Securing the Internet of Things (IoT): Challenges and Solutions

Securing the Internet of Things (IoT): Challenges and Solutions

Welcome to Day 28 of Vigilantes Cyber Aquilae! Today, we dive deep into the fast-evolving world of the Internet of Things (IoT) and the pressing challenges it poses to security. With billions of devices connected across industries, IoT is transforming the way we live and work—but it also opens up vast new avenues for cyber threats. From vulnerabilities in everyday smart devices to emerging threats in industrial IoT systems, understanding and mitigating these risks is more critical than ever.

The Internet of Things (IoT) represents a revolutionary leap in connectivity, enabling devices, machines, and sensors to communicate and share data seamlessly. From smart homes to industrial systems, IoT has permeated almost every aspect of modern life. However, the explosive growth of IoT has also led to an equally rapid increase in security vulnerabilities. Securing IoT devices and networks presents unique challenges that, if left unaddressed, can lead to catastrophic consequences. In this article, we explore the key challenges and offer solutions to enhance IoT security.

The Internet of Things (IoT) refers to the network of physical devices—ranging from household appliances to industrial machinery—that are embedded with sensors, software, and other technologies. These devices connect to the internet and to each other, enabling them to collect and exchange data, often in real-time.

The key characteristics of the Internet of Things (IoT) include:

1. Connectivity

  • Devices, sensors, and systems are connected through the internet or local networks, enabling them to communicate and share data with each other. This interconnectivity forms the backbone of IoT, allowing seamless data exchange and remote device management.

2. Sensing and Data Collection

  • IoT devices are embedded with sensors that gather real-time data from the environment, such as temperature, humidity, motion, light, pressure, and more. The data collected by sensors is crucial for triggering actions, analysis, or automation within IoT systems.

3. Automation and Control

  • IoT devices can be controlled remotely and often operate autonomously based on pre-set rules, reducing the need for human intervention. Automation optimizes processes, improves efficiency, and enables real-time decision-making, particularly in industrial and smart home environments.

4. Real-time Processing

  • IoT systems are designed to process data in real time or near real time, providing instant feedback, alerts, or actions based on the incoming data. Real-time capabilities enable quick responses to environmental changes, such as alerting users to equipment malfunctions or adjusting energy consumption in smart grids.

5. Scalability

  • IoT systems can grow and expand as more devices, sensors, or systems are added without compromising performance. This flexibility allows IoT networks to accommodate billions of connected devices globally, whether for home, industrial, or city-wide applications.

6. Intelligence

  • IoT devices and systems can analyze data through embedded intelligence (e.g., AI and machine learning algorithms) to identify patterns, optimize operations, and enable predictive maintenance. This intelligence allows IoT systems to become "smart," improving decision-making and creating value through automation and data-driven insights.

7. Heterogeneity

  • IoT involves a wide range of devices, platforms, communication protocols, and technologies, all working together despite their diversity. The ability to interoperate among different devices and platforms is crucial for creating cohesive IoT ecosystems that span various industries and applications.

8. Security

  • Ensuring that IoT devices, data, and communications are protected from unauthorized access, manipulation, or theft. Given the sensitivity of the data and the interconnected nature of IoT, robust security is essential to protect privacy, ensure device integrity, and prevent cyberattacks.

9. Data Management

  • IoT systems handle vast amounts of data that require efficient storage, processing, and analysis. Proper data management enables meaningful insights and actions from the data collected by IoT devices, facilitating real-time decision-making and long-term analytics.

10. Dynamic Nature

  • IoT systems operate in constantly changing environments, where devices frequently interact with other devices, adapt to new data, and respond to real-time events. This dynamic nature allows IoT systems to respond flexibly to evolving conditions, improving responsiveness and adaptability across various use cases.

These characteristics together form the foundation of IoT, enabling diverse applications across industries such as healthcare, manufacturing, smart cities, agriculture, and more.

Common Applications of IoT:

The Internet of Things (IoT) has numerous applications across industries, transforming how businesses, cities, and individuals interact with technology. Here are some of the most common and impactful applications of IoT:

1. Smart Homes

  • Description: IoT devices enhance home automation by connecting appliances, lighting, thermostats, security systems, and more to a central hub or mobile app.
  • Examples: Smart thermostats (e.g., Nest), voice-activated assistants (e.g., Amazon Alexa, Google Home), smart locks, and smart lighting systems.
  • Benefits: Improved energy efficiency, enhanced security, convenience, and personalized user experiences.

