The Rise of Agility as The Only Sustainable Competitive Advantage

Imagine building a fortress to keep competitors at bay, only to discover the ground beneath it shifts constantly. That’s the challenge of today’s business landscape. For years, the idea of a "sustainable competitive advantage"[1] has been held up as the ultimate goal. Companies invested heavily in moats—be they innovation, brand loyalty, or economies of scale—to safeguard long-term dominance. But the pace of change has made these once-formidable defenses unreliable. Markets evolve overnight, technologies upend industries, and customer preferences shift faster than ever. What’s left is not a castle, but a myth.

Action Step: Evaluate your company’s current competitive advantages. Identify which ones are at risk of becoming obsolete due to market or technological changes. Start exploring ways to adapt or replace these advantages.

Why the Old Playbook No Longer Works

The concept of a sustainable competitive advantage (SCA) is rooted in a simpler time when businesses could rely on unique resources or capabilities to maintain an edge. Think of companies like Kodak, Sears, or Blockbuster. Each dominated its market with what seemed like unassailable strengths. Kodak owned film photography. Sears was a retail giant. Blockbuster had a massive footprint of stores.

But what happened when the ground shifted? Digital photography replaced film. Online shopping redefined retail. Streaming services rendered DVD rentals obsolete. The once-dominant players were left defending their past glories while nimbler competitors seized the future.

Even today, companies celebrated for their SCAs aren’t immune. Apple’s brand equity and ecosystem are often cited as examples of enduring advantages. Yet even Apple must continuously innovate to stay relevant in a market that demands constant reinvention. The message is clear: resting on yesterday’s advantage is no longer an option.

Action Step: Study industry disruptors to understand how they adapted to change. Use their strategies as case studies to evaluate whether your organization is too reliant on outdated advantages.

Enter Temporary Competitive Advantage

If sustainability is a myth, then adaptability is the new reality. Temporary Competitive Advantage (TCA)[2] emphasizes agility over permanence. Instead of building an unshakable lead, companies focus on exploiting fleeting opportunities. Success comes from being faster, more responsive, and more willing to reinvent than the competition.

Netflix embodies this mindset. It began as a DVD rental service, pivoted to streaming, and then evolved into a powerhouse for original content. Each phase was a temporary advantage that propelled Netflix forward. Contrast that with Blockbuster, whose static reliance on its store network left it vulnerable to disruption. Netflix’s real strength wasn’t a single enduring edge; it was the ability to adapt repeatedly.

What Makes TCA Work?

1.????? Speed of Execution: In the world of TCA, speed trumps size. Companies that act quickly can outpace slower competitors. Amazon Prime’s rapid delivery guarantees and Toyota’s lean manufacturing are examples of how speed paired with innovation can redefine industries.

2.????? Agility and Flexibility: Agility isn’t just a buzzword; it’s a survival skill. Businesses that can pivot—whether to meet changing customer demands or counter competitors—gain an undeniable edge. Zara’s ability to bring new fashion designs to market in weeks showcases how agility drives success.

3.????? Continuous Reassessment: Markets and customer preferences don’t stand still, so neither can organizations. The companies that thrive regularly reassess their strategies, spotting new opportunities before others even see them.

Action Step: Incorporate regular strategic reviews into your operations. Identify short-term opportunities to gain a competitive edge and assign teams to execute these ideas quickly.

"The organization’s ability to learn faster (and possibly better) than the competition becomes its most sustainable competitive advantage." Arie de Geus[3]

A Shift in Mindset

Moving from SCA to TCA requires a fundamental change in how businesses view competition. Flexibility becomes the most sustainable advantage. Agility allows companies to:

·???????? Adapt to Customer Preferences: In a world of hyper-personalization, businesses that listen and respond quickly win loyalty.

·???????? Respond to Disruptions: Whether it’s technological innovation or economic shifts, being the first to act creates an edge.

·???????? Embrace Relentless Innovation: Innovation isn’t optional. But it’s the speed of execution that determines who benefits most.

Consider co-evolution[4] —the idea that businesses must grow in tandem with customers, suppliers, and market trends. This approach positions companies not just as competitors, but as industry shapers who influence change even as they adapt to it.

Action Step: Adopt a co-evolution mindset by building closer relationships with customers, suppliers, and industry partners. Develop feedback loops to stay attuned to emerging trends and demands.

