Process Discovery in Large Enterprises: Challenges and Solutions

1. Introduction

In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, large enterprises face unprecedented challenges in maintaining efficiency, agility, and competitiveness. As organizations grow in size and complexity, their business processes often become intricate webs of interconnected activities, spanning multiple departments, systems, and stakeholders. This complexity can lead to inefficiencies, bottlenecks, and a lack of transparency, ultimately impacting the organization's performance and ability to adapt to changing market conditions.

Process discovery has emerged as a critical discipline for large enterprises seeking to understand, optimize, and transform their operations. It involves systematically identifying, mapping, and analyzing business processes to gain insights into how work is actually performed within an organization. By uncovering the reality of how processes function, rather than relying on assumptions or outdated documentation, businesses can make informed decisions about process improvements, automation opportunities, and digital transformation initiatives.

However, implementing effective process discovery in large enterprises is not without its challenges. The scale and complexity of these organizations present unique obstacles that require careful consideration and innovative solutions. This essay aims to explore the challenges faced by large enterprises in process discovery and provide comprehensive insights into the solutions, best practices, and methodologies that can be employed to overcome these hurdles.

Throughout this aticle, we will delve into real-world use cases and case studies that illustrate the practical application of process discovery in various industries. We will also examine the metrics and key performance indicators (KPIs) that organizations can use to measure the success of their process discovery initiatives, as well as provide a roadmap for implementing and scaling these efforts across the enterprise.

Furthermore, we will analyze the return on investment (ROI) that large enterprises can expect from their process discovery initiatives, highlighting the tangible and intangible benefits that can be realized through improved process understanding and optimization.

By the end of this article, readers will have a comprehensive understanding of the challenges and solutions in process discovery for large enterprises, equipped with practical insights and strategies to drive meaningful improvements in their own organizations.

2. Understanding Process Discovery in Large Enterprises

2.1 Definition and Importance of Process Discovery

Process discovery is the systematic approach to identifying, documenting, and analyzing the various activities, steps, and flows that make up an organization's business processes. In large enterprises, this practice is crucial for several reasons:

1. Complexity Management: Large organizations often have hundreds or even thousands of processes spanning multiple departments and locations. Process discovery helps in understanding and managing this complexity.
2. Performance Optimization: By gaining visibility into how processes actually work, organizations can identify inefficiencies, bottlenecks, and areas for improvement.
3. Compliance and Risk Management: Accurate process knowledge is essential for ensuring regulatory compliance and managing operational risks.
4. Digital Transformation: Process discovery forms the foundation for successful digital transformation initiatives by providing a clear picture of current operations and opportunities for automation and innovation.
5. Knowledge Preservation: As employees come and go, process discovery helps in capturing and preserving institutional knowledge about how work is done.

2.2 Types of Process Discovery

In large enterprises, process discovery can be categorized into three main types:

1. Manual Process Discovery: This traditional approach involves interviews, workshops, and observations conducted by process analysts to document processes. While it can provide deep insights, it is time-consuming and may not scale well for very large organizations.
2. Automated Process Discovery: This method uses specialized software to analyze system logs, event data, and other digital footprints to automatically generate process maps and insights. It can quickly process large volumes of data but may miss context and informal processes.
3. Hybrid Process Discovery: This approach combines manual and automated methods, leveraging the strengths of both to provide a comprehensive view of processes. It is often the most effective approach for large enterprises.

2.3 Key Components of Process Discovery

Effective process discovery in large enterprises typically involves the following key components:

1. Process Identification: Determining which processes to focus on and prioritizing them based on business impact and improvement potential.
2. Data Collection: Gathering relevant information about processes through various methods such as interviews, system logs, and observations.
3. Process Mapping: Creating visual representations of processes, including activities, decision points, and flows.
4. Process Analysis: Examining the mapped processes to identify inefficiencies, redundancies, and improvement opportunities.
5. Process Simulation: Using modeling tools to test different scenarios and predict the impact of potential changes.
6. Process Documentation: Creating comprehensive, accessible documentation of processes for reference and training purposes.
7. Continuous Monitoring: Implementing systems to track process performance and detect deviations or changes over time.

2.4 The Process Discovery Lifecycle

In large enterprises, process discovery is not a one-time event but an ongoing cycle that typically includes the following phases:

1. Planning: Defining objectives, scope, and resources for the process discovery initiative.
2. Discovery: Collecting data and information about current processes.
3. Modeling: Creating visual representations and simulations of processes.
4. Analysis: Identifying improvement opportunities and potential issues.
5. Redesign: Proposing and evaluating process changes and improvements.
6. Implementation: Putting approved changes into practice.
7. Monitoring: Tracking the performance of implemented changes and identifying new areas for discovery.

2.5 The Role of Technology in Process Discovery

Technology plays a crucial role in enabling effective process discovery in large enterprises:

1. Process Mining Tools: These tools analyze event logs from IT systems to automatically discover and visualize process flows, providing insights into process performance and conformance.
2. Business Process Management (BPM) Suites: Comprehensive platforms that support the entire process lifecycle, from discovery and modeling to execution and monitoring.
3. Robotic Process Automation (RPA): While primarily used for automation, RPA tools can also aid in process discovery by tracking and analyzing human interactions with systems.
4. Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning: Advanced analytics capabilities that can identify patterns, predict outcomes, and suggest process improvements.
5. Collaboration and Documentation Tools: Platforms that facilitate the sharing of process knowledge and enable collaborative process mapping and analysis.

2.6 Stakeholders in Process Discovery

Large enterprise process discovery initiatives involve various stakeholders, each with unique perspectives and contributions:

1. Process Owners: Responsible for the overall performance and improvement of specific processes.
2. Process Participants: Employees who perform the day-to-day activities within processes.
3. Business Analysts: Professionals who facilitate the discovery, analysis, and documentation of processes.
4. IT Teams: Provide access to systems and data necessary for process discovery and support technology implementation.
5. Executive Sponsors: Provide strategic direction and resources for process discovery initiatives.
6. Customers and External Partners: Offer valuable insights into how processes impact external stakeholders.

Understanding these fundamental aspects of process discovery sets the stage for exploring the unique challenges faced by large enterprises and the solutions that can be employed to overcome them.

3. Challenges in Process Discovery for Large Organizations

Large enterprises face numerous challenges when undertaking process discovery initiatives. These challenges are often interrelated and can significantly impact the success of process improvement efforts. Understanding these challenges is crucial for developing effective strategies to overcome them.

