Reimagining Governance: Unleashing Innovation in Higher Education Boards

#HigherEducation #Innovation #Governance #Leadership #StrategicVision #BoardLeadership #ContinuousLearning #DataDriven

This is the fifth in a series of articles to guide college and university governing boards toward optimizing trusteeship in the strategic and generative dimensions of governance.

College and university governing boards have a vital role in guiding institutions toward success. Adopting a generative governance approach becomes essential as their responsibilities grow beyond traditional fiduciary oversight. This approach can transform boards into valuable thought partners, driving change and securing a bright future for their institutions.

Understanding Generative Governance

Generative governance goes beyond asking "What?" and "How?" to explore "Why?" It involves:

• Framing issues in new ways
• Identifying underlying assumptions
• Exploring alternative perspectives
• Generating innovative solutions

By engaging in generative thinking, boards can help institutions:

• Anticipate and prepare for future challenges
• Uncover new opportunities
• Challenge the status quo
• Foster a culture of innovation

Techniques for Fostering Generative Thinking

Reframe the Agenda

Traditional board agendas often focus on reports and approvals. To encourage generative thinking:

• Start meetings with open-ended strategic questions
• Allocate significant time for discussion before decision-making
• Include "blue sky" sessions with no formal agenda

Example: Instead of a standard "Enrollment Report," frame the agenda item as "Reimagining Student Recruitment in a Post-Pandemic World."

Practice Scenario Planning

Scenario planning helps boards think creatively about potential futures:

• Develop multiple scenarios based on key uncertainties
• Explore implications for the institution in each scenario
• Identify robust strategies that work across scenarios

Exercise: Annually, dedicate a board retreat to exploring 3-4 plausible future scenarios for higher education and their implications for your institution.

Encourage Diversity of Thought

Diverse perspectives are crucial for generative thinking:

• Recruit board members with varied backgrounds and expertise
• Invite external experts to challenge board assumptions
• Encourage respectful disagreement and debate

Technique: Implement a "devil's advocate" role in discussions, rotating this responsibility among board members.

Leverage Design Thinking

Adapt design thinking principles to governance:

• Empathize: Deeply understand stakeholder needs
• Define: Frame challenges from multiple perspectives
• Ideate: Generate a wide range of potential solutions
• Prototype: Develop low-risk pilots for new initiatives
• Test: Gather feedback and iterate

Workshop Idea: Conduct a design thinking session on "Reimagining the Student Experience" with input from students, faculty, and staff.

Implement Reverse Mentoring

Connect board members with students, faculty, or young alumni:

• Gain fresh perspectives on institutional challenges
• Stay attuned to emerging trends and technologies
• Bridge generational gaps in understanding

Program Suggestion: Pair each board member with a student leader for quarterly conversations throughout the academic year.

Foster a Learning Board Culture

Cultivate an environment of continuous learning:

• Dedicate time in each meeting to explore new ideas or trends
• Encourage board members to share insights from their professional domains
• Provide opportunities for board members to attend conferences or workshops

Practice: Begin each board meeting with a 15-minute "Learning Spotlight" where a board member or guest presents on an emerging trend in higher education or a relevant field.

Use Generative Questions

Train the board to ask probing, generative questions:

• What assumptions are we making?
• How might this issue look from a different stakeholder's perspective?
• What would success look like in 10 years?
• If we were creating this institution from scratch today, how would we approach this?

Tool: Develop a "Generative Question Bank" for board members to reference during discussions.

Engage in Appreciative Inquiry

Focus on strengths and possibilities:

• Identify what's working well and why
• Envision the ideal future state
• Design pathways to achieve that vision

Exercise: Conduct an Appreciative Inquiry summit with board members, administrators, faculty, and students to co-create a vision for the institution's future.

Practice Systemic Thinking

Encourage boards to consider the broader context and interconnections:

• Map the ecosystem in which the institution operates
• Identify potential ripple effects of decisions
• Consider long-term and indirect consequences of actions

Tool: Use systems mapping exercises to visualize complex issues and their interconnections.

Create Space for Reflection

Build in time for deep reflection:

• Schedule regular board retreats focused on big-picture thinking
• Encourage journaling or reflection essays from board members
• Allow silent contemplation time during meetings

Practice: End each board meeting with a reflective discussion: "What new insights did we gain today? What questions are we leaving with?"

Overcoming Barriers to Generative Governance

Implementing these techniques may face resistance. Common challenges include:

• Time constraints
• Comfort with traditional governance models
• Fear of overstepping into management's domain
• Difficulty measuring the impact of generative thinking

To address these:

• Gradually introduce generative practices, demonstrating their value over time
• Provide training and resources on generative governance
• Clearly delineate the board's generative role from management's responsibilities
• Develop qualitative measures to assess the impact of generative discussions

Conclusion

By embracing generative thinking, college and university governing boards can transcend their traditional roles to become true thought partners in institutional leadership. The techniques outlined here provide a roadmap for boards to foster innovation, challenge assumptions, and help their institutions navigate an increasingly complex landscape.

As boards become more proficient in generative governance, they will find themselves better equipped to anticipate challenges, seize opportunities, and guide their institutions towards a thriving future. In doing so, they not only optimize their own performance but also significantly enhance the value they bring to the institutions they serve.

Additional Readings

Books:

• "Governance as Leadership: Reframing the Work of Nonprofit Boards" by Richard P. Chait, William P. Ryan, and Barbara E. Taylor
• "Governance Reimagined: Organizational Design, Risk, and Value Creation" by David R. Koenig
• "The Fifth Discipline: The Art & Practice of The Learning Organization" by Peter M. Senge
• "Design Thinking for the Greater Good: Innovation in the Social Sector" by Jeanne Liedtka, Randy Salzman, and Daisy Azer
• "Systems Thinking for Social Change: A Practical Guide to Solving Complex Problems, Avoiding Unintended Consequences, and Achieving Lasting Results" by David Peter Stroh

Articles:

• "Strategic Leadership in Higher Education: A Transformative Framework" by John P. Kotter
• "Data-Driven Decision-Making in Higher Education: Challenges and Opportunities" by Rebecca Ferguson et al.

Reports:

• "Innovative Governance Models for Higher Education" by the World Economic Forum
• "Building a Culture of Continuous Learning: Implications for Higher Education" by the American Council on Education

_________________________________________________________________________________

Robert (Skip) Myers, Ph.D., advises and counsels college and university governing boards and their presidents seeking to optimize and align their joint leadership performance.

Follow him at Robert (Skip) Myers, Ph.D.