Balancing Opportunities

The key to thriving in a TCA world is managing a portfolio of advantages. Companies must:

·???????? Launch new products to stay ahead.

·???????? Expand into emerging markets to find new opportunities.

·???????? Adopt cutting-edge technologies to maintain relevance.

·???????? Develop internal capabilities that enhance adaptability.

Amazon exemplifies this balance. By pairing short-term wins, like same-day delivery, with long-term investments, such as cloud computing through AWS, Amazon demonstrates how to sustain relevance in fast-changing markets.

Action Step: Diversify your business strategy by balancing quick wins (e.g., product launches or geographic expansions) with long-term investments in emerging technologies or markets.

Leadership: The Catalyst for Agility

Agility begins at the top. Leaders must create environments where innovation and speed thrive. To succeed in a TCA world, leaders should:

·???????? Set a Vision for Agility: Make adaptability a core value.

·???????? Empower Teams: Flatten hierarchies and decentralize decision-making to enable swift action.

·???????? Encourage Experimentation: Foster a culture that celebrates calculated risks and learns from failure.

·???????? Model Adaptability: Leaders who embrace change inspire their teams to do the same.

·???????? Build Resilience: Balance short-term wins with long-term well-being to avoid burnout.

Action Step: Provide leadership training focused on adaptability, decision-making under uncertainty, and fostering innovation. Empower teams to experiment without fear of failure.

The Trade-Offs

Pursuing TCA isn’t without challenges. Constant pivots can stretch resources thin and lead to fatigue. Speed, while crucial, can sometimes come at the cost of quality or customer trust. Striking the right balance between agility and foresight is essential to sustain success.

Action Step: Develop clear priorities and allocate resources accordingly. Create systems to monitor team well-being and implement measures to prevent burnout.

A Real-world Example

For years, I co-owned and served as CIO for a network of outpatient medical imaging centers. We specialized in providing advanced diagnostic services—MRI scans, CT scans, and the like—but what set us apart wasn’t just the technology. It was the human touch we built into every aspect of our operations.

Most of our competitors outsourced the interpretation of scans to radiologists located miles away, relying on a faceless, transactional system. We did things differently. Our radiologists weren’t just onsite—they were deeply involved with patients. They didn’t just read scans; they guided imaging procedures and, when asked, sat down with patients to explain the results in plain, understandable terms. That personal connection wasn’t just a nice touch—it was a game changer. It made an intimidating process feel approachable.

But here’s the thing about competitive advantages—they’re only as strong as your competitors’ willingness to catch up. We knew others could shift their models and start placing radiologists onsite too. So, we didn’t stop there.

One of the most frustrating parts of medical imaging back then was the wait. The average turnaround time for a radiology report was four to five days—a delay that left patients anxious and treating physicians stalled. We tackled that problem head-on by implementing a cutting-edge voice recognition system designed to handle the complexities of medical terminology. With this technology, we slashed reporting times from days to mere minutes—15, to be exact. It was a bold move, and for a time, it gave us an edge that was hard to beat.

But even this innovation came with an expiration date. We knew our competitors could—and some eventually did—invest in similar systems or outsource to radiologists equipped with the same tools.

Our success wasn’t built on a single, unassailable advantage. It came from layering temporary advantages: radiologists onsite, human connection, and lightning-fast reporting. Each on its own could be replicated, but together they created a tougher barrier for competitors to overcome. It’s a lesson that has stuck with me—true resilience in business isn’t about finding a single moat. It’s about building a portfolio of advantages, each designed to deliver value while it lasts, and evolving relentlessly to stay ahead.

Action Step: Analyze your current operations to identify opportunities for layering multiple temporary advantages. Look for innovations that can complement existing strengths to differentiate your business.

Thriving in the Now

The illusion of sustainable competitive advantage has caused countless businesses to falter. Kodak, Nokia, Sears, BlackBerry, Yahoo, Toys "R" Us, Borders, MySpace, Xerox, RadioShack—and nearly every automobile manufacturer, department store, television network, and cable TV system are just a few examples of companies that clung to outdated strategies while the market left them behind. The lesson is clear: no advantage lasts forever. Competitors adapt, and customers expect more. Success lies in constant reinvention.

Agility isn’t a strategy; it’s a mindset. By cultivating a culture that prioritizes adaptability, businesses can seize one opportunity after another. From Confucius to Darwin, thought leaders across centuries have emphasized the power of adaptability. The future belongs to those who can pivot, innovate, and evolve—not just once, but constantly.

