Safe Work Load or Working Load Limit
Good engineering practices save lives and save money.

Safe Work Load or Working Load Limit

According to AISC, forged steel structural hardware products, such as clevises, turnbuckles, eye nuts and sleeve nuts, are occasionally used in building design and construction. These products are generally forged according to ASTM A668 Class A requirements. ASTM A29, Grade 1035 material is commonly used in the manufacture of clevises and turnbuckles. ASTM A29, Grade 1030 material is commonly used in the manufacture of steel eye nuts and steel eye bolts. ASTM A29 Grade 1018 material is commonly used in the manufacture of sleeve nuts. Other products, such as steel rod ends, steel yoke ends and pins, cotter pins, and coupling nuts are commonly provided generically as “carbon steel.”

I am frequently asked whether we should compare LRFD or ASD load demand with "Safe Working Loads" (SWL) or "Working Load Limit" published by manufacturer's for clamps or hangers or other forged or manufactured products.

It is my understanding that manufacturer's provide?a safe working load that is based upon a factor of safety as high as 5, assuming that the product will be used in rigging or similar applications subject to dynamic loading. The factor of safety in the range of 3 (static usage) to 5 (life safety or dynamic usage) is usually applied to tested?proof load or minimum breaking load.?So the published catalog values might be overly conservative for permanent installations and similar applications subject to static loading only.?

If desired, the published safe work load (SWL) can be converted into an available strength with reliability consistent with that of other statically loaded structural materials. So, the nominal strength, Rn, is determined as:

Rn?= (safe working load) x (manufacturer’s safety factor)

Let's conservatively assume the factor of safety of 3, that is more common and the available strength, φRn?or Rn?/Ω, is determined using φ = 0.50 (LRFD) and Ω = 3.00 (ASD).

Ultimate strength level factored load demand, F_LRFD?< φRn?= 0.5*(3*SWL) = 1.5 SWL

Service level or allowable load demand, F_ASD?< Rn?/ Ω = (3*SWL) / 3 = 1.0 SWL?

Fun Fact: φ*Ω is almost always 1.5, as it is expected that?F_LRFD?= 1.5*F_ASD

It would be very conservative if you calculate the demand based on LRFD load combination and choose the product based on the published safe working load capacities in the catalogs, and a safe practice.

Terry M. Zimmerman

EH&S Hospital Project Inspector, QAQC Manager, Const. Inspector, Senior Super.-IV, Experienced In - Hospital/Healthcare Const., Industrial Const..

3 年

Good comparisons and info.

回复
Vinay Damam, MS, MBA, PE, CEng

Field Engineering | Construction Technology | Licensed Professional Engineer | Chartered Engineer

3 年

Hemal Modi It is totally justifiable to use the FOS of 5 for the connections, especially while checking against dynamic loadings. What we learned during the Northridge earthquake of 94, that it is not the structural components that failed, but instead are the connections.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Hemal Modi的更多文章

  • Fundamental period and natural frequency of buildings

    Fundamental period and natural frequency of buildings

    A building’s natural frequency (n) is simply the inverse of the fundamental period (T), and, for flexible and…

    17 条评论
  • Two-Stage Analysis Procedure per ASCE 7

    Two-Stage Analysis Procedure per ASCE 7

    Two-stage analysis has been performed by structural engineers since its introduction to the code in the 1988 Uniform…

    13 条评论
  • Wind Speeds and Drifts

    Wind Speeds and Drifts

    Wind Speed As per IS 875 (Part 3):2015, important structures are designed for 100-yr MRI as compared to 50-yr MRI for…

    34 条评论
  • Bolt basics

    Bolt basics

    The ASTM F3125-15 specification consolidates and covers high strength structural bolts, both Hex Head & TC Bolts, that…

    2 条评论
  • New features of ASTM A1085 for Hollow Structural Sections (HSS) will save you money!

    New features of ASTM A1085 for Hollow Structural Sections (HSS) will save you money!

    On April 11, 2013, The American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) announced a new specification, A1085…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了