2. Healthcare (IoMT – Internet of Medical Things)

  • Description: IoT is revolutionizing healthcare through wearable devices, remote monitoring, and smart medical equipment that collect and transmit patient data in real time.
  • Examples: Wearable fitness trackers (e.g., Fitbit, Apple Watch), smart insulin pens, remote patient monitoring devices, and connected inhalers.
  • Benefits: Continuous health monitoring, early detection of medical conditions, enhanced patient care, and reduced healthcare costs.

3. Industrial IoT (IIoT)

  • Description: In manufacturing and industrial environments, IoT enables the monitoring, automation, and optimization of operations through connected machinery, sensors, and data analytics.
  • Examples: Predictive maintenance of machinery, real-time monitoring of production lines, and inventory management using smart sensors.
  • Benefits: Increased operational efficiency, reduced downtime, improved safety, and better supply chain management.

4. Agriculture (Smart Farming)

  • Description: IoT devices help farmers optimize agricultural operations by monitoring soil conditions, weather patterns, and livestock health.
  • Examples: Smart irrigation systems, soil moisture sensors, drone-based crop monitoring, and GPS-enabled tractors.
  • Benefits: Enhanced crop yields, water conservation, precision farming, and reduced environmental impact.

5. Smart Cities

  • Description: IoT helps cities manage resources efficiently, optimize traffic flow, reduce energy consumption, and improve public safety through connected infrastructure.
  • Examples: Smart street lighting, traffic management systems, waste management sensors, and air quality monitoring systems.
  • Benefits: Reduced energy usage, better traffic flow, improved public safety, and enhanced quality of life for residents.

6. Connected Vehicles

  • Description: IoT enables cars to communicate with each other, road infrastructure, and the cloud to enhance driving safety and efficiency.
  • Examples: Autonomous vehicles, vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) communication, smart parking, and fleet management solutions.
  • Benefits: Reduced traffic accidents, optimized fuel consumption, enhanced navigation, and real-time vehicle diagnostics.

7. Retail (Smart Retail)

  • Description: IoT transforms retail through smart inventory management, personalized shopping experiences, and automated checkout systems.
  • Examples: Smart shelves, connected point-of-sale (POS) systems, and personalized promotions based on customer behavior and preferences.
  • Benefits: Improved inventory management, enhanced customer experience, reduced wait times, and data-driven decision-making.

8. Energy Management and Smart Grids

  • Description: IoT devices enable utilities to monitor and manage energy consumption across grids more efficiently, balancing supply and demand in real time.
  • Examples: Smart meters, demand response systems, and renewable energy integration tools.
  • Benefits: Reduced energy waste, lower electricity costs, and improved grid reliability.

9. Supply Chain and Logistics

  • Description: IoT improves supply chain management through real-time tracking, predictive analytics, and automated logistics solutions.
  • Examples: RFID tags, GPS-enabled fleet tracking, and temperature sensors for perishable goods.
  • Benefits: Enhanced visibility into supply chains, reduced theft, minimized delays, and optimized inventory management.

10. Wearables

  • Description: IoT-enabled wearables allow users to track their fitness, health metrics, and stay connected to smart devices and ecosystems.
  • Examples: Fitness trackers, smartwatches, and AR/VR devices (e.g., Oculus, Microsoft HoloLens).
  • Benefits: Improved personal health monitoring, increased productivity, and new forms of entertainment and communication.

11. Smart Buildings and Infrastructure

  • Description: IoT enhances building management through automated lighting, heating, ventilation, and security systems.
  • Examples: Smart HVAC systems, security cameras with motion detection, and building management systems.
  • Benefits: Energy savings, improved security, and enhanced occupant comfort.

12. Environmental Monitoring

  • Description: IoT enables real-time monitoring of environmental conditions such as air quality, water levels, and weather patterns.
  • Examples: Air quality sensors, water quality monitoring, and smart flood warning systems.
  • Benefits: Improved environmental conservation, disaster prevention, and real-time response to natural hazards.

