Senior Vice President, Global Lead Data & AI Solutions Engineering | Field CDAO and CISO | Technology Thought Leader | Driving Customer Value with differentiated Cloud, Data, AI and Security solutions
As the cybersecurity landscape continues to evolve, the challenges associated with defending against cyber threats have grown exponentially. Threat vectors have expanded, and cyber attackers now employ increasingly sophisticated tools and methods. Moreover, the complexity of managing security in today's distributed hybrid/multi-cloud architecture, heavily reliant on high-speed connectivity for both people and IoT devices, further compounds the challenges of #cyberdefense.
One of the foremost concerns for corporate executives and boards of directors is the demonstrable effectiveness of cybersecurity investments. However, quantifying and justifying the appropriate level of spending remains a formidable obstacle for most enterprise security teams. Securing additional budget allocations to bolster an already robust security posture becomes particularly challenging in the face of a rising number of #cyberbreaches, which have inflicted substantial reputational and financial harm on companies across diverse industries.
The modern enterprise's IT infrastructure is an intricate web of dynamic networks, cloud resources, an array of software applications, and a multitude of endpoint devices. These enterprise IT ecosystems are vast and intricate, featuring a myriad of network solutions, a diverse array of endpoint devices, and a mix of Windows and Linux servers. Additionally, you'll find desktops and laptops running various versions of both Windows and macOS dispersed throughout this intricate landscape. Each component within this architecture boasts its own set of #securitycontrols, making the enterprise susceptible to #cyberthreats due to even the slightest misconfiguration or a shift towards less secure settings.
In this environment, a simple misconfiguration, or even a minor deviation towards less secure configurations, can provide attackers with the foothold they need to breach an organization's infrastructure, networks, devices, and software. It underscores the critical importance of maintaining a vigilant and proactive approach to cybersecurity in this ever-evolving digital era.
As organizations look for ways to demonstrate the effectiveness of their security spend and the policies and procedures put in place to remediate and respond to security threats, vulnerability testing can be an important component of a security team’s vulnerability management activities. There are several testing approaches that organizations use as part of their vulnerability management practices. Four of the most common are listed below:
Penetration testing: is a common testing approach that Enterprises employ to uncover vulnerabilities in their infrastructure. A Pen test involves highly skilled security experts using tools and attack methods employed by actual attackers to achieve a specific pre-defined breach objective. The pen test covers networks, applications, and endpoint devices.
?Red Teaming: A red team performs “ethical hacking” by imitating advanced threat actors to test an organization's cyber defenses. They employ stealthy techniques to identify security gaps, offering valuable insights to enhance defenses. The results from a red-teaming exercise help identify needed improvements in security controls.
Blue Teaming: is an internal security team that actively defend against real attackers and respond to red team activities. Blue Teams should be distinguished from standard security teams because of the mission to provide constant and continuous cyber defense against all forms of cyber-attacks.
Purple Teaming: The objective of purple teams is to align red and blue team efforts. By leveraging insights from both sides, they provide a comprehensive understanding of cyber threats, prioritize vulnerabilities, and offer a realistic APT (Advanced Persistent Threat) experience to improve overall security.
Although these vulnerability testing approaches are commonly used by organizations, there are several challenges associated with them:
These approaches are highly manual and resource intensive, which for many organizations translates to high cost and a lack of skilled in-house resources to perform these tests.
The outcome of these vulnerability tests provides vital information back to the organization to act on, they are performed infrequently due largely to the cost and lack of skilled resources mentioned previously.
These methods provide a point-in-time view of an organization’s security posture which is becoming less effective for companies moving to a more dynamic cloud-based IT architecture with an increasing diversity of endpoints and applications.
Traditional vulnerability testing approaches yield very little value because the security landscape and enterprise IT architectures are dynamic and constantly changing.?
Since testing the cybersecurity posture of organizations is becoming a top priority, it triggered an increased demand for the latest and most comprehensive testing solutions. Moreover, it’s almost impossible, from a practical standpoint, for multiple enterprise security teams to manually coordinate their work and optimize configurations for all the overlapping systems. Different teams have their own management tasks, mandates, and security concerns. Additionally, performing constant optimizations and manual testing imposes a heavy burden on already short-staffed security teams. This is why security teams are turning to Breach and Attack Simulation (BAS)to mitigate constantly emerging (and mostly self-inflicted) security weaknesses.
Definition - Breach and Attack Simulation (BAS)
?Gartner?defines, Breach and Attack Simulation (BAS) technologies as tools “that allow enterprises to continually and consistently simulate the full attack cycle (including insider threats, lateral movement and data exfiltration) against enterprise infrastructure, using software agents, virtual machines and other means.”
BAS tools replicate real-world cyber attacker tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs). They assist organizations in proactively identifying vulnerabilities, evaluating security controls, and improving incident response readiness. By simulating these attacks in a controlled environment, organizations gain valuable insights into security weaknesses, enabling proactive measures to strengthen overall #cybersecurity.
BAS automates the testing of threat vectors, including external and insider threats, lateral movement, and data exfiltration. While it complements red teaming and penetration testing, BAS cannot entirely replace them. It validates an organization's security posture by testing its ability to detect a range of simulated attacks using SaaS platforms, software agents, and virtual machines.
Most BAS solutions operate seamlessly on LAN networks without disrupting critical business operations. They produce detailed reports highlighting security gaps and prioritize remediation efforts based on risk levels. Typical users of BAS technologies include financial institutions, insurance companies, and various other industries.
BAS Primary Functions
Typical BAS offerings encompass much of what traditional vulnerability testing includes, it differs in a very critical way. At a high level, BAS primary functions are as follows:
Attack?(mimic / simulate real threats)
Visualize?(clear picture of threat and exposures)
Prioritize?(assign a severity or criticality rating to exploitable vulnerabilities)
Remediate?(mitigate / address gaps)
Where BAS differs from traditional approaches is in the use of closed loop automation that allows IT/security teams to evaluate an environment for threat indicators and attack behaviors, unprotected assets, misconfigurations, human errors, log gaps, and basic IT hygiene issues. Armed with this information, security personnel can take the recommended actions to close gaps, fix misconfigurations, strengthen credential management. The other key differentiator for BAS is in the variety of ways (on-demand, continuous, or set interval) vulnerability test can be performed. This gives security teams much greater flexibility in the frequency in which they can conduct vulnerability tests.
3 Categories of BAS technologies
BAS technologies fall into three main categories, depending on the approach they use:
Agent-based Vulnerability Scanners: This category involves deploying agents directly on target devices within an organization's LAN to identify known vulnerabilities. These agents are distributed across multiple machines, helping map potential attack paths within the network. Unlike remote protocols like SSH, this approach focuses on assessing devices from within.
Malicious Traffic Generation: BAS tools in this category evaluate an organization's security by generating simulated 'malicious' traffic within the internal network. Virtual machines are set up as targets, and a database of attack scenarios is used. The BAS initiates attack between these machines and assesses the organization's security solutions to ensure they can detect and block such traffic.
Multi-vector Simulated Attacks: Among the most advanced and true-to-life simulations, this 'black box' approach deploys lightweight agents on workstations within the network. Typically cloud-based, these assessments employ diverse attack tactics to test the security both internally and externally within the organization's LAN.
These categories encompass various methods of assessing an organization's cybersecurity defenses and readiness, each with its own strengths and suitability depending on the specific security needs and goals of the organization.
More security controls do not make your enterprise more secure.
BAS methodology - Attack simulation life-cycle steps
Critical Capabilities of BAS
In the realm of cybersecurity, Breach, and Attack Simulation (BAS) solutions stand as indispensable tools, demanding a specific set of critical capabilities to excel within the complexities of the modern enterprise. While BAS technologies offer a versatile range of applications for security and risk management teams, it's common for buyers to focus on only a subset of these capabilities. For Security and Risk Management (SRM) leaders, the evaluation of BAS capabilities becomes paramount in gauging their potential to enhance security postures and mitigate exposure to evolving threats.
Continuous & Consistent Simulations
Cyber Kill Chain
Automated Simulation
Reliability and Scalability
Visualize & Reporting
Remediation
Risk Scoring and Prioritization
Simple to configure and Deploy: It's crucial that the BAS platform operates without demanding intricate configurations to effectively execute attack simulations within the network. Complex setups could place undue burdens on security teams and hinder reporting processes.