3.1 Scale and Complexity

The sheer size and complexity of large organizations present significant challenges for process discovery:

1. Vast Number of Processes: Large enterprises often have thousands of processes spanning multiple departments, functions, and geographic locations. Identifying and prioritizing which processes to focus on can be overwhelming.
2. Process Variability: The same process may be executed differently across various business units or regions, making it difficult to create a standardized view.
3. Interconnected Systems: Large organizations typically use numerous interconnected IT systems, making it challenging to track process flows across different platforms.
4. Organizational Silos: Departmental boundaries can create information silos, hindering a holistic view of end-to-end processes.

3.2 Data-Related Challenges

Effective process discovery relies heavily on data, but large enterprises often struggle with data-related issues:

1. Data Volume: The sheer amount of data generated by large organizations can be overwhelming, making it difficult to process and analyze efficiently.
2. Data Quality: Inconsistent or inaccurate data can lead to flawed process insights and misguided improvement efforts.
3. Data Access: Stringent data security policies and legacy systems can make it challenging to access the necessary data for process discovery.
4. Data Integration: Combining data from multiple sources and systems to create a comprehensive view of processes can be technically challenging.

3.3 Stakeholder Engagement and Resistance

Engaging stakeholders and overcoming resistance to change are significant challenges in large enterprises:

1. Diverse Stakeholder Groups: Large organizations have numerous stakeholder groups with varying priorities and perspectives, making it difficult to align on process discovery goals.
2. Resistance to Transparency: Employees may resist process discovery efforts due to fears of job loss or increased scrutiny of their work.
3. Change Fatigue: In organizations where change is constant, employees may be resistant to yet another initiative.
4. Lack of Executive Support: Without strong executive sponsorship, process discovery initiatives may struggle to gain traction and resources.

3.4 Resource Constraints

Large enterprises often face resource-related challenges in process discovery:

1. Time Constraints: The day-to-day demands of running a large organization can make it difficult to allocate sufficient time for process discovery activities.
2. Skill Gaps: There may be a shortage of skilled personnel with expertise in process analysis and improvement methodologies.
3. Budget Limitations: Securing funding for process discovery initiatives can be challenging, especially when competing with other strategic priorities.
4. Technology Investments: Implementing and integrating advanced process discovery tools can require significant financial and technical resources.

3.5 Maintaining Currency and Relevance

Keeping process information up-to-date is an ongoing challenge for large enterprises:

1. Rapid Process Changes: In dynamic business environments, processes can change quickly, making it difficult to keep documentation current.
2. Evolving Technologies: As new technologies are adopted, processes may change, requiring continuous updates to process models and documentation.
3. Mergers and Acquisitions: Organizational changes can dramatically alter processes, necessitating frequent reassessment and rediscovery.

3.6 Balancing Standardization and Flexibility

Large enterprises struggle to find the right balance between process standardization and local flexibility:

1. Global vs. Local Processes: Determining which processes should be standardized globally and which should allow for local variations can be challenging.
2. Regulatory Compliance: Different regulatory requirements across regions can necessitate process variations, complicating standardization efforts.
3. Cultural Differences: Cultural nuances across different countries or regions may require process adaptations, making it difficult to implement a one-size-fits-all approach.

3.7 Technology-Related Challenges

While technology is crucial for process discovery, it also presents its own set of challenges:

1. Legacy Systems: Older, outdated systems may not provide the necessary data or integration capabilities for effective process discovery.
2. Tool Selection: Choosing the right tools from a plethora of options can be overwhelming and may lead to suboptimal investments.
3. User Adoption: Ensuring that employees effectively use new process discovery tools and technologies can be challenging.
4. Data Privacy and Security: Implementing process discovery technologies while maintaining strict data privacy and security standards can be complex.

3.8 Measuring and Demonstrating Value

Quantifying the impact and value of process discovery initiatives can be challenging:

1. Defining Metrics: Identifying appropriate metrics to measure the success of process discovery efforts can be difficult.
2. Attributing Improvements: Directly linking process improvements to business outcomes is not always straightforward.
3. Long-Term vs. Short-Term Benefits: Balancing the need for quick wins with long-term, strategic process improvements can be challenging.
4. Intangible Benefits: Some benefits of process discovery, such as improved employee satisfaction or better decision-making, can be hard to quantify.

3.9 Scaling Process Discovery Efforts

Expanding process discovery initiatives across a large enterprise presents unique challenges:

1. Methodology Consistency: Ensuring a consistent approach to process discovery across different parts of the organization can be difficult.
2. Knowledge Sharing: Facilitating the sharing of best practices and lessons learned across the organization is challenging but crucial.
3. Governance: Establishing effective governance structures to oversee and coordinate process discovery efforts across the enterprise is complex.
4. Sustainability: Maintaining momentum and enthusiasm for process discovery initiatives over the long term can be challenging.

Understanding these challenges is the first step towards developing effective strategies to overcome them.

4. Solutions and Best Practices

To address the challenges outlined in the previous section, large enterprises can employ a range of solutions and best practices. These strategies can help organizations overcome obstacles and maximize the value of their process discovery initiatives.

4.1 Addressing Scale and Complexity

1. Process Prioritization Framework: Develop a structured approach to identify and prioritize processes based on their impact on business objectives, customer satisfaction, and potential for improvement.
2. Process Architecture: Create a hierarchical process architecture that provides a high-level view of the organization's processes and their interconnections.
3. Modular Approach: Break down complex processes into smaller, manageable sub-processes for easier analysis and improvement.
4. Cross-Functional Teams: Form teams with members from different departments to ensure a holistic view of end-to-end processes.
5. Process Standardization: Where appropriate, standardize common processes across different business units to reduce complexity and improve efficiency.

4.2 Tackling Data-Related Challenges

1. Data Governance: Implement a robust data governance framework to ensure data quality, consistency, and accessibility across the organization.
2. Data Integration Platforms: Invest in data integration tools that can consolidate information from multiple systems and sources.
3. Data Quality Initiatives: Launch targeted data quality improvement programs to enhance the reliability of process-related data.
4. Automated Data Collection: Utilize process mining and RPA tools to automate data collection and reduce reliance on manual inputs.
5. Data Anonymization: Implement data anonymization techniques to address privacy concerns and facilitate broader data access for process discovery.

