POSITIVE INDICATORS ARE BLINKING FOR CEASEFIRE SUCCESS.ISRAEL’S THREAT OF OFFENSIVE AGAINST RAFAH IS BEING USED AS STRONG BARGAINING CHIP ?
Col (R) Hassan Yousuf
Trainer Futurology, Smart Management & IT / Digi Tech at Pakistan Institute of Management
KEY POINTS
1 .?Worthy audience amid extreme public pressure from international community ,youth of USA /Israel, facing acute diplomatic pressure of trial of Natanyahu before International Court of Justice over genocide in Gaza , Military leadership reluctance to continue atrocities & insistence over getting PWs released by Hamas as well as under very heavy clashes b/w Hezbollah (from Lebanon),the ?US State Secretary Antony Blinken is set to embark on his visit to?Saudi Arabia ?on April 29 to meet with regional partners.linken, ?on his two-day visit to Saudi Arabia, will discuss ongoing efforts to achieve a?ceasefire ?in?Gaza ?that secures the release of?hostages ?and "how it is?Hamas ?that is standing between the Palestinian people and a ceasefire," the US State Department said in a release. Moreover, the State Secretary will also discuss the recent increase in humanitarian assistance being delivered to Gaza and note the importance of ensuring that increase is sustained. At the two-day Special Meeting, Riyadh will convene more than 1,000 global leaders, including heads of state, government, and thought leaders from across the public and private sectors, as well as international organizations, academic institutions, and non-governmental organizations (NGOs), to address today's most pressing global development challenges CNN reported that last week, after months of delay, the Senate successfully passed a USD 95 billion package aimed at providing aid to Ukraine, Israel, and Taiwan,.
领英推荐
?2 .Ladies & gentlemen this time the question is why there appears to be greater optimism about the prospect of a truce and what could an agreement look like? Folks as you see there has been a recent flurry of activity around the talks, with an uptick of optimism about progress. According to Axios’s Barak Ravid, the Israeli proposal is for a potential deal with Hamas for a ceasefire in exchange for the release of hostages and talks over the “restoration of sustainable calm” in Gaza. In recent days Hamas has also broadcast several proof-of-life videos of hostages who might be expected to be exchanged at some point during in a deal, which could increase domestic political pressure on Israel, where the issue of the hostages’ return is a potent issue.The language is instructive. “Sustainable calm” suggests a solution somewhat short of the “total victory” repeatedly touted by the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, who has vowed to dismantle Hamas. Intriguingly it also mirrors a suggestion for a truce from a senior Hamas official, Khalil al-Hayya, last week who floated the idea of hudna,?a word used in Islamic jurisprudence to describe a kind of long-term truce or “calm”.However the messaging coming out of the talks has been very contradictory. While the Qataris, who represent one mediation route, have talked publicly about their frustration over stalled talks, there has been more activity in recent days around Egyptian-Israeli talks – a forum that has delivered ceasefires in previous conflicts. A senior Israeli official told Hebrew media that talks with the Egyptians were “very good, focused, held in good spirits and progressed in all parameters”. The position of the US, which has been pushing for a ceasefire deal, is that there is a good deal on the table, with the onus on Hamas to budge. With Hamas saying it is looking at the new Israeli offer, reports in the Israeli media on Sunday indicated recent meetings of the Israeli security cabinet suggested a more “flexible” position. The US secretary of state, Antony Blinken, is also expected to visit Israel in the coming days to discuss the negotiations.
3 .Worthy audience if we wish to know what is on the table,the answer is the essential shape of any deal hasn’t changed that much. It would be presented as a “humanitarian ceasefire”. At the heart of talks is a ceasefire-for-hostages arrangement. Hamas would release hostages in exchange for a ceasefire lasting weeks and the release of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails. The talks have stalled around both major issues – Hamas’s maximalist demand that Israeli troops withdraw from?Gaza ?and end the conflict – and granular detail, not least about numbers and which Palestinian prisoners should be released.The current formula would apparently allow the release of a slightly smaller number of hostages, 33 sick, elderly and wounded – representing the number of surviving hostages in the humanitarian category – in exchange for unspecified numbers of Palestinian prisoners.What is unclear is what the release of the humanitarian hostages would mean for those in other groups, including captive soldiers.There are also suggestions that the conversation in Israeli security circles may have moved from the destruction of the last four largely intact Hamas battalions in Rafah to whether closing the Hamas arms-smuggling routes from Egypt would achieve the same long-term objective, requiring a new agreement with Egypt over control of – and monitoring of – the so-called Philadelphi route on the border.
4 .Inference .Worthy audience speaking to Haaretz, a senior Qatari official accused both sides of sabotaging the process each time they came close to a deal.We have been here before, and there is a lot of cynicism in the positioning on both sides. Both Israel and Hamas will be maneuvering to be able to suggest the other side is responsible for any failure in the current ceasefire talks.However there seems to be some genuine movement for now, although the devil is in the detail, not least over which Palestinian prisoners would be released. While the dynamics on the Hamas side remain largely opaque, not least around the position of the leader of Hamas in Gaza, Yahya Sinwar, Netanyahu’s difficulties with his own coalition remain in evidence. Far-right coalition partners, including Itamar Ben-Gvir, remain opposed to any deal. However, a recent uptick in public support for Netanyahu, and drop in support for the senior cabinet ember Benny Gantz, may have taken some of the pressure off him. Therefore the bottom line is ,this time the talks are in good faith?
?
?