Offer the flexibility of deployment model (e.g., SaaS and an on-premises). Currently, most regulated environments (financial services, health care, government) require on-premises deployment. BAS platform must support major cloud environments including Microsoft Azure, AWS and GCP. A BAS solution must accommodate these evolving hybrid architectures.
BAS tools should run attack simulations continuously, consistently, and automatically. They assess validity and efficacy, such as whether the network segmentation is working, and which types of vulnerabilities are accessible. Also, they ensure that security tools are operating as designed — for example, detecting and blocking known threat techniques. BAS tools provide a view of multiple, if not all, stages of the cyber kill chain and where threat campaigns will likely be successful.
The continuous simulations enable the enterprise to progressively improve its security posture.
A scalable BAS platform must have the ability to abstract individual results and automatically deduce mitigation actions so that security and infrastructure teams can work holistically at a higher level to improve security posture based on business risk. BAS solutions should bring together critical data to help an organization understand its overall security posture. BAS platform should be able to detect misconfigurations and security holes and should go further to clearly indicate highest priority mitigations. This lets security teams accomplish more with fewer resources and move from a reactive to a proactive security stance that provides their organization with far greater levels of assurance that IT infrastructure and data are — and will remain — secure.
BAS Platform must have a clear process for keeping up on the latest threat landscape, and the research backed product roadmap and release strategy.
BAS Platform must have an ever-evolving library of Safe malware samples that will trigger security controls but will never impact production environments.
BAS tools should support reporting frameworks like MITRE ATT&CK, to represent details on specific methods if the security control was circumvented and prove which attacks worked and which ones failed. Ransomware is common threat often covered well by BAS tools to answer the question: “Am I at risk to ransomware?” BAS can be used to report on specific named “threat” or “threat actor” perspectives, where you may want to answer a question such as, “How might <breach xyz> breach my environment?” BAS platform adoption can bring together different security teams by applying a risk rating approach that is driven by comprehensive data. To make this capability broadly useful, good BAS platform should support:- Dashboards- Key Risk indicators: Risk indicators help to track your organization’s progress, validate that your security posture is indeed improving, and understand trends over time. The types of risk indicators tracked should reflect what your organization cares about most. For example, % of attack attempts which pass through defenses, success rate of defense against attacks, measured as the percentage of MITRE framework attacks that are blocked. An organization may want to calculate risks against its critical segments or elevate the risk value of services that involve business critical transactions or store healthcare data and PII. A BAS should make it easy to select, calibrate, and then measure against these indicators.- Heat mapping and visualization tools: Utilizing heat mapping and visualization tools within the framework of MITRE ATT&CK provides a shared language for the cybersecurity community. By harnessing the ATT&CK navigator, a BAS platform can create heat maps that illuminate vulnerabilities, facilitating collaborative efforts among teams for remediation. Simulating a wide range of attacks, including those associated with specific threat groups or techniques targeting the organization, proves highly valuable.Heat maps generated from simulation results swiftly direct teams' attention to areas of vulnerability. When integrated into the MITRE ATT&CK framework, these heat maps offer a comprehensive overview of the security posture concerning all tested attacks. This visual aid assists teams in selecting tests that delve into specific attack techniques, providing a detailed view of detected and prevented simulations, along with available remediation options.
Note: Immersive and interactive visualization capabilities empower security teams to comprehensively assess and understand their organization's entire attack surface
Mapping Attack Paths - To help teams properly prioritize different mitigation tasks, it is valuable to visualize how attacks may reach an asset from the outside. A map or diagram of the kill chain helps the information security team see how to break the chain most efficiently. A rich visualization capability helps security teams comprehend and assess the entire attack surface of their organization. Visual interaction like zoom in or out of different parts of the infrastructure, or filter results based on key attributes can be a nice value add ??. The visualization helps with prioritization by enabling teams to see and analyze the kill chains of the highest-threat security risks identified by the BAS. Visualizations can also show the entire series or steps included in an attack from initial infiltration modalities, host compromises, lateral movements, and propagation, to exfiltration, sequestration (ransomware) or destruction (wiping attacks).
Executive and automated reporting - While executive reports may not impact the prioritization of day-to-day operations, they help teams communicate their strategy for prioritizing security actions and allocating security assets. Key expected features of executive reports in a BAS solution are:o?? Depict clear picture organization wide security posture.o?? Supporting business case for configuration or strategy changes.o?? Assisting business case development such as budget requests.o?? Reflecting real-time trends and activities in the security landscape.o?? Detailing security posture concerning specific Threat Group TTPso?? Self Service Analyticso?? Enabling configuration of alerts based on progress tracking over time.
Accurate Prioritization with Manual Prioritization override - Because a BAS platform will continually run hundreds of thousands of breach methods to test the efficacy of all your security solutions and controls across known TTPs, this generates enormous number of alerts and suggestions for mitigation. Features such as risk scores, heat maps and network exposure maps help security teams and leaders see and quantify the areas to focus on for remediation. A well-designed BAS platform will aggregate results from all the simulations to provide holistic remediation actions, which is more efficient than fixing security gaps one by one. Threats should be grouped by categories, such as network, web, endpoint, and email. This makes it more feasible to coordinate efforts of security, IT, network, endpoint, and risk teams in a holistic remediation plan.To help security and infrastructure teams remediate the most critical security gaps first, the BAS solution should prioritize suggested mitigation actions in a stack, ranked by business risk. The BAS platform should create a top-priority unified workspace or dashboard where the full team can focus on the highest priority remediations to improve security posture based on business risk. For example, updating one rule in a NextGen firewall may have a great impact on protecting the most valuable IT assets of a business or customized patch management priority list that is focused on mitigating business risk.
BAS Platform should provide accurate prioritization capabilities to prevent “remediation paralysis dilemma.” ??
While I expect BAS tool prioritization engine to do its job effectively, I would suggest BAS tool needs to support manual override and schedule.
These help users to easily absorb and comprehend BAS simulation findings and recommended next steps. More specifically, this risk and prioritization capability should include the following components:
BAS should be able to calculate the exposure time from discovery of a breach until it is resolved, as well as the success rate of remediation, to track: o?? efficiency and responsiveness of a security teamo?? effectiveness of improving security posture?
Using BAS only for getting diagnostics is not enough, and wisdom comes from actioning the recommended improvements in the areas described below. In other words, a good tool should help drive remediation, not simply tell what’s not going well.
BAS platforms should be able to scale intelligently - To scale intelligently and easily, the BAS platform needs to determine which attacks should run against specific points in the attack surface. It must be able to determine automatically which types of attacks to run, where to run them in the infrastructure, and in what sequences or rotations. For example, a BAS platform should run Linux attacks only on Linux servers and Windows Servers attacks only on Windows Servers.
BAS platform should recognize the context of IT assets also and, for example, run data exfiltration exploits only against databases and other parts of the data infrastructure. This intelligence at using these capabilities helps the BAS system scale automatically to a large organization, without stressing the operations team. In addition, the BAS needs to be able to test attack playbooks across the entire kill chain to spot enhanced security remediation opportunities, even if the attack was blocked higher up in the chain by a control or other remediation measure.
BAS platforms should not require manual tuning and interactions to configure attack profiles and simulation parameters.For a BAS platform to report accurately on enterprise security posture, it must run in the production environment and not in a mirrored production environment. Running simulations in a lab or air gapping them from production does not effectively test all the moving parts of a real enterprise network.For a BAS Platform It’s important to distinguish between running simulations “in production” and “running against production applications.”Simulations must not impact live applications or services.BAS platform must ensure no interaction with real live production systems occurs while performing simulated attacks. The simulators must be installed in production traversing the production network, and they must represent and run on all the endpoints in the enterprise (Windows desktop OSs, Windows Servers OSs, Linux Server OSs, Mac OSs) and their security settings.
Note: Running simulations that interact with live production applications would introduce risk of causing downtime, lost revenues and excessive burdens on IT security and DevOps teams. If a BAS platform takes down or slows down any production services, then it will likely face resistance from Production support team and application owners.
BAS platform framework should ensure that any operation carried out as part of BAS activity is completely reversible and easy to roll back programmatically. This ensures safe execution of the attacks in a production environment. "Ensure all BAS operations can be undone."
A BAS platform should be easy to use and measurably increase the ease of use of other security tools and controls that an organization uses. - Most security teams suffer from “tool sprawl” which has added significant complexity to their jobs. Tool sprawl makes it harder to maintain security due to the complexity of using and configuring 70 to 100 security controls in place to guard against threats, and maintaining accurate awareness of how they work in combination.