4.3 Enhancing Stakeholder Engagement and Overcoming Resistance

1. Change Management Program: Develop a comprehensive change management strategy to address resistance and facilitate adoption of process discovery initiatives.
2. Stakeholder Mapping: Identify key stakeholders and their interests to tailor communication and engagement strategies.
3. Continuous Communication: Maintain regular, transparent communication about the goals, progress, and outcomes of process discovery efforts.
4. Quick Wins: Prioritize and showcase early successes to build momentum and demonstrate value.
5. Gamification: Incorporate gamification elements into process discovery activities to increase engagement and motivation.

4.4 Optimizing Resource Allocation

1. Center of Excellence: Establish a Process Excellence Center of Excellence to centralize expertise and resources for process discovery and improvement.
2. Training and Skill Development: Invest in training programs to build internal capabilities in process analysis and improvement methodologies.
3. Outsourcing and Partnerships: Consider partnering with external experts or service providers to supplement internal resources and expertise.
4. Resource Allocation Model: Develop a model for allocating resources to process discovery initiatives based on potential impact and strategic alignment.
5. Technology ROI Assessment: Conduct thorough ROI assessments for technology investments to ensure optimal resource allocation.

4.5 Ensuring Currency and Relevance

1. Continuous Process Monitoring: Implement automated process monitoring tools to detect changes and trigger updates to process documentation.
2. Regular Review Cycles: Establish a cadence for reviewing and updating process models and documentation.
3. Version Control: Use version control systems for process documentation to track changes and maintain historical records.
4. Process Ownership: Assign clear ownership for each process to ensure accountability for keeping information up-to-date.
5. Dynamic Process Repositories: Utilize dynamic, cloud-based process repositories that allow for real-time updates and collaboration.

4.6 Balancing Standardization and Flexibility

1. Global Process Owners: Appoint global process owners to oversee standardization efforts while considering local needs.
2. Flexible Process Models: Develop process models that allow for configurable elements to accommodate necessary variations.
3. Governance Framework: Establish a governance framework that defines criteria for process standardization versus local adaptation.
4. Cultural Sensitivity Training: Provide training to process teams on cultural differences and their impact on process design and execution.
5. Regulatory Mapping: Create a comprehensive map of regulatory requirements across regions to inform process design decisions.

4.7 Leveraging Technology Effectively

1. Technology Assessment: Conduct a thorough assessment of existing systems and tools to identify gaps and opportunities for integration.
2. Phased Implementation: Adopt a phased approach to technology implementation, starting with pilot projects before full-scale rollout.
3. User-Centric Design: Involve end-users in the selection and design of process discovery tools to ensure usability and adoption.
4. Integration Strategy: Develop a clear strategy for integrating process discovery tools with existing enterprise systems.
5. Continuous Evaluation: Regularly evaluate the effectiveness of technology solutions and be prepared to adapt or switch tools as needed.

4.8 Measuring and Demonstrating Value

1. Balanced Scorecard: Develop a balanced scorecard that includes both quantitative and qualitative metrics for process discovery initiatives.
2. Baseline Measurements: Establish clear baseline measurements before initiating process improvements to accurately track progress.
3. Value Stream Mapping: Use value stream mapping to visualize and quantify the impact of process improvements on overall value delivery.
4. Customer-Centric Metrics: Include customer satisfaction and experience metrics to demonstrate the external impact of process improvements.
5. Regular Reporting: Implement a regular reporting cadence to keep stakeholders informed of progress and value realization.

4.9 Scaling Process Discovery Efforts

1. Maturity Model: Develop a process discovery maturity model to assess and guide the evolution of capabilities across the organization.
2. Knowledge Management System: Implement a centralized knowledge management system to facilitate sharing of best practices and lessons learned.
3. Community of Practice: Establish a community of practice for process professionals to foster collaboration and knowledge exchange.
4. Scalable Methodologies: Develop and document scalable process discovery methodologies that can be consistently applied across the organization.
5. Executive Sponsorship: Secure ongoing executive sponsorship to maintain focus and resources for process discovery initiatives as they scale.

4.10 Best Practices for Sustainable Process Discovery

1. Align with Business Strategy: Ensure that process discovery efforts are closely aligned with overall business strategy and objectives.
2. Foster a Process-Oriented Culture: Cultivate a organizational culture that values continuous process improvement and data-driven decision making.
3. Embrace Agile Methodologies: Adopt agile approaches to process discovery and improvement to increase flexibility and responsiveness.
4. Leverage Cross-Industry Insights: Look beyond your industry for best practices and innovative approaches to process discovery.
5. Invest in Change Management: Allocate sufficient resources to change management to ensure sustainable adoption of process improvements.
6. Continuous Learning: Encourage continuous learning and professional development in process-related disciplines.
7. Celebrate Success: Regularly recognize and celebrate process discovery and improvement successes to maintain enthusiasm and engagement.

By implementing these solutions and adhering to these best practices, large enterprises can overcome the challenges associated with process discovery and create a foundation for continuous improvement and operational excellence

5. Use Cases

Process discovery in large enterprises can be applied across various industries and functional areas. This section presents several use cases that illustrate the practical application of process discovery techniques and the benefits they can bring to organizations.

5.1 Financial Services: Streamlining Loan Approval Process

Background: A large multinational bank was struggling with lengthy loan approval times, leading to customer dissatisfaction and lost business opportunities.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. Automated process mining of loan application systems
2. Customer journey mapping
3. Cross-functional workshops with front-office and back-office staff

Key Findings:

• Multiple handoffs between departments caused significant delays
• Redundant data entry points increased errors and processing time
• Lack of clear SLAs between departments led to inconsistent prioritization

Outcomes:

• Reduced loan approval time by 40% through process optimization
• Implemented an automated workflow system to reduce manual handoffs
• Increased customer satisfaction scores by 25%
• Boosted loan approval rate by 15% due to faster processing

5.2 Manufacturing: Optimizing Production Line Efficiency

Background: A global automotive manufacturer wanted to improve the efficiency of its production lines across multiple plants.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. IoT sensor data analysis from production equipment
2. Time-motion studies on the production floor
3. Value stream mapping of the entire production process

Key Findings:

• Significant variability in process execution between shifts and plants
• Bottlenecks in specific stages of production causing ripple effects
• Underutilization of certain automated systems due to lack of integration

Outcomes:

