The Playbook to Hiring a Team in India: Subsidiaries, Contractors, EOR, and Outsourcing

India is a booming destination for global talent, offering a rich pool of skilled professionals across industries like technology, engineering, and business services. With its large, dynamic workforce, companies across the world are increasingly looking at India to expand their teams and establish operations. However, tapping into this market requires careful consideration of the hiring models available, as each option presents unique benefits and challenges.

Whether you’re looking to build a local team for product development, customer support, or a hybrid structure, you broadly have four major pathways to evaluate: establishing your own subsidiary, using an Employer of Record (EOR) platform, hiring contractors, or outsourcing your needs to a development agency. Each of these options brings different strategic advantages depending on your operational goals, the level of control you want over your team, and your financial and legal considerations.

We’ll walk through the pros and cons of each method to help you decide the best approach for building your team in India.

1. Forming a Subsidiary in India: The Traditional Approach

Pros of Establishing a Subsidiary:

The most comprehensive option, establishing a subsidiary gives you a direct, full-fledged presence in India. It enables you to brand your local entity, build strong ties with employees, and maintain complete control over day-to-day operations. This model is ideal for companies looking to hire large teams (usually over 100 employees) and seeking a long-term presence in the country. Here are some key benefits:

1. Brand Visibility: Having your own subsidiary strengthens your brand in India, allowing employees and partners to connect directly with your brand name. This is critical in industries where brand reputation plays a major role in talent acquisition.
2. Employee Retention: Employees feel more integrated and secure when employed directly by the company. The sense of ownership that comes from being part of a company's legal entity increases their loyalty and engagement.
3. Simpler Stock Option Plans: For companies that plan to offer stock options or other forms of equity compensation to Indian employees, a subsidiary structure simplifies the process. Under the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA), issuing stock options becomes easier with a direct subsidiary.

Cons of Establishing a Subsidiary:

However, establishing a subsidiary in India can be time-consuming and expensive. Here’s why:

1. Complex Legal Setup: To establish a subsidiary, you need a detailed understanding of Indian laws and compliance regulations. These include taxes, labor laws, corporate governance, and Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) rules.
2. Long Setup Process: It can take anywhere from 6 to 18 months to fully establish an Indian subsidiary. This timeframe can delay the onboarding of your first employees by a significant period, which might not align with your business goals.
3. High Operational Costs: Running a subsidiary comes with ongoing costs, including managing the local office, maintaining tax compliance, and handling payroll. Additionally, Indian laws mandate transfer pricing rules, meaning any inter-company transactions (such as between your Indian subsidiary and your US-based parent company) must be profitable, and you will be subject to corporate tax on the markup.
4. Challenging Exit: Exiting the market can be equally time-consuming, taking anywhere from 12 to 60 months. Common exit timelines range between 3 to 4 years. Therefore, it's important to consider long-term commitment before establishing a subsidiary.

This option is best suited for companies with substantial hiring requirements and those seeking to establish a direct presence in India for the long term.

2. Employer of Record (EOR) Platform: Fast and Flexible

An Employer of Record (EOR) solution is a fast-growing alternative to subsidiaries and is gaining popularity due to its flexibility and ease of use. An EOR platform, like Rapid or Deel, allows companies to hire employees in India without the need to establish a local legal entity. The EOR partner takes care of all compliance, payroll, taxes, and employee benefits, while the employees work for you just as they would under a traditional model.

Pros of EOR Platforms:

1. Quick Onboarding: One of the major advantages of the EOR model is speed. You can hire and onboard employees in India in a matter of days, rather than months.
2. No Need for Local Legal Knowledge: The EOR provider handles all aspects of compliance, labor laws, and taxes, which saves your internal legal team from the burden of managing complex local laws.
3. Cost Efficiency: There is no need to worry about corporate tax or transfer pricing since the EOR partner manages the payroll. You only need to pay for the actual employee costs plus a management fee to the EOR provider.
4. Zero Employee Liabilities: All employee-related liabilities, including compliance with local labor laws and social security contributions, are borne by the EOR partner. This gives you peace of mind, knowing that you are not responsible for any unforeseen employee-related issues.
5. Full Control of IP and Processes: While the EOR handles the administrative side of things, you retain control over all day-to-day operations, intellectual property, and data protection processes.

Cons of EOR Platforms:

1. Higher Ongoing Costs: While EOR models eliminate the need for setting up a subsidiary, they often come with recurring management fees. Over time, this can add up, especially for companies looking to scale beyond a handful of employees.
2. Limited Employee Loyalty: Employees may feel less connected to the company if they are on the payroll of a third-party entity. Although EOR platforms are evolving and offering better customization options, such as branding and policies, there may still be a perception gap for employees not directly hired by the company.