Enterprise ready BAS should start by testing every security control for each solution by simulating attacks to infiltrate, exploit hosts, move laterally and exfiltrate data. This BAS process will serve as the single testing point across all controls, and it simplifies the cumbersome process of either manually verifying or tuning penetration testing systems.
An effective BAS should fit without friction into existing workflows and not require additional separate workflows or significant professional services to be effectively integrated and work properly. BAS Platform should support Integration with SOAR, SIEM, ITSM tool and other automated workflows and processes. Integrations with workflow systems can be used to trigger processes for additional information gathering configuration changes and analyst approvals that are required to direct mitigation and remediation of issues. Over time, these bi-directional workflow integrations improve the security posture and reduce the risk of a breach by improving the ability of the security team to quickly and effectively mitigate issues discovered by BAS.
BAS Platform should support Automated analysis of security events — Technology Integrations: Understanding how the security ecosystem responds to each type of attack is key to improving the security posture. BAS platforms must integrate with endpoint, network and SIEM solutions to automatically correlate security events to simulated attacks. This saves significant time for the security team in analyzing and searching for key events and recognizing gaps. Effective integration enables the BAS platform to automatically determine if a simulated attack was prevented, detected, or completely missed by the security ecosystem.
BAS solution must support Role Based access (RBAC) assignment - For example - Executives can view reports and dashboards, while blue teams can configure and execute the various simulations. Red teams would be unique in having the ability to create new and custom breach methods.
BAS Solution be able to deploy simulators of various operating systems including Windows, Linux, and MacOS.
Covering known threats is not enough. To cover unknown threats and patterns that may not be obvious, a comprehensive BAS platform must have sufficient coverage of attacker behaviors and general cybersecurity tactics, techniques, and procedures. Ideally, this coverage will leverage well-known attack information sources like GitHub and Reddit. Each organization should be able to determine which information sources are the most important and add those attacks to continuously update the attack playbooks.
Real World use cases for Breach and attack simulation (BAS) technologies
To get true value from BAS Technologies, the organization needs to select BAS tool carefully and deploy them to cover the below 9 use cases:
1. Attack Technique, Security Posture and Readiness Assessment -
With automated attacks escalating and growing in volume and severity, attackers try numerous exploits and test different types of weaknesses when they attempt to breach a target. Additionally, hackers can often ascertain which security controls and systems an organization is running and tune their attacks to map to the blind and weak spots of those systems.
Ensure you use BAS tools comprehensive playbook to draw upon, containing attack tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) covering all Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs).
Validating and tracking the security posture of complex and dynamic environments is extremely challenging and a burden to security and operations teams. Ensure you use BAS platform to cover the major attack surfaces: network, endpoint, cloud, and email. For example, test all major operating systems that you run on-premises, on local and distributed machines and in the cloud. Use BAS to cover all security controls because they are often subject to inadvertent misconfigurations as part of patching, updating, and other normal IT processes.
Ensure you use BAS Tool to simulate attacks against public and private cloud infrastructure (IaaS), addressing the control plane, including IAM, network, storage, and administrator access. It is also crucial to move up the cloud technology stack and address the data plane, covering lateral movement, system abuse, privilege escalation, and running unapproved processes. With attacks now focusing on container-based applications, do use BAS platform for Containers (e.g., Docker, Kubernetes).
Many BAS vendors leverage the MITRE ATT&CK framework to build dashboards that enable users to categorize findings and facilitate a discussion about exposure reduction and security readiness. Organizations should use attack simulation to hypothesize the outcomes of real-world scenarios and obtain an attacker’s view of their environments.
For example, the security operations team should use the BAS tool to simulate/emulate a high-profile threat technique related to 'known threat actor groups'. By doing this, the BAS tool should be able show how a possible first step of the breach (also known as “named attack”) would work without the risks or approval required for traditional penetration testing. They would be able to utilize the results from the simulation to prepare accordingly.
2. Security Control Validation and Efficacy
This is a core function of BAS tools. In-depth attack coverage is imperative for BAS to ensure the enterprise is secure from all known attacks. For efficiency and better interpretation of results, the BAS platform should emphasize and give testing priority to attack methods that are potentially damaging today.?
Just because an attack is known, it does not make it currently relevant in today’s infrastructure.
Threat exposure may be due to poorly configured security controls, lack of security controls or inadequate processes and procedures. Simulations assist teams trying to identify how to optimize existing security technology deployments. The simulation ascertains if current security technologies are configured properly to:?
Detect active threats.
Investigate instances where existing threat detection controls are not performing as expected.
Identify areas where current security controls may have failed or succeeded, highlighting potential configuration issues or gaps in capabilities required for threat detection and prevention. The insights provided offer detailed guidance to enhance existing controls.
Evaluate the processes followed by security operations teams, pinpointing areas for improvement to better prevent, detect, and respond to simulated threats.
Assess the functionality of security controls and the preparedness of the security team to respond effectively, including their skill set.
Validate configuration changes and product updates to ensure they haven't caused configuration drift, potentially introducing new or unforeseen security control gaps.
Organization should BAS platforms to focus on specific tactics or techniques. For example, they will require the ability to test TTPs of specific threat groups that are high priority for the organization. The team may decide to run all tactics and techniques associated with a specific threat group across all simulators in the enterprise. If an inquiry such as “how secure are we against threats x, y, and z?” comes from the executive suite or the board, the BAS platform should be able to quickly provide the answer.
Simulated attacks must be as close as possible to a real attack (!! Remember - Real Attacks Matter). For example, running a network recording of an attack is different than actually conducting the attack between two live, real entities running in a production or near-production environment. Likewise, scanning the environment and configurations and deducing the potential success of an attack is not equivalent to performing the attack and seeing the outcome.
3. Support Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A)
BAS technology can play a pivotal role in the context of mergers and acquisitions (M&A) by offering a unique avenue for organizations to gain valuable insights into the security posture of potential acquisition targets. Traditionally, organizations deploy BAS solutions after completing an M&A transaction to assess and reconcile security discrepancies. However, there is an emerging trend of utilizing BAS even before the acquisition to proactively evaluate the target company's security resilience.
Typical M&A process often restricts access to the target company's environment until the completion of the acquisition. This limitation hinders organizations from assessing the security landscape beforehand. Nonetheless, deploying BAS technology in this pre-acquisition phase offers several advantages.
Visibility into Target Company's Security Tools
Informed Integration Timelines:
Tool Selection and Replacement:
Risk Mitigation:
Incorporating BAS technology into the M&A process not only streamlines post-acquisition security efforts but also contributes to making informed decisions throughout the acquisition journey. It empowers organizations to navigate the complexities of merging two security landscapes effectively and ensures a smoother transition while preserving the integrity of both entities' security postures.
4. Third-Party Assessments
In an era where interconnectedness is paramount, organizations often collaborate with supply chain partners, vendors, and third-party entities to optimize their operations. However, these collaborations introduce a critical consideration: Security. To safeguard their networks and sensitive data, organizations frequently request that their partners undergo security assessments before gaining access to their systems. Frequently, organizations request that their supply chain partners perform a self-assessment of their security controls, should they want or need to connect to the organization’s network. BAS solutions can test without divulging or providing access to sensitive data, which addresses some of the privacy concerns of prospective partners.
BAS technology can play a vital role in enhancing third-party assessments while addressing privacy concerns.
?Facilitating Secure Collaboration
Privacy-Preserving Security Testing: One of the significant advantages of using BAS for third-party assessments is its ability to conduct comprehensive security testing without divulging or providing access to sensitive data. BAS cab acts as an impartial evaluator, assessing the effectiveness of security controls without compromising data privacy.
Tailored Reporting
Alternative to Security Rating Services (SRSs): While security rating services (SRSs) offer an alternative option for third-party assessments, BAS stands out as a more robust and versatile choice. SRSs primarily rely on automated reviews of publicly available data, which may not provide a comprehensive evaluation of security controls. BAS, on the other hand, actively simulates attacks and assesses security measures in a controlled environment, offering a more in-depth analysis of security readiness.
Third-party assessments powered by BAS contribute to building trust between organizations and their partners. By ensuring that partners adhere to security standards, organizations can collaborate with confidence, knowing that their network and data are safeguarded. This proactive approach not only strengthens security but also fosters a secure and collaborative ecosystem.
