The Pros and Cons of Reshoring for Small, Medium, and Large U.S. Manufacturing Companies

Reshoring, or bringing manufacturing operations back to a company's home country, has been a growing trend in recent years. Rising global uncertainties, supply chain disruptions, geopolitical tensions, and shifting consumer preferences have led businesses to reconsider their reliance on overseas production. While reshoring offers many potential benefits, including supply chain security and improved product quality, it also presents significant challenges such as higher labor costs and workforce shortages.

The impact of reshoring varies across different business sizes. Small, medium, and large manufacturing companies face unique challenges and opportunities when considering reshoring. Small businesses may struggle with the initial investment required for domestic manufacturing but can benefit from increased control and branding advantages. Medium-sized firms must balance cost considerations with supply chain efficiencies, while large corporations often need to make substantial infrastructure investments to realign their production processes.

This article explores the pros and cons of reshoring for manufacturing companies of different sizes, providing real-world examples and references for further research.

Advantages of Reshoring

1. Enhanced Supply Chain Resilience

One of the most compelling reasons for reshoring is the ability to create a more resilient and reliable supply chain. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed significant vulnerabilities in global supply chains, with many companies experiencing extended lead times, transportation bottlenecks, and material shortages. Reshoring allows businesses to reduce their dependence on international suppliers and improve overall supply chain security.

• Small Manufacturers: Small businesses, which often have limited supplier options, benefit greatly from reshoring because it enables them to work closely with local partners and reduce risks associated with overseas sourcing. For example, U.S.-based textile manufacturer American Giant shifted production back to the U.S. to ensure better supply chain control, allowing them to reduce lead times and maintain high product quality.
• Medium Manufacturers: Mid-sized companies can minimize logistical disruptions and increase production flexibility by reshoring certain operations. A notable example is New Balance, which produces a portion of its footwear domestically. By manufacturing in the U.S., the company can respond more quickly to changing market demands while reducing exposure to global shipping delays.
• Large Manufacturers: For large corporations, supply chain disruptions can result in multi-billion-dollar losses. To address this, Intel is investing $20 billion in a semiconductor manufacturing facility in Ohio, aiming to reduce reliance on overseas chip production. This move was partly driven by the global semiconductor shortage, which severely impacted industries such as automotive and electronics (Reuters, 2022).

2. Quality Control and Compliance

Manufacturing domestically often results in better product quality and adherence to strict regulatory standards. By reshoring production, companies can oversee their operations more closely, ensuring consistency in materials, workmanship, and safety standards.

• Small Manufacturers: Companies that specialize in high-quality, handcrafted, or artisanal goods benefit from reshoring because they can maintain tighter control over product quality. For example, Sherrill Manufacturing, the last flatware manufacturer in the U.S., emphasizes high-quality craftsmanship and strict quality assurance measures that are difficult to enforce with overseas production.
• Medium Manufacturers: For mid-sized firms, reshoring provides an opportunity to differentiate their products through superior quality. Airstream, the luxury travel trailer manufacturer, continues to build its products in Ohio, ensuring craftsmanship and attention to detail that align with its premium brand positioning.
• Large Manufacturers: In industries such as aerospace and automotive, compliance with safety regulations is critical. Boeing has reshored certain component manufacturing processes to meet stringent U.S. safety and quality regulations, ensuring greater reliability in its aircraft production (Bloomberg, 2024).

3. Economic and Job Growth Benefits

Reshoring contributes to domestic job creation and economic growth, providing new employment opportunities and revitalizing local manufacturing industries. The resurgence of domestic manufacturing helps stabilize economies by supporting local businesses and communities.

• Small Manufacturers: For small businesses, creating jobs within their local communities can be a powerful competitive advantage. Companies like WeatherTech, which manufactures automotive accessories in the U.S., market their products as “Made in America,” appealing to consumers who prefer to support domestic industries.
• Medium Manufacturers: Mid-sized firms, such as GE Appliances, have actively reshored production, generating thousands of jobs. GE’s investment in its Louisville, Kentucky, manufacturing plant has not only created employment but has also contributed to the region’s economic revitalization.
• Large Manufacturers: Major corporations, including Ford and General Motors, have been investing in reshoring, particularly in the electric vehicle (EV) and battery manufacturing sectors. By bringing production back to the U.S., these companies are reducing dependency on foreign suppliers while stimulating the domestic economy (Forbes, 2023).

4. Reduced Transportation and Tariff Costs

Producing goods domestically can significantly cut down on transportation expenses and avoid tariffs that add to production costs.

• Small Manufacturers: Businesses with limited capital benefit from reduced freight and import fees, allowing them to maintain competitive pricing.
• Medium Manufacturers: Mid-sized companies like Carhartt, which balances global and domestic production, use reshoring to control costs while ensuring reliable supply.
• Large Manufacturers: Apple has moved some MacBook assembly back to the U.S. to mitigate tariff-related expenses and logistical uncertainties.

