The Power of Scarcity: Turning Perceived Shortages into Strength

Imagine you’re at a bakery, and there’s a sign that reads: “Last 3 cinnamon raisin bagels left!” Instantly, your desire for that cinnamon raisin bagel skyrockets—even if you weren’t particularly hungry (by the way, toasted with butter please). That’s scarcity in action. Our brains are wired to value things more when they feel limited, and this concept has profound implications for how we save, invest, and even conduct meetings.?

Let’s explore the psychology behind scarcity and how we can harness it to make better financial and professional decisions.?

?Scarcity and the Brain: Why We Crave What’s Limited?

Scarcity triggers a survival mechanism in our brains. When we perceive something as rare or fleeting, our decision-making becomes sharper—sometimes to our detriment. Research shows that scarcity can narrow focus and drive urgency. In financial terms, this can lead to both positive and negative outcomes.?

In their fabulous book, Mullainathan and Shafir (2013) discuss how scarcity creates a "tunneling" effect, where we fixate on immediate needs while neglecting long-term considerations. This can explain why people overspend during a sale or fail to save for retirement in favor of present-day expenses.?

?Scarcity in Saving and Investing?

1. The Fear of Missing Out (FOMO): Scarcity often drives impulsive investment decisions, like chasing hot stocks or speculative assets. The perception that an opportunity is rare can override rational analysis.?

Investors often jump into stocks and currencies (without full knowledge of what they are investing or disregarding their own financial status and goals), driven by the belief that it was a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.?

2. The Power of Limited-Time Offers: Scarcity can be a helpful motivator in saving strategies. For instance, time-limited bonuses for contributions to retirement accounts or high-yield savings accounts can nudge people to take action.?

3. Behavioral Traps in Saving: The "I'll save more later" mindset stems from not viewing time as a scarce resource. Behavioral economists emphasize the importance of making savings automatic to overcome this procrastination.?

?Scarcity in Meetings and Time Management?

?Scarcity doesn’t only influence financial decisions—it also plays a role in how we value time. If meetings feel endless and unproductive, participants often disengage. But when meetings are framed as limited, with strict time constraints and high stakes, they become more focused and impactful.?Schedule shorter meetings with clear agendas. A 25-minute meeting with a specific goal often produces better results than a meandering hour-long session.?Living in a video conference world, advisors and team leaders can schedule short meetings with one singular objective and move on! Fabulous approach and wastes little time!

?5 Ways to Harness Scarcity to Your Advantage?

1. Create Artificial Scarcity to Save: Use apps or bank accounts that lock away savings for specific purposes. Knowing you “can’t touch” those funds makes you less likely to spend them impulsively.?

2. Limit Choices in Investing: Reduce decision fatigue by narrowing your focus to a few well-researched investment options. Overchoice often leads to inaction or poor decisions.? Choice architecture...oh, we did this in a previous newsletter.

?3. Use Deadlines Effectively: Set deadlines for financial goals, such as saving for a vacation or reaching an emergency fund target. Deadlines create a sense of urgency, especially when you revisit those goals and set deadlines. Advisors can really show their value here!

4. Focus on Time Scarcity in Meetings: Meetings often progress more quickly as time becomes scarce, such as near the end of a scheduled session. This phenomenon, known as the "deadline effect," occurs because participants prioritize key decisions when they sense time is running out. For example, teams often complete up to 80% of their work in the final 20% of the allocated time (Gersick, 1988).

5. Reframe Scarcity as Opportunity: View limited resources as a chance to prioritize what matters most. For example, if funds are tight, allocate them toward high-impact goals like paying down high-interest debt or investing in education.?

Scarcity is a double-edged sword. While it can drive poor decisions when left unchecked, it’s also a powerful tool for motivation and prioritization when used intentionally. By understanding its psychological impact, we can channel the urgency it creates into achieving financial and professional success.?

Now, back to that bagel!

To learn more about my work, explore our programs, or schedule a demo of MRI? for yourself or your firm, email me directly at [email protected].

Citations

Gersick, C. J. G. (1988). Time and transition in work teams: Toward a new model of group development. Academy of Management Journal, 31(1), 9–41. https://doi.org/10.2307/256496

Mullainathan, S., & Shafir, E. (2013). Scarcity: Why Having Too Little Means So Much. Times Books.?

Shefrin, H. M., & Thaler, R. H. (1988). The Behavioral Life-Cycle Hypothesis. Economic Inquiry, 26(4), 609-643.?

?