Pros and Cons of the 9-Box Grid

The 9-box grid has been used by HR leaders for decades to develop talent. While some swear by it, it’s also been the source of some controversy for its subjectivity and potential for oversimplification.?

So should you use it?

Here are the pros and cons of the 9-box grid to help you make a well-informed decision.

What Is The 9-Box Grid?

The 9-box grid is a matrix tool that sorts and categorizes employees based on their performance and potential to help determine and implement growth and development initiatives that will add the most value depending on individual employee needs.?

The grid is separated by two axes: performance – an employee’s current performance level – and potential – an employee's growth potential, typically referring to leadership roles or taking on more responsibility. Performance and potential are measured on a low, moderate, and high scale. The classifications can then determine how employees can be nurtured, developed, and managed based on their placement in the 9-box grid.?

The 9-box grid is primarily used for talent development, performance management, and succession planning. It can help with:

• Leadership pipeline development
• Personalized development programs
• Resource allocation
• Strategy alignment

Pros of the 9-Box Grid

Understanding the advantages and setbacks of the 9-box grid can help you make a more informed decision about how best to implement it in your organization.?

Here are some of the pros of the 9-box grid:?

1. Enhances Decision-making: The 9-box grid can give a concise but comprehensive view of employee performance to support decisions. It can help leaders discern insights about employee performance and growth trajectory and inform decisions about promotions or opportunities for high-performers.
2. Promotes Transparency: When used as a performance management tool, it can give employees a clear picture of where they fall within the company and explain why certain decisions were made to organizational leaders.
3. Aligns Performance Management Strategies: When employees are assessed based on performance and potential, it can help give leaders a comprehensive view of their performance, ensuring talent development initiatives are aligned with larger business goals.?
4. Simplifies Succession Planning: Looking at where employees fall on the grid can help identify employees with leadership potential to put into the leadership pipeline. Once high-potential employees are identified, HR can ensure that they get the support and mentorship that they need to grow into valuable leaders.
5. Delivers Insights in a Digestible Format: When trying to gain leadership buy-in for development programs or assessing performance, the 9-box grid can be a powerful tool to help visualize data. Rather than presenting stakeholders with slides of data about how employees are performing, that data can be organized into the 9-box grid.?

Cons of the 9-Box Grid

Here are some of the cons of the grid and a few action tips to help overcome them.

1. Leads to Subjective Assessments: There are no real criteria for what makes an employee score high or low in performance and potential. Biases and inconsistencies across assessments can lead to subjective results. Tip: To avoid claims of subjectivity, ensure that assessment techniques and criteria are defined across the organization. That way, leaders have a guide to look back on to ensure that employees are being assessed fairly.
2. Lacks Context and Oversimplifies Talent: Using the 9-box grid as a definitive guide for any strategic decisions can be dangerous because the assessment lacks the necessary context about individual complexities and needs.?Tip: Add context that the 9-box grid lacks into the assessment to ensure that external factors or nuances are accounted for. For example, flag employees in the grid whose low performance may be based on temporary factors, such as a role change or increased workload.
3. Puts Labels On Employees: The 9-box grid puts employees into boxes, which can stifle their potential and stop them from even trying to improve and develop their skills, which can have a significant impact on morale.
4. Erodes Trust: Misusing the 9-box grid can be a detriment to culture and can erode trust. Employees may see the grid as arbitrary. Especially if it’s being used for decisions about promotions or bonuses, employees may be disgruntled with the use of a grid to make decisions about their performance. Tip: Be open with employees about the methods that are used to evaluate performance and answer any questions to proactively avoid misunderstandings.
5. Causes Inaccurate Predictions: The 9-box grid can be seen as a tool to predict future outcomes of employee performance, but it’s not as accurate as some may think. In a rapidly changing environment, this type of assessment can’t account for the changing factors in today’s environment. Tip: Finding alternative assessment methods that can help provide a clearer, more holistic view of employee development and performance can help ensure that decisions are made strategically and fairly.

Final Thoughts

The 9-box grid is a popular tool for talent management, employee development, and succession planning. However, the efficacy and fairness of the tool have been widely debated for years by HR pros.?

The 9-box grid comes with its own set of pros and cons like any other assessment tool. If organizations do use the 9-box grid, using it strategically can help ensure that potential issues are mitigated and employees are evaluated fairly.??

Join 'Leading HR'!

The 'Leading HR' certificate program is meticulously crafted to provide the tools, insights, ideas, data, stories, and experience to enable senior HR executives and leaders to navigate the complexities of the modern workplace and drive strategic organizational change.

In this training program for Human Resources leaders, attendees will explore how to align workforce planning with organizational strategy and future needs, master workforce planning techniques, anticipate future workforce requirements, align workforce strategy with business objectives, and manage talent risks and opportunities.

To learn more about 'Leading HR' here.

Hacking HR

We are powering the future of HR!

Hacking HR is the fastest-growing global community of people leaders and professionals interested in all things at the intersection of people, organizations, innovation, transformation, workplace and workforce, and more. We deliver value through hundreds of events a year, community engagement opportunities, learning programs, certificate programs, and more.

To join our community platform, the Hacking HR LAB, Click here.

Sponsoring the Hacking HR's Newsletter

Hacking HR is one of the largest HR communities on LinkedIn and the number one global community in terms of engagement.

We have over one million community members across all our platforms. Our LinkedIn page has more than 739k followers; we have more than 60k members in our Hacking HR LAB community platform and over 504k subscribers to our LinkedIn newsletter (the largest and most engaged HR newsletter in the world!). Our new AI in HR newsletter has over 210k subscribers.

Click here to find out about our sponsoring plans.

The ROI for sponsoring our events is much higher than any other existing HR community, at a much lower price as well. If you are interested in sponsoring this newsletter with content-oriented subject matter expertise and thought leadership, please reach out to us at [email protected]