The Poppy Question

The Poppy Question

This is the US cemetery at St-Laurent-sur-Mer, which stands above Omaha beach on the Normandy coast and in which are buried over 9,000 servicemen. Visiting it is a sobering experience and you need to give yourself time to slow down and get in tune with the enormity of the allied invasion of the continent and, by extension, the Second World War itself. Visitors often report that it is the reading the names of the young men lost that hits the heart the hardest, for me it was the towns and places from where they came, the cities and rural communities that would never get to see how the children they had cherished would mature and take up their role in the communities in which they were raised.

The visit also ushered memories of my own youthful days, when I was not much younger than the fallen buried here. As Scouts we would parade through the village every November to commemorate the fallen of the two world wars (no mention was made of any other) and it was considered an honour to carry the flag, one that I eventually attained in my final year in the troop. But that is not why I remember those cold and often wet days as we shivered around the war memorial, no, it was the older men that came along and stood stiffly in the wind, their heads often bowed towards their medals as they silently cried.

We were just kids, we didn't understand back then, maybe we do now, I hope so anyway. We had spent our early years being told not to cry, it's only sissies that cry, grown men don't cry, yet here they were, crying. These were the very people we had been brought up to respect, they had been held up as examples for us to model our lives upon, and in a way we did. In fact, looking back, that respect has only grown as I think of those that attended to our upbringing in the sixties and seventies. Many of them had fought in the second conflict and had seen the horrors close up, lost their friends and known the terror of battle. Those that had come through were wiser for it, they were slow to judge or condemn, they respected the society that they had fought to preserve and we as youngsters could only be influenced by the environment of tolerance they exuded and for many years I wore the poppy as an act of gratitude and remembrance to those that had died.

Do I wear one now? An emphatic NO. There are many reasons for this and I am glad to see the debate raised and discussed in the media and beyond with what might be termed the establishment insisting that all should do as all right thinking people should do and that is wear the symbol in every moment of the day. To me that is the sort of nationalistic pride and coercion that the old soldiers fought to defeat, it was part of their enemies character, it had brought the pain and misery of war upon civilisation in the first place and had no position in the world which they had saved from fascism and foreign rule.

Today the poppy is, in the Royal British Legions own words, a " brand", a logo to be sold and pushed upon the public, tugging at their conscience with the sort of power that few other campaigns can match. Is this what earlier generations really fought for? They died for freedom and that freedom must encompass whatever the Legion choose to do, just as it must allow the rest us the liberty to remember our heroes in the way we feel most appropriate. Succumbing to the arrogance of the marketeers is not the way I wish to do so and the subliminal bullying that goes with it has no place in any sort of community that I would admire, and I doubt they would either.

This week I shall remember those who gave so much so that the following generations had so little need to know of war. My gratitude is not that as ordained by a group of well paid PR honchos round at the Legions HQ, but instead it is as deeply felt and sincere as the tears that rolled down those cheeks on the cold autumnal days of just a few short decades ago.

Timothy Balding

Author, humanist. Out now, 'The Spectator', a contemporary social novel on the poisoning of a nation's psyche by tabloid media.

8 年

The poppy is a noble, moving, poetic symbol for the fallen in war. Ask those still living who mourn their dead comrades. To pour abuse on this almost centenial tradition, as in this senseless article, is beyond comprehension. The origin of the symbol, for those who are interested, is a poem by a Canadian soldier, 'In Flanders Fields'.

Geetha S.

Business Consultant, Researcher in Geopolitical Risks, Media, Public Health Issues (Columbia),Consumer Law (Sorbonne). Conflict Resolution (Harvard).Independent Evaluator for EU global development projects.

8 年

It is true that the association of poppies flowering in the battlefields of France, Belgium, Gallipoli and elsewhere in the spring of 1915 is synonmous with the great loss of life in war. The devastation had made many foundations to use this 'Memorial flower' to raise support for those in need of help, especially veterans and civilians suffering from physical and mental hardship as a result of war. There is always a special place everywhere, that is in most of the towns and cities in Europe and nations abroad that fought, to honor these galant men and women. These fragile red flowers are a tangible symbol of honor just like national medals. Gratitude, or thankfulness does not need embellishment, it comes from a simple expression from genuine heart within.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Justin Roberts的更多文章

  • We are but mice in the grand scheme of climate change

    We are but mice in the grand scheme of climate change

    Does the climate change? Well of course it does nobody denies it, the contention is how much of the constant churn in…

    3 条评论
  • The Trouble with Volkswagen

    The Trouble with Volkswagen

    We have been hearing a lot about Volkswagen of late, mainly from the company itself . Most of the puffery surrounds its…

    13 条评论
  • A few casual deaths won't stop Ireland testing Autonomous Vehicles it seems.

    A few casual deaths won't stop Ireland testing Autonomous Vehicles it seems.

    Last week there was a cosy little conference Dublin where various speakers from the autonomous vehicle lobby got up and…

    6 条评论
  • Two Good Reasons Why Driverless Cars Are A Bad Bad Thing.

    Two Good Reasons Why Driverless Cars Are A Bad Bad Thing.

    First up is snow. Yes, the white stuff that falls from the skies and lies on roads making it difficult, but not always…

    2 条评论
  • The Hopeless Hype Behind AV's.

    The Hopeless Hype Behind AV's.

    I have been a critic of autonomous vehicles for some time now and their supporters are probably (hopefully) sick of my…

    31 条评论
  • Paris In Spring Can Mean Only One Thing.

    Paris In Spring Can Mean Only One Thing.

    Yes that's right, SIMA, or France's premier agricultural show. Purists might argue that the end of February isn't quite…

  • Brexit, an analogy

    Brexit, an analogy

    The arguments over Brexit have been raging over a year now with both sides claiming the ultimate expertise so I found…

  • A life less weird is hardly worth living.

    A life less weird is hardly worth living.

    This is Fidelle, a horse we kept for a while, I don't say owned for although we paid money to bring her into our lives…

  • Images from the ploughing.

    Images from the ploughing.

    Nearly a month after Ireland's premier agricultural show I have at last got round to sifting through the images and…

  • The Zen of Monochrome.

    The Zen of Monochrome.

    A scene from time, it could be any time, a cafe and band are not just of today neither are friends and companions…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了