The Role of Outliers in Machine Learning: Should You Keep or Remove Them?

In machine learning, outliers are data points that differ significantly from most other data points. For instance, if most people earn between $30,000 and $80,000 annually, but one person makes $5 million, that person is an outlier. While it’s tempting to remove outliers, the decision to do so is not always straightforward. In some cases, outliers can provide valuable information, while in others, they can distort predictions.

Let's explore when it’s best to remove outliers and when you should keep them, using simple examples and explanations.

What Are Outliers and Why Do They Matter?

Outliers are extreme values that don't follow the general trend of the data. For example:

• In a survey of household incomes, most people earn between $30,000 and $100,000, but one family makes $10 million. This $10 million income is an outlier because it’s much higher than most other incomes.
• In a dataset of students' heights, most students are between 4 and 6 feet tall, but one student is 7 feet tall. This student is an outlier.

Outliers can appear for many reasons, such as:

• Data entry errors: A typo in a number (e.g., entering $100,000 instead of $10,000).
• Natural variations: Sometimes, outliers reflect real differences in the data, like rare events or exceptional performances.
• Special cases: In fields like finance or medicine, outliers could represent high-value transactions or rare medical conditions.

Outliers matter because they can impact how well a machine learning model learns patterns in the data. If a model sees a lot of unusual data points, it might misinterpret these as the “norm,” leading to inaccurate predictions.

Should You Remove Outliers?

The answer depends on the type of machine learning model you are using, the domain you're working in, and the purpose of the analysis. Let’s explore this by looking at different models and real-world examples.

1. Models Sensitive to Outliers

Some machine learning models are highly sensitive to outliers, meaning that if an outlier is present, it could skew the model’s predictions. These include linear models like linear regression and neural networks.

Example: Linear Regression

In linear regression, we try to find a straight line that best fits the data. If there’s an outlier, it could "pull" the line toward it, making the line less representative of the majority of the data. For example, imagine we are predicting house prices based on square footage. If one house is very large (e.g., 10,000 square feet) and has an extremely high price, this house could make the regression line inaccurate for smaller homes.

Solution: In this case, you might consider removing the outlier or transforming the data (like taking the logarithm of prices) to reduce its impact.

Example: Neural Networks

Neural networks, which are used for more complex tasks like image recognition, can also struggle with outliers. Since they try to adjust their internal settings (weights) based on data, extreme values might cause the network to overfit to those values, reducing the model’s ability to generalize to new data.

Solution: You could remove outliers or use a robust neural network, which is designed to handle extreme values better.

2. Models That Are Robust to Outliers

Other models, such as decision trees or random forests, are less sensitive to outliers. These models work by splitting the data into smaller subsets, and each subset is handled separately. This approach makes them more resistant to the influence of a single extreme value.

Example: Decision Trees and Random Forests

Imagine you are predicting whether someone will buy a product based on their age and income. If one customer is very old (80 years old) and has a high income, this is an outlier. But decision trees will simply split the data based on features like age and income. It’s unlikely that the extreme values will drastically affect the decision tree’s decision-making process, because it looks at smaller subsets of data at each split.

Solution: With decision trees or random forests, outliers can often remain in the dataset without harming the model’s performance. These models tend to be more flexible and robust in handling different types of data, including outliers.

3. When Outliers Are Important

Sometimes, outliers represent rare but important events. In fraud detection or anomaly detection, outliers might be exactly what you’re looking for. For example, if you're trying to identify fraudulent credit card transactions, an outlier (a very large, unusual transaction) could be a sign of fraud.

Example: Fraud Detection

Imagine you are working on a system that identifies fraudulent credit card transactions. If most transactions are around $50, but one transaction is for $5,000, this might be an outlier. But in this case, the outlier is crucial because it could signal a fraudulent transaction.

Solution: Rather than removing the outlier, you would want to highlight and analyze it further, as it may hold the key to identifying fraud.

The Role of Outliers in Machine Learning: Should You Keep or Remove Them?

In machine learning, outliers are data points that differ significantly from most other data points. For instance, if most people earn between $30,000 and $80,000 annually, but one person makes $5 million, that person is an outlier. While it’s tempting to remove outliers, the decision to do so is not always straightforward. In some cases, outliers can provide valuable information, while in others, they can distort predictions.

Let's explore when it’s best to remove outliers and when you should keep them, using simple examples and explanations.

What Are Outliers and Why Do They Matter?

Outliers are extreme values that don't follow the general trend of the data. For example:

• In a survey of household incomes, most people earn between $30,000 and $100,000, but one family makes $10 million. This $10 million income is an outlier because it’s much higher than most other incomes.
• In a dataset of students' heights, most students are between 4 and 6 feet tall, but one student is 7 feet tall. This student is an outlier.

Outliers can appear for many reasons, such as:

• Data entry errors: A typo in a number (e.g., entering $100,000 instead of $10,000).
• Natural variations: Sometimes, outliers reflect real differences in the data, like rare events or exceptional performances.
• Special cases: In fields like finance or medicine, outliers could represent high-value transactions or rare medical conditions.

Outliers matter because they can impact how well a machine learning model learns patterns in the data. If a model sees a lot of unusual data points, it might misinterpret these as the “norm,” leading to inaccurate predictions.

Should You Remove Outliers?

