Printful vs Printify 2024 - First Hand Comparison

We conduct independent reviews of all the products featured in our comparisons. Please be aware that if you make a purchase through our links, we may receive a commission. You can view our editorial policy here .

Today we have an epic comparison to share. We're putting two heavyweight print-on-demand platforms against each other: Printful and Printify.

Which one will come out on top? Stick around to find out!

So, if you’re ready to witness the clash of the POD titans, let's jump right in and see who reigns supreme: Printify or Printful!

Printful vs Printify: A Comparison in the Print On Demand Industry

Let’s begin with some basic information about print-on-demand. The industry is booming, and is projected to hit $10 billion by 2025 , just from custom T-shirt printing alone! It’s a gold mine waiting to be tapped, and that’s where print on demand platforms like Printify and Printful come into play.

These two powerhouses have carved their names at the top of the industry.

So if you’ve ever found yourself torn between these platforms, worry not! Today, we’re going to dig deep and uncover the strengths and weaknesses of each of these two.

We’ll explore key factors like ease of use, pricing, order fulfillment, customer support, print quality, and integrations. By the end of this article, you’ll have a crystal-clear understanding of which print-on-demand solution is perfect for your ecommerce business.

So grab your cup of coffee and get ready for an exciting trip!

Printful - What We Like

Before we wrap up this Printful vs Printify showdown, let’s take a moment to highlight what we love about Printful.

This platform has certainly impressed with its array of features and offerings. Printful offers a comprehensive range of custom branding options, including personalized packing slips, branded tracking pages, logo tape, custom labels, and branded inserts. The platform stands out with its wide range of unique products , automated order fulfillment, numerous integrations, quick turnaround time, user-friendly interface, and exceptional product quality.

Printful - What We Don’t Like

But there is one aspect of Printful that can be improved. While this platform excels in product quality, their products are slightly on the higher end when it comes to pricing. It's important to weigh this against the value they provide in terms of product quality, customer support, and fulfillment capabilities.

Learn more about Printful here.

Printify - What We Like

Now, let’s shift our focus to Printify and explore some of the positive aspects that make it an appealing option for many entrepreneurs.

One of the standout features of Printify is the ability to handpick your printing companies, giving you full control over the production process.

This, combined with their flexible pricing model, diverse product range, and affordable pricing, makes Printify an excellent solution for your print on demand needs.

Printify - What We Don’t Like

While Printify has its strengths, it’s important to consider some of its drawbacks as well.

Firstly, it only offers a limited number of integrations. Additionally, Printify’s branding services are kind of limited too, offering less flexibility for customization. Lastly, the print quality can fluctuate as it relies on various printing providers, which can affect consistent print quality.

Learn more about Printify here .

What Is a Print On Demand Platform?

Before we dive deeper into the Printify vs. Printful showdown, let’s take a moment to understand what print-on-demand is all about. Imagine this: you have a really cool design that you want to sell as a T-shirt.

But you don’t want to deal with the hassle of stocking inventory or handling fulfillment. That’s where a print on demand service comes in.

Print-on-demand works like magic. As a seller, you team up with a print on demand service like Printful or Printify. The supplier has a warehouse and an online platform that seamlessly integrates with your online shop.

All you need to do is provide the design to the supplier, who then manufactures the T-shirt with your design and brand, one piece at a time. And the possibilities are endless! You can choose from caps, T-shirts, leggings, hoodies, pillows, curtains, and so much more.

Think of it as a cousin to drop shipping. With print-on-demand, you don’t need to keep any inventory or pay upfront fees until a customer buys a product.

Just like drop shipping, when you receive an order on your website, you simply forward it to your print-on-demand supplier.

The supplier then takes care of manufacturing, shipping, and even packaging. You can focus on creating and promoting your designs while the supplier handles the rest. It’s a convenient and efficient way to bring your ideas to life and deliver them to your customers.

How Printful Works?

Alright, now that you’re familiar with POD, let’s shine the spotlight on Printful and see how this powerhouse operates.

Printful takes charge of the entire process, from manufacturing the products to running production houses across the globe. With facilities in the USA, Mexico, and Europe, they ensure your customers’ orders are fulfilled in a timely manner.

But here’s where it gets exciting. Printful offers a whopping selection of over 200 products. We’re talking T-shirts, hoodies, hats, mugs, tote bags, and many others. It’s like having a never-ending catalog of products at your fingertips.

