Silicon-based devices have conventionally been the backbone of power electronics; however, issues concerning efficiency, thermal performance, and voltage handling have created a shift toward the use of Silicon Carbide (SiC) and Gallium Nitride (GaN) wide-bandgap semiconductors. These will dramatically improve switching speeds, power density, and overall system efficiency – the key factor for modern high-performance power systems.
The Fundamentals: Why Wide-Bandgap?
Before getting to SiC and GaN, we must understand why "wide-bandgap" matters. A little background: a semiconductor's bandgap is the energy it takes for electrons to jump from the valence band into the conduction band, and start conducting electricity. Traditional silicon has a relatively narrow bandgap (~1.1 eV), which limits its performance at higher voltages and temperatures.
SiC and GaN have much wider bandgaps, at about 3.26 eV for SiC and around 3.4 eV for GaN. The immediate advantages of such a wider bandgap include the following:
- Higher breakdown voltages allow devices to operate at significantly higher voltages without material breakdown.
- Improved thermal conductivity means they can operate more efficiently at higher temperatures without performance degradation.
- Faster switching speeds, lead to lower switching losses and higher operational efficiencies.
These properties make SiC and GaN particularly well-suited to the future of power electronics, where efficiency and miniaturisation are of prime importance.
Silicon Carbide (SiC): High-Power, High-Voltage Applications
Within a very short period, SiC has found its place in high-voltage applications regarding robust thermal management and high reliability, especially in EVs and industrial motor drives. The superior material properties make SiC particularly suited for applications above 1kV, where silicon performance shows evident deterioration.
Key Benefits of SiC
- Higher power conversion efficiency: SiC devices, especially MOSFETs and Schottky diodes operating at more than 1200V with less energy loss compared with their silicon cousins, have been applied to the power converters of electric vehicles. Of course, EVs' primary targets are maximising battery life and minimising heat dissipation.
- Thermal stability: Due to its higher thermal conductivity, it can operate efficiently at much higher temperatures- up to 200°C. This greatly eliminates the need for complex cooling systems, reducing design complexity and operational costs.
- High Power Density: Switching at higher frequencies allows SiC components to enable designers to shrink passive component sizes, such as inductors and capacitors, thereby leading to smaller and lighter systems. This is extremely useful when space and weight are of the essence, as in aerospace and EV inverters.
Key SiC Device Types
- SiC MOSFETs: These devices offer high breakdown voltage-up to 3.3 kV, low on-resistance (RDS(on)), and fast switching speeds, which result in improved efficiency and reduced energy losses within high-power systems such as EV inverters and solar inverters.
- SiC Schottky Diodes: With their low forward voltage drop and zero reverse recovery, the SiC Schottky diodes significantly reduce the switching losses, hence targeting a wide application area in power factor correction (PFC) circuits and DC-DC converters.
In the conventional EV inverter circuit, SiC MOSFETs replace silicon IGBTs to enable higher-frequency switching-up to 50 kHz-on the order of an order of magnitude higher than conventional technologies. This can reduce the size of passive components, inductors, and capacitors and reduce overall system size.
Overcoming Challenges
- High Cost: SiC devices have traditionally been more expensive than silicon because the manufacturing processes are more complicated, for example, concerning defect control in crystal growth. However, price reductions are happening with the scale of production.
- Gate Oxide Reliability: Early SiC MOSFETs encountered some issues with gate oxide reliability. Many of these problems have been surmounted with the introduction of enhanced epitaxial growth techniques and gate oxide engineering, improving device longevity.
Gallium Nitride (GaN): High-Speed, High-Frequency Applications
GaN excels in high-speed, high-frequency applications where fast switching and efficiency are paramount. Typically, the voltage range of operation for GaN devices is below 1 kV, but they have superior switching performance compared to Si and SiC.
Key Benefits of GaN
- High Switching Frequency: Most GaN power transistors can operate above 1 MHz, which reduces passive components' size and increases overall system efficiency. What makes them especially attractive is high-density applications like server power supplies and consumer electronics, where energy efficiency and size are important.
- Low On-Resistance (RDS(on)): Most GaN devices feature much lower on-resistance than silicon, thereby reducing conduction losses in high-current applications. What follows immediately after this is higher efficiency in power delivery and more compact designs.
- Improved efficiency in RF applications: It would be worthy to make use of it for RF amplifiers in wireless communications without having any significant loss due to their feasibility at high frequencies. It is also a highly promising material for next-generation 5G infrastructure, demanding high power efficiency and fast signal transmission.
Key GaN Device Types
- GaN HEMTs: With an extremely low RDS(on) and ultra-fast switching speeds of up to MHz, in switch-mode power supplies (SMPS), telecom power amplifiers and RF circuits, these devices outperform silicon MOSFETs.
- GaN-on-Si Devices: One of the popular approaches for integrating GaN layers onto silicon substrates is to achieve cost-effective solutions in high-frequency power conversion.
A GaN-based SMPS operates at frequencies higher than 1 MHz and allows passive component size reduction, higher efficiency, and high power density. In the PFC circuit, inductors may be much smaller since GaN can support higher switching frequencies of the switches. Also, the system size is substantially reduced.
Overcoming Challenges
- Thermal Management: For the time being, GaN exhibits lower thermal conductivity than SiC, and such traits may limit its use in high-power applications unless novel thermal management methods are employed, such as substrate cooling.
- Substrate Limitations: While GaN-on-Si lowers the cost, this can also introduce lattice mismatches, leading to reliability issues. These are mitigated with continuing advances in substrate engineering.
SiC vs. GaN: Application-Specific Strengths
- SiC has the edge in high-power and high-voltage applications where reliability and thermal performance are essential.
- GaN, on the other hand, is preferred in applications requiring high-frequency operation with medium power due to its faster switching and lower conduction losses.
Application Matrix
Market Adoption Trends
- Electric Vehicles (EVs) and Charging Infrastructure: SiC is being adopted in the EV inverter designs and fast-charging stations because it can handle high voltage more efficiently. Though still uncommon in EV powertrains, GaN does find application in on-board chargers and low-power auxiliary systems.
- ?Telecom and 5G Infrastructure: GaN has been reported to support high-frequency switching, which makes it suitable in applications such as 5G base stations where efficient power amplification and minimum heat generation are required.
- Renewable Energy: SiC and GaN are used in solar inverters, with SiC yielding higher efficiency at high voltage, while for lower-power converters, the trend is towards GaN because of its switching speed.
- Consumer Electronics: The high-frequency operation of gallium nitride is also used in compact high-efficiency power supplies for consumer electronics applications: smartphones, laptops, and even wireless chargers. Gallium nitride-based chargers are becoming more mainstream, with smaller sizes and higher-speed charging capability.
Conclusion
SiC and GaN wide-bandgap semiconductors represent the new faces in the field of power electronics. SiC-based devices find their use in robust, high-powered applications because of their high-voltage and high-efficiency capability, while GaN applies to compact and low-power systems owing to their high-frequency performance. As cost and manufacturing continue to be overcome, wide adoption is inevitable across industries, including EVs, telecom, and renewable energy.
Further Read
Related Product Range
For detailed analysis and the latest semiconductor technology and application trends, subscribe to Farnell Aspire eNewsletter today!