13. Smart Retail and Customer Engagement

  • Description: Retailers use IoT to enhance customer experiences through targeted marketing, inventory management, and seamless payment methods.
  • Examples: Beacon technology for in-store promotions, smart checkout systems, and AI-driven product recommendations.
  • Benefits: Improved customer satisfaction, personalized shopping experiences, and operational efficiency.

Key Challenges in IoT Security

Securing the Internet of Things (IoT) presents unique challenges due to the complexity, scale, and heterogeneity of IoT ecosystems. Here are the key challenges in IoT security:

1. Device Proliferation and Limited Resources

  • Challenge: Billions of IoT devices are already connected, many of which have limited processing power, memory, and battery life. This makes it difficult to implement robust security features such as encryption or firewalls.
  • Impact: Devices may lack basic security protocols, increasing their vulnerability to attacks. With so many devices, the attack surface becomes vast, making it harder to monitor and defend.

2. Weak Authentication and Authorization

  • Challenge: Many IoT devices ship with default or weak credentials, which users often fail to change. These devices may also lack proper authentication and authorization mechanisms.
  • Impact: Weak credentials and lack of strong authentication allow attackers to gain unauthorized access, leading to data breaches, device control, or network infiltration.

3. Lack of Standardization

  • Challenge: There is no universally accepted standard for IoT security across industries. Different manufacturers and platforms use diverse protocols, making it hard to establish uniform security measures.
  • Impact: Inconsistent security practices lead to vulnerabilities, as devices may not communicate securely or protect data effectively. This lack of interoperability hinders the overall security of IoT ecosystems.

4. Data Privacy and Integrity

  • Challenge: IoT devices collect vast amounts of sensitive data, such as health records, financial information, and industrial control data. Ensuring the confidentiality and integrity of this data is critical.
  • Impact: Inadequate encryption or insecure transmission can lead to data breaches, eavesdropping, or manipulation of critical information, compromising privacy and security.

5. Vulnerable Firmware and Software

  • Challenge: IoT devices often run on outdated or insecure firmware, and manufacturers may fail to provide timely updates or patches for known vulnerabilities.
  • Impact: Unpatched vulnerabilities can be exploited by attackers, leading to unauthorized access or the hijacking of devices for malicious purposes (e.g., botnets).

6. Physical Security Threats

  • Challenge: IoT devices, especially those in industrial or public spaces, can be physically accessed by attackers. They can tamper with the hardware, extract sensitive data, or inject malicious code.
  • Impact: Physical tampering can result in device compromise, theft of sensitive information, or even disruption of critical operations.

7. Botnet and Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) Attacks

  • Challenge: IoT devices are often targeted by attackers to form botnets, which can be used to launch large-scale Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) attacks.
  • Impact: Botnets like Mirai have demonstrated how poorly secured IoT devices can be hijacked to disrupt major websites, services, or even critical infrastructure.

8. Complex Supply Chain Security

  • Challenge: Many IoT devices are assembled from components provided by multiple suppliers across the globe. These supply chains often lack transparency, making it difficult to verify the security of individual components.
  • Impact: Vulnerabilities or backdoors introduced during manufacturing can go undetected, compromising the security of the entire IoT system once deployed.

9. Insecure Network Services

  • Challenge: Many IoT devices use outdated or insecure communication protocols, making them vulnerable to attacks such as Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) or packet sniffing.
  • Impact: Attackers can intercept or manipulate data being transmitted between IoT devices, potentially disrupting operations or stealing sensitive information.

10. Scalability and Complexity

  • Challenge: As IoT ecosystems grow, managing and securing large numbers of devices across multiple networks becomes increasingly complex. Security measures that work on small scales may not perform effectively in large, dynamic environments.
  • Impact: Organizations may struggle to monitor and protect their entire IoT network, increasing the risk of undetected breaches or vulnerabilities.

11. Patch Management and Device Lifespan

  • Challenge: Many IoT devices are deployed in environments where regular software updates or patches are difficult to apply, particularly in long-lived devices like industrial sensors.
  • Impact: Without proper patch management, vulnerabilities can persist for years, leaving critical infrastructure exposed to attacks.