Printful also provides custom packaging inserts like flyers, coupons, business cards, branded stickers, postcards, and thank-you cards to create a personalized unboxing experience for customers.

So, naturally, Printful is considered as the superhero of print-on-demand. A single supplier that caters to all your needs. No more juggling multiple vendors or worrying about different production processes.

How Printify Works?

Now, let's turn our attention to Printify and see how they shake things up.?

Printify has a unique approach that sets them apart from the crowd. Instead of handling the manufacturing and shipping themselves, they've created a platform of third-party print providers from around the world. It's like a business marketplace for print-on-demand providers.

But here's the genius part: Printify has streamlined the entire process with their seamless software integration. You no longer need to deal with each supplier individually.

Instead, you work directly with Printify, and they handle all the coordination with the actual print providers. It's like having a personal assistant for your print-on-demand needs.

One major advantage of this approach is the flexibility it offers. You can mix and match then select the best suppliers for different products and even for different countries.

You are basically building your own dream team of print providers to suit your specific needs. That level of customization is a game-changer.

But, like any coin, there's another side to consider. Because the suppliers are different, the product quality and shipping times can vary greatly. It's a trade-off for the flexibility Printify offers.

Additionally, if you have any issues or questions, you can't directly contact the print provider. You have to go through Printify, which adds an extra layer of communication.

Product Options

Now that you have a good understanding of how Printful and Printify operate, let’s talk about one of the most exciting aspects of print-on-demand: the print on demand products. Both Printful and Printify have got you covered with a massive variety of print on demand products to choose from.

Printful, as we discussed earlier, manufactures its own products and offers over 200 options.

From tech products like phone cases to eye-catching accessories like notebooks and drinkware, Printful has curated a collection that covers various niches and interests.

On the other hand, Printify takes a different approach. They serve as a marketplace for third-party print providers, allowing you to choose from a wide array of print on demand products. This means even more product choices at your fingertips!

So, whether you opt for Printful’s in-house manufacturing or Printify’s marketplace approach, you can rest assured that both platforms offer an extensive selection of print on demand products.

Sky’s the limit when it comes to unleashing your creativity and finding the best product to showcase your design.

Pricing

Alright, let's dive into the world of pricing and see how Printful and Printify compare to each other. The good news is both platforms offer options that can fit different budgets and business needs. Let's break this down!

First up, we have Printful, and the exciting part is It's free to use! Printful doesn't charge any upfront fees to access their platform.

However, keep in mind that the product costs themselves are slightly on the higher side compared to some other options out there. But hey, you're paying for the convenience and quality that Printful offers.

Now, let's talk about some additional features and costs. With Printful, you’ve got the opportunity to have your logo printed on the packing slips for free. That's a nice touch to add some branding to your orders.

If you want to take it a step further and personalize the label, Printful charges $2.49 per label. And if you want your order to include pack-ins like flyers, business cards, or stickers, there's an additional cost of $0.75 per order.

On the other hand, Printify operates on a freemium subscription model. Their free account allows you to integrate with up to 5 stores.

That's a great starting point. However, if you're looking for more advanced features and discounts, Printify offers a premium plan priced at $29 per month.

This plan is very popular as it provides up to 20% discount on all products. Additionally, the premium plan gives you the option to sell personalized products, which is not available on the free plan.

Our verdict - in terms of sheer pricing, Printify is the winner.

Integrations

Now let’s explore the world of integrations and see how Printify and Printful stack up against each other. While both Printify and Printful offer integrations with popular e-commerce platforms, there is a notable difference in the size of their integration lists. This is crucial for managing an ecommerce store effectively.

Printify’s premium plan, for example, only connects with two marketplaces: Etsy and eBay.

On the other hand, Printful connects with platforms like Amazon, Storenvy, Inktale, Wish, and Bonanza, just to name a few. This extended integration list opens up more opportunities for you to expand your reach and tap into different marketplaces.

So, when it comes to integrations, our verdict leans towards Printful as the winner because it offers a longer list of integrations that make your life easier.

Fulfillment & Shipping Costs

It’s time to talk about the crucial aspects of fulfillment and shipping. Let’s see how these platforms handle the process of getting your products into the hands of your customers.

Printful estimates that their production times can range from 2-7 business days. When it comes to shipping, it may take about 4 business days. In fact, Printful delivers over 3 million orders each year by partnering with global carriers such as FedEx, DHL, USPS, and DPD.?

