Select Talent by What Matters Most

The NHL has a long history of valuing tall goaltenders, with many believing that the added height gives them a more significant advantage in the crease. However, this belief has been challenged in recent years as several shorter goaltenders have made a name for themselves at the sport's highest level.

One such goaltender is Team Canada's Thomas Milic, who stands at 6'0" and plays for the Western Hockey League's Seattle Thunderbirds. Despite his relatively small stature by NHL standards, Milic has been a star since his rookie season and has consistently put up impressive numbers, proving that his body of work matters more than 3" of height.

So why do NHL teams continue to prioritize tall goaltenders over those like Milic, who have a proven track record of success? It's a question that has no easy answer, but there are a few factors that likely come into play.

One reason for the preference for tall goaltenders is that they can cover more net with their extended reach. This can be especially important on high shots, where a taller goaltender may be more likely to make the save. However, this advantage is less pronounced than some may believe, as several shorter goaltenders have proven that they are more capable of remaining economical vs making more acrobatic saves. They now have figured out how to maximize their net-space coverage by prioritizing depth, angle and squareness and covering a significant portion of the net through "articulated pivots."

Another factor that may contribute to the preference for tall goaltenders is the perception that they are more intimidating to shooters. Some believe that the added height of a taller goaltender can make it more difficult for opposing players to score, as they may be more hesitant to shoot in their direction. However, this is essentially a psychological advantage, and it's worth noting that many shorter goaltenders have successfully used their quick reflexes, agility and economic movements to compensate for any perceived physical disadvantage.

One thing to consider is that NHL teams may be more willing to take a chance on a taller goaltender because they have a higher upside. This is because fewer tall goaltenders are available, so those who do make it to the NHL may be in higher demand. However, this doesn't necessarily mean they are a better investment or asset for a team. Many shorter goaltenders have proven to be more consistent and durable over their careers, making them a more reliable long-term option.

It's important to note that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to choosing a goaltender, and each team will have its criteria for what it values in a player. However, size should not be the only factor considered when evaluating goaltenders. A player like Thomas Milic, who has a substantial body of work, impressive stats, career longevity, and emotional control, should be noticed because he doesn't fit the traditional mould of an NHL goaltender.

In the end, what matters most is a goaltender's ability to make saves and help his team win games consistently. And while height may be a factor in some cases, it's ultimately just one of many attributes that NHL teams should consider when choosing their franchise goaltender. I suppose we will need to wait for the 2023 draft for Thomas Milic for a second chance to make a "solid gold" impression on NHL's Hockey Brass.