Rethinking: Leadership and The Imperative of Positive Employee Communication - With Checklist

A Rethinking Impulse by Klaus-Dieter Thill

What it's all about

In an era of ceaseless transformation, the capacity to engage in positive, constructive, and respectful dialogues with team members has become a defining trait of effective leadership. Through the lens of “Rethinking,” a methodology for reflecting upon and realigning one’s modes of thought and action, a new approach emerges: How might a leader conduct conversations with their team in a way that fosters authenticity and yields enduring, positive outcomes for collaboration? This endeavour requires more than mechanical mastery of communication techniques; rather, it positions the art of dialogue within a deep psychological, philosophical, and occupational psychology framework. At the intersection of self-awareness and professional leadership, Rethinking reveals that a renewed consciousness of communication does not merely enhance the workplace atmosphere; it also fortifies the leader’s resilience and capacity for action.

Defining the Topic: Conversations as the Core of Leadership Communication

Positive conversations with employees transcend superficial pleasantries or mere goal orientation. They embody a leadership approach that prioritises respect, transparency, and developmental potential. A “positive conversation” is not solely a harmonious exchange but a purpose-driven dialogue that promotes teamwork and clarifies objectives. In this sense, Rethinking signifies a conscious, reflective departure from traditional communication practices, moving towards a concept that infuses authenticity and depth into each interaction. The aim is to cultivate a leadership climate rooted in mutual trust, openness, and respect, enabling team members to realise their full potential.

Philosophical Perspective: Conversations as a Medium for Ethical Leadership

From a philosophical standpoint, a positive conversation can be seen as an act of ethical engagement. Dialogue between leaders and employees embodies responsibility and respect for the individuality of others. Authentic communication transcends mere information exchange, transforming into a tool for ethically grounded leadership. Rethinking invites team leaders to reconceptualise their role, not as an authoritarian decision-maker, but as a guide and inspirer for their team. In this light, communication becomes a practice of humility and attentiveness, capturing the essence of mature leadership. The art of dialogue affords the opportunity to explore the values and beliefs of others, turning conversations into a space of mutual exchange and appreciation.

Psychological and Deep Psychological Dimensions: Communication and the Leader’s Self-Image

In psychology and depth psychology, dialogue plays a vital role in shaping the self-image and identity of a leader. The way a conversation unfolds reflects the internal attitude and emotional intelligence of the leader. Empathy—demonstrated through understanding and attentiveness to the needs of the other—affects not only the relational bond but also bolsters the self-confidence of the leader. Here, Rethinking sees dialogue as a mirror of one’s personality, continuously refined through reflection and openness to self-criticism. Leaders are encouraged to question entrenched thought patterns, discovering new, more constructive communication pathways.

Occupational Psychological Dimensions: Dialogue as a Framework for Collaboration and Performance

From an occupational psychology perspective, the dialogue between leaders and employees becomes a key factor in team development and cooperative efficiency. The quality of communication significantly influences the trust and commitment employees feel towards their leader. Within the Rethinking paradigm, dialogue is a central tenet of a modern, people-centred leadership approach grounded in transparency and fairness. It becomes an instrument of structural guidance, offering employees clarity while creating space for feedback and input. Rethinking fosters a culture where employees are motivated to contribute their perspectives and align themselves with the company’s objectives.

Self-Management and Leadership Competence: The Relevance for Today’s Leaders

For leaders, the ability to conduct positive conversations is not merely a collaborative skill but also a critical element of self-management. Engaging with conversation techniques in the context of Rethinking enhances self-awareness of one’s communication patterns and encourages adaptability in diverse situations. This conscious engagement strengthens the leader’s presence, cultivating a sovereignty that inspires employee trust. Given the complexities of the modern work environment, this competence is indispensable, enabling leaders to navigate conflicts constructively, articulate clear goals, and foster lasting employee commitment.

Future Outlook and Digital Transformation: Dialogue in the Age of Technological Change

In the digital age, the ability to conduct positive conversations takes on a new significance. Virtual teams, remote work structures, and digital communication tools are transforming the way leaders connect with their teams. Rethinking in communication involves not only mastering classical techniques but also adapting to the nuances of digital communication. In an increasingly depersonalised work environment, it becomes a leader’s responsibility to cultivate human connection through mindful and respectful conversations. Particularly in digital meetings, recognising and responding to interpersonal subtleties is essential for fostering a sense of closeness and trust. Thus, digitalisation necessitates a rethinking and intentional adaptation of communication to virtual contexts.

Practical Application with the R2A Formula: Reflect, Analyze, Advance

The R2A Formula of Rethinking offers a structured approach for reflecting on, analysing, and developing positive communication techniques. By applying this formula, leaders can gradually refine their conversational style and enhance the quality of dialogue within their team.

Reflect: Becoming Aware of One’s Attitude and Intention in Dialogue

The first step involves reflecting on one’s communicative stance. Leaders should consider the values and motivations that underpin their approach to dialogue and clarify their expectations for each conversation. By examining one’s inner posture and acknowledging the role of a conversational partner, leaders establish the foundation for authentic, respectful communication. This reflection primes them to approach dialogue with attentiveness to employee perspectives.

Analyze: Assessing the Dynamics and Structure of Dialogue

In the second step, it is essential to analyse conversational dynamics and identify factors that either enhance or inhibit positive communication. Observing non-verbal cues, tone, and word choice provides a comprehensive view of one’s communicative strategy. Such analysis helps pinpoint areas for improvement, fostering a climate of openness and engagement.