5. Complement Penetration Testing
BAS introduces a transformative approach to security assessments that distinguishes it from traditional Penetration Testing and Vulnerability Management tools. While both Penetration Testing and Vulnerability Management have their merits, they often necessitate substantial manual guidance, resulting in increased workload and noise for security teams. BAS, on the other hand, offers a complementary solution that expands the scope and frequency of security posture assessments in a more automated and cost-effective manner.
BAS is fundamentally different from legacy Penetration Testing and Vulnerability Management tools. Both of those approaches require substantial manual guidance and create more work and more noise for your security teams.
Penetration testing is often performed at a point in time and normally has a specific scope that covers only a small portion of an environment. Although BAS is not a replacement for traditional penetration testing, it supplements this process to drastically increase the scope and frequency of security posture assessments and potentially at a considerably lower cost.
BAS provides a simulation of predefined attacker techniques and has lower assurance when compared to pen testing (and red teaming). Vulnerabilities are not being tested fully, nor is the process testing accessibility to the network. BAS enriches an organization's security strategy by offering continuous, broad-spectrum security assessments that complement traditional penetration testing. By leveraging the strengths of both approaches, organizations can enhance their security posture, reduce risks, and adapt to the evolving threat landscape in a more agile and cost-effective manner.
Note: Combining the attack simulation with the depth and sophistication of Penetration testing can provide a more consistent and iterative value than relying simply on one approach.
BAS and vulnerability assessment (VA) tools are complementary technologies. BAS technology offers functionality to identify which vulnerabilities will likely be successfully exploited in the environment. Testing vulnerabilities and their exploitation is a core feature of many BAS tools.
BAS can be leveraged to help with vulnerability prioritization. For example, if a vulnerability cannot be patched for any business or technical reasons, BAS tools deliver insights into “how” an asset may be compromised. Also, they provide the means to test the efficacy of the already deployed security controls and whether those compensating controls adequately address the common vulnerabilities and exposures (CVE) discovered.
The synergy between BAS technology and Vulnerability Assessment (VA) tools is a cornerstone of robust Risk-Based Vulnerability Management (RBVM). While VA tools excel at identifying vulnerabilities within an environment, BAS technology complements this by assessing which of these vulnerabilities are most likely to be successfully exploited.
Organizations must plan to use BAS tool to enrich RBVM:
Vulnerability Prioritization: When certain vulnerabilities cannot be promptly patched due to business or technical constraints, BAS steps in to provide critical insights into the "how" of potential asset compromise. It goes beyond merely identifying vulnerabilities and delves into assessing the likelihood and consequences of successful exploitation. This information becomes instrumental in prioritizing vulnerabilities for remediation based on their real-world risk.
Evaluating Security Controls: BAS tools offer a unique vantage point to evaluate the efficacy of deployed security controls. They probe whether the existing security mechanisms, including compensating controls, effectively address the identified Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVEs). By simulating attacks that attempt to exploit known vulnerabilities, BAS validates the resilience of these controls. This verification ensures that security defenses are aligned with the current threat landscape and can thwart potential threats effectively.
Holistic Security Posture Assessment: RBVM is not solely about managing individual vulnerabilities but also about evaluating the overall security posture. BAS extends its capabilities to assess the collective impact of vulnerabilities and their potential exploitation on the organization's security posture. It helps security teams understand the systemic vulnerabilities that may arise from the interaction of multiple CVEs and provides actionable insights to mitigate these risks comprehensively.
Continuous Monitoring: RBVM is an ongoing process, and vulnerabilities can emerge or evolve over time. BAS technology complements this need by facilitating continuous monitoring and assessment. It allows organizations to stay vigilant by simulating evolving attack techniques and adapting security controls accordingly.
7. Support Red and Purple Teams Activities
A robust BAS platform can serve as a dynamic ally for Red and Purple teams, facilitating their activities by offering scalability and versatility previously unattainable. These teams play a pivotal role in identifying vulnerabilities and weaknesses within an organization's security infrastructure. To support their endeavors effectively, an extensible BAS platform is indispensable.
An extensible BAS platform provides Red teams with the capacity to scale their operations and conduct broader testing coverage. This scalability enables red teams to simulate a wider array of attack scenarios and explore potential vulnerabilities comprehensively.
Purple teaming in most organizations struggles to deliver value due to:
Limited Scenario Realism: Purple teams struggle with realistic attack simulations. BAS offers a library of authentic attack scenarios based on real-world threats.
Resource and Skill Constraints: BAS automates attack simulations, reducing the need for extensive personnel. Purple teams can focus on analysis.
Lack of Attack Coverage: Purple teams often miss diverse attack vectors. BAS provides comprehensive attack coverage across various domains.
Limited Post-Attack Analysis: Manual analysis is time-consuming. BAS automates data collection and report generation for efficient post-attack assessment.
Difficulty in Tracking Progress: BAS offers tracking and reporting tools, enabling purple teams to monitor security enhancements and measure progress over time.
By leveraging BAS, purple teams can overcome these challenges and enhance their effectiveness in improving security resilience.
In this context Red Team and Purple team can benefit from BAS Platform with:
Ability to combine building blocks of attacks which already exist in the platform, to develop new attack combinations. Organizations should be able to run common attack simulations, replicating the approach and methods of genuine threat techniques in a controlled manner via automated and repeatable tasks. This enables organizations to execute timely and pragmatic improvements iteratively and improve their existing technologies and processes.
Custom scenario modules that allow offensive security practitioners to blur the lines between simulation and real testing (taking scope of BAS tools beyond attack simulations!! ??).
Adding New Attacks: Red teams benefit from the ability to introduce new attack methods through various means, including network recording (PCAP) or programming languages like Python.
Rapid Response to Emerging Threats: BAS platforms should be capable of swiftly covering newly introduced threats. When a new threat is identified and reported through channels like CISA or US-CERT alerts, security teams must have the means to promptly test their defenses against it. BAS vendors typically commit to shipping comprehensive sets of simulations for any newly identified or emerging threats within a short timeframe, typically within weeks / days. This ensures that organizations can validate their defenses promptly and effectively, aligning with the dynamic nature of modern cyber threats.
8. Measurement of SecOps Processes and ‘Defenders’ Enablement
Measuring the effectiveness of security operations center (SOC) processes has always been a challenge. However, BAS tools not only help in enhancing SOC processes but also empower defenders, such as incident responders, in multiple ways.
Quantifying SOC Performance: BAS tools can maintain a comprehensive timeline and record of all security-related actions taken within the organization. This meticulous tracking will allow defenders to measure the impact of new security tools and processes. It will enable them to establish key metrics like Mean Time to Detect (#MTTD) and Mean Time to Respond (#MTTR). These metrics are crucial for assessing how efficiently security incidents are detected and addressed, providing a clear picture of SOC performance.
Enhancing Incident Response Planning: BAS tools can serve as a valuable supplement to table-top exercises, which are essential for incident response planning. By continually testing and retesting various attack scenarios, BAS tools offer real-time visibility into security exposure. This dynamic perspective becomes particularly valuable when new security solutions or content are introduced. It allows defenders to assess how these changes affect the organization's ability to detect and respond to threats.
Facilitating Strategic Security Roadmap: BAS reports can serve as powerful conversation starters when planning the organization's strategic security roadmap. They offer a wealth of metrics related to residual risk, security posture, and attack surface. These metrics provide valuable insights into the organization's security landscape, helping security leaders make informed decisions. Moreover, they play a crucial role in demonstrating the return on investment (ROI) of security initiatives, validating security budget allocations, and ensuring alignment with strategic security goals.
BAS tools not only measure the effectiveness of SecOps processes but also empower defenders with actionable insights. They enable security teams to continuously refine their processes, adapt to evolving threats, and make data-driven decisions that enhance the overall security posture of the organization.
9. Actionable Threat Intelligence
In a cybersecurity landscape characterized by rapid and dynamic threats, actionable and adaptive threat intelligence is critical for effective defense. BAS technology elevates threat intelligence from being a passive information source to a proactive and strategic asset. By leveraging BAS-generated insights, organizations can fortify their security posture, respond agilely to emerging threats, and ensure that their defenses remain resilient in the face of evolving cyber challenges.
BAS solutions can offer a multifaceted approach to threat intelligence, providing valuable insights that empower security teams to make informed decisions and proactively protect their infrastructure. Here's how BAS transforms threat intelligence into actionable strategies:
Threat Profiling: BAS solutions excel in threat profiling, tailoring threat intelligence to suit the specific industry and geographical location of the organization. By customizing threat feeds, BAS can ensure that security teams receive information about threats that are directly relevant to their operations.
Continuous Threat Monitoring
Enhancing Purple Teaming Exercises: Purple teaming exercises, where defensive and offensive security teams collaborate to assess security readiness, benefit significantly from BAS-generated threat intelligence. Armed with BAS insights, security teams can strategically select and simulate relevant threats during these exercises.
Proactive Threat Mitigation
Decision Support: The actionable threat intelligence provided by BAS serves as a valuable decision support tool. Security leaders can use this intelligence to allocate resources, prioritize security initiatives, and make informed choices about which threats require immediate attention. It enhances the overall strategic alignment of cybersecurity efforts with the organization's goals and risk tolerance.
Note: Above list is not in any order of preference, maturity, or capability mapping. 3rd party links shared on as-is-basis. Please do check the applicability or look for authoritative BAS evaluation from your Security partner or leading research firms.
Future Outlook
The global BAS market is expected to reach?$1.68 billion by 2027
?- a 37.8% growth from 2018’s figures - primarily driven by demand for prioritizing security investments as?vulnerability management
?grows ever more complicated.
BAS technologies were highlighted as one of the top solutions for?CISOs
?to consider in a recent?report
?from Gartner, because of its effectiveness at testing against known threats.
?Few additional areas where I see BAS technology needs more work:
Resource Optimization during simulations executed by BAS platforms.
Zero Trust Architecture (ZTA) Compatibility
Integration with SOAR and ITSM tools
Leveraging GenAI for sophisticated realistic attack simulations.
Securing emerging technologies like 5G, Blockchain, IoT, GenAI LLM models
Potential regulatory changes that may impact BAS adoption.
The adaptation of BAS for cloud-native environments
Intelligent Management of false positives/negatives during simulations.
Collaborative Threat Intelligence Sharing
Summary
In conclusion, Breach, and Attack Simulation (BAS) stands as a cornerstone of modern cybersecurity, providing enterprises with a powerful arsenal of features and functionalities. Not only does it serve as a litmus test for the effectiveness of security controls, but it also champions a proactive approach to cyber defense through automation. In today's security landscape, where the pursuit of cyber resilience hinges on vigilant monitoring and swift remediation, BAS emerges as a pivotal strategy to minimize the impact of threats on business operations.
Looking forward, BAS is poised to become an indispensable component of an enterprise's cyber defense strategy. However, for BAS to thrive in this dynamic landscape, it must embody above listed critical set of features and capabilities, both currently and in its future roadmap. Any deficiency in these elements could limit an organization's ability to harness the full potential of BAS technology. It is crucial to underscore that a BAS solution lacking these critical capabilities and integrations could mire an organization in confusion, resource drain, and potential disruptions to production services. Conversely, a fully featured and well-integrated BAS platform serves as a force multiplier, elevating security posture through profound insights into the attack surface and efficient remediation. Such an investment has the potential to pay for itself within a matter of months, empowering information security teams to enhance their effectiveness without the need for additional personnel or the purchase of additional security tools. In this ever-evolving realm of cybersecurity, BAS shines as a beacon of resilience, guiding enterprises toward proactive defense and heightened cyber preparedness.
Jili 200 casino withdrawal
online slots games for real money
winhq.ph casino
Slots go casino Login
Philucky app download for android latest version
July 9 zodiac sign compatibility
Jili22 login download
Bonus 365 app download for android latest version
Jili lodi login
7 juli jarig
online casino games canada
91059 water tank
Golden empire jili online
peraplay.com login register
Jili 365 bet withdrawal fee
Franck Muller Crazy Hours replica
555 online casino
Ph646 ph login register
5 jili casino login register philippines app apk
Rehistro ng jili h1 download free
Okebet168 slot withdrawal
377 JILI casino Login registration
Anvil Fittings
Jili money coming cheat android
Phil lucky game apk
Jolibet php login password
Paano ka mananalo sa mga fruit slot download
slots 777 apk
Eternal Slots no deposit bonus free spins
Jiliasia online casino register
I met a pretty girl na taga is meaning
HB888 Casino Login
Global Games 2024 Taup艒
Casino Frenzy login register mobile
Matukio ya leo VIDEO Download
Jili8 login philippines withdrawal
Bonus Hunter casino
Super Sic Bo prediction software
Maraming tao sa panaginip
PH cash casino real money
casino online games real money
JILI slot jackpot app
Super Ace slot 777 login register
Sobrang alas libreng laro login
Elden ring more talisman slots reddit
Phdream 777 slot download
Old school casino slots online free
Free GSN games list
Wizard of Oz Slots Free Scratchers 2024
Jugar gratis Pharaoh's Fortune
Royale jili withdrawal
Toledo bend lake country cabins
Roulette simulator Unblocked
Infinity 88bet app
Super bingo jili demo apk
Super rich casino real money
Jelly cake design for Birthday
MERKUR Slots online UK
Slotxoz1688 register
35phfun
Betso login philippines
Slots Palace Casino promo code 2023
Libreng laro ng online slot machine real money
Extreme gaming 888 download
Jili official app ios apk download
Double Diamond Wheel of Fortune slots free
PHLBOSS online casino
Hot 646 slot real money
567 slots online
Yes jili com login registration online philippines
How old is Leon Kennedy in RE6
Demo jili free play demo no deposit
Ii89aa philippines
Maxjili com login philippines
Lodigame 1 login ios
Ubet63 jili slot online login app
Baccarat online casino
jili h1 register
Mega ace slot demo download
Ube halaya koi in english
Jili t7 register philippines online app
How to win at Cache Creek Casino
Slots how to win online
Go88 casino ios
Bulelani jili wikipedia harvard university
Funny casino Instagram captions
Best online slots philippines no deposit bonus
Fortune Gems 3 Jili
How to create transaction pin
Mwplay888 net login password reset
Slots ug real money
Jili q25 register download
Www 90 jili com login register philippines
Lucky Neko slot PNG
Royal casino game login register
Slot machine pictures cartoon
Jili free 100 new member apk
Alberta online casino no deposit bonus
Cc6 online casino login philippines
Gogo jili 777 login philippines sign up
winhq.com online casino
Fc178 download app apk
拢3 deposit bingo
Tongits online pc windows 10
casino plus customer service number 24/7
Galaxy88casino net login philippines
Fb777 win apk
JILI live casino login Philippines
Jiliplay login Register
Hot 646 ph login register download
Pin lucky game gcash download
Ph 646 casino login download
Free unlimited bingo card generator
Fc178aa review
CB1 and CB2 receptors
Jili club apk
Jiliko online casino pagtaya registration
When is pasig day 2021
Jili app casino download for android latest version
Gates of Olympus vs Gates of Olympus 1000
Biofloc fish farming book
Vegas7Games free credits
Jollibee Delivery Mix and Match
JB CASINO fb
X570 a pro m 2 slots manual
Golden joker jili withdrawal app
747 Live app download for android latest version
5 jili casino login philippines
July 8th 2024 weather
olympus tg-7 release date
FF16 Joshua companion
Ano ang kahulugan ng halimbawa
Lucky cola online casino games philippines
Online casino jili philippines real money
Bingo plus mines cheat android
Wilde Wealth Management
Jili 49 dot com login app
Julie's Bakeshop description
Is gambling illegal for minors
Slot Attendant salary in the philippines
Is jilivip legit philippines
Jili x superace88 login philippines
啶啶澿 啶曕啶?啶膏ぞ 啶班い啷嵿え 啶す啶ㄠえ啶?啶氞ぞ啶灌た啶?
