The Road Ahead: Major Challenges Facing General Insurance in 2024

"In a world where the only constant is change, expect the unexpected."

This timeless adage rings especially true as we navigate the twists and turns of the general insurance market in 2024.

The latest data from the Marsh Global Insurance Market Index reveals a consistent 3% increase in global insurance prices, marking an unbroken growth streak over 24 quarters. Some of this may be good news for moderating insurance costs; but in reality, continued challenges remain across various insurance lines and coverages, not to mention geographical differences that may impact regions differently throughout the country.

We continue to witness a surge in natural disasters, escalating insurance premiums and claims costs. This fact, coupled with social inflation and heftier legal settlements, makes for unpredictable times – even further complicated in an election year.

And as we venture deeper into 2024, the ability to understand and adeptly navigate these evolving challenges becomes paramount for resilience and progress in an ever-shifting environment.

The Storm of Natural Disasters

In 2023, the U.S. experienced a record number of 28 separate weather and climate disasters , each with costs exceeding a billion dollars. This astonishing statistic makes 2023 the year with the most billion-dollar disasters in history, accumulating a staggering $92.9 billion in damages.

Floods, the nation's most common and costly natural disaster, are now occurring in areas never before considered high-risk. This shift is driving up premiums, leading to more frequent policy non-renewals and presenting increased challenges in securing coverage nationwide.

In contrast to these national trends, Arizona's climatic and geographical conditions of course make it less susceptible to natural disasters, tornadoes and massive floods that plague other parts of the country. This relative immunity from severe natural disasters is an advantage for insurers and policyholders alike; however, clients can still be impacted given the insurers’ overall risk portfolio.

Social Inflation’s Invisible Wave

Social inflation, a less conspicuous yet profoundly influential force, is reshaping the insurance sector. This trend, characterized by escalating litigation costs and a surge in nuclear verdicts (jury awards exceeding $10 million), mirrors a societal shift toward more substantial compensations for plaintiffs.

Economists at the Swiss Re Institute have brought attention to how this trend, coupled with surging economic inflation, is particularly impacting automobile liability and property insurers . Yet, the "looming shadow of social inflation" is becoming increasingly pronounced in all liability lines of coverage.

The repercussions of social inflation are twofold:

• Skyrocketing Costs: Social inflation first hits businesses where it hurts the most — their wallet. Insurance costs are soaring, placing heavier financial weights on companies trying to keep up with rising premiums.
• Strategic Overhaul Needed: Companies now face the urgent need to revamp their risk management strategies, aligning with a world where hefty legal awards are becoming the norm and many times aren’t warranted. This shift is crucial for businesses to stay afloat.

This evolving landscape is compelling insurers to revise their pricing models significantly, with premiums and coverage limits being recalibrated to mitigate the risk of these astronomical claim amounts.

Election Year Uncertainties

Election years stir up a whirlwind of change for just about everyone including the insurance market. It's a time when regulatory shifts, political appointments and legal and compliance legislative changes can swiftly alter coverage norms and premium structures, keeping insurers on their toes. They need to be agile, ready to adapt at a moment's notice to new policy reforms.

• Coverages for Strikes, Riots and Civil Commotion: As 2024 gears up for the polls, there's also an expected shift in focus toward coverages for strikes, riots and civil commotion. What used to be hypothetical risks now take center stage in an election year, demanding heightened attention from both insurers and policyholders.
• Economic Volatility Impact: Adding to this dynamic is the economic volatility typical of election years. This unpredictability can sway insurers' investment strategies and financial health, impacting their capacity to underwrite risks.

Being quick on your feet, having a keen eye on political shifts and understanding their ripple effects across policies and premiums can be the difference between navigating these uncertainties successfully or being caught unprepared.

Mixed Messages in Earnings Reports

In the insurance industry, interpreting earnings results can be a nuanced task, marked by a delicate balance of information dissemination. There is a notable difference between what underwriters communicate to brokers and the narrative executive leadership presents in earnings released to institutional investors and analysts regarding profitability and performance.

Highlights of many of the largest insurance companies use language like “record results” and “highest ever,” leaving many insurance buyers confused by the clear disconnect. These insurance companies employ a portfolio approach across their book of business and have risk transfer exposures that need to be managed, but many of our carrier partners have done quite well at the macro level.

In their interactions with brokers, underwriters may candidly acknowledge challenges and uncertainties, painting a nuanced picture of the company's financial landscape and their exposure to Natural Catastrophe and Nuclear Verdict losses that do impact the business. Meanwhile, when addressing a much different audience, executive leadership tends to adopt a much more optimistic stance to a different constituency.

This disparity in messaging presents a challenge for stakeholders, including investors, policyholders and industry analysts, who rely on accurate and transparent information to inform their decisions. It underscores the importance of exercising diligence and discretion when seeing what companies are quoting and how they are reacting to an individual risk profile.

This mixed messaging isn’t going away and remains a topic of conversation with carrier partners, especially when insureds are reading and listening to analyst reports and questioning their broker and underwriters about the pricing challenges on an otherwise clean account, and even more so considering the “records” their executives continue to communicate to the broader community.

Transform Challenges into Opportunities with MMA

MMA can help you transform these challenges into opportunities. We are always ready to work in partnership to create a strategic plan that aligns with your short- and long-term organizational goals.

Discover our comprehensive range of business insurance , employee health & benefits , retirement and private client insurance solutions tailored to both businesses and individuals. Connect with an MMA representative today to explore how we can serve your unique needs.