Revisiting the Minimum Wage

No alt text provided for this image

Many want to boost the minimum wage to help with lockdown recovery. Others wonder if a minimum wage hike will merely elevate good intentions over good outcomes. This past week, Congressman Ro Khanna (D-Ca) revealed a justification for the increase when he said, “We don’t want low-wage businesses.” 

Having begun my career with low-paying jobs, I still work with small business owners who depend on them. So, I wanted to understand his declaration. Moreover, because I contributed $1,000 to Congressman Khanna’s campaign, I wanted to understand his willingness to risk the entry-level jobs from which I (and so many others) gained our start in the world of work.

I was discouraged by what I discovered. The Los Angeles Times (March 5, 2018) noted that not only is the Congressman’s $27 million declared net worth held in his wife’s name, but, as a well-heeled Yale law school graduate, he hadn’t paid off a $50,000 student loan, even as he argued that the taxpayer forgive it. Since he’s never met a payroll, I wouldn’t expect him to understand why others point to mandated wage hikes as unlikely to be any more successful in 2021 than when President Nixon implemented wage and price controls 50 years ago. 

Those concerned with market interventions by government note that durable wage growth is fueled by: 1) innovation, 2) profitability and/or 3) increases in productivity. And only when there are more jobs than people seeking them do wages naturally rise. However, if government intervenes to legislate an increase, unintended consequences arise. They include: 1) businesses being forced to cut back on hours, to hire fewer people, and to let people go, 2) people from lower wage markets displacing the less skilled (limiting wage growth, particularly If borders are open, 3) jobs (and industries) migrating overseas, and 4) smaller businesses laying people off, cutting back on their hours, and restricting new hiring. In the long run, it’s the young and the least skilled who are hurt, making them increasingly dependent. 

On the other hand, who isn’t troubled by the thought of families surviving on today’s minimum wage?  When investigative reporter Sharyl Attkisson (CBS News) was assigned to find parents raising kids on a minimum wage, she contacted every higher minimum wage advocacy group. After failing to turn up a single example, she sought a family where just one parent was working for minimum wage. Still failing to find anyone, she looked for a couple without kids surviving on minimum wages. Again, no luck. Even the category of a single parent working for minimum wage came up empty. (See “Slanted,” Sharyl Attkisson, HarperCollins 2020, pps 12-15). 

So, if a minimum wage hike is the solution, what is the problem? And what will be the longer-term consequences of a simple-minded solution? Our recent experience with similar virtue-signaling legislation has  been disappointing. For example, the well-intentioned Community Reinvestment Act resulted in the 2008 financial crisis that hurt the middle class as government bailed out banks. Likewise, the Federal Student Aid legislation contributed to college costs rising 8 times faster than wages. Moreover, Hugo Chavez’s platform of economic “equity” merely resulted in one of the wealthiest nations in the Western Hemisphere being unable to feed its population. 

It seems that local, free-market decision-making beats centralized decision-making every time.  So, instead of a Washington mandated minimum wage that can be easily absorbed in large cities and by large, well-established companies, why not allow every state to set its own minimum wage – and to make it as high as it would like?

Joni Fleck

I'm back in the classroom and love it! I learn something new from the kids when I'm in the classroom and they learn from me. Love being a Jr Pre-K Aide at Saint James Catholic School.

2 年

Total crap that Congressman Ro Khanna has $27 million dollar net worth in his wife's name and still owes $50,000 on his student loan. We can't get a student loan to help out our daughter because the government says we make to much which is total crap! We would like to retire someday and not be broke and are middle income earners. We do a 60/40 split with our kids where we pay 40% of their tuition so they have to be accountable for their schooling. If they fail a class they are throwing away more of their money than ours. Our daughter works and saves enough money each semester to pay off her schooling each semester so she doesn't have to pay interest. And she has good grades to boot. What gives that congressman the right to not pay off his student loan when he has the money to do it. Heck, he could help others with all that he has. My kids work their butts off and get no help from the government.

回复
Narghiza E.

Finance Executive

3 年

Please follow me just click this link https://www.dhirubhai.net/in/narghizaergashova/

Jon Allen

Managing Partner @ Ampleo | Fractional Executives for growth businesses | M&A / CFO

4 年

This was a really interesting thread to read. Actually not 100% where I stand on this issue yet but find this discussion informative and like the diverse set of arguments on both sides. I have a lot to learn and study on this topic.

回复
Cynthia Levesque

DBS Program Coordinator Brigham and Women’s Hospital

4 年

I agree, it should be state regulated for the simple reason the cost of living in each state is different. Now I haven’t done the research you all have, nor do I want to or have time to. I would love to see the “cost of living” mandated pay raise come back instead. For those still making less (for whatever reason; difference in education?) then the welfare department can make up the difference. But that’s an entire other issue which needs to be addressed. No one should struggle, but we’ve all been there.

Robert Mckee

--I am Robert and I enjoy working as a team and feel that goals, and values in life, are keys to success. I love learning new skills and look upon education as a lifetime journey.

4 年

Treat your employees well and treat your customers well.....because that is your business...investing in “people!” ??

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Joel Peterson的更多文章

  • Power from Position or from Trust?

    Power from Position or from Trust?

    To lead, one must be empowered. Stanford professor Jeff Pfeffer, a leading expert in the dynamics of power, describes…

    4 条评论
  • ON CREDULITY

    ON CREDULITY

    Once bewildered by COVID’s origin, lockdowns, and restrictions, many have gone on to embrace once-contentious…

    3 条评论
  • .

    .

    Last week, I made a decision to give up teaching “MGE,” a signature second-year course at Stanford’s Graduate School of…

    82 条评论
  • Opinion: Time to cancel ‘cancel culture’ on college campuses

    Opinion: Time to cancel ‘cancel culture’ on college campuses

    Management guru Peter Drucker once observed, “Culture eats strategy for breakfast.” Since values are at the heart of…

    69 条评论
  • Growth Through Adversity

    Growth Through Adversity

    It was a delight to host Hamid Moghadam, Chairman and CEO of Prologis, on the Running Stuff podcast. As one of the…

    5 条评论
  • How to Ruin a Meeting

    How to Ruin a Meeting

    The granular work of entrepreneurial leaders comes down to running meetings and having difficult conversations. Every…

    12 条评论
  • In the Era of Big Data, are Job Interviews Passé?

    In the Era of Big Data, are Job Interviews Passé?

    Nothing is more important to the entrepreneurial leader than assembling the right team. In "Entrepreneurial…

    3 条评论
  • Surviving COVID (and other disasters)

    Surviving COVID (and other disasters)

    Pandemics, wars, depressions, panics, natural disasters – each tests our preparedness, ingenuity and character. They…

    5 条评论
  • The World Needs More Entrepreneurial Leaders

    The World Needs More Entrepreneurial Leaders

    I love many things about teaching at Stanford, but one of my favorite parts of the job is spotting people who have the…

    16 条评论
  • Churchill and the Pale Blue Dot

    Churchill and the Pale Blue Dot

    During challenging times – when it’s easy to “fold in” on oneself – I reflect on two things. The first comes from…

    35 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了