Slot machine games online no download
Wowph casino login
What did the Council of Nicaea do
Olympic casino online games no deposit bonus
Dragon Cash slot app
啶掂啷嵿ぐ啶ぞ啶?啶曕ぞ 啶ぐ啷嵿く啶距く啶掂ぞ啶氞 啶多が啷嵿う
How many days until July 3
Www jilino1 club registration
Philwin download apk
Pagpapanatili ng jili download apk
Jili h1 register philippines app
Old IGT slot machines
Tadhana slots 777 apk download latest version
Ajili in swahili meaning
online slots that pay real money
Atwood Water Heater parts near me
6s app casino login
Up 777 casino login download
Restore slotomania download android
Casino slots online real money
royal 777.in login
Pros and cons of gambling
Tadhana jili slot real money login
Ezjili login register philippines
Fishing app earn money
How to withdraw money from OKBET
Zynga Game of Thrones Slots support
Betjili apps download apk
Yesjili com app ios
Philadelphia News today
Noir cowboy TDS
Gogojili redemption code 2024
Jililuck download ios
Jackpot meter jili download apk
Slot777 casino login no deposit bonus
Railway Sar Sangrah Khan Sir book pdf in Hindi
106 jili casino withdrawal
QQ international sign up with email
Fb777pro login registration
Best free slot play no deposit
jili real money
Treasures of egypt slots free games download no download
Evolution Gaming lawsuit
7 libreng online na slot machine legit
CG777 Casino login register
Https slotbet com home game login
Pinakamahusay na oras upang maglaro ng jili slot
49 jili queens withdrawal form
Https ii89phn com download
Betjili app download
Jili libreng 100 login register
Play casino games online for free without downloading
Super ace jackpot pattern
LiveBet prediction
Official Journal of the European Union PDF
Maritime Industry Authority function
Marvel bet app download for pc
Journal of jilin university multidisciplinary journal impact factor
49jili apps download free ios 2021
Mitran de boot mp3 song download mr jatt pagalworld
Best free slots treasures of egypt no download
Angelina Jolie children Vivienne
Jili voucher code free chips 2021
啶掂啷嵿ぐ啶ぞ啶?啶膏 啶啶距さ 啶曕 啶溹ぞ啶ㄠ啶距ぐ啷€
Kabibe Game code 2024 free
Feestdagen Belgi毛 2024
DIY feminine wash for odor
49 jili apps philippines login
Brick Alpha
Jilivip 02 apk
Jili 49 login
Award winning chili recipe Allrecipes
online casino games like luckyland slots
Arena plus apk
Super ace hack download apk
Where There's a Will FF16
Jili777 oi login
Phwin777aa login
Betvisa Philippines login
Jollibee menu c1
Jili amazing withdrawal
Phrich download
Fish Farming in Bihar in Hindi
Top 10 best online slots in the world
Jiliasia 49 login
Ano ang pagsasalin pdf
"casino" casinomeister complaint
Jollibee promo 75
Jili city 829 apk latest version
Golden empire casino login download
Online casino games free money no deposit
Bet999bet login download
1xBet casino bonus
Casino Plus promo code today Philippines
Cow 888 Casino login Philippines
Peso63 login philippines app
MNL777 download free APK
Fake gambling Plinko
63win Casino
Jili city download apk
777pnl casino link download
Ilunsad ang Kraken demo
Kerri Strug ankle injury
Video poker online free play no download
Slotomania update
Jili 200cc login password philippines
White Rabbit slot
Tracksino Crazy coinflip
Euro casino slots no deposit bonus
xxjili live
Slots 999 casino online
SM Sale schedule June 2024
Paano maglaro ng slot para kumita register
Thunderkick slot apk
Spina bifida ultrasound newborn
Jiliasia app Download for Android
Kit timefree ph login register
USA online casino no deposit bonus
Phlwin Mines Game
Pay777 log in
5-ingredient vegetarian chili
King game888 register
Demo jili try out free
Jilibay VIP login password
Pci slot vs pcie gaming
Mines game hack scanner ios
Best casino for free slots
Falconplay web download
Sigeplay online casino register download
Scatter philippines withdrawal
Ano ang super 6 sa baccarat strategy
Baccarat card game strategy pdf
Ox jili casino login Register
ez jili app download apk
Fachai88 login app
Mines signal App
188 jili com login philippines
Yeriko BORA Injili download
Wild chili Scoville
Super ace jili slot login
bonus free casino
Casino frenzy app download ios
J jill promo code july 2024
49 jili road register app
100 free spins no deposit codes
Jili event app apk
Pnxbet philippines registration
Barrel bonanza slot demo hack
Jili t7 login registration online
Libreng computer video poker free download
QQ jili casino login registration
How did this part of the epic poem Beowulf end
Orion stars slots apk
Free online games jili philippines
Phlove Casino Login Register
Casumo - Live Casino & Slots
Mini Phone Touch Screen
Jiliko747 slot game login app download apk
Online pokies Australia real money no deposit
Lodibet com login password
devil fire jili slot
Lucky 777 apk old version
How to play Lucky JILI Slot
774pub register online
Super ace slot free play download
Windows 10 download
gogo jili log in
Yes jili free 68 login philippines apk
Hugph1 login password
777 pub online casino games downloadable content apk
釣€釣夺灍釤娽灨釣庒灱 online
Sloto kahibangan casino login
Scatter game jili download
Lucky calico casino login philippines register
Tongits Go Mod APK Unlimited everything
Mines predictor online free
New free slot machines with free spins
Deli zone boulder menu
Slots zone apk
Libreng paglalaro ng video poker online withdrawal
777 jili casino login registration
APaldo slot Login
Pp77 bet download
baba wild slots casino - free coins
Game slot 777 online apk
Release the Kraken slot review
Bagong jili register app
New slot machines 2024
Julie's bakeshop wikipedia biography
Lodi VIP bet
Jeetbuzz 168
5jili online casino philippines
Yy777aa app download
Ano ang fruit party?
Lodigame app download latest version
Popular online Games in the philippines 2024
J jill petites online
Good luck wishes for match
Online casino game dealer philippines
Best online pokies Australia real money
online gambling for real cash
phil168web
Kk jili free 58 login app
Jollibee Burger Chicken
Masaya si jili real money philippines
Julie's bakeshop history pdf
Casino online free philippines
Winph111 login bonus
Free slots online free games no download for android
NN777 Slot login
GOGO Jili casino login registration Philippines
Jili opisyal na website register philippines
Temple slots com login
Philadelphia State
Apollo game download
Jili 999 casino login philippines
888php login app
88casino
Osm gcash login problem
Cazino Zeppelin Reloaded demo
Free online slot games win real money philippines
5jiliorg download
Jili games free no deposit bonus
Big bass splash sam rayburn 2023 results
slots you can win real money
Gg777 download
777 lucky jili slots casino download apk
Dinosaur tycoon jili download apk
Free slots 777 apk latest version
888php casino login philippines
Bingo jili slot download
Jili slot 777 login register online download
Www mwgames188 com login download apk
Aratbet online casino register
Slot games for real money philippines
Wild Wild Riches
VIP slot online
Walang 1 jili login password
啶ぞ啶ㄠじ啶苦 啶班啶?
