Protecting Intellectual Property in the Age of AI: The Complex Legal Landscape
The rapid development of emerging technologies such as the Internet of Things (IoT), artificial intelligence (AI), and big data is transforming the future as we know it. As these technologies become increasingly pervasive, we can look forward to a time when our children will grow up with AI and blockchain as standard components of their lives. It is an exciting journey that we are on, and as things continue to change, the legal system will need to respond accordingly.
In particular, the legal system will need to consider how intellectual property laws will be influenced by artificial intelligence. Stephen Hawking predicted that computers will soon have the same capacity as humans, and we are already seeing snippets of this today. Therefore, it is essential to understand what artificial intelligence is and how it works.
Artificial intelligence has significantly advanced to the point where it can now perform tasks that were traditionally associated with human intelligence. These tasks include cognitive abilities like creativity, autonomy, and the ability to learn. Furthermore, AI machines can create new products and manage high-level tasks with minimal human intervention. They can also mimic human cognitive skills, such as rational intelligence and perception, and learn from data to make informed decisions. As a result, machines are generating new layers of knowledge that never existed before, along with this context, legislative protection has not yet advanced as quickly as AI technology,? which significantly makes early and ongoing IP measures of particular importance
What is intellectual property:
Intellectual property (IP) is a fundamental aspect of our society that enables us to protect and benefit from our uniquely human qualities such as intellect, creativity, and inventiveness. These qualities are so crucial that the law grants us property rights to control what happens to our creations and to reap commercial benefits from them.
The World Intellectual Property Organization defines intellectual property as the unique value creations of the human intellect that arise from human ingenuity, creativity, and inventiveness. This property right allows us to have control over our creations, much like owning a house, where we decide who comes on the property, whom we rent it to, and what colour it should be. By having these rights, we can ensure that our ideas are safeguarded and that we have the opportunity to profit from them. These protections not only benefit the creators but also help to promote innovation, which leads to the growth and development of society.
Intellectual property covers various intangible assets like inventions, brands, new technologies, source code, and artistic works. Patents, trademarks, copyright, and industrial design are some kinds of IP. Although all types of IP are relevant to AI, I will focus on patents, trademarks, and copyrights.
Copyright:
Copyright is an essential intellectual property asset for AI as it safeguards the technology product, including code, data, and graphics, from unauthorized use and reproduction. Companies should clearly specify ownership and confidentiality of copyright in a written agreement and implement policies for developers to avoid infringement of other's IP rights. AI systems often involve large data sets and algorithms that can be protected by copyright as compilations of data. Contractual terms with end-users and third parties should specify permitted use. However, ownership of machine-generated works is a contentious issue, and agreements should attempt to clarify ownership where possible. Additionally, AI systems may operate autonomously, potentially infringing third-party IP rights. If existing laws do not extend liability to machines, then related stakeholders may be responsible.
Trademarks:
A strong brand helps AI companies differentiate their products and services from competitors and establish a strong reputation in the market. AI technology and algorithmic accountability can help a company develop goodwill for its brand. However, co-branding agreements may be necessary for an AI tool embedded in a finished product offered by a third party to help the provider become recognizable by the end consumer.
领英推荐
Patents
Patents provide time-limited protection for inventions and can exclude others from making, using, or selling the patented technology. They may provide a competitive advantage and protect research and development investments. However, AI software is increasingly difficult to patent, and patent offices and courts struggle with establishing clear delineations of what is patentable.
Challenges in the Road Ahead: Complex and multidimensional Issues
The use of artificial intelligence (AI) is causing a shift in the traditional paradigm of intellectual property (IP) laws, and there is a need to adapt these laws to handle the impact of AI. Currently, a human inventor or author is contemplated in IP laws, but with the use of AI as a tool for innovation, there are open questions on what can be patented, copyrighted, or maintained as a trade secret.
The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has issued two notices seeking input from the public and stakeholders on the impact of AI on patents, copyright, trade secret, databases, and trademark law. The USPTO has accumulated many comments from stakeholders, and they are currently evaluating these comments. The USPTO plans to promulgate some type of guidance that summarizes these comments and offers some preliminary thoughts on the impact of AI on IP.
The uncertainty surrounding AI-related innovations is affecting almost all clients in the space, and it is essential to have a strategy in place for protecting key IP and implementing AI in an ethical manner. Legislation may be necessary to define what is patentable or what can be protected under the copyright or other systems and to identify who is the inventor for patents or author for copyright. Intelligent regulation is critical in the high-tech space to provide order and predictability for companies and to encourage them to invest in R&D and technology development.
The future scope:
The AI field is expanding quickly, especially in subsets of deep learning and neural networks, which are witnessing the fastest growth rates, of around 55%. AI is penetrating all commercial sectors, with transportation, life sciences, medical sciences, personal devices and computer-human interaction sectors being the most popular.
The US, China, and Japan are leading the way in the development and deployment of AI, with companies dominating the field in terms of patent applications. Companies like IBM, Microsoft, Toshiba, and Samsung are at the forefront of innovation, constantly pushing the boundaries of what is possible with AI.
However, as exciting as the future of AI may be, it’s important more than ever to take serious measures towards the IP challenges and gaps that need to be addressed.
This includes determining ownership of property rights in the AI space, particularly when it comes to authorship or creatorship of intellectual property generated by AI. Another challenge is the intersection of policies that encourage the free flow of data to feed algorithms and policies that restrict the use of data through intellectual property rights. Finally, there are gaps in the existing intellectual property system, especially relating to data, which is often protected through trade secrecy policies.
In conclusion, as artificial intelligence continues to evolve, we will need to reconsider our existing laws and regulations to ensure that they remain relevant and effective in protecting intellectual property rights. The potential for AI to create new knowledge and inventions that are not solely human-made poses a significant challenge to the current legal framework. However,?
Despite these challenges, the future of AI is full of possibilities. By embracing these emerging technologies and developing new laws and policies that recognize their unique capabilities and limitations, we can create a legal system that protects intellectual property while fostering innovation and growth, to build a world where humans and machines work together to create a better future for all.