Retail Taught Me How to Handle Harsh Feedback. Here's How to Avoid Feeling Like Crap.
Kit Campoy
I write for world-class SaaS Retail Tech Companies. Retail Leadership Expert & Author | Retail, Leadership, Business.
I got my ass handed to me more than once, leading retail teams.?
Nothing is ever good enough in the retail business. That's how it feels. Few successes are triumphed, and every failure is scrutinized.?
I led retail teams for over twenty years. By the time I left, I could've been told I was a complete failure, and it would've rolled off me. I was in my business for over forty hours a week. There was nothing I didn't know about it.?
No one-hour corporate visit would shake my confidence. I'd seen the worst and lived to speak about it.
The Worst of it
One manager I had was stoic and cold. She'd pencil in TB by your name on the schedule for the day, which meant?touch base. A touch base was never good. She wasn't going to sit down with me and tell me what an asset I was to the team. She wasn't going to tell me how stylish I was or thank me for coming in ten minutes early every day.
No. No, she wasn't.
I'd see TB on the schedule and be flooded with anxiety.
One of the craziest moments was when she said, "I'm not sure about your personality,"
We were sitting down at a TB in our windowless office. Outside, the sun shined bright in a cloudless sky. Inside our office was no light other than artificial, fluorescent light. (God forbid the people who design retail buildings install a window in the office.)
Wait, what did she just say? Oh, that's right, she wasn't sure about my personality.
She went on to say that I was always calm and I didn't express much emotion. Nothing seemed to shake me.?
I guess leading with a calm and even tone was a bad thing. I was beyond confused.?
She also said that I was too slow. I needed to pick up my pace — physically. She wanted me to walk faster through the building. I already felt like I was running around and couldn't fathom how to move any quicker, but I vowed to try.
What Now
Whenever I received harsh feedback like this, I'd listen and do my best to implement what my bosses wanted. However, at some point in your career, you realize certain requests are just bullsh!t.?
I can't "change my personality." It was also rude and hurtful that she expressed this. What did she expect me to do? She didn't say.
Also, I will not run around like the store is always on fire. It's unnecessary and causes stress within the team. I knew that even then.
领英推荐
Listen to what your bosses say. Take notes and reflect. Take action on what they tell you to do. If it doesn't work, tell them. Explain why it doesn't work.?
Years into my career, I realized I was free to make decisions and take action — as long as I could back up why I did it.?
Building confidence at work takes time. Be honest with yourself about what's working and not working.?
Be vocal. I did this too late. I didn't want to upset anyone or rock the boat. Finally, I no longer cared. I wanted my store to run as well as it possibly could, so I always gave feedback.?
Then when I had a pop visit from corporate, and they called me out for something, I could say, "Yes. I emailed my regional manager about that. We're working on it."
Being shaken by harsh feedback is never easy.?
Take a deep breath. Repeat back the expectations and do your best to move forward. Tomorrow is a new day.?
When you leave work, leave everything at the door. Clear your mind on your commute home. Do something you love for an hour. Listen to loud music or call your friend. I used to go to the gym, turn up my playlist, and imagine all my frustrations under my feet on the treadmill. With every step, I'd imagine I was stomping them into flat little pancakes.
Whatever works, right?
Remember, most companies move quickly. Next week, your boss' focus may be somewhere else.?
Me? I eventually took my personality elsewhere and ended up running a totally kick-ass store for a company and for people who appreciated me.
Remember, this is one day, and your options for work are endless.
You got this.
Hey, I'm Kit. I spent two decades leading teams in retail stores. I now write full-time and help smart business people with their LinkedIn presence. DM me.
Grab Your Guide - The Retail Leader's Field Guide is here! This is the how-to retail handbook you wish your company had given you. Get it now .
Join me in The Break Room. A safe space for retail leaders. Come as you are, vent, ask questions, and chill out. I'll see you there. Let's go.
Founder @ Unicorn Metrics LLC -"If you want change, Be the Change"
11 个月According to online HR Hacker newsletter; they mentioned a study by McKinsey showing productivity and performance that drive higher engagement. However the truth is, that without empathy for people there will not be engagement or productivity. Leading to organizational breakdown. Supporting the article article from the HR perspective. https://www.dhirubhai.net/newsletters/hacking-hr-6911723049536929792/
Retail Enterprise Leadership is my Skill - Customer Experience and Employee Engagement is my Passion
1 年Kit - leadership means so much to their direct report's success. It rolls downhill as well. The higher up, the more people you impact and don't even realize it. If a leader is out of touch with their people and those under them, you begin to run into analyzing every little behavior and it becomes cold and artificial like that office you sat in to have that TB. All of us (former) retail leaders have experienced this to some degree, and some of us can filter the info and just keep doing what we do best and not sweat the out of touch feedback. Others have a difficult time coping and it either affects personal lives or work performance. Here's to leaders stop talking about leadership and actually lead. You will have a more engaged staff and greater results. A rising tide raises all ships (and vice versa).
Regional Director/ Multi-Site Operations Manager/Business Owner
1 年Great article! I left a 20 year career in retail because of the culture of perfection. At some point the constant focus on the constructive while nonchalantly, dismissing the positive impacts your own personality. At one of my last retailers I had a brand new female boss tell me to my face “you are given high praises by everyone I have spoken to, but I dont care for it/you because I just don’t see it”. Turns out she was just as toxic at her last job and had been fired. No surprise shes moved on again. She was the straw that broke the camels back. Ultimately, she did me a favor because I left shortly after she came on. Unfortunately, her reign of terror didn’t end with me. My point being is that when you are focused on the constructive, the type of people that you bring into lead tend to be very toxic, and quite frankly, not very good at their jobs. I will never go back to retail because of this.
Chief People Officer & Co-Founder, Kustom HR | Fractional HR Consultant | Driving value for companies through human interaction, operational excellence & customized solutions
1 年Really appreciate you sharing this, Kit. This is a tough topic for any leader in any industry, and it's nice to see it handled empathetically. One of my favorite mantras for dealing with this is simply, "let it flow."