Questions Any Risk Histogram Should Answer

Questions Any Risk Histogram Should Answer

The Risk Distribution Graph (Risk Histogram and S Curve) is one of the primary outputs of any Quantitative Risk Analysis. It looks like this from Primavera Risk Analysis.

No alt text provided for this image

The bars/bins on the Histogram indicate the number of iterations that land on a specific date. For this analysis, I did 1000 iterations and about 90 of the iterations fell on 1st September 2006.

On the Right side, we see the Probability of meeting a particular date, called P-values or Confidence Levels. P80 date means 80% chance of hitting the date, 06 Oct 2006.

When you perform quantitative risk analysis or participate in a risk meeting where the analysis is being carried out, there are questions this diagram should answer and they are:

  1. What is our chance of the ENTIRE PROJECT finishing on or before a particular date such as the 12th May 2008??
  2. What chance is there of finishing a PARTICULAR ACTIVITY within the project on or before a date. Example Activity A230 (Building Demolition) on the 31st of December 2007?
  3. What date do I have an 80% chance or confidence of finishing the project by? That is what is my Project's P80?
  4. What date do I have a 90% chance or confidence of finishing a particular Activity by? That is my P90 for a particular Activity?
  5. What date can I be 90% confident of starting this Activity?
  6. What amount of contingency do we need if we want to have a certain level of confidence say 90% confidence (P90) or finish on a particular date?

For a particular course I did, here is the sample question that was posed

"For a Project, we need a plant shutdown (an external work) to carry out the Hook-Up task on our schedule. The shutdown is done annually every December 1st to 10th. What is the probability that we can complete the hook-up activity in our project’s schedule on or before December 10th before the Shutdown is over?"

I will show how the risk histogram answers the questions in my next article.

You are invited to follow me on LinkedIn.

Ir. Mohd Amirul Ismail

Senior Manager - Projects & Operation Risk | Governance, Risk & Compliance | PhD Candidate

2 年

Sometimes, you can straight telling your audiences from the shape of histogram itself. - If there are two (2) or three (3) humps, means there are two (2) or three (3) risks with high probability of occurences being dominated. -If there are gaps, indicating bad weather factor or a period of non productivity in actioned during simulation. - If long tail gate to the left or right, means black swan-related risks skewed the outcomes These shapes indirectly implied the risk profile of a project

Santosh B.

Independent Consultant for Project Planning and Scheduling, Schedule Risk Analyses and also Co-Founder of Turbo-Chart

2 年

Shimonkepha One thing I always explain when I'm training on using these histograms, is that the vertical axis for the confidence levels, the "P" numbers, is not linear. So P50 to P60, will not be the same quantum as P80 to P90.

William A. Baehrle

Tags, Nameplates , ID Products

2 年

Thanks for sharing

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Shimonkepha Onwuneme PMP? PMI-RMP?的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了