This ensures a reliable and efficient shipping solution. Speaking of shipping costs, Printful offers transparent pricing. Typically, the shipping cost for the first product ranges from $4 to $6, with an extra cost of $1.25 for each additional product.

Now let’s talk about Printify. Printify also collaborates with top carrier companies. In addition to these, the platform has also partnered with local companies to handle order fulfillment.

However, it's worth noting that the rates for some of these solutions can be a bit higher. And when it comes to international orders, Printify's shipping solutions tend to take longer, typically ranging from 7-20 business days.?

Taking all of this into consideration, our verdict leans towards Printful as the winner in the fulfillment and shipping category. The platform provides more detailed information about their shipping and fulfillment process, giving you a clearer picture of what to expect.

Customer Support

Now, this battle is getting intense! Let’s see how the platforms compete against each other for customer support.

Printful starts off on a positive note by offering an onboarding session to all new users, completely free of charge.

This helps users start on the right foot. In addition, Printful's blog section is a great resource. B ut where Printful shines the most, is it’s 24*7 support. If you have any questions or concerns, you can reach out to Printful's customer support via phone, live chat, or email.

On the other hand, Printify provides a help center with informative articles covering various topics. These include topics like integrations, troubleshooting, products, payments, and mockup designs.

They also have a blog filled with helpful tips on marketing, design trends, and success stories. However, Printify doesn’t offer 24-hour live support. This can be a drawback for users who may need immediate assistance.

But this is not the end of the story. When it comes to customer support, it's important to consider user experiences and feedback too.

While Printful has a ton of positive reviews, there are mixed reactions regarding their customer support. Some users praise their responsiveness, while others claim that their customer support can be slow in addressing pressing questions.

Considering all these factors, we have come to a verdict - and that's a tie! Both Printful and Printify offer valuable customer support resources, including simple onboarding, informative blogs, and help centers. However, they also have their respective limitations. It ultimately comes down to personal preferences and experiences.

Overall Features

Let’s take a look at the overall features offered by Printful and Printify and uncover the unique aspects that make each platform stand out.

Both platforms enable ecommerce store owners to sell custom products, offering personalized and customizable items for sale on their online stores. Printful starts strong with its ecommerce photography service.

This is a rarity among other print-on-demand services. The platform has also got an amazing pricing calculator. This powerful tool helps you strike the right balance between profitability and competitiveness in the market.

On the other hand, Printify boasts a rich catalog of products, giving you a wide range of options to choose from. However, it falls short when it comes to design services.

Our verdict: in terms of overall features, the winner is Printful! Its organized structure, unique ecommerce photography service, and the game-changing pricing calculator give it an edge over Printify.

Product Designs & Quality

Next, let’s dive into the world of product designs and quality, a critical aspect that can make or break your print-on-demand business. To gather insights, we scrubbed the internet and collected user-generated reviews to help us assess the performance of the platforms. Here’s what we found.

Printful has shown a keen interest in staying up-to-date with winning product designs. They constantly hunt for fresh and trendy designs that resonate with customers. On the other hand, Printify seems to follow a more conventional approach.

When it comes to product quality, the feedback we gathered from users suggests that Printful ranks higher. Customers have praised the overall quality of their products. High product quality can significantly impact profit margins, as better quality often leads to higher customer satisfaction and repeat purchases.

This could be because Printful has made significant investments in printing machines, warehouses, and graphic designers. With such robust infrastructure in place, maintaining the quality of their products becomes more manageable.

On the flip side, some complaints have been raised regarding the print quality of Printify. Users have claimed that certain apparel products tend to fade and crack within a short period. It’s worth noting that Printify acts as a middleman, coordinating with various print providers. This may contribute to inconsistencies in product quality.

Taking these factors into account, our winner in the category of product quality and design is Printful!

Their commitment to sourcing winning designs and their investments in infrastructure have earned them a reputation for delivering products of higher quality.

For a more detailed analysis of both products, you can explore our comprehensive Printful vs Printify comparison available on the main Ecommerce-Platforms site.

Further Reading

• Printify Review
• Printful Review
• Best Print on Demand Companies

Final Verdict

After considering all the factors, it’s time for the final verdict in the Printful vs Printify comparison. And the winner is clear: it’s Printful.

While Printify may have some limitations in terms of integrations and print quality consistency, it remains a solid choice for those seeking a flexible and affordable print-on-demand solution for their online store.

Check out our video on Printful vs Printify