A self defeating policy

IS DITCHING THE PROTOCOL GOOD FOR THE UNION..






While visiting relatives in London , I was invited to give an interview to Times Radio yesterday .?


It was a great chance to speak to to an English audience.


The subject was the stated policy of Liz?Truss?not only to enact , but to implement , the legislation that would unilaterally disapply a Protocol , that the?UK freely agreed to in an international treaty , signed and then ratified by the UK Parliament.?


This extraordinary and damaging course , for the UK , is being justified on the grounds that it is good for the Union, by which is meant in this case the union of Britain and?

Northern Ireland.


Indeed it is being pressed forward by a?self described “Conservative” and supposedly “Unionist” party.


My argument to Times Radio listeners was that this?radical , and deeply unconservative,?attempt to break a solemn treaty , is actually DAMAGING to the Union, for the following reasons


1. It is opposed by a majority in Northern Ireland. A majority there would like changes to the Protocol alright , but do not favour such a radical course as Truss is insisting upon. Adopting a course , in defiance of a majority view in Northern Ireland,?politically weakens “unionist” sentiment there. That should be fairly obvious.


2. Northern Ireland has prospered disproportionately under the Protocol.?


From being one of the worst performing regions of the UK before the Protocol, Northern Ireland has become second best after London , under the Protocol.?


Prosperity in Northern Ireland, as part of the UK and under the Protocol , is objectively good for the Union. Business in Northern Ireland knows this. The “ Conservative and Unionist” party in Britain does not seem to care.?


Incidentally, the more Northern Ireland prospers under the Protocol, the less subsidisation will it require from London, which also would strengthen the Union.?


3 . Unilaterally ditching the Protocol will initiate a a major trade war between the UK, including Northern Ireland, and the EU. Liz Truss, a former Trade Secretary, knows this.


?This trade war will inevitably be disproportionately severe on Northern Ireland , because it is a region?directly on the UK/EU frontier. Again this is obvious.?


The consequences of this UK initiated trade war will?thus be bad for the Union because it will hurt the people of Northern Ireland more than anyone else in the UK. Again, that is bad for the Union.


Incidentally, this UK initiated trade war will also weaken the western alliance economic and political capacity to support Ukraine, a concern for democrats everywhere.


4 . Ditching the Protocol will not restore the?economic status quo ante?for Northern Ireland that preceded the Protocol, when it was lagging behind the rest of the UK.


The new situation will be much worse than that for Northern Ireland. This is because the economy there will be engulfed in?new duplicative bureaucracy of a kind never seen before.


Long existing links will be broken.?

Supply chains will be destroyed.?

Expensive investments will be rendered valueless.?


This is because the ditching of the Protocol will allow the UK to impose increasingly different product regulations in Northern Ireland , to the ones it uses at the moment and which allow it free access to the EU market, the only market in the world to which Northern Ireland has?unimpeded road access.?


The damage will be be felt especially severely by Northern Ireland’s dairy sector.


One third of Northern Ireland milk is processed in the EU?( in Ireland).?There are 5400 dairy businesses in Northern Ireland and the business generates 1.5 billion sterling every year.. This cross border processing?of Northern Ireland milk have to stop if?the milk is longer produced to EU standards. This will be massively disruptive .


To get around that ,?a special supply chain would have to developed, separate from the one for supply?for milk destined for the NI/ UK .?Northern Ireland Farmers will be forced to choose to be EU or UK suppliers, whereas they can be both at the moment.


Massive duplication and additional expense would the thus be imposed on dairy producers in Northern Ireland , most of whom?probably vote for “unionist” parties,?and who are enterprising people , and vital contributors to their neighbourhoods. They do not deserve this.


So ditching?the Protocol will not only be bad for the Union, it will be bad for unionists.


For all these reasons Liz Truss’ policy is not only unConsrvative, it is anti Unionist !

Edward Donelan: Consultant PhD????; Translation: "Using a client's clock, to tell them the time; due to his: Permanent head Damage!?" QED!

回复
Edward Donelan

Consultant in Regulatory Governance (Policy - making, legislative drafting and managing the stock of legislation)

2 年

Time for John Bruton to recede into his shell and shut up. He did little in Office and less since.

回复
Gerry Walsh

Managing Director at Barentz Ireland Limited

2 年

A very logical assessment of the situation.

回复
James K.

Commissioning Qualification Engineer

2 年

Great Analysis John

回复
Richard H.

Audit and assurance partner at Deloitte Ireland with a deep interest in tech.

2 年

Another clearly thought out viewpoint as ever. Thank you.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

John Bruton的更多文章

  • DEMOCRACY AND THE THREAT OF WAR

    DEMOCRACY AND THE THREAT OF WAR

    LESSONS FOR TODAY Last week, I published here a short review of aspects of Frank McDonough’s book “The Weimar Years”, a…

  • A Moving Experience

    A Moving Experience

    SHANE MCGOWAN RIP Watching Shane McGowans funeral Mass in Nenagh was, for me, one of the most moving experiences of…

    5 条评论
  • a great article

    a great article

    I am reprinting below a brilliant article published by Tony Connelly ne the RTE website. It deserves to read and read…

    2 条评论
  • David Sweetman RIP

    David Sweetman RIP

    LEADING FIGURE IN THE RESTORATION OF TRIM CASTLE Tribute by John Bruton, former Taoiseach I wish to pay tribute to the…

  • GAZA

    GAZA

    WHAT IS JUSTICE? There is a tendency, in the media reporting of crimes, to mix up retribution with justice. In my view,…

    19 条评论
  • A SYMPTOM OF POLITICAL FAILURE

    A SYMPTOM OF POLITICAL FAILURE

    PUNISHMENT SHOOTINGS TREBLE According to figures released by the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) , the number…

  • THE IRISH CIVIL WAR

    THE IRISH CIVIL WAR

    WERE THERE TWO CIVIL WARS OR JUST ONE? I have just finished reading the “Civil War in Dublin” by John Dorney. Dorney…

    1 条评论
  • WE NEED ONE VOICE ON FOREIGN POLICY

    WE NEED ONE VOICE ON FOREIGN POLICY

    Statement by John Bruton, former Taoiseach The President of Ireland, Michael D Higgins, chose the address he was…

    12 条评论
  • CENTRAL ASIA

    CENTRAL ASIA

    STRATEGIC BATTLEGROUND OF THE FUTURE? I have just completed a very informative book , about a part of the world, of…

  • ECONOMICS IN THE ROCKIES

    ECONOMICS IN THE ROCKIES

    JACKSONS HOLE Jacksons Hole is a valley in the Rocky Mountains in Wyoming. It has a number of ski resorts and is one…

    4 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了