The EOR model is best suited for companies looking to hire small to medium-sized teams in India, with the flexibility to scale up or down quickly. It’s ideal for businesses seeking a fast market entry without the commitment of establishing a legal entity.

3. Hiring Contractors or Consultants: A Flexible Alternative

Hiring contractors or consultants is a more flexible alternative for companies that want to avoid long-term commitments or those with project-based needs. This option allows you to hire talent on a temporary basis, often through freelancing platforms or direct contracts.

Pros of Hiring Contractors:

1. Low Commitment: Contractors allow for flexibility without the long-term commitment of full-time employment. You can hire people for a specific project or timeframe and terminate the contract when the job is complete.
2. Cost Savings: Contractors don’t require the company to provide benefits such as health insurance, paid leave, or provident fund contributions. This can reduce your overall costs significantly.

Cons of Hiring Contractors:

1. Limited Availability: Most skilled professionals in India prefer full-time employment due to the benefits and job security it offers. As a result, the pool of high-quality contractors may be limited, and finding the right talent can be challenging.
2. Permanent Establishment Risk: When hiring full-time contractors, you may run the risk of triggering “Permanent Establishment” (PE) status in India. If the Indian tax authorities determine that your contractors are essentially functioning as employees, your global profits could be subject to Indian taxes.
3. Contractor Misclassification: Misclassifying full-time workers as contractors can lead to legal risks. If a contractor decides to sue for employment benefits that were denied to them, there is a high chance that Indian courts will rule in their favor. This could lead to hefty fines and back payments.
4. Lower Employee Engagement: Contractors are generally less connected to the company and its culture. They may not be as loyal or invested in your long-term success compared to full-time employees.

This option works best for short-term or highly specialized projects where flexibility is key, but companies should be cautious of the legal and operational risks involved.

4. Outsourcing to a Development Agency: Costly but Effective

Another popular model, especially in the tech industry, is outsourcing your needs to a development agency or a software service provider in India. Agencies can provide a fully functional team that works on a specific project or deliverable, under the management of the agency itself.

Pros of Outsourcing to an Agency:

1. Immediate Access to Talent: Outsourcing agencies offer immediate access to pre-vetted teams with specific skills. This is particularly useful if you have a defined project scope or a tight deadline to meet.
2. Less Administrative Burden: You don’t have to worry about hiring, managing payroll, or dealing with compliance, as the agency takes care of all these aspects.

Cons of Outsourcing to an Agency:

1. Limited Control Over the Team: When outsourcing to an agency, you have less direct control over the team’s daily activities, processes, and performance. While you can monitor the scope of work and deliverables, you lose the ability to shape the working methods and culture.
2. Expensive: Outsourcing comes at a premium, as agencies often charge a markup for their services. For long-term or complex projects, this cost can become prohibitive.
3. Short-Term Focus: Outsourcing agencies are often better suited for short-term or one-off projects. If your goal is to build a long-term team in India, this may not be the best option.

Outsourcing is ideal for businesses with short-term projects, specific deliverables, or a need for niche technical expertise. However, for companies looking for a long-term commitment or deeper integration, this model might not be sustainable.

Choosing the Right Model

Each of these hiring models—setting up a subsidiary, using an EOR, hiring contractors, or outsourcing to an agency—comes with its own set of advantages and drawbacks. Choosing the right option depends largely on your company’s size, goals, and the level of control you want over your Indian operations.

• If you’re looking for long-term presence and deep brand visibility, forming a subsidiary is the right path but be prepared for a lengthy and costly setup process.
• If you need speed, flexibility, and scalability, EOR platforms offer a strong balance of compliance and operational efficiency.
• For short-term or project-based work, hiring contractors or outsourcing to an agency can be a cost-effective solution.

By carefully weighing these options and considering your long-term objectives, you can make the right choice for building a successful team in India.

Unlock Your Business's Full Potential with SimplyBiz

At SimplyBiz, we help businesses navigate complex challenges with tailored, expert guidance. Whether you're a startup or an established enterprise, our team is here to simplify compliance, legal, and financial processes, allowing you to focus on growth and innovation. Join the countless businesses that trust SimplyBiz to be their partner in success. Contact us today to see how we can support your journey.

Reach out to us

Website : www.simplybiz.in I www.gosimplybiz.com

LinkedIn page : SimplyBiz I SimplyBiz GCC

Email : [email protected] I [email protected]