• Increased overall equipment effectiveness (OEE) by 18%
• Standardized best practices across all plants, reducing variability
• Implemented predictive maintenance, reducing unplanned downtime by 30%
• Achieved annual cost savings of $15 million through efficiency improvements

5.3 Healthcare: Enhancing Patient Flow in Emergency Departments

Background: A large hospital network aimed to reduce wait times and improve patient experience in its emergency departments.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. Process mining of electronic health records (EHR) data
2. Patient and staff interviews
3. Observational studies of emergency department operations

Key Findings:

• Triage process was a major bottleneck, especially during peak hours
• Lack of real-time visibility into department capacity led to suboptimal resource allocation
• Delays in diagnostic testing significantly impacted overall treatment times

Outcomes:

• Reduced average patient wait time by 35% through process redesign
• Implemented a real-time dashboard for better resource management
• Improved patient satisfaction scores by 40%
• Increased emergency department capacity by 20% without adding resources

5.4 Retail: Optimizing Order Fulfillment Process

Background: A large e-commerce retailer wanted to improve its order fulfillment process to meet increasing customer demands for faster delivery.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. Process mining of order management and warehouse management systems
2. Gemba walks in fulfillment centers
3. Analysis of customer complaints and feedback

Key Findings:

• Inefficient picking routes in warehouses led to longer fulfillment times
• Lack of integration between inventory and order systems caused delays
• Manual quality check processes were slowing down the packing stage

Outcomes:

• Reduced order fulfillment time by 30% through process optimization
• Implemented an AI-driven picking route optimization system
• Integrated inventory and order systems for real-time updates
• Increased same-day delivery capability by 50%

5.5 Telecommunications: Improving Customer Onboarding

Background: A global telecommunications company sought to streamline its customer onboarding process to reduce churn and improve customer satisfaction.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. Customer journey mapping across multiple channels
2. Process mining of CRM and service activation systems
3. Voice of Customer (VoC) analysis

Key Findings:

• Disjointed processes between online and in-store sign-ups caused confusion
• Credit check process was a major bottleneck in service activation
• Lack of proactive communication led to high call volumes to customer service

Outcomes:

• Reduced average onboarding time from 24 hours to 2 hours
• Implemented an omnichannel onboarding system for consistent experience
• Automated credit checks, reducing processing time by 80%
• Decreased customer churn during onboarding by 40%

5.6 Public Sector: Streamlining Permit Application Process

Background: A large city government wanted to improve its building permit application process to support economic development and improve citizen satisfaction.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. Process mining of permit application systems
2. Citizen and staff focus groups
3. Benchmarking against other cities' processes

Key Findings:

• Multiple departments involved in approvals with no clear ownership
• Paper-based processes caused delays and increased errors
• Lack of transparency in the approval status led to high volumes of status inquiries

Outcomes:

• Reduced average permit approval time from 90 days to 30 days
• Implemented an online portal for application submission and status tracking
• Established a "one-stop-shop" model for permit applications
• Improved citizen satisfaction ratings by 60%

5.7 Insurance: Optimizing Claims Processing

Background: A major insurance company aimed to improve its claims processing efficiency to reduce costs and enhance customer satisfaction.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. Process mining of claims management systems
2. Analysis of call center logs and customer feedback
3. Workshops with claims adjusters and managers

Key Findings:

• High percentage of claims required manual review due to data quality issues
• Lack of integration between different insurance products led to duplicated efforts
• Inefficient allocation of claims to adjusters based on complexity and expertise

Outcomes:

• Reduced average claims processing time by 50%
• Implemented AI-driven claims triage and routing system
• Increased straight-through processing rate from 15% to 45%
• Improved customer satisfaction scores for claims handling by 35%

These use cases demonstrate the versatility and impact of process discovery across various industries and functional areas. They highlight how large enterprises can leverage different process discovery techniques to uncover inefficiencies, streamline operations, and deliver significant improvements in performance and customer satisfaction.

6. Case Study Examples

While the use cases provided a broad overview of process discovery applications across industries, this section delves into detailed case studies that offer an in-depth look at the implementation, challenges, and outcomes of specific process discovery initiatives in large enterprises.

6.1 Case Study: Global Pharmaceutical Company - Clinical Trial Process Optimization

Company Profile: PharmaCorp (pseudonym), a Fortune 500 pharmaceutical company with operations in over 50 countries.

Challenge: PharmaCorp was facing increasing costs and timelines in their clinical trial processes, threatening their competitive position in bringing new drugs to market.

Objective: To reduce the time and cost of clinical trials while maintaining quality and regulatory compliance.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. Data Collection: Gathered data from clinical trial management systems spanning the last five years Conducted interviews with 50+ stakeholders across different departments and geographies Analyzed regulatory submission documents and audit reports
2. Process Mining: Utilized Celonis process mining software to analyze event logs from clinical trial systems Created process maps for different types of clinical trials and across different therapeutic areas
3. Value Stream Mapping: Conducted a series of workshops to create detailed value stream maps of the end-to-end clinical trial process Identified value-adding and non-value-adding activities
4. Root Cause Analysis: Employed fishbone diagrams and 5-Why analysis to identify root causes of delays and inefficiencies

Key Findings:

1. Site selection and initiation were major bottlenecks, with an average of 6 months from site identification to first patient enrolled
2. 30% of clinical trial protocols required amendments, leading to significant delays and costs
3. Data cleaning and query resolution accounted for 70% of the time spent in data management
4. Inconsistent processes across different geographic regions led to inefficiencies and compliance risks

Solutions Implemented:

1. Developed a centralized, AI-driven site selection tool to optimize site selection based on historical performance data
2. Implemented a cross-functional protocol review process with clearly defined quality criteria to reduce amendments
3. Introduced risk-based monitoring and real-time data analytics to streamline data management
4. Standardized core processes across regions while allowing for necessary local adaptations

Outcomes:

1. Reduced average time from site identification to first patient enrolled by 40% (from 6 months to 3.6 months)
2. Decreased protocol amendments by 50%, saving an estimated $5 million per study
3. Improved data quality, reducing query rates by 35% and data cleaning time by 45%
4. Achieved overall reduction in clinical trial timelines by 25% and cost savings of approximately $80 million annually

Lessons Learned:

1. Importance of cross-functional collaboration in complex process discovery initiatives
2. Value of combining quantitative (process mining) and qualitative (interviews, workshops) approaches
3. Need for change management to ensure adoption of new processes and tools
4. Criticality of maintaining a balance between global standardization and local flexibility

6.2 Case Study: Global Logistics Company - Last-Mile Delivery Optimization

Company Profile: LogiGlobal (pseudonym), a multinational logistics and supply chain management company operating in over 200 countries.