Advance: Applying Techniques to Strengthen Positive Communication

In the final step, leaders should adopt techniques that contribute to a respectful and motivating conversational atmosphere. These include active listening, offering clear and constructive feedback, and creating space for employee input. By consciously implementing these techniques, dialogue becomes an inspiring moment that not only strengthens team spirit but also underscores the leader’s personal excellence in thought and action.

As communication increasingly comes under the influence of technological developments, the art of dialogue gains in significance. For leaders who expand their communicative competence in line with Rethinking principles, there lies the potential to develop a leadership style that is enduringly humane, offering their team security and guidance. The skill of positive conversation thus becomes integral to a forward-thinking, authentic, and effective leadership culture.

RethinkGuide: Positive Communication

Preparation Techniques

• Goal Definition: Establish clear goals for the conversation, whether to provide feedback, clarify expectations, or discuss new tasks.
• Creating Conditions: Ensure a suitable space and a welcoming atmosphere that minimises interruptions.
• Empathetic Alignment: Mentally and emotionally align with the conversational partner, actively adopting their perspective.
• Thematic Structuring: Draft a loose structure with key points, flexible enough to foster a natural flow.
• Preparing Examples: Equip oneself with relevant examples to clarify and enrich the dialogue.
• Questioning Techniques: Focus on open, exploratory questions to probe the employee’s perspectives and thoughts.

Techniques for Fostering Trust and Openness

• Active Listening: Demonstrate attentiveness with nodding, eye contact, and brief verbal acknowledgements.
• Paraphrasing: Reflect or summarise what is heard to avoid misunderstandings and affirm that the other is truly heard.
• Open Questions: Use questions beyond simple yes-or-no responses to gain deeper insights and views.
• Empathetic Feedback: Mirror emotional reactions, showing awareness of what resonates with employees.
• Allowing Pauses: Permit natural pauses to provide space for thoughts and emotions, allowing the conversation to breathe.
• Showing Understanding: Acknowledge challenges without rushing to solutions.

Feedback Techniques for Constructive Responses

• Positive Starts: Begin with positive points before addressing areas for improvement.
• I-Statements: Use “I” statements to communicate personal impressions, taking responsibility for one’s remarks.
• Addressing Behaviour: Critique behaviour rather than personality.
• Specific Feedback: Highlight concrete details instead of general praise or criticism.
• Explaining Consequences: Clarify the impact of behaviour on the team or work.
• Goal-Oriented Feedback: Offer feedback aligned with developmental aims or improvement opportunities.

Motivational Techniques for Engagement and Responsibility

• Targeted Praise: Recognise specific achievements and behaviours rather than offering general approval.
• Shared Goal-Setting: Define developmental goals together, empowering employees to take responsibility.
• Forward-Thinking Questions: Encourage future-oriented approaches with questions like, “How might you tackle this in future?”
• Encouraging Self-Reflection: Prompt employees to consider their progress and potential.
• Emphasising Resources and Strengths: Draw on employees’ capabilities and past successes.
• Fostering Initiative: Incorporate employees’ suggestions, encouraging active participation.

Concluding Techniques for Clear Agreement

• Shared Summary: Conclude with a brief recap of key discussion points.
• Concrete Agreements: Set and document agreed next steps or objectives.
• Clarifying Responsibilities: Ensure all parties understand who is accountable for each task.
• Follow-Up Schedule: Arrange a timeframe for follow-up or progress review.
• Encouraging Final Words: End on a positive note to reinforce trust and engagement.
• Expressing Gratitude: Show appreciation for the dialogue and the employee’s input.

By applying these methods, leaders can foster a culture of respect, appreciation, and productivity. This approach not only strengthens employee engagement but also establishes an environment conducive to personal growth and sustainable teamwork.

Further reading

• “Rethinking Communications” by Steve MacAulay and David Buchanan, UNLEASH, 2023.
• “Leadership Communication: The Key to Transforming Workplace Culture” by Stuart Cheesman, Headspring Executive, 2023.
• “Silent Leadership: The Power of Humility” by Humans of Globe, 2023.
• “Rethinking Leadership in the Learning Organization” by The Systems Thinker, 2023.
• “Rethink Your Employee Value Proposition” by Harvard Business Review, 2023.
• “Rethinking Leadership Communication: The Transformative Power of I-Statements in Leadership” by IFABST Hill, 2024.
• “Rethinking Leadership: The Urgent Need for Respect and Empathy” by Santini Ph.D., LinkedIn, 2023.
• “Rethinking Leadership in the Digital Age” by ResearchGate, 2023.

Note

The provisions of statutory copyright law apply.

The thematic scope and the matters described in this publication / self assessment are subject to continuous development. As such, all information provided in this guide reflects the knowledge available at the time of publication.

The reader/ user/ practitioner remains responsible for the application and implementation of the content provided. Consequently, the author assumes no responsibility and accepts no liability for any damages arising from the use of the information contained within this publication.

We use artificial intelligence to enhance the structural readability of our texts, optimise content for users, ensure the quality management of formal aspects, and generate attractive, context-appropriate images as well as audio versions of our articles (podcasts). Additionally, AI helps us analyse reader feedback, respond to trends, and continuously improve our content to provide you with the best possible reading experience.