?Emerging Threats in IoT Security

1. Ransomware Targeting IoT Devices

  • Threat: Attackers have begun to shift their focus from traditional IT systems to IoT devices, using ransomware to lock or disable critical devices until a ransom is paid.
  • Impact: IoT devices, particularly in healthcare (e.g., medical devices), industrial environments (e.g., manufacturing robots), and smart homes (e.g., smart locks or thermostats), can be crippled by ransomware, leading to operational disruptions and potentially life-threatening situations.

2. IoT Botnets and Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) Attacks

  • Threat: IoT botnets, such as Mirai, have demonstrated how attackers can harness thousands or millions of compromised IoT devices to launch large-scale Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) attacks.
  • Impact: These botnets can overwhelm websites, networks, or critical infrastructure, causing widespread service disruptions. As IoT devices proliferate, botnets pose an ever-growing threat to the availability of internet services.

3. Artificial Intelligence (AI)-Driven Attacks

  • Threat: Attackers are beginning to employ AI to automate and enhance attacks on IoT systems, such as using AI to scan for vulnerabilities, crack encryption, or evade detection by security systems.
  • Impact: AI-driven attacks can target a wide range of IoT devices more effectively and faster than traditional attacks, making it harder for defenders to keep up with evolving threats.

4. Edge Computing Vulnerabilities

  • Threat: With the rise of edge computing, where data is processed locally on IoT devices or edge servers rather than centralized cloud platforms, new security vulnerabilities are emerging. Edge devices may have limited security controls, making them attractive targets.
  • Impact: Compromising edge devices can lead to data manipulation or hijacking of sensitive information before it reaches the cloud, leading to privacy breaches and unauthorized control over critical systems.

5. Supply Chain Attacks

  • Threat: IoT devices often rely on components and software from multiple vendors, increasing the risk of supply chain attacks. Attackers may infiltrate a vendor's systems to plant malware or backdoors in the devices during manufacturing or software updates.
  • Impact: Compromised IoT devices can enter the market with pre-installed vulnerabilities, giving attackers access to entire networks once these devices are deployed.

6. Hardware-Level Attacks

  • Threat: Attackers are increasingly targeting the hardware of IoT devices, exploiting physical components such as chips, sensors, and embedded systems. Hardware-level attacks, like side-channel attacks, can bypass traditional software-based security measures.
  • Impact: By tampering with or reverse-engineering hardware, attackers can extract sensitive information, disrupt device functionality, or even clone devices for malicious purposes.

7. Firmware Manipulation

  • Threat: Firmware, the software that controls IoT devices at a low level, can be vulnerable to attacks that manipulate or replace it with malicious versions. Many IoT devices lack mechanisms to verify the integrity of their firmware.
  • Impact: Malicious firmware can allow attackers to control devices remotely, access sensitive data, or render devices inoperable, potentially affecting entire networks.

8. IoT Device Hijacking

  • Threat: Many IoT devices are exposed to the internet with weak or default passwords, making them vulnerable to hijacking. Attackers can gain control of devices to launch other attacks, such as DDoS or data theft.
  • Impact: Once a device is hijacked, attackers can use it as a launching point to access more sensitive systems or steal data. IoT device hijacking is particularly dangerous in industrial settings, where it can lead to physical damage or operational disruptions.

9. Physical Attacks on IoT Devices

  • Threat: Many IoT devices are deployed in environments where they are physically accessible, such as public spaces or industrial sites. Attackers can physically tamper with these devices to extract data, inject malicious code, or disable them entirely.
  • Impact: Physical attacks can lead to long-term disruption of services, data breaches, and the loss of sensitive information. This is especially concerning in critical infrastructure sectors like transportation and energy.

10. Privacy Invasions via IoT Devices

  • Threat: IoT devices, especially in homes and workplaces, collect vast amounts of personal data. This data can be intercepted or stolen if security measures are weak, leading to privacy violations.
  • Impact: Compromised IoT devices can leak sensitive information such as location data, user behavior, and private conversations. This data can be used for surveillance, blackmail, or identity theft.

11. Quantum Computing Threats to IoT Encryption

  • Threat: While still in development, quantum computing poses a future threat to encryption algorithms currently used to secure IoT devices and communications. Quantum computers will be able to break widely used cryptographic systems, making current encryption techniques obsolete.
  • Impact: As quantum computing advances, it could potentially decrypt encrypted communications and data in IoT systems, leading to widespread breaches and the need for quantum-resistant encryption.

