Reflections from Israel: A Journey Through Time and?Emotions
Alfred G. Sogja
Strategy + Operations | Growth Advisor to Startups & Political Campaigns | Passionate about Companies Building the Future
A blog series from “Israel Through My Eyes: Observations and Reflections from a Personal Journey.”?
Landing in Israel this time felt different. As the wheels of the plane touched the ground, a heavy mix of anticipation and dread settled in my heart. Having visited Israel before under vastly different circumstances – from the joyous camaraderie of educational trips to forming deep, personal connections – I've come to know this land in ways that both inspire and challenge me. But this visit stands apart; it's about witnessing, understanding, and sharing a narrative that goes beyond the headlines, aiming to capture the soul of a nation in turmoil.
My connection to this land is multifaceted, woven from threads of history, academia, and personal engagement. At The Fletcher School, where I studied diplomacy and international business, I delved into the intricacies of global conflicts and the art of diplomacy, framing my approach to the complexities I now face on the ground. My Albanian roots, interlaced with the poignant echoes of Kosovo's past, remind me of the harsh realities of war and the fragile beauty of peace, shaping my perspective as I step back onto Israeli soil.
Moreover, my bond with Israel is deeply personal and historically significant. It started long before my first visit, sparked by the heroic stories of Albanians who risked everything to save Jewish lives during World War II. This legacy of courage and compassion is a cornerstone of my identity and a guiding light in my journey. Leading educational trips to Israel for my graduate peers, I sought to share this profound connection, exposing them to the multitude of voices and narratives that paint the true complex picture of this land.
This visit, however, is driven by a different purpose. As I navigate the streets and interact with its people, I carry with me a responsibility to observe, to listen, and to convey the realities of a nation grappling with its present while anchored to its past. Through my eyes, I hope to offer you a glimpse into the heart of Israel, beyond the surface-level portrayals, into the depths of its soul.
The Silence of Vibrancy: Observations in Tel Aviv
The Tel Aviv I remembered, once brimming with life and laughter, now feels like a distant memory. As I wandered through the streets, the stark contrast was unmistakable. Rothschild and Dizengoff Street, once a pulsating heart of city life with its lively bustle, now lay shrouded in a somber stillness. Cafés and spots that used to be meeting hubs, teeming with vibrant conversations and laughter, stood eerily quiet. The places where I once shared joy and camaraderie with friends now bore the weight of a profound, collective shock.
The city's once indefatigable spirit seems temporarily subdued, reflecting the deep scars left by recent events. Streets that were once the backdrop for nightly revelry and spontaneous gatherings now host only sparse, hurried footsteps. Locals, usually known for their warmth and outgoing nature, now move with a cautious awareness, a stark reflection to the current mood. It's not just the empty chairs or the quieter ambiance; it's the palpable change in the air — a mixture of resilience and reticence.
This new reality in Tel Aviv isn't just a change of scenery; it's a reflection of a community in the throes of processing an unimaginable horror. To put it into perspective, the impact here, in terms of the local population, mirrors the profound shock and grief experienced in the United States after 9/11. It’s a shared understanding of deep loss on a national level, bringing an unspoken need for reflection and solace. People are staying home, not out of the customary desire for relaxation, but perhaps out of an unspoken need for reflection and solace. The shift is more than physical; it's emotional, a shared experience of upheaval and uncertainty. The city, known for its unyielding energy and joy, now whispers the question on everyone’s minds: How do we move forward from here?
The Echoes of Urgency: "Bring Them Home Now!"
In every corner of Tel Aviv, the "Bring Them Home Now!" posters create a pervasive mosaic of urgency and memory that wraps around the city's very fabric. These posters aren't just fleeting images; they are a constant, haunting presence in the lives of every Israeli, a reminder of the individuals behind the headlines whose fates hang in a delicate balance between hope and despair.
This campaign to remember the hostages transcends mere words, transforming public spaces into living memorials. It serves as a poignant reminder that if we don't remember them, who will? The faces on these posters span the spectrum of loss and longing: from those whose bodies have yet to be recovered, silent testimonies to unresolved grief, to those presumed still alive, snatched away by conflicts past and present. Their images are a fixture in the collective Israeli consciousness, a call to action that is as much about ensuring their memory as it is about the relentless pursuit of their return.
One evening, amid the city's altered rhythms, I was drawn to a graffiti-covered wall. Among the painted cries for peace and justice, the image of a young man – someone's son, brother, friend – stopped me in my tracks. His eyes, captured in the frozen moment of the photograph, seemed to transcend his own story, reaching out not just for rescue, but for a deeper understanding and a plea for peace that transcends individual suffering.
This silent plea resonates deeply within the heart of Israel, a shared mission that unites the nation across divisions of politics, religion, and ideology. The presence of these posters and graffiti across the country is an indication of a collective resolve: to bring them home, to heal as a community, and to never forget those who are missing. In the shadow of these reminders, the streets of Tel Aviv and beyond speak a powerful message of shared loss, hope, and the unyielding human spirit.
