Polarity & Flourishing

Polarity & Flourishing

This week, I want to discuss polarity. It has been bothering me for a while, and I see it everywhere in our society. It has the potential to undo any attempts for humanity to flourish, and is causing endless strife and conflict in our world today. You don't have to look far to find it.

By polarity, I mean taking sides to the detriment of listening, learning, and understanding.

Whether it is the traditional polarity of the political left and right, or our inability to see something from another angle, it lurks everywhere in our lives. Humanity has lost the ability to hold two opposing points of view.

Back when I was in school, we were taught to debate. When you went into a debate, you never knew whether you would be pro or con to a topic but, regardless, you had to be able to argue the contrarian view. In this day and age, though, we take a stand, stick to it, and lock into our beliefs and opinions without even exploring or seeking to understand the other side.

People are becoming entrenched in their viewpoints to the extent that they are euphemistically willing to go to war for their stance. Rational thought has given way to passionate beliefs. In this battle of opinions, the truth is the real victim. It may be fuelled by the reality that truth is seen as fleeting, and that facts are manipulated through conjecture or possibility.

In the past, I have written missives about the loss of truth in favour of what we believe is right. What may have been a "truth" in the past is questioned because I couldn't experience, or haven’t experienced, it myself, so it can't be true. I may believe that man didn't land on the moon because I didn't see it or because I don't see the earth's curvature on the prairie, so the world must be flat.

The proliferation of information has muddied the waters. I can seemingly find a fact to prove my point from anywhere. Social media is also a culprit, as confirmation bias via algorithms reinforces what I like and presents seemingly supportive and affirming information back to me. When this happens, the polarity of what I like leads me to hate the other side, and the proliferation of hate has become the byproduct of it.

By sticking to our beliefs, we choose an easy way out of not thinking and challenging our thoughts and those of others. By choosing not to select one pole over another, our neutrality sets the stage for hate to grow.

In the age of inclusion, there is a paradox when we allow ourselves to fall into one camp or another. We do not include others' views when we entrench on one side. We become exclusionary, which reinforces hate.

For our world to flourish, we need to address this polarity. To address it, we need to open ourselves up to possibility. We must move from judgement to exploration. We must remember that there are always two sides to an argument, and there is never only one cause for an event.?

We also need to stop listening to those who would divide us and, instead, find those who will heal us by showing us that there are other ways to see things. This is done by questioning and challenging what we see daily and asking, "How else might this be seen?" It requires moving from the emotional state to the cognitive state.

This shift in thinking takes work, but the cost of locking into a polarity will be far more costly than the effort to see other ways. Yes, you won't get likes on social media for taking a contrarian or middle-road view, but you will have lived a better life.

So, try it: explore the contrarian view of your own beliefs and see if that helps you better understand others.

The way I see it, there is an element of arrogance. I don’t think there is anything inherently arrogant about thinking you are right, even about important things. In fact, it is probably impossible to believe something is true and not think you are right about it. But arrogance comes into play when you try to assert something beyond what your reason can support or reject or belittle the other side as being wrong just based on your own stance. There’s a lot of literature that says “being right” is fundamentally incapable of existing with “the truth”. The word “right” itself implies that there is an opposing stance to “be right” against (that must, therefore, be “wrong”). But, the person on the other side holds that similar belief. So how can you reconcile that both are “right”? It comes back to arrogance. When you attempt to be right, you are inserting your ego into your argument. You can never argue from a state of complete neutrality. When you start to debate, you’re now fighting using ego, not truth, in your search to come out on top and win the argument. “The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function” ~F. Scott Fitzgerald

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Julian Chapman的更多文章

  • Stepping Up (As a Managerial Leader)

    Stepping Up (As a Managerial Leader)

    Many thanks to all who reached out after last week’s missive. The idea that we live in unprecedentedly discombobulating…

    2 条评论
  • The Comfort of Control

    The Comfort of Control

    If you are like me, the beginning of 2025 has been bewildering. There was uncertainty at the very beginning certainly…

    2 条评论
  • Dealing with Bureaucracy

    Dealing with Bureaucracy

    This is the last week in my ongoing series of missives on bureaucracy. I wanted to highlight bureaucracy not just…

    1 条评论
  • The Costs of Bureaucracy

    The Costs of Bureaucracy

    This week, I am continuing my ongoing series of missives on bureaucracy with a discussion of its impact on…

  • Ballooning Structures

    Ballooning Structures

    Last week, I explored the causes of bureaucracy and it raised several questions, so, I thought I would continue with a…

  • Bureaucracy

    Bureaucracy

    There is much talk these days about bureaucracy. So, for this week and the next few, I will focus on bureaucracy: what…

  • Delegation

    Delegation

    Last week's missive received considerable attention. The issue of working at a level resonated.

    1 条评论
  • Working at Level

    Working at Level

    For this week's managing the maelstrom, I am returning to a topic from three years ago as a reminder for myself and…

    2 条评论
  • New Year Reflection

    New Year Reflection

    Welcome to 2025. This is just about the fifth year of Managing the Maelstrom, which started on the eve of the shutdown…

  • Leader Self-Care (and Happy Holidays)

    Leader Self-Care (and Happy Holidays)

    This week’s Managing the Maelstrom will continue the theme of accountability and responsibility but from a unique…

社区洞察