12. Zero-Day Vulnerabilities in IoT Devices

  • Threat: Zero-day vulnerabilities are security flaws in software or hardware that are unknown to the manufacturer and for which no patches exist. Attackers who discover these flaws can exploit them before they are detected or fixed.
  • Impact: Exploiting zero-day vulnerabilities can give attackers access to IoT networks, allowing them to carry out espionage, sabotage, or data theft. These vulnerabilities are particularly dangerous because they can remain undetected for long periods.

Best Practices for Securing IoT Devices

In a world increasingly dependent on IoT, securing these devices is not just a priority—it’s a necessity.

Securing IoT devices is critical due to the increasing number of connected devices and the sensitive data they collect, transmit, and store. Without robust security measures, IoT systems can be vulnerable to various cyber threats. Here are detailed best practices for securing IoT devices:

1. Strong Authentication and Authorization

  • Description: Many IoT devices come with weak or default login credentials that users often fail to change. Strong authentication ensures that only authorized users and systems can access IoT devices.
  • Best Practices: Enforce strong, unique passwords: Replace default credentials with strong passwords. Use password managers to manage multiple credentials. Multi-factor authentication (MFA): Add a second layer of authentication, such as one-time passwords (OTP) or biometrics. Role-based access control (RBAC): Ensure that users and applications only have access to the devices and data they need. Limit administrative access to IoT devices.

2. Regular Software and Firmware Updates

  • Description: Many IoT devices run outdated firmware that may have vulnerabilities. Regular updates ensure that security flaws are patched promptly.
  • Best Practices: Automated updates: Enable automatic firmware and software updates where possible, to ensure timely patching of vulnerabilities. Security-first firmware releases: Ensure that manufacturers provide secure updates and verify the authenticity of firmware using digital signatures. Monitor for new vulnerabilities: Stay informed of known vulnerabilities (CVEs) for your devices and apply patches as soon as they are available.

3. Encryption of Data (In Transit and At Rest)

  • Description: Encryption protects data from being intercepted or tampered with as it travels between IoT devices and networks. It also ensures that data stored on devices cannot be accessed if the device is compromised.
  • Best Practices: Encrypt data in transit: Use secure communication protocols like TLS (Transport Layer Security) or SSL (Secure Sockets Layer) to protect data moving between devices, apps, and the cloud. Encrypt data at rest: Use strong encryption (e.g., AES-256) to protect sensitive data stored on IoT devices or in cloud storage. End-to-end encryption: Ensure that encryption is applied from the source (device) to the destination (cloud or user app), leaving no weak points in the data flow.

4. Network Segmentation

  • Description: Network segmentation involves creating isolated network zones for different device types, limiting the lateral movement of threats within a network.
  • Best Practices: Create separate networks: Segregate IoT devices from the main network (e.g., using a VLAN) to reduce the potential impact of a compromised device. Use firewalls and intrusion detection systems (IDS): Deploy firewalls and IDS to monitor traffic between network segments and detect suspicious activity. Least privilege network access: Limit device access to only the networks they need to operate. Avoid giving IoT devices access to critical systems or sensitive data.

5. Device Identity and Integrity

  • Description: Ensuring the unique identity of each IoT device is critical for verifying legitimate devices and preventing unauthorized ones from entering the network.
  • Best Practices: Device certificates: Use digital certificates to authenticate and verify the identity of devices before allowing them to connect to a network. Secure boot: Implement secure boot processes to ensure that the IoT device's software has not been tampered with and is running trusted code. Device attestation: Use hardware-backed attestation to verify the integrity of devices, ensuring that they have not been altered or compromised.

6. Secure Communication Protocols

  • Description: IoT devices often use various communication protocols that can be vulnerable if not properly secured.
  • Best Practices: Use secure protocols: Adopt secure versions of communication protocols like HTTPS, MQTT with TLS, or CoAP with DTLS. Disable unnecessary services: Turn off unused services and ports to reduce the attack surface. Ensure backward compatibility with secure standards: If older protocols need to be supported, ensure that they have been securely configured.