Challenge: LogiGlobal was struggling with inefficiencies in its last-mile delivery process, leading to missed delivery windows, high costs, and customer dissatisfaction.

Objective: To improve the efficiency and reliability of last-mile deliveries while reducing costs and enhancing customer experience.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. IoT Data Analysis: Analyzed GPS data from delivery vehicles Collected data from handheld devices used by delivery personnel
2. Process Mining: Used ARIS process mining tools to analyze event logs from order management and delivery systems Created process models for different types of deliveries (e.g., residential, commercial, express)
3. Customer Journey Mapping: Conducted online surveys and phone interviews with customers Analyzed customer complaint data and social media feedback
4. Gemba Walks: Conducted ride-alongs with delivery personnel in various urban and rural settings Observed operations in distribution centers and sorting facilities

Key Findings:

1. 40% of delivery attempts to residential addresses were unsuccessful on the first try
2. Inefficient routing led to excessive fuel consumption and overtime costs
3. Lack of real-time communication with customers resulted in missed deliveries and customer frustration
4. Significant variability in processes between different regions and types of deliveries

Solutions Implemented:

1. Developed an AI-driven dynamic routing system that adapts to traffic conditions and delivery priorities in real-time
2. Implemented a customer communication platform with real-time tracking and delivery time updates
3. Introduced flexible delivery options, including secure drop-off locations and preferred time windows
4. Standardized core delivery processes while allowing for necessary local adaptations

Outcomes:

1. Increased first-time delivery success rate from 60% to 85%
2. Reduced fuel costs by 15% through optimized routing
3. Improved customer satisfaction scores by 30%
4. Achieved a 20% increase in deliveries per driver per day
5. Realized annual cost savings of $150 million through efficiency improvements

Lessons Learned:

1. Importance of integrating multiple data sources for a comprehensive view of the process
2. Value of involving front-line employees in the process discovery and improvement efforts
3. Need for flexible technology solutions that can adapt to varying local conditions
4. Criticality of customer-centric process design in service operations

6.3 Case Study: Global Bank - Know Your Customer (KYC) Process Improvement

Company Profile: GlobeBank (pseudonym), a multinational banking and financial services corporation with operations in over 70 countries.

Challenge: GlobeBank was facing regulatory pressure and operational inefficiencies due to its complex and time-consuming Know Your Customer (KYC) process.

Objective: To streamline the KYC process, reducing processing time and costs while enhancing regulatory compliance and customer experience.

Process Discovery Approach:

1. Process Mining: Utilized Disco process mining software to analyze event logs from KYC and customer onboarding systems Created process models for different customer segments and jurisdictions
2. Regulatory Mapping: Conducted a comprehensive analysis of KYC regulations across all operating jurisdictions Created a matrix of regulatory requirements to identify commonalities and differences
3. Customer and Employee Surveys: Conducted surveys with customers who recently went through the KYC process Gathered feedback from front-line staff and compliance officers
4. System Architecture Analysis: Mapped the current system landscape involved in the KYC process Identified data flows and integration points between systems

Key Findings:

1. 60% of KYC cases required multiple customer contacts for additional information
2. Duplicate data entry across multiple systems led to errors and inefficiencies
3. Lack of a risk-based approach resulted in over-processing of low-risk customers
4. Inconsistent interpretation of regulations across different jurisdictions led to variable processes

Solutions Implemented:

1. Developed an intelligent document processing system using OCR and machine learning to automate data extraction from customer documents
2. Implemented a centralized KYC database to eliminate duplicate data entry and ensure data consistency
3. Introduced a risk-based KYC approach, tailoring the process based on customer risk profiles
4. Created a global KYC policy with clear guidelines for regulatory interpretation, allowing for necessary local adaptations

Outcomes:

1. Reduced average KYC processing time by 50% (from 20 days to 10 days)
2. Decreased the need for multiple customer contacts by 70%
3. Improved regulatory compliance, with audit findings reduced by 80%
4. Achieved cost savings of $50 million annually through process efficiencies
5. Increased customer satisfaction scores for account opening process by 40%

Lessons Learned:

1. Importance of balancing regulatory compliance with operational efficiency
2. Value of a risk-based approach in process design for financial services
3. Need for clear governance structures in global process standardization efforts
4. Criticality of technology integration in complex, data-intensive processes

These case studies provide detailed examples of how large enterprises have successfully implemented process discovery initiatives to address significant operational challenges. They highlight the importance of a comprehensive approach to process discovery, combining various techniques and tools to gain a holistic understanding of complex processes. Furthermore, they demonstrate the substantial benefits that can be realized through effective process discovery and subsequent improvement efforts.

7. Metrics Roadmap

Measuring the success of process discovery initiatives is crucial for demonstrating value, guiding improvement efforts, and ensuring continued support from stakeholders. This section outlines a comprehensive metrics roadmap that large enterprises can use to assess the effectiveness of their process discovery efforts and the resulting process improvements.

7.1 Framework for Process Discovery Metrics

To create a holistic view of process discovery success, we propose a framework that encompasses four key dimensions:

1. Operational Efficiency: Measures that reflect improvements in process performance and resource utilization.
2. Financial Impact: Metrics that quantify the monetary benefits of process discovery and subsequent improvements.
3. Customer Experience: Indicators that capture the impact of process improvements on customer satisfaction and loyalty.
4. Employee Engagement: Measures that assess the effect of process discovery initiatives on employee satisfaction and productivity.

7.2 Operational Efficiency Metrics

7.2.1 Process Cycle Time

• Definition: The total time taken to complete a process from start to finish.
• Measurement: Compare average cycle times before and after process improvements.
• Target: Aim for a 20-30% reduction in cycle time within the first year of implementation.

7.2.2 Process Variability

• Definition: The degree of variation in process execution.
• Measurement: Calculate the standard deviation of process cycle times.
• Target: Reduce process variability by 25-40% within 18 months.

7.2.3 First Time Right (FTR) Rate

• Definition: The percentage of processes completed correctly on the first attempt.
• Measurement: (Number of error-free completions / Total number of process executions) x 100
• Target: Improve FTR rate by 15-25% within the first year.