Casino games slots free download
Jili club login download
Bwenas 999 Live Register
Winph222 login download
Maxjili casino
Poker machines online
Jili999 register app login
jili9889
Jil monthly theme
Ruby Slots free spins no deposit Plentiful Treasure
1 kilo ube halaya recipe
Best gambling slots
Tamabet app download
nice88 legit
matinding amazon big bass
Paano mag withdraw sa jili games
Jili50aa review
Macau casino minimum bet reddit
Bigballer club log in
July 3, 2024
Best smelling homemade laundry detergent
Jili 188 no deposit bonus
Lucky 777 login app philippines
Jiliko online live
291 bet casino withdrawal
Reusable ice cubes IKEA
Jelly App tik tok
Queen777 casino no deposit bonus
啶掂啷嵿ぐ啶ぞ啶?啶膏 啶啶距さ 啶曕 啶溹ぞ啶ㄠ啶距ぐ啷€
Royal888 deposit bonus codes
Jili free 100 register download philippines
Tapwin 2024 login
60 jili login philippines register
337 jili live casino
FF777 casino Login
Phil Online Service Center
PanaloKO referral code
111jili login
Best lenses for sports photography Nikon
Sm 777 casino login Philippines
Big bass Splash Guntersville 2024 Results
Mwgooddomain com login download
Online casino games usa real money
Gogo jili casino login download free
What is PCI in computer Architecture
Nn777 slot jili online real money download
Is July 2 a holiday in Pasig City
Geely gx3 pro engine review
Pagal Khana drama cast tina
Is Calico Spin affected by luck
Hot Vegas Slots Free coins
Majili clan names
lodi291 online casino games gameplay
Ff777 casino link app
Mga kahinaan ng mga pragmatic slot machine login
FB JILI Login
Fijne dag meaning
download jili
MPL PH
Jlbet 26 register
Jilibet Promo code Philippines no deposit bonus
Fg777 pro login philippines
Video poker games free download no download for android
Konnyaku jelly ingredients
Ph646bet app
Lucky Tiger 777
21.com casino no deposit bonus
Charge Buffalo free play
Super jili 777 casino Login
Royal 888 casino app
Jili slot 777 free 100
Jilibet promo code 2024 philippines
Jili live app download apk old version
online casino video slot games
Slingo originals free download
Slots the game download
118 jili casino login
Phjl55 philippines
646 jili
Ijility trabaho address new york
Rush Fever 7s Deluxe
Slot machine simulator online
Tetris free
Jili777 online casino login
Winjili ph login registration
Jili 53 casino login download
Y777 jili withdrawal limit
Ijility las vegas warehouse jobs salary
Flush Fever video poker online free
Libreng jili games login registration
ck jili casino
Pay 777 casino login register philippines
Ye7 login philippines
Casino Royale 88 login register
Please complete the required turnover for withdrawal tagalog meaning
Osm Jili Official Website
Hacker keyboard download
Ijility llc milton ga address
Jili999 register philippines download apk
List of Aristocrat slot machines
Transaction password example gcash
SUPERX Casino app
Jili ez apk mod
FBM bingo Pilipino online login
Mnl168 link login
Crown88 login
Sugal777 app apk
megapanalo
Jili update philippines today
Superaccess industrial login
Esball Online Casino com
July 9 bts song
Nexus gaming slot login download
Bingo jili ph download
Tg777aa philippines
Libreng paglalaro ng video poker online app
Lv bet app login
Jili slot machine real money legit
Jili rich download for pc
200 jili casino login register philippines
mayari ng jili
Lucky 777 Login app
Kumuha ng jili app ios apk
188 Jili Casino login Philippines
Hack mines game
Lodi 291 online casino register app
laro ng pera ng dragon
No cash in online casino
Best online casino slots kenya real money
ILI bibliography format
777 casino login register philippines download
Jiliplay 9 today
Jackpot meter jili download apk
Jili 777 lucky slot login register download
30 free slot games online slot machine no deposit philippines
Jiliko casino online games philippines
Bmw casino slot app
Osm jili gcash register online download
Yahoo daily horoscope Scorpio
BET999 Login Register
Dragon Link slots online free download
WINPH com casino
Free slots treasures of egypt no download
X570 AORUS ELITE WIFI price
Kk jili login registration app philippines
Online casino games to win real money philippines
Hot 646 ph online casino register
Mahal si jili casino login register
Lodi 291 online casino games free chips
Tongits offline mod apk
www.scatter slots.com
Casino game real money free play
3rd hand slots
Gamebato alternative
101 jili com login philippines
puwang ng dragon hatch
Pagal Khana Episode 28
Virtual browser online free download
Phlboss888 app for android
slots nigeria
JB Music moa
Crazy 777 jili login download
Yono Slots APK download latest version
Best free online slots fake money no deposit
1xBet online casino free download
Platincasino Deutschland
JILI 646 PH login
Jili 747 casino login register philippines
Zodiac Casino app
Gogo jili App download apk latest version
Play to win Casino registration online real money
Ace demo slot free download
Mahjong ways 2 tricks
Top 10 free online casino games philippines
Side quest ni jill
6bet com redeem code philippines
777 lucky slots casino login
how online casino games work
usajili yanga 2023/24
Okbet 168 login password
Jili 464 login register philippines
Casino frenzy app download for android
Jili games apk old version
Fire Joker free spins no deposit
Manila online casino
Jlbet33 login
60win asia
Free 100 casino 2024
X570 AORUS MASTER drivers
200 JILI cc
Book of ra free game apk
Good Luck Guys Netherlands
Kk jili login registration online 2021
Jilibay pro withdrawal
Baliw 777 jili login download
Chili pepper
Q25 jili login app
Slots of Vegas $300 no deposit bonus codes 2024
Tp777 download apk
Boxing king slot png free download
Coffee jelly ingredients and procedure
magicjili
Best online casino games philippines gcash
Philucky official casino
Jili cc login philippines
Jili lucky slots real money philippines
Jili super ace hack download apk
Jili777 free 100 no deposit bonus Philippines
Asia jili register mobile
Jili games gcash real money
Online casino no minimum deposit philippines gcash
LIMBO Mod APK
Jilibet download app for android latest version
Ano ang ibig sabihin ng time slot brainly
Play Dice and Roll free online kaz
777 casino real money login
Betpawa Games today Football match live
Kirin games online casino download
Www 90 jili com login register
Jili rich login philippines
Betjili bangladeshi saiet login
Dbx777 login philippines registration download
J Jill coupon codes $50 off
Helens 777 Casino login download apk
4 talisman slots elden ring bug
Jili online slots apk latest version
JILI official GCash
Jackpot Party apk
49jili casino official site philippines
Quick hits slots free download apk
Lol646one download
Kkjili com 777 login password
Wow88 malaysia login register
Golden Empire Gcash
Ano ang speed roulette online
Who invented mobile phone in which year
Jili code free 2021
Best slots free
49 jili queens register app
Jili turnover calculator philippines
Jili referencing indian law pdf
Slots 213 apk
Slot Super Ace Jili Games gameplay
Jili gcash register link
Golden empire free demo no deposit
Best slot machines to play at the casino for beginners
49jili vip login download
Electronic Bingo tablets
Jackpot meter slot philippines
Jili city 829 login password
JILI casino PH
Double Ball Roulette rules
49jili casino slots login download
Jili irich bingo app free download
49 jili today philippines login
49jili login to my account register philippines
Love Jili online casino
What day is july 2nd 2024 holiday
How to withdraw jili casino philippines
Helens gogo jili register app
Jili 365 casino login registration philippines
50jili fun withdrawal
Peso 888 register bonus
Espanyol to Tagalog words
Jili tryout free
Pagal Khana Episode 26
Ice wild slot real money
Double Rainbow game cgebet
Jili scatter download
Crazy Hour Watch price
Big bass splash strategy
Jili easy win download apk
Jilibet020 com login Register
FB777 PH login
Maritime Industry Authority function
60 jili login register mobile
Blackjack rules not 21
XXXtreme Lightning Roulette
Bloxflip Mines predictor discord
Sg777 bet login philippines app
99bet app login
Pb777 login register mobile
1xSlots no deposit bonus
Libreng slots treasures of egypt download
Mini777 download apk
Phjl casino app download
365 jili casino login philippines download
July 12 holiday Philippines proclamation
Jili8 COM log in
Super JILI asia
10 online casino games philippines
Okebet168 com login password
Jili7 jili slot register
Get jili app login philippines download
Nakakatawang palaro sa mga bata
vegas7games play online casino games https //m.vegas7games.com
BBM777 free 188
Infinity Games free 100 download
Casino Filipino Coin
El filibusterismo kabanata 30 buod
啶椸ぐ啷嵿ぎ 啶ぞ啶ㄠ 啶膏 啶溹げ啶ㄠ 啶ぐ 啶曕啶ぞ 啶侧啶距え啶?啶氞ぞ啶灌た啶?
Jili178 promotion philippines
Irich bingo slot login
Jili slot 777 real money
88jili login registration
188 jili casino login app download
Xtreme gaming casino login
Best online penny slots real money
Jili online casino apk mod
Euro slot packaging
FF16 Phoenix, Heal Thyself
Lucky Tiger Casino no deposit bonus
Royal777 slot apk
Betso88web login
Dermaplaning powder Spray
Apps na pwedeng kumita ng pera legit 2023
Singilin ang kalabaw jili withdrawal
best online casino games that pay real money
Win99 slots game real money
jili com
Jili online slot real money app
Jelly cubes food
Lodivip4 com login password
Solid bet777 com login philippines
Jigsaw Puzzles - Puzzle Games
Jili opisyal na website login philippines
8k8 online casino games downloadable content philippines
Aceph 99 review
Jili tv login
Pure swerte99 live login register
188 jili
How to get badlands cowboy skin
Demo jili try out apk mod
Jili official website login register
Jili Slot 777 login register online no deposit bonus
Jilibay pro withdrawal
Free 60 pesos online casino
Ano ang pinaka kumikitang diskarte sa baccarat?