The Politics of Crisis: A Nation Divided Yet United
So there I was, just wandering around when I quite literally stumbled into a protest. It was an unexpected turn in my day – one minute I'm soaking in the sights and sounds of the city, and the next, I'm amidst a sea of passionate voices, each clamoring for a better future for Israel. I couldn’t help but dive in, talking to people, trying to get a sense of the varied emotions and perspectives in the crowd.
领英推荐
You’ve got folks arguing that now’s the time we should all be pulling together, putting aside our differences. And then there are others, just as vocal, who believe that keeping quiet is the last thing anyone should do in times like these. Witnessing these protests, right in the heart of a city that’s already dealing with so much, really puts the spotlight on the tug-of-war within the society, wrestling with who they are and where they're headed.
But here’s the kicker: despite the noise, the arguing, and all the tension, what I’m seeing is democracy in action. Sure, it’s messy and loud, but it’s also alive and kicking. People here aren’t shy about standing up for what they believe in, and that’s something I can’t help but respect.
Campus Conversations: The Pulse of the Youth
After Tel Aviv, I visited Be'er Sheva in the south with a Shabbat invitation from one of my best friends who studies at Ben Gurion University. While I didn't step inside the classrooms – as restrictions apply to non-students – the stories my friend and her peers shared painted a vivid picture. Each classroom harbors one or two 'empathy chairs,' left empty in honor of former students held hostage. These aren't just absent students; they're friends, family, or someone a friend knows. The presence of these chairs serves as a stark, daily reminder of the intersecting personal lives and national crises.
During my stay, conversations inevitably gravitated towards the current situation. In one particularly poignant discussion, a friend of a friend expressed her growing uncertainty about her future in Israel, influenced by the changing demographics and political landscape. The response from another was immediate and visceral: "WHY? But you are a Jew, and they hate us everywhere." The raw honesty of this exchange struck me – it was a window into the internal conflicts many young Israelis are grappling with.
The visit took an uplifting turn when my friend invited me to a rooftop davening session organized by Beit Prat. This group's mission is to bridge gaps between religious and secular Jews, and what I witnessed there was nothing short of inspiring. Together, under the open sky, the group found common ground in prayer and song. But as a red medical helicopter flew by, a palpable shift occurred – the collective heartbeat of hope briefly gave way to one of anxiety, a stark reminder of the fragile line between normalcy and crisis in Israel today.
Strong Together: A Message of Unity and Peace
In every conversation and every quiet moment of reflection, one theme resurfaced like a beacon in the night: "Strong Together." This mantra, echoing through the words and actions of Israelis from all walks of life, struck a chord with me. It’s a symbol of an unbroken spirit facing relentless adversity, a reminder that unity and collective strength can navigate the roughest seas.
But this message of solidarity goes hand in hand with a complex truth: the pursuit of peace and human rights must remember all sides of history. It’s a delicate balance, recognizing the pain and narratives of each community, ensuring that in our quest for justice, we don't overshadow one tragedy with another. My journey and conversations here underscored that real strength lies in our shared humanity – in understanding, empathy, and the relentless pursuit of a peace that honors all.
Conclusion: A Journey of Observation and Understanding
Each day here is a step deeper into the heart of Israel's current reality. My background, with its roots in a land also scarred by conflict, guides my observations, seeking not to judge but to understand, to share, and to bridge gaps. In the days to come, I will continue to unpack the layers of this complex narrative, aiming to offer a lens of empathy and insight. Together, through these posts, my hope is to start unraveling the intricate mix of conflict, culture, and human resilience that defines this land.
MBA candidate at MIT Sloan School of Managment
8 个月Well said
Marketing and Strategy Consultant for Convivium Graduate Researcher Harvard Medical School | NASA Grant Research
8 个月Beautiful writing Alfred, excited to read more
Finance and Policy Analyst at Meidata working in the fields of Policy, Economic and Financial Regulation, Innovation in Finance and Market Research.
8 个月Thank you for sharing your thoughts, Alfred! Your support during a time like this really means a lot, my friend. It was fascinating to read how our streets look through the eyes someone who saw only the before and after of the massacre of the 7th of October. The names and faces of the hostages are ingrained into our minds and follow us everywhere we go, making sure we remember them and act to bring them home safely as soon as possible as we pick up the pieces and build a better, safer future for the Jewish people.
Research Manager | MBA
8 个月Thanks for sharing your compelling piece, Alfred. You have a knack for curating your astute observations into a portrait gallery of Israeli society in this delicate and critical moment in history. It's encouraging to hear about everything Israelis are doing right now to cope and support each other--protesting at Kikar HaBima, reserving empty chairs in classrooms as a reminder of those kidnapped or those no longer with us, and how people are taking the time to reflect and find solace. I look forward to your next blog post!
Impact, Innovation and Investment
8 个月Interesting article, Alfred. Reminds me of the time you told me about a classroom incident where a Fletcher classmate denied the Albanian genocide during Kosovo war. And how an inconsiderate discussion followed debating the technicalities of a massacre vs genocide to whether indeed it happened. I found it so shocking at the time but now not so much.