So, how will your organization embrace agility? The path to enduring success isn’t through permanence—it’s through continuous change. Together, let’s thrive in the now.

Action Step: Conduct a market agility audit to assess your organization’s readiness for change. Develop a roadmap for implementing small, incremental changes that build toward long-term agility.

Interested in learning more? Let’s do an innovation keynote or workshop with your team!

[1] The concept of "sustainable competitive advantage" became central to strategic management through Jay Barney's 1991 article, Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage (Journal of Management, 17(1), pp. 99–120). Barney expanded on earlier ideas, particularly Birger Wernerfelt's 1984 paper, A Resource-Based View of the Firm (Strategic Management Journal, 5(2), pp. 171–180), which emphasized internal resources as drivers of long-term advantage. Michael Porter also employed the term in the early 1980s, notably in Competitive Strategy (1980) and Competitive Advantage (1985), focusing instead on external positioning and industry forces.

[2] The concept of "temporary competitive advantage" was first introduced in Richard D'Aveni's Hypercompetition: Managing the Dynamics of Strategic Maneuvering (Free Press, 1994). Rita Gunther McGrath later expanded on this idea with "transient advantage" in her book The End of Competitive Advantage: How to Keep Your Strategy Moving as Fast as Your Business (Harvard Business Review Press, 2013).

[3] Geus,?Arie de.?The Living Company.?United States:?Harvard Business School Press,?1997. Page 157

[4] The concept of co-evolving with customers and markets was introduced by James F. Moore in his May-June 1993 Harvard Business Review article "Predators and Prey: A New Ecology of Competition." Robert Axelrod hinted at the idea in his 1984 book, “The Evolution of Cooperation.” (United States: Basic Books.)

--

About the Author

As a Transformation Navigator, Bob specializes in illuminating the path to innovative thinking, a future-proof mindset, and the leadership prowess needed to overcome today's challenges and grasp tomorrow's possibilities. He is a renowned keynote speaker, delivering powerful presentations and interactive workshops at numerous events across the globe. In addition to speaking, Bob writes extensively about organizational change and works directly with clients to implement effective strategies.

For further advice, insight, and perspective on the tools and techniques to transform your business, subscribe to this newsletter on LinkedIn: https://www.dhirubhai.net/newsletters/7099140608132358144

And Follow Bob on LinkedIn: www.dhirubhai.net/comm/mynetwork/discovery-see-all?usecase=PEOPLE_FOLLOWS&followMember=bobroitblat

Learn more at www.roitblat.com or call Bob at 847-572-3269.

Permission to reprint this article is hereby granted to all print, broadcast, and electronic media, provided that the contact information at the end of the article is included in your publication. For organizations publishing articles electronically, a live, clickable link to https://www.roitblat.com must also be included and be visible.

Permission is also granted for reasonable editing of content, including the exchange of industry-specific examples, adjustments to length, and modifications to the article title.

[1] The concept of "sustainable competitive advantage" became central to strategic management through Jay Barney's 1991 article, Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage (Journal of Management, 17(1), pp. 99–120). Barney expanded on earlier ideas, particularly Birger Wernerfelt's 1984 paper, A Resource-Based View of the Firm (Strategic Management Journal, 5(2), pp. 171–180), which emphasized internal resources as drivers of long-term advantage. Michael Porter also employed the term in the early 1980s, notably in Competitive Strategy (1980) and Competitive Advantage (1985), focusing instead on external positioning and industry forces.

[2] The concept of "temporary competitive advantage" was first introduced in Richard D'Aveni's Hypercompetition: Managing the Dynamics of Strategic Maneuvering (Free Press, 1994). Rita Gunther McGrath later expanded on this idea with "transient advantage" in her book The End of Competitive Advantage: How to Keep Your Strategy Moving as Fast as Your Business (Harvard Business Review Press, 2013).

?[3] Geus,?Arie de.?The Living Company.?United States:?Harvard Business School Press,?1997. Page 157

[4] The concept of co-evolving with customers and markets was introduced by James F. Moore in his May-June 1993 Harvard Business Review article "Predators and Prey: A New Ecology of Competition." Robert Axelrod hinted at the idea in his 1984 book, “The Evolution of Cooperation.” (United States: Basic Books.)