Rethinking the MBA: Why Veterans Need to Consider a Tactical Masters for Career Success

Rethinking the MBA: Why Veterans Need to Consider a Tactical Masters for Career Success

Having navigated through academia, government and commercial business dynamics, and the challenges encountered by military veterans, I have noticed a worrisome pattern: a considerable portion of veterans opt for a Master of Business Administration (MBA) degree without sufficiently evaluating its compatibility with their career goals. As an advocate for the achievements of military veterans, I feel compelled to directly address this issue.

This article aims to examine the limitations of the Master of Business Administration (MBA) program for military veterans and suggests a more strategic approach by offering specialist tactical master's programs that are better suited for employment opportunities, and career satisfaction and are industry-relevant and appropriate.

Veterans possess unparalleled leadership, problem-solving, and teamwork abilities... These assets are occasionally disregarded in conventional Business Administration curricula.

The Master of Business Administration (MBA) degree has long been regarded as the ultimate achievement in business school, offering a flexible set of skills for advancing one's career. However, the extent to which it benefits military veterans transitioning into civilian positions is occasionally overstated. Because the MBA curriculum follows a standardised approach, it fails to consider the unique skills and experiences that veterans possess. Veterans possess unparalleled leadership, problem-solving, and teamwork abilities that they have honed via their military experience. These assets are occasionally disregarded in conventional Business Administration curricula.

The MBA is notably deficient in providing detailed details or information. Although it offers a thorough grasp of basic business principles, it does not tackle the intricate challenges that experienced professionals face when transitioning into the non-military job market. Adaptability and real-time decision-making are crucial in high-pressure and dynamic situations, particularly for veterans. Conversely, traditional MBA schools often fail to offer veterans the practical, experiential learning opportunities that deeply appeal to them.

To be qualified, you have to get qualified.

The MBA industry is already quite competitive. As the number of individuals joining the workforce with an MBA degree increases, the significance of the degree diminishes, resulting in it becoming less effective as a distinguishing factor in the labour market. This circumstance poses a significant challenge for veterans seeking meaningful employment. Veterans should explore specialty master's degrees that leverage their unique skill sets instead of getting lost among the numerous MBAs currently joining the workforce. Project management, cybersecurity, logistics, and supply chain management are all professions that provide distinct career trajectories that can lead to professional achievement.

Another hindrance that veterans have when considering the MBA is the financial burden. Transitioning from military to civilian life can pose financial challenges, and enrolling in a costly MBA degree may not necessarily provide anticipated returns. Tactical master's degree programs offer veterans tailored training that aligns with their employment objectives, while also being a more economical option.


Having said that, if you are being offered a “free” MBA that is being paid for by Defence etc. then you really need to question both the ethics and contracted dealings behind that and the fact that you, once again, are being placed onto a treadmill touting success. In short, you and the systems you support are ripping you off out of a lack of integrity and an understanding of both your skillsets and desires to have a bespoke new career.

Veterans should reassess their approach to higher education in light of the challenges they currently encounter. Veterans are advised to seek degrees that offer a personalised and hands-on education instead of simply choosing the MBA as their default choice. To enhance the transition of veterans into the civilian business, it is recommended to provide a strategic master's course that integrates experiential learning, simulations, and case studies specifically relevant to military contexts.

To be qualified, you have to get qualified.

The Master of Business Administration is not the panacea it is sometimes touted as for veterans. Veterans can make more informed decisions about their educational pursuits by carefully analysing their professional objectives, experiences, and skill sets. Specialised master's degrees offer veterans the necessary tools to excel in their chosen industries, presenting a strategic alternative. The prevailing narrative should be redirected from the MBA being the automatic choice to a customised approach that empowers veterans to fully unleash their potential in civilian work.

This really resonates Prof. Neil Curtis thankyou. As someone navigating this as we speak, it’s an interesting space and why I chose my Masters not based on an MBA. My suggestion for veterans and first responders and their organisations is that this should be leveraged as those consider transition: https://www.education.gov.au/national-industry-phd-program There is so much lived experiance not getting reinvested into acedemia and I’ve observed a shift where Defence and first-responder’s have been leaning to acedemics to tell us what we already know but struggle to articulate. If we could bridge the gap for those that don’t have a Batchelor to access this program I know it would also help the retention issues.

回复
Alex S.

Medilinks | Youth Mentor | Veteran

8 个月

Interesting article Prof. Neil Curtis. I listened to some analysis about MBA programs at Ivy League schools in the US where they can cost up to $200k. If that sum of money, or even the lesser amount for an Australian MBA, goes into a student loan then that definitely should be considered against salary expectations. ie. how long before the juice is worth the squeeze? I have done several uni degrees related to CT and Intelligence and found that both were too far abstracted to offer many practicable skills. The challenge as you say is what the person wants to get out of the qualification. Personally I am about to explore a Diploma of Business (thankfully funded through a veteran program) as I have heard that Tafe level qualifications are more practical than an MBA.

Bryce Turner

Executive | GAICD | Capability Management

8 个月

Like anything, you need to know where you’re going before you set off. My experiences from the MBA are as follows: 1. Being exposed to my equivalents in the civilian sector humbled me as to my gigantic skill gap when compared to my peers. (A CO is not a CEO…) 2. Provided me opportunity to leverage leadership experience without the accompanying authority the DFDA grants. (How good of a leader/shaper am I?) 3. Exposed me to industry’s and roles I did not know existed. Having completed two Masters degrees prior to the in person MBA I selected, I can say I learned considerable more. The MBA for me was a tool to establish a foot outside of defence, not the whole plan…

David Ballantyne

CEO at HomeFront Australia

8 个月

The best thing about an MBA for many veterans is when the study acts as a halfway house tempering the friction of transition. Whether pre-separation by burning long service or through injury or other entitlement, or post-separation as a way of decompressing into the civilian world, it's a traction point to push off from. Any fun sounding grad cert or master's program would do the same thing for sure, I agree. Residential MBAs at sandstone unis may still offer some peripheral benefits I would have thought, at least enough to grab hold of one if offered for nothing e.g. Commando Welfare Trust. Thanks Neil

David New

Executive at Dyadic Consultancy

8 个月

I agree. Moreover, universities themselves can be problematic. I discontinued my MBA after obtaining a Graduate Certificate, as the courses lacked any useful feedback and could have been easily replaced with online courses. Perhaps pursuing a Masters by Research or a PhD would be more fitting for veterans?

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Prof. Neil Curtis的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了