Resigned, Then Offered a Promotion? Smart Career Move or Short-Term Fix?
Md Mehbub Ullah Ratul
Tech Project Manager || Java | Spring | SQL || Fintech | Cyber Security
Why I Wrote This Article
Recently, I came across a LinkedIn post where someone asked:
"What should an employee do after resigning if management promises growth?"
The post provided four options:
1?? Stick to the decision and move
2?? Stay if promised growth
3?? Negotiate a better offer
4?? Wait and see how things unfold
This question struck a chord with me. Many professionals face this dilemma at some point in their careers. Resigning is rarely an impulsive decision—it’s usually the result of deeper frustrations, career stagnation, or better opportunities elsewhere.
Yet, should one reconsider when management suddenly offers promotions, salary hikes, or career growth after a resignation?
Rather than relying on opinions, let's explore real-world data, industry reports, and case studies to find answers.
Option 1: Stick to the Decision and Move
Best choice if:
? You’re leaving due to fundamental issues (poor leadership, toxic culture, lack of growth).
? The new opportunity aligns better with long-term career goals.
? The counteroffer is a reaction to your resignation rather than a genuine career plan.
What Data Says:
?? Studies indicate that a significant percentage of employees who accept counteroffers eventually leave their jobs within a short period. For instance, research suggests that many employees who accept counteroffers move on within 6 to 12 months. (Momentum Legal)
??Accepting a counteroffer may not address the underlying issues that prompted the resignation, leading to continued dissatisfaction. (Stanton House)
Real Example:
While specific public examples are limited due to confidentiality, industry reports highlight that employees who accept counteroffers often find that the underlying issues prompting their initial resignation remain unresolved. This can lead to continued dissatisfaction and eventual departure from the company. (Stanton House)
Pro Tip: If your company truly valued you, they would have acted before your resignation. Don’t let a counteroffer delay your career growth.
Option 2: Stay if Promised Growth
Best choice if:
? The company has a strong track record of fulfilling promises.
? The offer includes a clear, structured plan with timelines.
? The growth potential is better than the new opportunity.
What Data Says:
?? A study by Robert Half indicates that employees who accept counteroffers often leave the company within two years, suggesting that such offers may not lead to long-term satisfaction or career growth. (Robert Half Press)
?? If management didn’t recognize your value before, there’s a high chance they won’t prioritize you later unless there’s a formal agreement.
Real Example:
At Google, retention efforts are comprehensive and personalized. The company has expanded its "Stay and Thrive" team to support employees' career paths, including creating structured career plans with clear timelines. This approach ensures that promises made during retention discussions are fulfilled, providing employees with well-defined growth paths. (Google)
Pro tip: Ensure all promises are documented with clear timelines and measurable outcomes. This keeps management accountable and increases the chances of real career growth.
Option 3: Negotiate a Better Offer
Best choice if:
? You’re open to staying but want to maximize benefits.
? You negotiate beyond salary (job title, leadership opportunities, stock options, flexibility).
? Your skills are in high demand, giving you leverage.
领英推è
What Data Says:
?? Employees who negotiate their salaries can secure increases ranging from $5,000 to $15,000 more per year. (Glassdoor).
?? Employers often anticipate negotiations; a survey revealed that 70% of managers expect candidates to negotiate their salary offers. (Source)
Real Example:
While specific public examples of engineers negotiating counteroffers with significant salary increases, leadership roles, and hybrid work arrangements are rare due to privacy considerations, companies like Microsoft have established flexible work policies. Microsoft's approach to hybrid work allows employees to design a work experience that best suits their needs, offering flexibility in worksite, location, and hours. (Microsoft Career)
Pro tip: Always negotiate—even if you decide to leave!
Option 4: Wait and See How Things Unfold
Risky choice because:
?? Counteroffers often fade once the urgency of resignation is gone.
?? You might lose the new opportunity while waiting.
?? Management may have made a temporary offer to prevent disruption, not for long-term retention.
What Data Says:
?? A study by Robert Half found that 39% of employees who stayed after receiving a counteroffer reported no career growth within a year. (Source)
?? Delaying a decision might weaken your position in both companies, as the company might perceive you as less committed, and your future employer may move on to other candidates
Hypothetical Scenario:
A cybersecurity specialist was promised a promotion "in the next quarter" if he stayed. He waited. A year later, he was still in the same role, watching colleagues get promoted while his new opportunity had long disappeared.
A Better Approach: The Hybrid Strategy
Instead of picking a single option, use a hybrid approach:
? Test management’s intent: Ask for a formal commitment—salary adjustment, promotion letter, or timeline.
? Compare both offers objectively: Which aligns better with your 5-year career plan?
? Control the timeline: If management needs time, ask for a trial period before rejecting the new offer.
Final Thoughts: Think Long-Term
A counteroffer is often a short-term fix for your employer, not a long-term career solution for you. Your career growth should never be reactive to a resignation—it should be intentional.
Before deciding, ask yourself:
? Why did I want to leave in the first place?
? Has management truly changed, or is this just damage control?
? Does the counteroffer align with my long-term career goals?
If you're uncertain, remember why you decided to resign—those underlying issues likely haven’t changed.
References
1?? Counteroffers & Employee Retention:
- Momentum Legal: Surprising Data About Counteroffers
- Stanton House: Counteroffers—Revealing Statistics and Their Short-Term Fix
2?? Salary Negotiation & Career Growth:
3?? Employee Regret & Career Stagnation:
- LinkedIn Insights: 50% of Professionals Regret Accepting a Counteroffer
- Robert Half: 39% of Employees Who Waited Saw No Career Growth
4?? Company Retention Strategies:
- Harvard Business Review: 80% of Employees Who Accept Counteroffers Leave Within 6 Months
- Microsoft Hybrid Work Policy: Microsoft Official Blog on Flexible Work