A practical application of translanguage in the ESL classroom
Co-teaching an ESL class. Printed with permission.

A practical application of translanguage in the ESL classroom

It is a well-known fact that the native/non-native English teacher debate is still apparent in education. There is a fair degree of conversation about how problematic the binary terminology is. The argument is recently explored in this interview S06Ε31 Teacher's Coffee with Penny Hands - YouTube

This past academic year, I had the privilege of working with co-teachers who are trilingual (fluent in Uzbek, Russian and English). The institution I work in hires international teachers, not only English first language speakers, I might add, for the purpose of creating modern, student-centred classrooms. And this is done in conjunction with a local teacher. The idea is that the international teacher brings a toolbag of student-centred learning where we encourage learners to be critical thinkers and risk takers. The whole idea is to help local teachers get used to modern teaching methods. In reality the local teacher has some clever ideas of (her) own to deliver knowledge in a way that is often fun and informative for students.

Translanguaging in the ESL classroom

No alt text provided for this image
CEFR B1 students translating video text from L1 (Uzbek) to L2 (English). Reprinted with permission.

Translanguaging (using more than one language to communicate and understand academic content) is something I promote as an ESL instructor. I actively encourage the co-teacher to use the L1 for translating terminology, new vocabulary and classroom management. Groupwork is almost always a matter of students using all their communicative resources to collaborate on a task. Recent statistics show that there are three times as many English second language speakers as there are English mother tongue speakers https://lemongrad.com/english-language-statistics/. My view is that the ESL classroom needs to be a space that honours that fact.

Pronunciation and correctness

The co-teachers I work with do not have target language pronunciation. I do not single out teachers whose pronunciation is *"fossilised", but as for the students, I do use the tried-and-tested CELTA techniques of drilling pronunciation. In truth, students are exposed to both standard English pronunciation and L2 pronunciation forms. IELTS tests still judge students on how closely they can produce L1 standard pronunciation. The IELTS exam is the benchmark for English proficiency where I am based, so students want to be IELTS-ready. Teacher language is a doubt that a lot of international teachers have. Personally, I have softened my view on teacher language. I attend international conferences where pronunciation is not standard L1, but this is the nature of English language today. You are going to come across different pronunciations. So students hear my pronunciation, and they hear the co-teacher pronunciation. This, I believe, is the strength of diversity.


* error that is a mistake, a habit that is difficult to change.


Gulmira Viker

a Delta-certified freelance online teacher

1 年

Love it, Shifa. And miss you as my coworker and cubicle neighbor.

Colin Michell, BA(Hons), MA

Doctoral student at the University of Exeter, forensic linguist, Communications instructor, EFL/ESL teacher, martial arts enthusiast

1 年

You're quite right about IELTS. When I examined in SA we had plenty of Afrikaans, black South Africans, and Nigerians who were at the 8 and 9 level but "head office" wanted them marked down because they didn't have the "right" accent/pronunciation.

What is a native English speaker, exactly? I remember a controversy in a college I worked in where one teacher, Turkish, said that another teacher, Scottish, should not be allowed to teach English because his spoken English was not good enough! :-)

Nicola Prentis ??

Teaching people in ELT how to make money doing (almost) nothing. ?? I create and run online courses about investing ?? and making your money work for you instead of the other way around.?? Investing ? Money ? Finance ?

1 年

Whenever I meet anyone no matter how proficient they are, they complain about their own pronunciation - a very hard self-doubt to overcome I am sure.

Jennie Reed

English Pronunciation Coach | English Language Consultant | Founder at Excellence in English Education | Co-Founder at True Voice English | Helping you feel proud of your English Communication Skills

1 年

Very interesting article, thanks Shifa Desai - I know a lot of English teachers I work with worry about their 'strong' accent, but in this world of global English, I don't feel it's a huge problem. Also, if our (younger) learners hear a mix of accents, it's going to help them become better communicators in whatever they end up doing in life. And at the end of the day, communication is the main reason we learn languages, isn't it?!

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Shifa Desai的更多文章

  • Competently incompetent

    Competently incompetent

    As a teacher educator I often have to observe teachers delivering English lessons. My interest perked today when I…

    2 条评论
  • Academic Coining

    Academic Coining

    This past weekend I had the privilege of being in two places at the same time. Such is the wonder of online conferences…

    3 条评论
  • We (don't) need to talk about G*za

    We (don't) need to talk about G*za

    I recently travelled to my home country, South Africa. In my neighbourhood there is so much visual representation of…

  • The clothes maketh the teacher

    The clothes maketh the teacher

    I'm inclined to comfort. That means I wear clothes in soft fabrics, non-confrontational tones and shoes that don't…

    8 条评论
  • Do educators need to challenge dangerous ideologies?

    Do educators need to challenge dangerous ideologies?

    Recently I watched Ordinary men: The Forgotten Holocaust on Netflix. The documentary focuses on how Nazi killing squads…

    7 条评论
  • When Gen X teachers retire

    When Gen X teachers retire

    This past summer break I had the opportunity to have a lunch reunion with former colleagues I used to work with in the…

    7 条评论
  • "What makes a great leader?" Gen Z responds ...

    "What makes a great leader?" Gen Z responds ...

    What do the following people have in common? Muammar Gaddafi, Vladimir Putin, Stalin, Hitler, Pablo Escobar? These are…

    6 条评论
  • Subject+verb+object and other lies I teach

    Subject+verb+object and other lies I teach

    I live in two worlds. My world of work is based around language, linguistics and communication.

    2 条评论
  • Help! I teach gifted students!

    Help! I teach gifted students!

    I’m a Gen Xer. My class of high school seniors are Gen Z.

    2 条评论
  • My tips for teaching the college essay

    My tips for teaching the college essay

    I teach high school senior students to write their personal statement and college essays. The fall semester is a…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了