7.2.4 Resource Utilization

• Definition: The efficiency with which resources (human and technological) are used in the process.
• Measurement: (Actual time spent on value-adding activities / Total available time) x 100
• Target: Increase resource utilization by 10-20% within 18 months.

7.3 Financial Impact Metrics

7.3.1 Cost per Transaction

• Definition: The average cost to execute a single instance of the process.
• Measurement: Total process costs / Number of process executions
• Target: Reduce cost per transaction by 15-25% within two years.

7.3.2 Return on Investment (ROI)

• Definition: The financial return relative to the investment in process discovery and improvement initiatives.
• Measurement: (Net benefits / Cost of investment) x 100
• Target: Achieve a positive ROI within 12-18 months, aiming for 200-300% ROI within three years.

7.3.3 Cost Avoidance

• Definition: Potential costs that are avoided due to process improvements.
• Measurement: Estimate costs that would have been incurred under the old process versus the new process.
• Target: Demonstrate cost avoidance of 1.5-2 times the investment in process discovery within two years.

7.4 Customer Experience Metrics

7.4.1 Customer Satisfaction Score (CSAT)

• Definition: A measure of how satisfied customers are with the process or service.
• Measurement: Survey customers on a scale (e.g., 1-5 or 1-10) after process completion.
• Target: Improve CSAT scores by 15-20% within 18 months.

7.4.2 Net Promoter Score (NPS)

• Definition: A measure of customer loyalty and likelihood to recommend.
• Measurement: Survey customers on a scale of 0-10, calculate the percentage of promoters minus detractors.
• Target: Increase NPS by 10-15 points within two years.

7.4.3 Customer Effort Score (CES)

• Definition: A measure of how much effort customers expend to complete a process or resolve an issue.
• Measurement: Survey customers on the effort required (typically on a scale of 1-5 or 1-7).
• Target: Reduce average CES by 20-30% within 18 months.

7.5 Employee Engagement Metrics

7.5.1 Employee Satisfaction Score

• Definition: A measure of employee satisfaction with their work processes and tools.
• Measurement: Conduct regular employee surveys (e.g., quarterly or bi-annually).
• Target: Improve employee satisfaction scores by 15-20% within 18 months.

7.5.2 Process Adoption Rate

• Definition: The extent to which employees are following the newly discovered or improved processes.
• Measurement: (Number of process executions following the new process / Total number of process executions) x 100
• Target: Achieve 80-90% adoption rate within six months of process implementation.

7.5.3 Innovation Rate

• Definition: The number of process improvement ideas generated by employees.
• Measurement: Track the number of employee-submitted improvement suggestions.
• Target: Increase the number of actionable improvement ideas by 30-50% within the first year.

7.6 Process Discovery Effectiveness Metrics

7.6.1 Process Coverage

• Definition: The percentage of organizational processes that have undergone discovery and documentation.
• Measurement: (Number of processes discovered and documented / Total number of identified processes) x 100
• Target: Achieve 70-80% process coverage within two years.

7.6.2 Discovery Accuracy

• Definition: The degree to which discovered processes match reality.
• Measurement: Conduct periodic audits to compare discovered processes with actual execution.
• Target: Maintain discovery accuracy above 90%.

7.6.3 Time to Insight

• Definition: The time taken from the initiation of a process discovery initiative to the delivery of actionable insights.
• Measurement: Track the duration of process discovery projects from kick-off to final report delivery.
• Target: Reduce time to insight by 20-30% year-over-year.

7.7 Implementing the Metrics Roadmap

To effectively implement this metrics roadmap, large enterprises should follow these steps:

1. Baseline Measurement: Establish current performance levels for each metric before implementing process improvements.
2. Goal Setting: Set realistic, time-bound targets for each metric based on organizational priorities and industry benchmarks.
3. Data Collection Systems: Implement robust systems for collecting and analyzing data related to each metric. This may involve integrating data from multiple sources and implementing new tracking mechanisms.
4. Regular Reporting: Establish a cadence for reporting on these metrics, typically monthly or quarterly, depending on the metric and organizational needs.
5. Dashboard Creation: Develop visual dashboards that provide real-time or near-real-time views of key metrics for different stakeholder groups.
6. Continuous Refinement: Regularly review the relevance and effectiveness of the metrics. Be prepared to adjust or add metrics as the process discovery initiative evolves.
7. Benchmarking: Where possible, benchmark performance against industry standards or peer organizations to provide context for the improvements achieved.
8. Storytelling: Use the metrics to create compelling narratives about the impact of process discovery initiatives. This can help in securing ongoing support and resources for these efforts.

By implementing this comprehensive metrics roadmap, large enterprises can effectively measure the success of their process discovery initiatives across multiple dimensions. This approach not only demonstrates the value of these efforts but also provides the insights needed to continuously refine and improve processes over time.

8. Return on Investment (ROI) Analysis

Return on Investment (ROI) analysis is crucial for justifying the resources allocated to process discovery initiatives and demonstrating their value to stakeholders. This section outlines a comprehensive approach to calculating and interpreting ROI for process discovery efforts in large enterprises.

8.1 Understanding ROI in the Context of Process Discovery

ROI for process discovery initiatives can be complex to calculate due to the often intangible and long-term nature of some benefits. However, a well-structured ROI analysis can provide powerful insights into the value created by these efforts.

8.1.1 Basic ROI Formula

The basic formula for ROI is:

ROI = (Net Benefits / Cost of Investment) x 100

For process discovery initiatives, this translates to:

ROI = ((Total Benefits - Total Costs) / Total Costs) x 100

8.2 Identifying and Quantifying Costs

8.2.1 Direct Costs

• Software licenses for process mining and analysis tools
• Hardware costs (if any)
• Consultant fees
• Training costs for staff
• Staff time dedicated to the initiative

8.2.2 Indirect Costs

• Opportunity cost of staff time
• Potential short-term productivity dips during implementation
• Change management costs

8.3 Identifying and Quantifying Benefits

Benefits from process discovery initiatives can be categorized into tangible and intangible benefits.

