The Power of Card Sorting: Organizing Content for Better Usability

I guess you guys are expecting to learn something really interesting today! Well, you’re in for a treat. Let’s imagine a scenario where,

You give your users a set of sticky notes; every sticky note represents some part of your website or application. Then, you instruct your users to put these notes in an order of their choice. It’s like letting them play a real-life puzzle where they design the flow! This simple, yet insightful activity helps you understand how your users think, categorize, and navigate information!

Excited to make the user experience even better? Let’s dive into card sorting! ??

I’ll walk you through step-by-step techniques and tips to enhance user experience using card sorting. ????

Card sorting is a technique for helping designers understand how people think in terms of grouping and labeling any form of information.

Why Card Sorting Matters ?

• Deep User Insights: Card sorting uncovers how users mentally categorize and label content, revealing their natural thought processes and preferences.
• Enhanced Information Architecture (IA): It directly informs how to structure content in a way that aligns with users’ mental models, making navigation smoother and more intuitive.
• User-Centered Design: The method ensures that design choices, particularly in layout and organization, meet user expectations, leading to a more satisfying user experience.

Key Components of Card Sorting ??

• Participants: Real users who bring authentic insights.
• Cards: Represent core items or concepts to be sorted.
• Categories: User-defined or pre-existing groups that organize content.
• Analysis: Insights drawn from users’ sorting behavior inform strategic design decisions, ensuring a logical, user-driven structure.

Most Common Types of Card Sortings ???

1. Open Card Sorting: A Deep Dive

Open card sorting allows participants to freely group and categorize items based on their own understanding, which offers invaluable insights into how users naturally structure information. By not pre-defining categories, this method:

Use When: You’re in the early stages of development, exploring how users think and want to organize information. It’s ideal when there’s no predefined structure.

• Encourages Creativity: Users create categories based on their thought process, offering fresh perspectives.
• Uncovers Mental Models: You can deeply understand how users perceive relationships between elements.
• Informs Design Decisions: Helps shape an intuitive user experience by reflecting how users naturally think and navigate content.

2. Closed Card Sorting: Testing Predefined Structures

Here participants organize items into categories that are already established. It helps when you want to validate an existing structure.

Use When: You have a structured system and want to validate if it resonates with users.

• Structured: Tests how well users understand and use your predefined categories.
• Efficient: Easier to analyze, as participants work within set categories.
• Validation: Confirms whether the current organization matches user expectations, ensuring the system meets their needs.

3. Hybrid Card Sorting: Combining Exploration and Validation

It merges both open and closed methods. Participants first create their categories (open sorting), and then map those into predefined ones (closed sorting).

Use When: You’re refining existing categories while exploring new ideas. It offers both discovery and validation.

• Balanced: Provides insights into user-driven categories while validating existing ones.
• Refinement: Improves and adjusts current structures based on user input.
• Comprehensive: Delivers a holistic view of how users naturally group and interpret information, balancing discovery with testing.

For the Better Understanding of Hybrid Card Sorting, here I’m dropping a statement,

“ I use hybrid card sorting to map all the content of the website. First, I ask users and stakeholders to group the content into categories, and then I get the participants to name or create their own categories.

— Vaida Pakulyte , UX Researcher and Designer at Electrolux

Great! We already know the types and how or when to use them…??

Let’s Consider a Real-Life Scenario: Our Task is to Enhance an E-commerce Website’s Navigation with Card Sorting

Steps to Conduct Card Sorting ??

1. Prepare Cards: For an e-commerce site redesign, create cards for products, categories, or features like “Checkout” or “Wishlist.”
2. Select Participants: Choose a mix of regular and new users who reflect your customer base.
3. Conduct the Session: Facilitate an online session where users group items intuitively.
4. Analyze Results: Identify common patterns, like users grouping “Sales” and “Discounts” together.
5. Implement Findings: Use insights to create easy-to-navigate categories on your site.

Task Objective:

--- To enhance an e-commerce website’s usability and navigation by refining product categorization through card sorting.

Preparation:

• Create Cards: Write product names on individual cards (such as: Smartphones, Sofas).
• Select Participants: Recruit 10–15 users that reflect the target audience.

Open Card Sorting:

• Session: Allow participants to group products based on their logic.
• Labeling: Let them name the categories they create.

Closed Card Sorting:

• Predefined Categories: Provide categories like “Electronics,” “Clothing,” etc.
• Task: Ask participants to sort products into these predefined categories.

Analysis:

• Compare: Identify patterns from both the open and closed card sorting.
• Alignment: Check how closely the user-created groups match predefined categories.

Implementation:

• Adjust Navigation: Reorganize the website’s product categories according to the insights.
• Test: Conduct further usability testing to confirm the effectiveness of the new structure.

Possible Outcome:

By using card sorting, you will be able to build a more user-friendly and intuitive navigation system, where the users can easily find the products that they’re looking for, therefore enhancing their experience.

Note: This is a demo example to explain the card sorting process, but now that you understand it, hopefully you can apply it to your own projects to refine information architecture and user navigation!

#sabbir10r #cardsorting #uxresearch #ux #informationresearch #userfeedback #producdesign