The Real Reason DEI Is Under Attack: It’s About What It Represents, Not How It’s Practiced.
Shari Dunn
Author, QUALIFIED (Harper Collins, 2025) | Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion Leader | Executive Consultant
I’m often surprised when I hear people in the field of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) blaming other practitioners for the backlash we’re seeing against DEI efforts. Don’t get me wrong—some folks are doing more harm than good in this space, just like in any other field. Whether it’s executive coaching, recruitment, or systems change consulting, there are always practitioners who aren’t effective or, worse, are damaging. But here’s the question: Why aren’t we seeing these other fields under attack or being outlawed? The answer lies in what DEI represents—not how it’s practiced.
Those who oppose DEI are resisting its ultimate goals, not simply critiquing its methods. They are fundamentally opposed to the vision of a multiracial, multiethnic, multigender, and multi-ability workforce. This resistance is not new—it’s part of a long and troubling pattern in American history.
Let’s look back. The end of slavery in 1865 led to the establishment of the Freedmen's Bureau to help newly freed Black people transition to freedom (Carpetbaggers and Scalawags were rebranded to become the "woke warriors" of their day, but using much harsher language, the exact meaning as today though). The backlash was swift, and cries of “reverse discrimination” were heard for the first time. In the 1960s, when the Civil Rights Movement pushed for fundamental human rights for Black Americans, the backlash was fierce again. Affirmative Action? There was more backlash and lies reframing it as favoring "unqualified" candidates. What do all of these moments have in common? Anti-Blackness.
Most people don’t fully understand how anti-Blackness is at the root of much of the backlash to DEI, nor do they grasp how it affects everyone, regardless of race. For instance, millions of white Americans have died needlessly because President Harry Truman couldn’t pass universal healthcare due to anti-Black Southern Democrats who didn’t want Black Americans to have access to the same care. Why do so many people—Black, white, Hispanic, and more—struggle in low-wage, tipped jobs? The practice of tipping stems from post-slavery policies that undervalued Black labor, claiming their work didn’t warrant wages.
Those practicing DEI but failing to trace these historical threads are missing the bigger picture. Yes, DEI practitioners can improve—just like any other profession—but the field shouldn’t be outlawed or held to higher scrutiny than others. There are no magic words to say or NOT say that will change this organized campaign against advancement. What we need to address is the long-standing, unchecked disinformation campaigns from institutions like the Claremont Institute, which have worked for decades to reframe and redefine any effort to create a multiracial, inclusive society as inherently destructive.
领英推荐
Instead of turning on one another, we need to recognize the real challenge. The attack on DEI isn’t about methodology or individual missteps—it’s about resisting the very goals DEI seeks to achieve. To build a truly inclusive, multi-racial democracy, we must focus on countering these divisive, destructive narratives rather than policing ourselves to death.
#DEI#DiversityEquityInclusion#AntiRacism#InclusiveLeadership#SocialJustice#AntiBlackness
#LeadershipDevelopment#WorkplaceEquity#EquityMatters#DiversityMatters #lowwagejobs #marketing #pr
#MultiracialWorkforce#InclusionRevolution#RacialEquity#InclusiveCulture#SocialImpact#EquityAndInclusion#HistoryAndEquity#LeadershipForAll#InclusiveDemocracy #StopDEIdisinformation
Carson & Associates
1 个月I wrote my thoughts on DEI today. But deleted them. There is no room for an intelligent conversation on this topic. You can thank the "lunatic fringe" like Dylan Mulvaney for its being shunned by much of today's corporate America and society at large.
Community connector | I love connecting people!
1 个月This is spot on! Thank you for laying it out so clearly. The comparison to executive coaching and/or systems change consulting is insightful - no one is trying to outlaw all the unlicensed, uninformed, and often harmful efforts done in the name of those fields. Anti-DEI sentiment (like anti-CRT a few years ago) is just another name for anti-Black racism.
Enhanced Inclusive Leadership | Coaching White Male Leaders to Master the Skills for Effective, Dynamic Teams
1 个月I absolutely agree. Anti-Blackness is truly an intoxicant that is addictive to some. Why are they so threatened? What are they hiding that all these measures of terror are necessary to uphold the status quo? Can they feel they've sold their humanity as well?
Author, QUALIFIED (Harper Collins, 2025) | Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion Leader | Executive Consultant
1 个月Abi Adamson “The DEIB Ajagun”??The Associated PressWarren S.The Wall Street Journal The Authors Guild Foundation Jenny Kim Partners in Diversity Danne Smith Mathis, FRSA, MPW, CF APMP James Orlick L C De Shay Mike Green Reuters News Agency Ivy McGregor Shereen Daniels ???????????? Ashqelynn Ayers Theodore Kim #healthequity #livingwage Ernest Crim III, MA Jessica P. Rachel Wolfe Menah Pratt Timnit Gebru Crystle Johnson
Wellness Professional | Podcast Host | Content Producer
1 个月Thank you for sharing. This is extremely insightful. Especially since I've had to make a conscious pivot in my own career due to the discontinuation of DEI initiatives which overlaps with employee wellness workshops that I lead.