8.3.1 Tangible Benefits

• Reduced process cycle times
• Decreased error rates
• Improved resource utilization
• Reduced operational costs
• Increased throughput

8.3.2 Intangible Benefits

• Improved customer satisfaction
• Enhanced employee satisfaction
• Better regulatory compliance
• Increased organizational agility
• Improved decision-making capability

8.4 Quantifying Intangible Benefits

While intangible benefits are harder to quantify, several methods can be used to assign monetary value:

1. Proxy Measures: Use related tangible metrics as proxies. For example, link customer satisfaction improvements to reduced churn or increased repeat business.
2. Willingness to Pay: Estimate how much the organization would be willing to pay for the improvement if it were offered as a service.
3. Benchmarking: Use industry benchmarks or case studies to estimate the value of improvements.
4. Risk Reduction: Quantify the reduced risk of negative events (e.g., regulatory fines, reputational damage) as a result of process improvements.

8.5 Time Value of Money Considerations

For a more accurate ROI calculation, consider the time value of money using Net Present Value (NPV) calculations:

1. Project the costs and benefits over the expected lifecycle of the process improvements (typically 3-5 years).
2. Apply a discount rate to future cash flows to calculate their present value.
3. Use the NPV of benefits and costs in the ROI calculation.

8.6 ROI Calculation Example

Let's consider a hypothetical process discovery initiative in a large financial services company:

Costs (over 3 years):

• Process mining software licenses: $500,000
• Consultant fees: $750,000
• Staff time: $1,000,000
• Training: $250,000
• Total Costs: $2,500,000

Benefits (over 3 years):

• Reduced operational costs: $3,000,000
• Increased revenue from improved customer satisfaction: $1,500,000
• Avoided regulatory fines: $1,000,000
• Total Benefits: $5,500,000

ROI Calculation: ROI = ((5,500,000 - 2,500,000) / 2,500,000) x 100 = 120%

This indicates that for every dollar invested in the process discovery initiative, the company gained $1.20 in return.

8.7 Interpreting ROI Results

When interpreting ROI results for process discovery initiatives, consider the following:

1. Timeframe: ROI typically improves over time as initial costs are offset by ongoing benefits. Consider both short-term and long-term ROI.
2. Risk Adjustment: Apply risk adjustments to both costs and benefits to account for uncertainties.
3. Sensitivity Analysis: Perform sensitivity analysis by varying key assumptions to understand the range of possible ROI outcomes.
4. Benchmarking: Compare ROI results with industry benchmarks or similar initiatives within the organization.
5. Non-Financial Impacts: Remember to consider non-financial impacts that may not be fully captured in the ROI calculation.

8.8 Challenges in ROI Calculation for Process Discovery

Several challenges can complicate ROI calculations for process discovery initiatives:

1. Attribution: It can be difficult to attribute specific improvements solely to process discovery efforts, especially in large, complex organizations.
2. Long-Term Benefits: Many benefits of process discovery may only materialize in the long term, making short-term ROI calculations challenging.
3. Evolving Baselines: As processes improve, the baseline for comparison shifts, potentially understating the cumulative benefits over time.
4. Interdependencies: Process improvements in one area may have ripple effects across the organization, complicating the isolation of benefits.

8.9 Best Practices for ROI Analysis in Process Discovery

To ensure robust and credible ROI analysis for process discovery initiatives, consider the following best practices:

1. Conservative Estimates: Use conservative estimates for benefits and liberal estimates for costs to avoid overstating ROI.
2. Regular Updates: Recalculate ROI periodically as more data becomes available and initial assumptions are validated or refuted.
3. Stakeholder Involvement: Involve key stakeholders in defining and validating the ROI model to ensure buy-in and credibility.
4. Transparency: Clearly document all assumptions and calculations to allow for scrutiny and refinement.
5. Multiple Scenarios: Develop multiple ROI scenarios (e.g., best case, worst case, most likely) to provide a range of potential outcomes.
6. Qualitative Context: Always present ROI figures alongside qualitative context and non-financial benefits for a holistic view of value.
7. Continuous Improvement: Use ROI analysis not just for justification, but as a tool for continuous improvement of process discovery initiatives.

ROI analysis is a powerful tool for demonstrating the value of process discovery initiatives in large enterprises. By carefully identifying and quantifying both costs and benefits, organizations can make informed decisions about investments in process discovery and improvement efforts. However, it's crucial to remember that ROI is just one piece of the puzzle. A holistic evaluation should also consider strategic alignment, risk reduction, and long-term organizational capabilities developed through these initiatives.

By combining robust ROI analysis with the comprehensive metrics roadmap discussed in the previous section, large enterprises can create a compelling case for ongoing investment in process discovery and continual process improvement.

9. Conclusion

Process discovery has emerged as a critical discipline for large enterprises seeking to optimize their operations, enhance customer satisfaction, and maintain competitiveness in an increasingly complex business environment. Throughout this comprehensive exploration of process discovery in large enterprises, we have examined the challenges, solutions, use cases, and methodologies that define this field. As we conclude, it's important to synthesize the key insights and look toward the future of process discovery in large organizations.

9.1 Key Takeaways

1. Complexity as Both Challenge and Opportunity: The scale and complexity of large enterprises present significant challenges for process discovery, but also offer immense opportunities for improvement and value creation. By leveraging advanced technologies and methodologies, organizations can turn this complexity into a competitive advantage.
2. Holistic Approach is Crucial: Successful process discovery initiatives require a holistic approach that combines technological solutions with human insights. The integration of process mining, interviews, workshops, and on-the-ground observations provides a comprehensive understanding of processes that neither technology nor human analysis alone can achieve.
3. Data is the Foundation: High-quality, accessible data is the bedrock of effective process discovery. Large enterprises must prioritize data governance, integration, and quality to ensure the success of their process discovery efforts.
4. Balancing Standardization and Flexibility: While process standardization can drive efficiency and consistency, large enterprises must also maintain the flexibility to adapt to local needs and regulatory requirements. Striking this balance is key to successful global process management.
5. Change Management is Essential: The human element of process discovery and improvement cannot be overstated. Robust change management strategies are crucial for overcoming resistance, ensuring adoption, and realizing the full benefits of process improvements.
6. Continuous Improvement Mindset: Process discovery should not be viewed as a one-time project but as an ongoing discipline. Adopting a continuous improvement mindset enables organizations to adapt to changing business environments and consistently drive value.
7. Measurable Impact: As demonstrated through our metrics roadmap and ROI analysis, the impact of process discovery initiatives can and should be measured. Quantifying both tangible and intangible benefits is crucial for justifying investments and maintaining stakeholder support.

