Retail Bankruptcy: Gradually, Then Suddenly
Photo by Melinda Gimpel on Unsplash

Retail Bankruptcy: Gradually, Then Suddenly

JC Penney, J. Crew, Neiman Marcus, Pier One – all announced bankruptcy in the past couple of weeks. That’s after Lucky’s Markets, Earth Fare, Macy’s, and Mattress Firm and others filed. The list will only grow – we’re only five months into 2020.

 In 2019, 16 of the 25 retailers that filed ended up liquidating. So far this year five of the 15 have plans to liquidate.

Many of these companies blame the pandemic lockdown for their failures. Others blame Amazon, or online shopping in general, or millennials. What’s interesting is that none of them blame poor management, bad decisions, or a lack of a coherent strategy.

“How did you go bankrupt?,” Bill asked.

“Two ways,” Mike said. “Gradually, then suddenly.”

This is a well-known and oft-repeated quote from Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises. As is true with much of his work, there is a much deeper meaning than the surface humor. The line is actually about change, and how we adapt to it. We develop bad habits or make poor decisions. When those don’t have immediate ill effects, we make more bad decisions and develop bad decision-making habits.

Those poor choices might be financial, or health-related, or about our relationships. The process is similar for each. But we’re talking about business here, so we’ll stick to that.

Gradually then suddenly is how many public companies end up in bankruptcy court. They put the focus on this quarter’s results, losing sight of the long-term. Soon it becomes a habit: making decisions that impact the short-term, while the underlying health of the company begins to erode as inflating the stock price becomes the only goal.

Much as it is with a poor diet or not exercising, the effects aren’t immediately apparent. Over time, the impact of poor decisions starts to have a multiplier effect, and by the time we figure out that something is really wrong, it’s too late. We get a cavity, or have a heart attack – or we can’t pay our employees.

Chapter 11 bankruptcy allows the filing company to “reorganize.” This generally means restructuring debt loads that have become unmanageable. A committee is formed to represent the interests of creditors and stockholders, and a plan is created to help the company emerge as a profitable entity.

What is frequently missing from the restructure process is a change in company leadership. Those who got the company into this mess are frequently left in place to supposedly make better decisions. But old habits die hard, and the success rate for post-bankruptcy is less than 50 percent.

Once a company declares bankruptcy, everything should be on the table. Anything that was in place before should be required to prove that it will contribute to the future success; this includes senior management and the board of directors. But often the exact opposite happens: those on whose watch the failures multiplied are offered stay-on bonuses when in reality they ought to be the first out the door.

Amazon is often at the top of the list for the retail failure blame game. While it’s true that online shopping has changed the landscape, that change isn’t strictly Amazon-led. The company gets about 36 percent of online shopping orders, which is down from 42 pre-pandemic.

Amazon has seen a significant drop in sales since the start of the pandemic crisis as its supply chain was overwhelmed and delivery times went from overnight to “maybe next week.” This exposed a crack in the Amazon fortress; its shoppers were more than willing to go elsewhere when Amazon couldn’t provide what they wanted. So much for loyalty.

Walmart and Target have both seen solid gains for online shopping. Best Buy has been able to successfully reinvent itself in a category that is famously online-centric. But its entire business model changed.

But Amazon, along with Best Buy, is playing the long game. Both make investments that may not pay off for months or longer, but that help to build solid foundations for the business. They take a customer-centric view and haven’t been afraid to change things wholesale when it was necessary.

The real problem for retail isn’t online shopping, or Amazon, or millennials. The problem is failing to understand and adapt to the changes that have always been part of retail. History is full of those who didn’t adapt to change – from the British Army during the American Revolution to railroads to Blockbuster video.

Pier One has already announced it plans to liquidate. JC Penney is taking a different tack, eager to emerge as soon as possible. But unless the underlying cause of the failure is addressed – sales have been in decline for 20 years – then this step only serves to prolong the inevitable.

The real question is what will change at JCP? How will the company become relevant to shoppers who have long since lost interest? What miraculous offering is in development that will have shoppers lining up to get in? Those same questions apply to Neiman Marcus, J.Crew, Macy’s and so on.

Unfortunately, the likely answer to “what will change” is: “Not much.” And in 12 or 24 months, we will be talking once again about the sad decline of a once-great retailer that is now gone forever. Gradually at first, then suddenly.

Ron Orgiefsky

Business leader, strategic advisor, mentor and problem solver in CPG and Retail

4 年

Great article, Jeff! Indeed, there will be many names to be added to the "retail graveyard" this year, joining the likes of Ames, Bradlees, Caldor, Venture, Radio Shack, Borders...and the list goes on. Behaviors change, tastes change, cultures morph, debt loads become too big, and other factors all are contributors. And just like the "overnight success" that takes 20 years to build up, the demise of once-successful companies, be they retailers or otherwise, never JUST happen all of a sudden, but are brought down by a build-up, layer-after-layer, or wrong decisions made, or decisions made for the wrong reasons.

Gary Newman

Retail Authority/Mentor

4 年

Did someone mention M&S UK???

Cynthia Jordan

Breast Cancer Advocate | Empowering Global Advocacy for Prevention, Diagnosis, and Treatment

4 年

Great article!!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Jeff Weidauer的更多文章

  • Over 50 and Employed? Good for You Feeling Secure? Good Luck

    Over 50 and Employed? Good for You Feeling Secure? Good Luck

    Job security. You know that term.

    1 条评论
  • Brownie Wise: The Marketing Genius You've Never Heard Of

    Brownie Wise: The Marketing Genius You've Never Heard Of

    Tupperware has been in the news this week after announcing it was on the verge of going of out business. Its reliance…

    1 条评论
  • From Employed to Unemployed to Unemployable

    From Employed to Unemployed to Unemployable

    Four years ago I was laid off from my job of nearly 11 years. It wasn’t a surprise; I had made copies of everything I…

    2 条评论
  • Is Infinite Leisure Really the Goal?

    Is Infinite Leisure Really the Goal?

    In 1905, William Osler, who was physician-in-chief at Johns Hopkins hospital and a leading figure in the global medical…

  • Congrats on the New Job. What's Next?

    Congrats on the New Job. What's Next?

    As a career coach I talk with a lot of people who are in a state of career disarray. Many – right now maybe most – are…

  • Conquering the Paycheck Mentality

    Conquering the Paycheck Mentality

    “A ship in the harbor is safe, but that’s not what ships are for.” That quote has been attributed to a few people over…

    2 条评论
  • The Paradox of Barriers

    The Paradox of Barriers

    Humans are creatures of habit. Once we find something that feels like it works, we stick with it, rarely pursuing…

    6 条评论
  • The Dark Side of WFH

    The Dark Side of WFH

    If you normally work in an office, chances are you currently WFH (work from home). This has been the standard since…

  • Whither Grocery?

    Whither Grocery?

    Until the mid-20th century, shopping for food meant a trip to several stores: the produce market, the butcher, the dry…

    10 条评论
  • Home for the Holidays?

    Home for the Holidays?

    Remember last December? No one imagined what the coming weeks and months would bring. Seems like forever ago.

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了