a role in easing the use of CBDCs by providing training and awareness programs. This could include:

• Developing educational resources and tools: Central banks can develop educational resources, such as websites, videos, and brochures, to help consumers learn about CBDCs. They can also develop tools, such as CBDC wallets and simulators, to help consumers practice using CBDCs.
• Partnering with financial institutions: Central banks can partner with financial institutions, such as banks and credit unions, to provide CBDC education and training. This can help to reach a wider audience of consumers.
• Leveraging technology: Central banks can use technology to reach consumers with CBDC education and training. This could include using social media, online platforms, and mobile apps.

Educating the public about the use and benefits of CBDCs is another critical aspect of UX. Comprehensive educational campaigns can demystify CBDCs, address common concerns, and provide guidance on how to use digital currencies safely and effectively. These campaigns could include workshops, online tutorials, and informational materials distributed through various channels.

4. Continuous Improvement

Finally, the UX of CBDCs should not be static. Continuous feedback loops, involving user testing and surveys, can provide insights into how the system is being used and where improvements are needed. This iterative approach ensures that the CBDC evolves in line with user needs and technological advancements.

Conclusion: Embracing the Digital Currency Era

As we stand at the threshold of a new era in finance, marked by the advent of Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs), it's clear that we are not just witnessing a technological revolution, but a fundamental reshaping of how money is perceived and used. The journey towards CBDCs is more than a mere shift from physical to digital; it's a stride towards a future that promises greater efficiency, inclusivity, and innovation in the global financial landscape.

The exploration and development of CBDCs across various nations have highlighted the immense potential these digital currencies hold. From enhancing financial inclusion and streamlining cross-border transactions to fortifying security and ensuring greater economic stability, CBDCs could address some of the most pressing challenges of our current financial systems. However, this journey is not without its complexities. As we have seen, the successful implementation of CBDCs requires meticulous consideration of various factors, including the choice of core ledger technology, ensuring robust security, maintaining user privacy, achieving interoperability, and providing an inclusive and accessible user experience.

The global landscape of CBDC development is a tapestry of diverse approaches and strategies, reflecting the unique economic, technological, and regulatory environments of each region. This diversity is not a hurdle but rather a strength, offering a wealth of insights and lessons as countries embark on their CBDC journeys. The collaborative efforts seen in cross-border payment projects and the shared learning from pilot programs underscore the importance of collective progress in this domain [14].

As we move forward, it is crucial for policymakers, technologists, and financial experts to continue fostering dialogue and collaboration. The decisions made today will shape the financial infrastructure of tomorrow. It is an opportunity to build systems that are not only technologically advanced but also equitable and resilient, catering to the needs of all segments of society.

Embracing the digital currency era is about more than adopting new technology; it's about reimagining and reinventing the financial landscape for a better future. As we continue to navigate the complexities and opportunities of CBDCs, let us do so with a vision that is forward-thinking, inclusive, and grounded in the principles of security, efficiency, and public trust. The era of digital currency is not just upon us; it is ours to shape and define.

Citations:

• [1] Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) - Virtual Handbook. [online] Available at: https://www.imf.org/en/Topics/fintech/central-bank-digital-currency/virtual-handbook.
• [2] Brookings. (n.d.). Design choices for central bank digital currency. [online] Available at: https://www.brookings.edu/articles/design-choices-for-central-bank-digital-currency/.
• [3] Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) Tracker. (n.d.). Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) Tracker. [online] Available at: https://cbdctracker.org/.
• [4] Central bank digital currency (CBDC) information security and operational risks to central banks. (2023). www.bis.org. [online] Available at: https://www.bis.org/publ/othp81.htm [Accessed 4 Dec. 2023].
• [5] CBDC Privacy Concerns: Striking the Right Balance. [online] Available at: https://fastercapital.com/content/CBDC-Privacy-Concerns--Striking-the-Right-Balance.html#Ensuring-Privacy-and-Security [Accessed 4 Dec. 2023].
• [6] www.mas.gov.sg. (n.d.). ‘Yes to Digital Asset Innovation, No to Cryptocurrency Speculation’ - Opening Address by Mr Ravi Menon, Managing Director, Monetary Authority of Singapore, at Green Shoots Seminar on 29 August 2022. [online] Available at: https://www.mas.gov.sg/news/speeches/2022/yes-to-digital-asset-innovation-no-to-cryptocurrency-speculation.
• [7] ARTICLES THE EUROPEAN STABILITY MECHANISM. (2011). Available at: https://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/other/art2_mb201107en_pp71-84en.pdf.
• [8] Multiple CBDC (mCBDC) Bridge. (2021). www.bis.org. [online] Available at: https://www.bis.org/about/bisih/topics/cbdc/mcbdc_bridge.htm.
• [9] World Economic Forum. (n.d.). Central Bank Digital Currency Global Interoperability Principles. [online] Available at: https://www.weforum.org/publications/central-bank-digital-currency-global-interoperability-principles/.
• [10] IMF. (n.d.). Central Bank Digital Currency’s Role in Promoting Financial Inclusion. [online] Available at: https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fintech-notes/Issues/2023/09/22/Central-Bank-Digital-Currency-s-Role-in-Promoting-Financial-Inclusion-538728.
• [11] Kosse, A. and Mattei, I. (2023). Making headway -Results of the 2022 BIS survey on central bank digital currencies and crypto. [online] Available at: https://www.bis.org/publ/bppdf/bispap136.pdf.
• [12] blogs.worldbank.org. (n.d.). CBDC and financial inclusion: Changing the paradigm (Part 1). [online] Available at: https://blogs.worldbank.org/allaboutfinance/cbdc-and-financial-inclusion-changing-paradigm-part-1.
• [13] Kraft, J.G. and C. (2023). The Subtle Art of Slow: The CBDC Adoption Journey. [online] www.coindesk.com. Available at: https://www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/11/15/the-subtle-art-of-slow-the-cbdc-adoption-journey/ [Accessed 4 Dec. 2023].
• [14] Syed, M. (2023). Designing the IT Solution Architecture for a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC). [online] Available at: https://www.dhirubhai.net/pulse/designing-solution-architecture-central-bank-digital-currency-syed/ [Accessed 4 Dec. 2023].