9.2 Future Trends in Process Discovery

As we look to the future, several trends are likely to shape the evolution of process discovery in large enterprises:

1. Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning: AI and ML will play an increasingly significant role in process discovery, enabling more accurate predictions, anomaly detection, and automated process optimization recommendations.
2. Real-time Process Intelligence: The ability to monitor and analyze processes in real-time will become more prevalent, allowing organizations to make instant adjustments and improvements.
3. Democratization of Process Discovery: User-friendly tools and platforms will make process discovery more accessible to non-technical users, fostering a culture of continuous improvement across all levels of the organization.
4. Integration with Emerging Technologies: Process discovery will increasingly integrate with emerging technologies such as IoT, blockchain, and augmented reality, providing new data sources and insights.
5. Ethical Considerations: As process discovery becomes more pervasive, organizations will need to grapple with ethical considerations around data privacy, employee monitoring, and the societal impacts of automation.

9.3 Final Thoughts

Process discovery in large enterprises is not just about improving efficiency or reducing costs. It's about creating a deep understanding of how work really gets done, fostering a culture of continuous improvement, and building the organizational agility needed to thrive in an ever-changing business landscape.

The challenges are significant, but so are the potential rewards. By embracing advanced technologies, fostering cross-functional collaboration, and maintaining a relentless focus on value creation, large enterprises can leverage process discovery to transform their operations and create sustainable competitive advantages.

As we move forward, the organizations that will succeed are those that view process discovery not as a one-time initiative, but as a fundamental capability woven into the fabric of their operations. These enterprises will be well-positioned to navigate the complexities of the modern business environment, continuously adapt to changing market conditions, and deliver exceptional value to their customers, employees, and stakeholders.

The journey of process discovery is ongoing, and the destination is a state of continuous evolution and improvement. For large enterprises willing to embark on this journey, the potential for transformation and value creation is boundless.

10. References

1. van der Aalst, W. M. P. (2016). Process Mining: Data Science in Action. Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
2. Dumas, M., La Rosa, M., Mendling, J., & Reijers, H. A. (2018). Fundamentals of Business Process Management (2nd ed.). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
3. vom Brocke, J., & Rosemann, M. (Eds.). (2015). Handbook on Business Process Management 1: Introduction, Methods, and Information Systems (2nd ed.). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
4. Jeston, J., & Nelis, J. (2014). Business Process Management: Practical Guidelines to Successful Implementations (3rd ed.). Routledge.
5. Trkman, P. (2010). The critical success factors of business process management. International Journal of Information Management, 30(2), 125-134.
6. Rosemann, M., & vom Brocke, J. (2015). The Six Core Elements of Business Process Management. In Handbook on Business Process Management 1 (pp. 105-122). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
7. Fernández-Llatas, C., & García-Gómez, J. M. (Eds.). (2015). Data Mining in Clinical Medicine. Springer New York.
8. Reinkemeyer, L. (2020). Process Mining in Action: Principles, Use Cases and Outlook. Springer International Publishing.
9. zur Muehlen, M., & Shapiro, R. (2015). Business Process Analytics. In Handbook on Business Process Management 2 (pp. 243-263). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
10. Kerremans, M., Searle, S., Surdulescu, R., & Pezzini, M. (2020). Market Guide for Process Mining. Gartner Research.
11. Syed, R., Leemans, S. J. J., Eden, R., & Buijs, J. C. A. M. (2020). Process Mining Adoption. Business & Information Systems Engineering, 62(3), 193-196.
12. Lederer, M., Knapp, J., & Schott, P. (2017). The digital future has many names—How business process management drives the digital transformation. In 2017 6th International Conference on Industrial Technology and Management (ICITM) (pp. 22-26). IEEE.
13. van Eck, M. L., Lu, X., Leemans, S. J. J., & van der Aalst, W. M. P. (2015). PM^2: A Process Mining Project Methodology. In Advanced Information Systems Engineering (pp. 297-313). Springer International Publishing.
14. Aguirre, S., Parra, C., & Alvarado, J. (2013). Combination of Process Mining and Simulation Techniques for Business Process Redesign: A Methodological Approach. In Data-Driven Process Discovery and Analysis (pp. 24-43). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
15. Suriadi, S., Wynn, M. T., Ouyang, C., ter Hofstede, A. H. M., & van Dijk, N. J. (2013). Understanding Process Behaviours in a Large Insurance Company in Australia: A Case Study. In Advanced Information Systems Engineering (pp. 449-464). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
16. Mans, R. S., van der Aalst, W. M. P., & Vanwersch, R. J. B. (2015). Process Mining in Healthcare: Evaluating and Exploiting Operational Healthcare Processes. Springer International Publishing.
17. de Leoni, M., van der Aalst, W. M. P., & Dees, M. (2016). A general process mining framework for correlating, predicting and clustering dynamic behavior based on event logs. Information Systems, 56, 235-257.
18. Grisold, T., Mendling, J., Otto, M., & vom Brocke, J. (2020). Adoption, use and management of process mining in practice. Business Process Management Journal, 27(2), 369-387.
19. Rahimi, F., M?ller, C., & Hvam, L. (2016). Business process management and IT management: The missing integration. International Journal of Information Management, 36(1), 142-154.
20. van der Aalst, W. M. P., Bichler, M., & Heinzl, A. (2018). Robotic Process Automation. Business & Information Systems Engineering, 60(4), 269-272.
21. Kerremans, M. (2018). Market Guide for Process Mining. Gartner Research.
22. Syed, R., Suriadi, S., Adams, M., Bandara, W., Leemans, S. J. J., Ouyang, C., ter Hofstede, A. H. M., van de Weerd, I., Wynn, M. T., & Reijers, H. A. (2020). Robotic Process Automation: Contemporary themes and challenges. Computers in Industry, 115, 103162.
23. vom Brocke, J., Jans, M., Mendling, J., & Reijers, H. A. (2020). A Five-Level Framework for Research on Process Mining. Business & Information Systems Engineering, 62(3), 185-192.
24. Thiede, M., Fuerstenau, D., & Bezerra Barquet, A. P. (2018). How is process mining technology used by organizations? A systematic literature review of empirical studies. Business Process Management Journal, 24(4), 900-922.
25. Reinkemeyer, L. (Ed.). (2020). Process Mining in Action: Principles, Use Cases and Outlook. Springer International Publishing.