Revolutionizing Talent Allocation in BigLaw: The Power of Internal Talent Marketplaces

In the fast-paced and demanding environment of BigLaw, the emerging concept of internal talent marketplaces holds the promise to redefine the landscape of legal talent allocation, heralding a potential new era of efficiency, collaboration, strategic growth, and meaningful strides in diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI).

The quest for operational excellence in BigLaw is perennial, with firms continually striving to optimize the delivery of legal services, revenue growth, and profitability. On the cost side, maximizing associate utilization and retention is critical. On the revenue side, complying with clients’ increasing DEI demands is a growing challenge.

Recent industry reports underscore the gravity of this issue. A 2023 Wells Fargo Legal Specialty Group analysis revealed significant financial strains among law firms stating: “capacity utilization continues to remain firms’ biggest challenge near term.” The American Lawyer reported that 68% of AmLaw 200 firms are grappling with the underutilization of their attorneys. The irony is that partners in these law firms reporting low utilization simultaneously report that they have difficulty finding associates available to participate on matters when the partners need them.

Data Analytics: A Partial Solution with Limitations

A number of large law firms have attempted to address their capacity utilization challenges by employing data analytics to assess associate capacity—analyzing time and billing data to determine associate availability. These approaches often fail because associates’ stories about why they think they are too busy do not appear in the data. Partners then find themselves frustrated by associates who are reported to be available responding that they are in fact (at least in their minds) not available.

At the same time, many of these same law firms report difficulty in addressing their DEI objectives to make career growth opportunities available to associates regardless of gender or background. They have not yet found a way to help partners overcome the subconscious affinity bias that tends to drive more client engagement opportunities to the non-diverse attorney subset.

The co-existence of these issues poses a real conundrum negatively impacting law firm revenue and margin growth.

Embracing the Internal Talent Marketplace

Enter the internal talent marketplace—a game-changing solution for optimizing capacity utilization and enhancing firm performance. By leveraging digital platforms and advanced analytics, firms can now allocate and deploy talent far more effectively. McKinsey & Company’s 2022 report highlights the effectiveness of internal talent marketplaces in addressing capacity utilization issues across other professional services firms. These platforms enable firms to match talent with relevant projects based on expertise, availability, and preferences. By empowering associates to participate in an effort to achieve productivity targets, internal talent marketplaces enable firms to make effective data-driven decisions and maximize billable hours. Industries like technology, finance, consulting, healthcare, and others have swiftly embraced internal talent marketplaces, leveraging them to optimize workforce efficiency and organizational agility.

In the law firm context, partners post client projects in the marketplace, associates indicate an interest in participating, and an AI-driven system identifies associates that match objective criteria like industry or work product expertise. By marrying digital platforms with advanced analytics, these marketplaces facilitate a more equitable distribution of opportunities, ensuring that assignments are based on expertise, availability, and performance. This merit-based system naturally aligns with DEI objectives by providing all attorneys, regardless of gender or background, an equal footing to showcase their capabilities and contribute to high-profile projects.

Conclusion: A More Prosperous and Equitable Future

The legal industry's adoption of internal talent marketplaces is nascent and emerging. Following on the heels of financial services and consulting firms, large law firms are coming to appreciate the value of the marketplace approach. According to Gartner, professional services firms that have embraced this innovation report not only improved capacity utilization but also heightened employee engagement and client satisfaction. The adoption of internal talent marketplaces in Big Law signifies a pivotal shift approaching in talent management practices. By leveraging the power of technology and data analytics, firms can unlock the full potential of their legal talent, foster a more inclusive culture, and drive sustainable growth.

?