Online casino games example for students
Heart of Vegas Slots casino
Cowboy Slots best slots
Ph sabong go perya login registration
S888 org live betting app
218aceph com login register
FC777 register
wow888 casino login
Www jilibet888 com login app
Swcup6 net live login Register
Jili 646 register philippines
Bet88 agent
1p slots Foxy games
Jili777 login register online philippines
Golden Temple JILI Slot
Journal of Tianjin University Science and Technology impact factor
Live casino slots online philippines
Pisobet88 philippines
Is casino legal in India on land
Casino Jackpot Slots early access APK
PG gaming slot login
Jili kilig casino login download
Phl vip slot download
Halimbawa ng online slot na pagsusugal app
online slot machines for fun
Max jili casino login
Zeus casino game free download
Good luck in Hindu
Jilino1aa philippines
GSN Casino free Tokens 2024
Jackpot Wins gift code list today
Phtaya download free
49jili casino games download ios
byu games casino 968 online casino
Lol646pro review
Wagi 777 download for android
yyy777web
49 jili quartz withdrawal
Please complete the required turnover for withdrawal phdream login
Voslot apk download for android
Paano maglaro ng slot88 withdrawal
Ano ang pinakamalakas na kamay sa blackjack cards
Jili jackpot 777 login app download
Jili yes casino login download
XBet app
Tmtplay pro apk
Jili live slot
Deepwoken wiki
Slot machine Plants vs Zombies
Phbwin com login password
Best online casino philippines gcash real money
online casino free games on slots
Jili link casino no deposit bonus
Pasig gems slot register
Baccarat table philippines
Jili 8888 real money login
Casino slot free no deposit
Slots Ninja match bonuses
Tadhana jili slot apk download old version
Turnover not met cannot withdraw amount meaning
How to deposit in philucky Online
How to cash out in JILIBET
Max jili App
joy slots
Taya365 bet
41 jili withdrawal
337 jili com login register mobile
Jili 8998 login register download
Winehq slot online login register
Alberta online casino games no deposit bonus
Jili999 withdrawal fee
Best free online pokie games with free spins
Rummy Culture
Saan maglaro ng baliw na coinflip?
Jilibet download for android
How to make a gel ice pack without rubbing alcohol
177bet cc register
gille helmet full face price
Jili 178 ph register app
Teen Patti Gold old version
Play Dragon Mighty Cash free
s888aa
Ggbet net registration
啶掂啶ぞ啶ぞ啶?啶啶?啶膏か啶侧い啶?啶曕 啶侧た啶?啶曕啶?啶膏ぞ 啶班い啷嵿え 啶оぞ啶班ぃ 啶曕ぐ啷囙
772 pub withdrawal
88JL Login
Qq jili ph register online casino
Jiliasia withdrawal app
Legit online casino games philippines real money
Take Action pill
Slot online game free play no deposit
Yugioh forbidden Memories Ultimate Dragon Ritual
Lucky 778 casino no deposit bonus
Mr Fortune casino login
Gogojili old version
Jili deposit 50 philippines legit
Empire slot machine free chips
9y game city casino real money
Z790 ram slots specs
JILIHOT register download
49 jili tv shows 2021 philippines
Hb888 casino login
royal ace casino "hidden" coupons
Most expensive helmet in the philippines
Dragon Link slot machine app
337 jili live
Zeus casino game free download
PHMACAO apk free download
Mnlwin game login philippines
Poki unblocked github io
J jill promo code free shipping no minimum
Example of TV show in the Philippines
Super PH casino online real money
King game Casino free 100 no deposit bonus
Pragmatikong dula pdf
Dahilan at epekto ng suliranin sa pangingisda
Jili 999 casino login registration download ios
Dream 111 login forgot password
Zili app video download apk latest version
All games free download
Real money online casino Ohio no deposit
Jackpot World free coins code
Kkjili casino login register
Tesla Roadster
Agilaplay login philippines
Egypt slots no deposit bonus codes
Scatter free play
Best slot sites for real money philippines
Yes jili com login registration form download
Boeing aircraft price
God of Wealth slot game
Tesla inventory
Helens 777 Casino login download ios free
Quick hit slots app cheats android
Taya777 bet app
SLOTVIP Download app
Jili reward login app download
Casino score Crazy Time
Jili joy casino login philippines download
777d online casino register
Mga larong wild classic slots sa casino download
Mi777 login password free
Jili188 tw no deposit bonus
Yaman777 download
啶ぞ啶椸啶?啶氞ぎ啶曕ぞ啶ㄠ 啶曕 啶熰啶熰啷?
Online betting casino real money
Vipph casino login
Bet199 APP
DALI 777 Casino legit
S888 org live betting login registration
Tesco Hampers sale
What National Day is July 10
Sizzling sevens slot machine price
Phwin666
Anong uri ng laro ang Dragon Tiger?
Igt slots download
GTA Online slot machine trick
PHLOVE Casino link app
QQ Jili Casino login
E isang verdad traduction english pdf
FF777 Casino Login Register Philippines download
Pinakamahusay na mga site ng slot register
Phbwin com login register mobile
66pgslot
Abc Jili download free
Big win 777 PAGCOR Casino login registration Philippines
Is jp7 still made reddit
Recall balance meaning
Cheat Engine slot
Superball Keno online
Legacy of Dead free spins no deposit
Jili jackpot register mobile
Lodi888 login philippines
Golden empire free demo no deposit
Jollibee philippines menu price
Stake Crash strategy
free buffalo slots
Fortune gems real money philippines
Swerte Win
Jiliko register philippines login download
July 20, 2024 Mike Tyson
Gsn laro sa casino real money
Girl andrew lyrics
Ezjili code free ios
Ano ang diskarte sa power blackjack online
Pb777 login register mobile number
Ace casino real money
Jili isa login registration
Hqwin slot app
568 Slots yono apk download
Lumulutang na dragon megaways demo apk
Lion Slots Free Spins
Jili999 online casino login app philippines legit
100 free spin and win real money
How many days till July 8th
Ano ang pagsusugal
Jili app casino download for android ios
Jiliph club withdrawal
Quick hit slots unlimited coins hack
8m8 casino login register
Starmania slot real money
Yes zili app download apk old version
best online casino games in kenya
Online casino games not real money reddit
Royal fishing demo hack
Gambling online, free
Galaxy casino login philippines
Jili 11 casino login
Pb777 login app download for android
Betso888aa register login
online slot machines nz
Galaxy Casino Frenzy
Panalo99 ph register
milton 888 casino login
RTP Gorilla Kingdom
Videoslots freeroll no deposit bonus
Jilipark login register philippines download
63win withdrawal app
335 jili casino login register
Best alkansya for paper bills
Unli scatter super ace hack download
Jili mine casino login app
Best slot machines to play online
啶班ぞ啶多た 啶班い啷嵿え 啶曕 啶ㄠぞ啶?
free 100 sign up bonus no deposit
55 JILI casino Login
Play Alberta Free Spins
J jill facebook shoes
Fruit Party slot
Khan Sir Railway Book pdf
Which RAM slots to use for 2 sticks
Jlph3333
Pop Slots free chips 4m+ today
Live RTP slot
Jili slot free try out no deposit
Jili 369 login download apk
Halimbawa ng pagganyak sa filipino
Listahan ng laro ng skillz apk download
Super Ace game download
Jili999 login Register philippines download
crown89ph.com net
Slots 555 no deposit bonus
Portuguese to english dictionary
Pragmaticplay com legit
Win99 casino no deposit bonus
Bonus 365 login register mobile
Deli zone menu boulder pdf
Online casino games for real cash philippines
Lvbet com register
Bingo Plus download
Fufafa technology ltd co register
Yes zili app download old version apk
Jili no 1 com withdrawal app
Jili tv casino
Himala director
Tongits online casino
Wild West Gold download
Mnlwin free 100 login
BetOnline Reddit
Nn777 login philippines download
Bmy88 login password
Jili city login password
335 jili casino Login
888 casino - withdrawal problems
5e sorcerer spell slots reddit
Big Bass Splash registration
Jili super ace free play app
Slot synonym and antonym
Jili fun888 login app
Is casino jackpot slots legit for real money
Games for girls 2
Bmy888web app
Jili 365 casino login register download free
C9TAYA Facebook
Lucky wheel spin and win
Get jili app login registration philippines
Royal 888 ph login register download apk
Malaking bass bonus
PG gaming casino login
Lucky jili casino login download no deposit bonus