The answer depends on the type of machine learning model you are using, the domain you're working in, and the purpose of the analysis. Let’s explore this by looking at different models and real-world examples.

1. Models Sensitive to Outliers

Some machine learning models are highly sensitive to outliers, meaning that if an outlier is present, it could skew the model’s predictions. These include linear models like linear regression and neural networks.

Example: Linear Regression

In linear regression, we try to find a straight line that best fits the data. If there’s an outlier, it could "pull" the line toward it, making the line less representative of the majority of the data. For example, imagine we are predicting house prices based on square footage. If one house is very large (e.g., 10,000 square feet) and has an extremely high price, this house could make the regression line inaccurate for smaller homes.

Solution: In this case, you might consider removing the outlier or transforming the data (like taking the logarithm of prices) to reduce its impact.

Example: Neural Networks

Neural networks, which are used for more complex tasks like image recognition, can also struggle with outliers. Since they try to adjust their internal settings (weights) based on data, extreme values might cause the network to overfit to those values, reducing the model’s ability to generalize to new data.

Solution: You could remove outliers or use a robust neural network, which is designed to handle extreme values better.

2. Models That Are Robust to Outliers

Other models, such as decision trees or random forests, are less sensitive to outliers. These models work by splitting the data into smaller subsets, and each subset is handled separately. This approach makes them more resistant to the influence of a single extreme value.

Example: Decision Trees and Random Forests

Imagine you are predicting whether someone will buy a product based on their age and income. If one customer is very old (80 years old) and has a high income, this is an outlier. But decision trees will simply split the data based on features like age and income. It’s unlikely that the extreme values will drastically affect the decision tree’s decision-making process, because it looks at smaller subsets of data at each split.

Solution: With decision trees or random forests, outliers can often remain in the dataset without harming the model’s performance. These models tend to be more flexible and robust in handling different types of data, including outliers.

3. When Outliers Are Important

Sometimes, outliers represent rare but important events. In fraud detection or anomaly detection, outliers might be exactly what you’re looking for. For example, if you're trying to identify fraudulent credit card transactions, an outlier (a very large, unusual transaction) could be a sign of fraud.

Example: Fraud Detection

Imagine you are working on a system that identifies fraudulent credit card transactions. If most transactions are around $50, but one transaction is for $5,000, this might be an outlier. But in this case, the outlier is crucial because it could signal a fraudulent transaction.

Solution: Rather than removing the outlier, you would want to highlight and analyze it further, as it may hold the key to identifying fraud.

4. How to Handle Outliers: Best Approaches

If you decide to handle outliers, here are some methods you can use:

• Remove Outliers: This is a good approach if the outliers are likely errors or don’t add value. For example, if someone mistakenly entered a house price as $1,000,000 when it should have been $100,000, removing this outlier is a reasonable choice.
• Transform the Data: Sometimes, it’s not necessary to remove outliers. Instead, you can transform the data (e.g., using a logarithmic scale) to reduce the impact of extreme values while preserving their information.
• Use Robust Models: Some models, like robust regression or tree-based models, are designed to handle outliers more effectively. You may prefer to use these models if you want to keep outliers in the dataset without distorting the predictions.
• Feature Engineering: In some cases, you might want to create new features that account for the outliers (e.g., creating a separate feature for "high-value transactions" if you're working in finance).

Real-Time Example: Financial Data

Let’s consider a real-world example to help explain how outliers can impact machine learning models in the financial world.

Problem: Predicting Credit Card Expenditure

You’re developing a model to predict a customer’s credit card expenditure based on factors like age, income, and spending history. However, in your dataset, you find that customers aged 60 or older with high incomes tend to have much higher expenditures than younger customers. These are outliers because they fall outside the typical spending behavior.

If you remove these outliers, your model might perform poorly when predicting expenditure for older, wealthier customers. However, if you leave them in, the model might struggle to understand the relationship between age, income, and expenditure for everyone else, leading to incorrect predictions for younger customers.

Best Approach: Instead of removing these outliers, you could:

1. Transform the data to compress the range of expenditure values.
2. Use a tree-based model, which handles outliers better and can split the data based on age and income more flexibly.
3. Keep track of these outliers separately to better understand how older customers behave.

Conclusion: When to Keep or Remove Outliers

In machine learning, whether you remove outliers or keep them depends on the type of model you're using, the nature of your data, and your specific use case. Here’s a quick summary:

• Remove outliers if they represent errors or distort the model (for linear models or neural networks).
• Keep outliers if they represent meaningful rare events (e.g., in fraud detection or anomaly detection).
• Use robust models like decision trees, random forests, or robust regression when you want to include outliers without them harming model performance.

By understanding the role of outliers and the impact they have on your machine learning model, you can make more informed decisions to improve model accuracy and reliability.

Don't miss out! ?? (Subscribe on LinkedIn https://www.dhirubhai.net/build-relation/newsletter-follow?entityUrn=7175221823222022144)

Follow me on LinkedIn: www.dhirubhai.net/comm/mynetwork/discovery-see-all?usecase=PEOPLE_FOLLOWS&followMember=bhargava-naik-banoth-393546170

Follow me on Medium: https://medium.com/@bhargavanaik24/subscribe

Follow me on Twitter : https://x.com/bhargava_naik