The Psychology Behind Advance Fee Scams

In the wake of the recently released fraud report by UK Finance (1) indicating a concerning 33% increase in the volume of advance fee scams(even though the value seems to be stable), it has become more urgent than ever to delve into the underlying mechanisms of these deceptive practices. While the financial ramifications of these scams are often discussed, there is another facet that demands our attention: the psychological aspect. This edition of the newsletter aims to shed light on the psychology behind advance fee scams, exploring the tactics employed by scammers, the reasons why people fall prey, and the strategies we can adopt to combat these frauds.

What’s an Advance Fee Scam ?

The term 'Advance Fee Scam' refers to a type of #fraud where the victim is convinced to pay a fee upfront with the promise of receiving a significant amount of money or a valuable item later. The promised return never materializes, and the #scammer disappears with the advance fee.

Advance fee scams can take various forms such as lottery scams, inheritance scams, loan scams, employment scams, and also romance scams. Each type involves a different narrative, but the central idea remains the same - paying a fee in advance for a promised reward.

Scammers usually reach out to potential victims via email, social media, or even phone calls. They weave convincing stories to lure victims and ask for an advance fee to process the promised rewards. The fee may be presented as a tax, a processing fee, or a security deposit.

The scammer’s motivation behind conducting scams

The motivations driving individuals to conduct advance fee scams are manifold. Often, the primary incentive is financial gain; the allure of acquiring money quickly and easily can prove a potent lure. However, some scammers may be motivated by desperation, with factors such as unemployment, debt, or other financial hardships pushing them toward these fraudulent activities. For others, the thrill of deception and the sense of power derived from controlling situations and people can be motivating factors. A lack of empathy towards their victims can further enable their fraudulent activities by making it easier for them to rationalize their actions. Additionally, social and cultural factors can also play a role in motivating scammers. Some may operate within social or cultural contexts where such activities are seen as acceptable or even admirable ways to earn a living, often due to factors such as widespread poverty, lack of opportunities, or cultural acceptance of scamming as a form of "business."

Psychological Tactics Used in Advance Fee Scams

Use of authority

Scammers often employ the tactic of posing as authoritative figures or institutions to lend credibility to their schemes. By impersonating reputable organizations, government agencies, or individuals in positions of trust, they aim to exploit the inherent trust that people often give to authority (Refer to our edition on Audio Deepfakes and Pig Butchering Scams). This could involve using official-looking logos, language, or documentation in their communications to further create an illusion of legitimacy. Additionally, they may use tactics such as name-dropping or referencing insider knowledge to enhance their perceived authority. This exploitation of authority serves to reduce skepticism and lower the defenses of potential victims, making them more susceptible to the #scam.

Exploiting emotions

A range of emotions are skillfully exploited by those perpetrating advance fee scams. Potential victims often find themselves manipulated through feelings of fear, urgency, empathy, and greed. Urgency, for example, is induced to pressure victims into making quick decisions without ample time for thought or advice. Threats of legal repercussions or the loss of a promised opportunity can instill a sense of fear. Empathy however, is evoked through sharing fabricated personal hardships or crises, and the promise of large returns or valuable rewards can exploit feelings of greed. An emotional manipulation is also a potent tool in clouding judgement and prompting impulsive actions, facilitating the success of scams.

Persuasion and manipulation techniques

In the orchestration of advance fee scams, persuasion and manipulation techniques are commonly employed. Principles of persuasion such as reciprocity, commitment and consistency, and scarcity are often exploited. For example, a sense of liability might be created by offering a small favor or gift, a technique known as reciprocity. Commitment and consistency can be leveraged by getting victims to agree to small requests or commitments, which makes them more likely to comply with larger demands later. Scarcity, on the other hand, is invoked by presenting the promised rewards and/or opportunities as limited or exclusive. These techniques, rooted in the psychology of persuasion, serve to subtly influence victims' decisions and actions in favor of the scammer's intentions.

Building fake trust

Trust forms the cornerstone of any successful advance fee scam. A sense of familiarity or rapport is carefully crafted with potential victims, often through frequent and friendly communication. This could involve sharing personal stories or showing interest in the victim's life to create a bond. Sometimes, a period of honest transactions might precede the scam, further strenghtening trust in the fraudulent scheme. Additionally, testimonials, references, or fake credentials might be used to enhance the scammer's credibility. By building this false trust, the defenses of potential victims are lowered, making them more susceptible to the scam.

