The Resilience of Art: How the French Art Market Thrived Under Nazi Occupation

When we think of World War II, images of destruction, hardship, and cultural suppression often come to mind. However, a groundbreaking study by economist Kim Oosterlinck reveals a surprising narrative from this dark period: the remarkable resilience and even prosperity of the French art market during the Nazi occupation from 1940 to 1944. This fascinating research sheds light on a little-known aspect of art history and offers valuable insights into the nature of art as an investment and a cultural commodity.

The Unexpected Boom

Oosterlinck's study, based on extensive sales data from the renowned H?tel Drouot auction house in Paris, paints a picture starkly different from what one might expect during wartime. Rather than collapsing, the art market experienced an extraordinary boom. By early 1943, the real value of artworks had surged to more than three times their pre-war levels. This remarkable increase outperformed nearly all other investment options available at the time, including stocks, bonds, and even black market currencies.

The numbers are striking: art prices soared while the French stock market and government bonds struggled. Only gold traded illegally on the black?market,?rivalled art in terms of investment performance. This phenomenon raises intriguing questions about the nature of art as an asset and its role in times of crisis.

Understanding the Surge

Several factors contributed to this unexpected art market boom:

1. Discretion and Portability: Art offered a unique advantage in an era of uncertainty. Paintings, especially smaller pieces, could be easily concealed or transported. This made them attractive to those looking to hide wealth from occupying forces or potential looters and to individuals who feared they might need to flee the country at short notice.

2. Inflation Hedge: With wartime inflation on the rise, tangible assets like art served as a reliable store of value. Unlike currency, which rapidly lost its worth, a painting's intrinsic value remained stable or increased.

3. Legal Safe Haven: Unlike gold or foreign currencies strictly controlled by occupying forces, art could be bought and sold relatively freely. This made it an attractive option for those seeking to invest or protect their wealth without resorting to illegal black market activities.

4. International Appeal: Artworks retained their value across borders, making them ideal for those considering leaving France. A painting in Paris would likely be valuable in New York or London, providing a form of portable wealth.

5. Limited Alternative Investments: With restrictions on many traditional forms of investment, art became one of the few accessible options for those looking to protect or grow their wealth.

Trends Within the Boom

Oosterlinck's research reveals trends within this overall market surge:

Preference for Smaller Works:?During the occupation, more miniature artworks commanded higher premiums relative to larger pieces. This trend likely reflected the increased value placed on discretion and portability. A small canvas could be easily hidden or taken along if one needed to leave quickly.

Subject Matter Shifts: Landscapes and still-lifes became particularly popular during this period. This may have been due to their generally apolitical nature, making them safer choices in a politically charged environment.

The "Degenerate" Art Phenomenon: One of the most intriguing aspects of the study concerns what the Nazis termed "degenerate" artworks by avant-garde, Jewish, or otherwise disapproved artists. Initially, these pieces saw a sharp decline in value. However, as the liberation of Paris approached, their prices began to recover, eventually converging with "approved" art. This fluctuation provides a unique insight into the role of "conspicuous consumption" in art valuation and how quickly artistic values can shift with changing political winds.

Lessons for Today's Art World

This historical episode offers valuable insights for contemporary art collectors, historians, and economists:

1. Art's Resilience: The study demonstrates art's resilience as an asset class, even in the most challenging times. This supports the notion of art as a "haven" investment during economic or political turmoil.

2. The Impact of Societal Changes: The rapid shifts in the valuation of "degenerate" vs "approved" art highlight how quickly societal changes can impact artistic values and preferences.

3. The Role of Discretion: The premium placed on?smaller, more portable works during this period underscores the importance of considering practical factors like size and subject matter in art valuation, especially in uncertain times.

4. Art as a Store of Value: The art market's performance during this period reinforces the idea of art as not just a cultural asset but also a financial one.

5. The Complexity of Art Valuation: The study reveals how factors beyond aesthetic value - including political climate, practical considerations, and potential for conspicuous consumption - can significantly impact art prices.

A New Perspective on a Dark Era

Oosterlinck's research provides a fresh perspective on a well-studied historical period. It reminds us that human creativity and the desire for beauty and culture persist even in the darkest times. The thriving art market under Nazi occupation speaks to the resilience of the human spirit and the enduring value placed on artistic expression.

This study offers art lovers a new lens through which to view works from this era. Each painting from this period potentially carries a complex history - it may have been a prized investment, a portable form of wealth for a family in flight, or a silent act of resistance against a repressive regime.

As we reflect on this turbulent period in art market history, we're reminded of the multifaceted nature of art. It serves not just as a form of cultural expression but as a store of value, a political statement, and even a lifeline in times of crisis. The next time you stand before a painting created or sold during World War II, take a moment to consider the unseen role it may have played in preserving wealth, culture, and perhaps even lives during one of history's most trying periods.

In the end, the story of the French art market under Nazi occupation is more than just an economic curiosity. It's a testament to the enduring power of art to adapt, survive, and thrive, even in the face of overwhelming adversity. As we face our own uncertain times, perhaps we can draw inspiration from this remarkable chapter in art history, finding in it a reminder of art's unique ability to preserve value - both cultural and economic - even in the most challenging circumstances.

More articles:

https://artxchange.substack.com

?