Challenges of Reshoring

1. Higher Labor and Operational Costs

One of the biggest challenges of reshoring is the significantly higher cost of labor in developed countries compared to low-wage regions like China, Vietnam, and Mexico.

• Small Manufacturers: Many small businesses operate on tight profit margins, making it difficult to absorb increased labor costs without raising prices. This can make reshoring less feasible for businesses that compete primarily on cost rather than quality or brand reputation.
• Medium Manufacturers: Mid-sized companies must find ways to balance labor costs, often by investing in automation and lean manufacturing techniques.
• Large Manufacturers: Large corporations, such as Boeing, have encountered major cost hurdles when reshoring production due to higher wages and increased operational expenses (Bloomberg, 2024).

2. Limited Skilled Workforce

The shortage of skilled labor in the U.S. has become a significant barrier to reshoring efforts.

• Small Manufacturers: Finding workers with the necessary technical expertise can be difficult, requiring additional investment in training programs.
• Medium Manufacturers: Companies like Timken, a bearings and steel manufacturer, have established apprenticeship programs to bridge the skills gap.
• Large Manufacturers: Intel’s Ohio plant has faced challenges in recruiting skilled semiconductor engineers, highlighting a broader issue within advanced manufacturing (Reuters, 2022).

3. Initial Capital Investment and Infrastructure Challenges

Establishing new manufacturing facilities requires substantial financial investment.

• Small Manufacturers: Many small businesses lack the necessary capital to build new factories or upgrade existing facilities.
• Medium Manufacturers: Mid-sized companies may struggle to finance new production sites and equipment without government incentives.
• Large Manufacturers: TSMC’s semiconductor facility in Arizona required billions in subsidies to remain competitive (Commerce.gov, 2024).

4. Supply Chain Realignment and Supplier Dependence

Transitioning to domestic suppliers can be challenging, particularly when international vendors offer lower costs and greater efficiency.

• Small Manufacturers: Many businesses still rely on imported raw materials, making complete reshoring difficult.
• Medium Manufacturers: Companies like Leatherman have reshored some operations but continue to source certain components from abroad.
• Large Manufacturers: Tesla manufactures EV batteries domestically but still imports critical materials from China.

Conclusion: Should Companies Reshore?

Reshoring presents a mix of benefits and challenges, making it a strategic decision that requires careful planning. While it can lead to greater supply chain stability, quality control, and economic benefits, companies must also consider the costs and labor constraints associated with domestic manufacturing.

Ultimately, the decision to reshore depends on a company’s size, industry, and financial resources. For some businesses, reshoring may be the key to long-term success, while for others, a hybrid approach—balancing domestic and offshore production—may be the best strategy.

Reshoring is not merely a trend; it represents a fundamental shift in global manufacturing dynamics. Companies that adapt strategically will be better positioned to thrive in an increasingly complex economic landscape.

References

1. Forbes (2023): "Why ‘Made in America’ Is Making a Comeback"
2. Bloomberg (2024): "Boeing’s Reshoring Push Hits Cost Hurdles"
3. Reuters (2022): "Intel Breaks Ground on $20 Billion Ohio Chip Plants"
4. McKinsey & Company: "Reshoring in the Post-Pandemic World"
5. Harvard Business Review: "The Economics of Bringing Manufacturing Home"
6. U.S. Department of Commerce: "Reshoring Incentives and Policies"
7. Reshoring Initiative: "Reshore Now Organization"

Contact Strategic Value+ for a Free Strategic Session

The Veteran Advisors of the Strategic Value+ Collaborative are experienced and well-versed in the issues facing U.S. manufacturing companies as they pave their roads to their futures. For a fresh perspective on strategic alternatives, contact the Strategic Value+ by emailing [email protected] or schedule a free comprehensive 90-minute 360-degree strategic impact session at https://strategicvalueplus.com/contact. You have nothing to lose and a new view on your manufacturing company's future to gain.

Join the Strategic Value+ Solutions Collaborative for the Free U.S. Manufacturing Webinar Event Featuring Harry Moser

Your hosts are Brian McCollough - MBA, CEPA?, CMAA? , Maria L. Perez , Ruoyu Loughry . Roy Dickan , Mike Liu , William Feder , Bill Schweber , Justice Darko, PMP , Steven Shrinsky and Nelinia (Nel) Varenas, MBA

Our guest speaker is the distinguished Founder and President of The RESHORING INITIATIVE, Harry Moser. This timely and high-powered webinar will be live streaming Wednesday, March 19th, 11am PST to 12pm PST. Learn more and register for the U.S. Manufacturing Nexus Webinar Event by clicking here: https://strategicvalueplus.com/webinar-registration .

"Why Reshoring Matters for Our Economy and Our National Security" with Harry Moser, Founder and President of The Reshoring Initiative

RESHORING INITIATIVE Harry Moser Strategic Value+ Solutions #additivemanufacturing #manufacturingrenaissance #industry4 #madeintheusa #reshoring #domesticsourcing #mergers #acquisitions #exitplanning #strategicplanning