The Victim's Perspective

Why do people fall for these scams ?

Understanding the reasons why people fall for scams involves delving into the realm of human psychology and circumstances. Cognitive biases often play a major role. For instance, the 'availability heuristic,' a mental shortcut that relies on immediate examples that come to mind, might lead individuals to overestimate the legitimacy of a scam because it reminds them of a genuine situation they've heard about or encountered before.

A lack of knowledge or awareness about scams also leaves individuals vulnerable. Without knowing what signs to look for, they may not recognize a scam even when they're in the midst of one. This underscores the importance of widespread scam awareness and education.

Feelings of loneliness and social isolation can also increase susceptibility to scams. Isolated individuals may be more open to conversations with strangers and could be more easily swayed by the attention or apparent kindness of the scammer.

Also, people experiencing financial desperation may be more willing to gamble on a too-good-to-be-true promise of significant returns. The urgent need for money can cloud judgment, making risky propositions seem like lifelines.

Finally, optimism bias – the belief that negative events are less likely to happen to oneself compared to others – can lead to carelessness. This bias can cause individuals to let down their guard, opening the door for scammers to take advantage.

Impact of scams on victims

The impacts of falling for advance fee scams are far-reaching, affecting victims in a lot of differents ways. The immediate and most apparent impact is of course financial loss. Victims can lose significant amounts of money, potentially even their life savings, which can lead to financial instability or even bankruptcy. Beyond the financial repercussions, victims may also experience emotional trauma, including feelings of shame, guilt, embarrassment, and betrayal. The realization that they've been scammed can be deeply distressing. This distress can manifest as psychological impacts, including anxiety, depression, and a pervasive loss of trust in people and institutions. In some cases, these psychological effects can be long-lasting and profound. Falling victim to a scam can also strain relationships with family and friends, especially if they were also involved in the scam or if they blamed the victim for being naive. Lastly, being scammed can lead to a crisis of self-perception. Victims may grapple with feelings of foolishness and self-blame, which can deliver a significant blow to their self-esteem and confidence. Understanding these impacts can help foster empathy for victims and undertand why they would blame the bank for not recognizing the scam and authorizing the transaction.

Prevention and Protection

The importance of awareness and education

Education plays a pivotal role in preventing advance fee scams. By increasing individuals' knowledge about the nature of these scams, the tactics used, and the red flags to watch out for, they become better equipped to identify and avoid such deceptive practices. Awareness campaigns serve as a vital tool for disseminating this knowledge, and these campaigns can be run by a range of organizations, from government agencies to non-profits and businesses and of course the banking industry.

How banks can help prevent advance fee scams

In the ongoing battle against advance fee scams, banks play a pivotal role not only as financial institutions but also as guardians of their customers' trust and security. Key to this is raising customer awareness about the nature of frauds and scams, with a special emphasis on social engineering tactics that are commonly employed in advance fee scams. Education initiatives, such as workshops, seminars, informational brochures, and online resources can be instrumental in arming customers with the knowledge they need to detect and avoid scams.

However, customer education is only one part of the equation. With the advancements in technology, banks can also harness the power of artificial intelligence (AI) to fortify their defenses against fraud. Implementing AI-driven fraud detection systems like NetGuardians allows banks to proactively monitor and analyze transaction patterns. These systems are capable of alerting banks to suspicious transactions in real-time, providing them with critical insights to identify potential scams.

Moreover, these advanced systems can assist banks in blocking fraudulent payments before they leave the bank, thereby preventing financial loss. By deploying such technologies, banks can provide an extra layer of security, helping to safeguard their customers' assets and maintain their trust. This, combined with customer education, creates a robust, two-pronged approach in the fight against advance fee scams.

Who is NetGuardians and how can they help with Microsoft Support Scams?

NetGuardians is an award-winning Swiss FinTech helping financial institutions in over 30 countries to fight fraud. More than 80 banks worldwide rely on NetGuardians' smarter artificial intelligence solution to prevent fraudulent payments and various scams in real time like MS support Scams. Don't hesitate to reach out to me if you're interested in learning more about how NetGuardians can benefit your organisation. Always happy to help.

Learn more about Advance Fee Scams:

#fraud #scam #fraudprevention