The Revolutionary Invention that Almost Saved the Titanic
Erich R. Bühler
Philanthropist, logosophist, founder and CEO of Hanna Prodigy and Enterprise Agility University. Author of Leading Exponential Change, Enterprise Agility Fundamentals, and The Convergence.
Who invented the telephone? If you say Alexander Graham Bell, you're among the majority who are wrong and I will tell you why. This weekend, I reflected on the things we did well in my companies and the things we didn't do so well. Many of them have driven me to ruin several times. This reminded me of a story that not many know, but which has a lot of wisdom in it. The story is of the telephone is complex and contains an important lesson that has several lessons for entrepreneurs—myself included.
You will see why this invention would not only have saved the Titanic, but also why you are wrong if you answer that Graham Bell was the inventor of the telephone.
In 1849 and in a small workshop in Staten Island, New York, an Italian immigrant named Antonio Meucci developed something revolutionary: the "Telettrofono".
This device, which could transmit voice through electrical impulses, was decades ahead of the Bell telephone. Meucci finally applied for a a provisional patent in 1871 when he got the money—22 years before Bell and five years before he refined the commercially viable telephone was patented.
The implications of Meucci's missed opportunity are staggering. Had he secured the 250-dollar patent in 1849, the telecommunications industry might have begun its revolution two decades earlier. In 1912, when the Titanic set sail, voice communication technology would not only have been available, but likely much more advanced than the Morse code system the ship relied on.
Instead of the agonizingly slow and often misinterpreted Morse code messages on that fateful night, ship-to-ship voice communication could have provided immediate, clear warnings about ice conditions. The Californian, the nearby ship that famously failed to respond to the Titanic's distress signals because the radio operator was not on duty, could have had a voice communication system that would have been easier to operate and maintain around the clock.
This isn't just historical speculation—it's a reminder of how a single failed innovation, halted by practical and financial constraints, can halt technological progress that impacts countless lives. For modern entrepreneurs like us, this is a crucial point: if we fail to bring viable innovations to market, not only will our businesses fail, but we may be delaying solutions that could change or save lives.
In my case, I've developed innovative solutions but failed to bring them to market several times. In 1993 I developed the first platform in Uruguay that allowed real estate agents to share photos of properties in an internal network across the whole country and in real time. At that moment, the Internet was not yet part of our lives but we developed a fully working network to cover all the cities. The platform was revolutionary, but people were not yet able to understand it, let alone the companies.
Meucci's invention faced two similar key challenges that ultimately led to it being forgotten—challenges that still plague entrepreneurs today. Firstly, although his device worked, it couldn't transmit signals over long distances as effectively as Bell's magnetic system. Meucci had developed a solution that was innovative but not commercially viable on a large scale unless you invested more money. I made the same mistake with my first startup: I developed a product that worked wonderfully in controlled environments, but didn't meet the needs of the real world.
The second and perhaps more serious blow was financial. Meucci couldn't afford the 250 dollars patent application fee (equivalent to about 10,000 dollars today). He filed for provisional patent protection for 10 dollars, but couldn't sustain even this modest payment. Sound familiar? I've seen several promising start-ups, including my own, wither away, not because the idea wasn't brilliant, but because the rug was pulled out from under us before we could establish ourselves in the market.
The entrepreneurial landscape is littered with similar stories everywhere—great ideas that failed not because of a lack of innovation, but because of practical limitations or financial constraints. This pattern repeats itself with regularity in today's startup ecosystem.
Meucci's invention was groundbreaking, but Bell's design had the financial backing to scale up. While Meucci's Telettrofono had clearer sound quality over short distances, Bell's telephone offered a more comprehensive solution for the needs of the time. However, had Meucci had the necessary capital, he could have further improved his invention in the 22 years between the telettrofono and the telephone.
This brings us to two important lessons for modern entrepreneurs:
First, feasibility is more important than perfection. Your product may be technically brilliant, but if it can't solve a practical problem on a large scale, it probably won't succeed. I learned this the hard way when my second startup developed a great product that simply couldn't be scaled cost-effectively.
Secondly, financial planning is just as important as innovation. The best idea in the world won't succeed if it doesn't have the financial resources to develop, protect and commercialize it. Many entrepreneurs, myself included, have made the mistake of focusing only on product development and neglecting the business fundamentals or the selling aspects.
The tragedy isn't only that Meucci wasn't recognized for his role in inventing the telephone—he died poor and almost without unawarded—, but also that his innovation never reached its full potential.
The lesson many of us whould learn the hard way? Innovation alone isn't enough. Success requires a delicate balance between technical feasibility, market viability and financial sustainability. As entrepreneurs, we must learn from Meucci's story and ensure that our innovations not only work in theory, but are also applicable in practice and based on solid business foundations.
The next time someone asks who invented the telephone, the answer isn't just about historical accuracy, but also about the fact that even the greatest innovations can fail without the right combination of practical feasibility and financial backing.
Free Access to Hanna Prodigy Enterprise Edition
Today, I want to tell you something that fills me with emotion. And this time, we say... Yes, we can! As you know, competing with technology and AIs from larger countries is difficult due to economic issues and the ease of innovation. There is always the myth of “It can't be done here.”
Today, we are changing that myth again and starting to lead the way in the field of Strategic Artificial Intelligence (SAI). We are launching version 1.2 of Hanna Prodigy Enterprise edition. And the best part is that you will have free access.
Unlike the AIs you find in the market that are LLM (large language models), Hanna is a Large Strategic Model (LSM). This transforms the way organizations like yours leverage AI for strategic success.
This update to our LSM also includes something important, as it allows you to create new versions of Hanna Prodigy with new functionality called ?Hanna Minds? These are customized versions of Hanna tailored to your specific organizational needs and trained for different departments, initiatives or strategic goals, while maintaining seamless integration the organizational knowledge flow.
Again, we are innovating and taking companies in a new direction, where we created the 1st LSM (Large Strategic Model) in the world and we are offering it to every person and company.
The good news is that you can use Hanna Prodigy Enterprise edition FREE and see the difference between AIs and our revolutionary Large Strategic Model (LSM) that adapt to the unique structure and objectives of your organization.
---> FREE ACCESS to the new version of Hanna Prodigy: https://HannaProdigy.com
Learn what an LSM (Large strategic models) is here: https://enterpriseagility.community/large-strategic-model-lsm-glfb5s3vk4
Interested in Neuroscience? We have something for you!
Transform your approach to organizational change by harnessing the power of neuroplasticity, the brain's ability to reorganize itself, to overcome resistance to change and drive innovation, collaboration, and continuous learning, and unlock a new era of transformation for your teams.
"A tool that revolutionises how to transform individuals, teams and leaders the natural way at record speed!, a step by step solution " Greg Pitcher
Special limited offer for the EA World Community Next year this price is likely to triple
December 3rd Time: 12 pm to 13:30 pm PDT
December 10th Time: 12 pm to 13:30 pm PDT
January 28th Time: 12 pm to 13:30 pm PDT
Total value: $597
Just $199 + VAT
Just $168 USD +VAT Limited to 20 Places for immersed learning Plus Bonus offers Find out more and get access to this EAWC limited offer https://orgfitinternational.com/neurostarterpartnership
Free AI Magazine
As organizations around the world grapple with AI implementation decisions, we're pleased to announce the publication of our comprehensive magazine: "The True Cost of AI Implementation" This free publication is based on our two years of experience in developing Hanna Prodigy, the world's first Large Strategic Model (LSM), and provides valuable insights for decision makers.
What's inside: