Power BI Desktop vs. Power BI Service

My PowerBI Course.

Comparison between Power BI Desktop and Power BI Service, highlighting their key differences, features, and use cases:

1. Definition

• Power BI Desktop: A free, on-premise application used to create reports and data models on a local machine.
• Power BI Service: A cloud-based platform (SaaS) used for publishing, sharing, and consuming reports and dashboards via a web browser.

2. Main Purpose

• Power BI Desktop: Primarily used for building, developing, and authoring reports. It’s the tool where users import data, transform it, and create visualizations and models.
• Power BI Service: Mainly used for publishing, sharing, collaborating, and consuming reports. It allows users to view and interact with reports and dashboards on the web.

3. Cost

• Power BI Desktop: Completely free to download and use.
• Power BI Service: Has both free and paid (Pro/Premium) versions. The free version allows basic access to personal reports, while Pro and Premium versions offer sharing and collaboration features.

4. Data Connections and Import

• Power BI Desktop: Supports a wide range of data sources, including files (Excel, CSV), databases (SQL Server, Oracle), online services (SharePoint, Salesforce), and APIs. It's the tool used to import, transform, and model data before visualizing it.
• Power BI Service: Allows limited live data connections to specific sources (such as DirectQuery and live connections), but generally relies on reports created in Power BI Desktop for more extensive data modeling.

5. Data Modeling and DAX

• Power BI Desktop: Has powerful data modeling capabilities where users can clean, transform, and shape data using Power Query. It also allows the creation of calculated columns, measures, and relationships between tables using DAX.
• Power BI Service: Does not allow deep data modeling or advanced transformation. It’s mainly for viewing and interacting with already-developed models and reports. Some light modification of datasets is possible in Premium workspaces.

6. Sharing and Collaboration

• Power BI Desktop: No native sharing capabilities. Reports need to be saved and manually shared via files, or published to Power BI Service.
• Power BI Service: Built for sharing and collaboration. Users can share dashboards and reports with others within the organization or with external users (using Power BI Pro or Premium). It also supports version control, comments, and collaboration.

7. Real-Time Dashboards

• Power BI Desktop: No native support for real-time updates or streaming datasets.
• Power BI Service: Supports real-time dashboards by integrating with live data streams (e.g., IoT or social media feeds). Users can create streaming datasets that push data directly to dashboards.

8. Refreshing Data

• Power BI Desktop: Data refresh is manual. Users need to re-import data and refresh reports.
• Power BI Service: Offers scheduled refreshes, allowing datasets to be updated at regular intervals. Pro and Premium users can schedule up to 8-48 refreshes per day.

9. Report and Dashboard Types

• Power BI Desktop: Primarily used for building detailed reports with multiple pages and interactive visuals.
• Power BI Service: Allows the creation of dashboards, which are single-page summaries of visuals from different reports. It also lets users pin visuals from multiple reports for a high-level overview.

10. Row-Level Security (RLS)

• Power BI Desktop: Allows the definition of Row-Level Security (RLS) roles during the development process.
• Power BI Service: Enforces RLS roles set up in Power BI Desktop and allows administrators to manage security and access for users.

11. Integration with Other Services

• Power BI Desktop: Does not have direct integrations for sharing reports but allows exporting to PDF and PPT.
• Power BI Service: Integrates with Microsoft Teams, SharePoint, and Power Automate for seamless collaboration, report sharing, and automation workflows.

12. Mobile Access

• Power BI Desktop: Only available on Windows desktop; there is no mobile app for it.
• Power BI Service: Provides access through the Power BI mobile app (available for iOS, Android, and Windows), allowing users to view and interact with dashboards on the go.

13. Premium Features

• Power BI Desktop: Does not offer Premium-specific features like larger dataset limits or AI-driven functionalities.
• Power BI Service: Offers Power BI Premium features like Paginated Reports, AI visuals, Dataflows, and the ability to handle large datasets (beyond 1 GB) with advanced collaboration features.

Use Cases

• Power BI Desktop:Ideal for individual report authors and developers who need to build, transform, and model data before sharing.Useful for businesses that need to create detailed ad-hoc reports locally.Best suited for creating reports that require complex data transformations.
• Power BI Service:Perfect for teams and enterprises needing to share and collaborate on reports.Best for real-time monitoring, cloud-based access, and distributed reporting.Suitable for businesses that need a centralized platform to distribute, refresh, and manage reports.

Join My PowerBI Group.