Is there really only one internet?

Last week, in an interview with CNBC, former Google CEO Eric Schmidt predicted that in the next ten or 15 years the internet will be split into two parts, independently developed by the United States and China. The question is important, not only in the context of the trade war between the two countries started by Donald Trump, but because of recent accusations of aggressive espionage tactics by China against US companies through LinkedIn or the successive cleanups of thousands of web sites by Beijing aimed at “protecting” the population from “harmful” material.

The latest China Internet Report 2018 compiled by Abacus, 500 Startups and the South China Morning Post paints a picture of an internet dominated by different players to those in other countries, with a total disregard for privacy, a credit rating system that intervenes in virtually every aspect of daily life, and that is now in a development phase where China no longer adapts ideas imported from the West, but instead is exporting its own.

Thanks to an all-powerful state with a long-game strategy, China is now rapidly overtaking the United States in areas such as AI and machine learning: want to see drones being used for deliveries? Go to China. Smartphones as a universally accepted form of payment, identification and everything else necessary for everyday life? China is the place to go. A growing number of companies, when they want to provide some visionary experience to their managers, send them to China. Foreign Affairs predicts China will end up running the internet, while Google fights to return to China with a product that bows to the demands of the Communist Party but that is supposedly better than nothing for theoretically information-hungry Chinese. At the same time, the company has to deal with a workforce that has made clear its opposition to working with Beijing, as well as the US government.

Some might argue that Schmidt’s prediction has already come true. I would say the internet has been undergoing a process of Balkanization for some time: if I travel to China and try to work as I would at home, I have to jump through increasingly complex hoops. As a rule, I do not use Chinese websites except for research, while few Chinese look at those from outside their country, not because they’re censored but because they’re not interested in them. For some time, I’ve have been telling my Chinese and Russian students particularly that knowledge of the tools, uses, customs and players in their respective countries will be a very interesting asset for companies targeting those markets, because the level of specificity has reached such a point that finding profiles with a multicultural perspective and that can properly manage those environments is getting harder.

Is there really only one internet? Language is clearly a factor, despite the progress of translation tools, but independent development has already turned some countries into islands with other internets that require particular knowledge, skills and where different rules apply, otherwise, you’re not going to get anywhere. I think that the Internet fragmented some time ago, and although we may see cases of Chinese companies launching products and services abroad and to a lesser extent in the opposite direction, the reality is that the internet outside China is already very different from the one say, in Europe and North America and the two are very unlikely to merge. The dream of a universal internet remains further away than ever.


(En espa?ol, aquí)

?

Arturo Varona

Director Of International Office at Universidad Pontificia Comillas

6 年

The short answer is : no, there isn't, and there hasn't been for at least a decade. As someone who has experienced the boom of the Chinese internet first hand, I encourage anyone to try to straddle both sides. It is highly enlightening. Whichever way the Internet goes from here, it will have at least two focal points. And if you are really curious about how it can play out in the end, watch Hong Kong and how it is trapped between the two. Fascinating.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Enrique Dans的更多文章

  • El desastre del software y la automoción

    El desastre del software y la automoción

    GM se ve obligada a detener temporalmente las ventas de su Chevy Blazer EV después de detectar un sinnúmero de…

    11 条评论
  • El enésimo drama de la automoción tradicional: la interfaz

    El enésimo drama de la automoción tradicional: la interfaz

    Porsche acaba de anunciar que se une a toda la legión de empresas de automoción tradicionales y renuncia a tener una…

  • Poniendo a prueba a ChatGPT: consultores centauros o cyborgs

    Poniendo a prueba a ChatGPT: consultores centauros o cyborgs

    Un working paper de Harvard, ?Navigating the jagged technological frontier: field experimental evidence of the effects…

    12 条评论
  • Suscripciones, tramos… y spam

    Suscripciones, tramos… y spam

    Elon Musk confirma sus intenciones de convertir la antigua Twitter, ahora X, en un complejo entramado de suscripciones…

  • El código abierto y sus límites

    El código abierto y sus límites

    Sin duda, el código abierto es la forma más ventajosa de crear software: cuando un proyecto de software toma la forma…

  • La gran expansión china

    La gran expansión china

    El ranking de apps más descargadas en el mundo en iOS y Android para el mes de septiembre de 2023 elaborado por…

    1 条评论
  • Starlink y las torres de telefonía en el espacio

    Starlink y las torres de telefonía en el espacio

    Starlink remodela su página web y a?ade una oferta de internet, voz y datos para smartphones provistos de conectividad…

    3 条评论
  • La fotografía con trampa

    La fotografía con trampa

    La presentación de los nuevos smartphones de Google, Pixel 8 y Pixel 8 Pro, y fundamentalmente de las funcionalidades…

  • Las consecuencias de reprimir los procesos de innovación

    Las consecuencias de reprimir los procesos de innovación

    Mi columna de esta semana en Invertia se titula ?El mercado de trabajo y la innovación? (pdf), y previene sobre los…

  • We are on the verge of the most dangerous election in history

    We are on the verge of the most dangerous election in history

    In just a few days, on November 3rd, the US presidential elections will take place, the most dangerous in history, and…

    2 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了