7. Device Hardening

  • Description: Device hardening involves reducing the attack surface of IoT devices by disabling unnecessary functions, removing insecure services, and enforcing strong security controls.
  • Best Practices: Disable unused features: Turn off or remove unnecessary services, ports, and protocols on devices to limit entry points for attackers. Minimize open ports: Only allow access to essential ports that are required for device functionality. Regularly scan for and close open ports. Limit local access: Restrict local device access by disabling debugging interfaces (e.g., JTAG, SSH) or using strong access controls for physical access.

8. Monitoring and Logging

  • Description: Continuous monitoring of IoT devices and networks helps to detect abnormal activity, and logging provides detailed records for auditing and incident investigation.
  • Best Practices: Implement device logging: Enable detailed logs on IoT devices, including login attempts, network traffic, and data access. Centralized monitoring: Use centralized monitoring platforms to aggregate device logs and analyze them for suspicious activity. Set up real-time alerts: Configure alerts for critical security events, such as unauthorized access attempts, anomalous traffic, or device failure.

9. Physical Security

  • Description: Many IoT devices are deployed in environments where they can be physically accessed. Physical tampering can compromise security, bypass software protections, or lead to theft of sensitive data.
  • Best Practices: Secure physical access: Ensure that IoT devices deployed in public or industrial environments are protected from unauthorized physical access (e.g., locked enclosures, surveillance). Tamper-resistant designs: Use hardware that is resistant to tampering or that provides tamper-evident features. Disable physical ports: Restrict access to ports (e.g., USB, JTAG) that could be used to exploit the device.

10. Establish IoT Security Standards and Frameworks

  • Description: Adopting established security frameworks and standards ensures a consistent and comprehensive approach to securing IoT devices.
  • Best Practices: Adopt security frameworks: Use established security frameworks like the NIST IoT Cybersecurity Improvement Framework, OWASP IoT Top Ten, or ISO/IEC 27001 to guide IoT security efforts. Compliance with industry standards: Ensure that IoT devices and services comply with relevant security regulations, such as GDPR (for data privacy) or HIPAA (for healthcare devices). Security certifications: Choose devices that have been certified or adhere to security standards like UL 2900 or CSA's IoT cybersecurity certification.

11. Vulnerability Management and Incident Response

  • Description: Having a robust vulnerability management process and incident response plan helps to quickly identify and mitigate security weaknesses in IoT devices.
  • Best Practices: Perform regular vulnerability assessments: Conduct periodic security audits and penetration testing on IoT devices and infrastructure. Develop a response plan: Establish a clear incident response plan that outlines steps for responding to security breaches or device compromise. Collaborate with manufacturers: Work with device vendors to ensure timely reporting and patching of security vulnerabilities.

12. Device Lifecycle Management

  • Description: Managing IoT devices throughout their lifecycle—from deployment to decommissioning—is essential to ensure security.
  • Best Practices: Secure provisioning: Ensure devices are securely onboarded to the network and authenticated before they are operational. Secure decommissioning: When devices are retired, erase all data and revoke any network permissions to prevent unauthorized access after decommissioning. Regular maintenance: Periodically review the security of IoT devices to ensure that they remain secure throughout their operational lifespan.

13. Third-Party and Supply Chain Security

  • Description: IoT devices often rely on third-party components and services, which can introduce security risks if those components are not properly vetted.
  • Best Practices: Evaluate third-party vendors: Ensure that IoT device manufacturers and service providers have strong security practices in place. Supply chain transparency: Work with vendors to ensure that security is embedded at every stage of the device lifecycle, from manufacturing to deployment. Use trusted components: Opt for devices that use secure, certified components and provide transparency into their supply chain security practices.


As we move forward into a hyper-connected world, securing IoT devices isn’t just a technical challenge—it’s an imperative for both individuals and organizations. Whether you’re managing smart home devices or overseeing industrial IoT networks, proactive measures can make all the difference.

I encourage you to reflect on the devices in your life—are they as secure as they could be? What steps can you take to better protect them?

I’d love to hear your thoughts: What IoT security challenges have you faced, and how have you tackled them? Let’s keep this conversation going! Reply with your experiences, and together, we can build stronger, more secure IoT ecosystems.

?

?

?

The complexities of IoT security are indeed pressing. I'm eager to explore your insights further Riya Pawar

赞
回复
Aiman elnaili

information security

5 个月

Good morning every day waiting your post to increase my knowledge

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Riya Pawar的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了