The Sad Truth About Developing Executives
Africa Studio/Shutterstock

The Sad Truth About Developing Executives

The truth is hard to swallow, and hard to say, too
But I graduated from that bullshit, now I hate school
— Lil Wayne, “CoCo

My greatest disappointment as CEO was the day I realized that helping my executives develop their skill sets was a bad idea. Up to that point in my career, I prided myself on my ability to develop people and get the most out of them. In my jobs running product management, product marketing and engineering, developing young talent was the most rewarding part of the job. Helping them learn to manage, improve their judgment and be more effective in their domains made my organizations better, and people genuinely appreciated the effort.

How could a great practice for a functional manager be a destructive one for a CEO? Let me count the ways.

You don’t have the skills. The first question that you must ask yourself is how are you going to develop a poor performing head of sales into a good one if you have never run sales? What exactly are you going to teach them? Would a sales VP who became a CEO be able to develop you into a better engineering manager?

You don’t have the time. A company depends entirely on the CEO for an important set of functions, which includes timely and high-quality decisions, clear direction, hiring a great team, and architecting and implementing a super-high-functioning communication architecture. Any time wasted trying to develop executives when you don’t even have the skills to do it takes away from the essential CEO functions.

They don’t have the time. A leader’s effectiveness is largely a function of how much confidence her followers have in her. If someone is running a large organization and doesn’t show competence immediately, her people will quickly write her off, and she will never recover. Executives have no time to be developed before they become useless.

Your results will suck while you work on a task that you cannot complete. It’s bad enough that you will work on something that you will add zero value to, but as you are doing that, the organization in question will continue to be awful. You will lose time and ground in the marketplace while you try and fail to figure it out. Meanwhile, everyone who works for that executive will be working in a crappy organization, doing crappy work and developing a crappy reputation for being part of it.

Executives are compensated for their existing ability, and therefore should not be evaluated on their potential. While it’s common practice and a good idea to take potential into account with regular employees, this methodology does not work well for executives. When you hire an executive, he will demand around 1 percent of the company. How do you explain to a great engineer with less than one-fifth that amount of stock that you are waiting for the executive’s potential to kick in?

Trying to help can make things far worse. If an executive is failing and you keep him around, thinking that you will develop him, things will get ugly quickly. You know he’s incompetent, so you will likely discount everything he says. When he raises a point in a meeting that contradicts a high-performing executive, you will take the high-performer’s side 100 percent of the time.

This will make your failing executive feel badly, but more importantly, it will completely destroy the credibility of the function that he is running. If the exec is, for example, the head of marketing, everyone in the rest of the organization will draw the conclusion that marketing is unimportant in your company. That conclusion will be surprisingly long-lasting.

While you cannot develop an underpowered executive into a high-performing one, there are several things that you can do in your role as his manager that will help all of your executives succeed.

Provide the proper context. When you hire an executive, she may know her function, but she does not know your company. She does not know your management philosophy, the top performers, the history of the decisions that were made, how product flaws were created and fixed, etc. This information will be invaluable to her success and you should invest heavily to make sure that she quickly gets all the context she will need.

Be very clear about the rules of the game. You should be extremely clear up front that you expect your executives to be world-class in their functions. If they are not, they will not keep their jobs. Furthermore, you will not be able to make them world-class, because you are not world-class in their areas.

Know what you want, and be clear about it. Tell them what you think world-class performance is. If you don’t know, go find out by interviewing some world-class CEOs and world-class executives, and then tell them.

Be clear about relative performance. If you think your marketing is not as good as other companies in your sector, then let your head of marketing know. If you know that other companies generate five times the number of qualified leads than you do and you don’t understand why, then say something. This will make it much easier for you to make a swift decision if your executive does not know what he is doing.

In the end, a CEO has got to know her limitations.

Ben Horowitz is co-founder and partner of Andreessen Horowitz, and the New York Times bestselling author of The Hard Thing About Hard Things.” He was co-founder and CEO of Opsware (formerly Loudcloud), which was acquired by HP, and ran several product divisions at Netscape. He serves on the board of such companies as Capriza, Foursquare, Jawbone, Lytro, Magnet, NationBuilder, Okta, Rap Genius, SnapLogic and Tidemark. Follow him on his blog, and @bhorowitz.

This post originally appeared on Re/Code.

Tania Gulliver

Building capability in individuals, teams and businesses / Coach, Facilitator, Leader, Team Player

1 年

Interesting and challenging reading as an L&D person. A different and persuasive point of view. Thank you

回复
Rajiv Iyer

Founder, Enterpreneur

1 年

What an insightful commentary! Knowing where you can and cannot make a difference brings so much clarity to your work. Thanks for writing this Ben.

回复
Narayanan Subramaniam

Life Ambition: Sustainable NetZero with Space Tech by 2050 | Climate & Space Deep Tech Entrepreneur | NASSCOM Mentor | Edge Compute, AI, SaaS | IIT Madras, Univ. of Maryland, UT Austin, IISc Bangalore, ISB Hyderabad

2 年

Ben Horowitz this is a golden article and to the point. Thank you for posting

回复
Steven Atneosen

CEO & Cofounder @ tomtA | AI, Privacy Law and Technology, Sustainability, Strategy and Board Member

7 年

Amen to hiring knowledge and experience over potential. The truth is, most CEO's don't possess the skills to extract this mythical potential, and it becomes a downward spiral.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Ben Horowitz的更多文章

  • Bill

    Bill

    “Winter, spring, summer or fall All you’ve got to do is call And I’ll be there, ye, ye, ye You’ve got a friend” -James…

    122 条评论
  • The Man Who Built Silicon Valley: A Tribute to Andy Grove

    The Man Who Built Silicon Valley: A Tribute to Andy Grove

    Andy Grove, former Chairman and CEO of Intel, came to the United States as a refugee from Hungary. With a relentless…

    33 条评论
  • How to Ruin Your Company with One Bad Process

    How to Ruin Your Company with One Bad Process

    “Real quick, whole squad on that real sh*t 0 to 100, n***a, real quick” —Drake, "0 to 100/The Catch Up" I am a giant…

    132 条评论
  • Don't Follow Your Passion

    Don't Follow Your Passion

    My Columbia University commencement speech:

    117 条评论
  • Estonia: The Little Country That Cloud

    Estonia: The Little Country That Cloud

    Co-authored with Sten Tamkivi, EIR at Andreessen Horowitz Follow the leader is a title, theme, task Now you know, you…

    83 条评论
  • Cash Flow and Destiny

    Cash Flow and Destiny

    Wait 'til I get my money right Then you can't tell me nothing, right? —Kanye West, “Can’t Tell Me Nothing” If you are…

    53 条评论
  • Shareholder’s Best Interests

    Shareholder’s Best Interests

    To me it's kinda funny, the attitude showing a n***a driving But don't know where the f**k he's going, just rolling…

    35 条评论
  • Why Founders Fail: The Product CEO Paradox

    Why Founders Fail: The Product CEO Paradox

    If I knew what I knew in the past I would have been blacked out on your a**” —Kanye West, Black Skinhead Because I am a…

    33 条评论
  • Capital Market Climate Change

    Capital Market Climate Change

    Hope that you feel this Feel this way forever You can plan a pretty picnic But you can’t predict the weather. —Outkast,…

    32 条评论
  • Shared Command

    Shared Command

    "Cause two suckers can’t agree on something a thousand mutherfuckers die for nothing" —Geto Boys, Fuck a War "Battle is…

    31 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了